Arkansas 2023 2023 Regular Session

Arkansas Senate Bill SJR2 Draft / Bill

Filed 02/22/2023

                    Stricken language would be deleted from and underlined language would be added to the Arkansas 
Constitution. 
*MBM079* 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
State of Arkansas 	As Engrossed:  S2/22/23  1 
94th General Assembly       2 
Regular Session, 2023  	SJR 2 3 
 4 
By: Senator J. Payton 5 
By: Representatives Cavenaugh, G. Hodges 6 
  7 
SENATE JOINT RESOLUTION 8 
AN AMENDMENT TO THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTIO N TO CREATE A 9 
PROCEDURE FOR THE RE CALL OF PERSONS ELEC TED TO THE 10 
OFFICES OF GOVERNOR, LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR, ATTORNEY 11 
GENERAL, SECRETARY O F STATE, TREASURER O F STATE, 12 
AUDITOR OF STATE, CO MMISSIONER OF STATE LANDS, MEMBER 13 
OF THE HOUSE OF REPR ESENTATIVES, MEMBER OF THE 14 
SENATE, CHIEF JUSTIC E OF THE SUPREME COU RT, JUSTICE 15 
OF THE SUPREME COURT , CHIEF JUDGE OF THE COURT OF 16 
APPEALS, JUDGE OF TH E COURT OF APPEALS, CIRCUIT 17 
JUDGE, DISTRICT JUDG E, PROSECUTING ATTOR NEY, COUNTY 18 
JUDGE, JUSTICE OF THE PE ACE, SHERIFF, CIRCUI T CLERK, 19 
COUNTY CLERK, ASSESS OR, CORONER, TREASUR ER, COUNTY 20 
SURVEYOR, COLLECTOR OF TAXES, OR CONSTAB LE.  21 
 22 
 23 
Subtitle 24 
A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT TO CREATE A 25 
PROCEDURE FOR THE RECALL OF CERTAIN 26 
ELECTED OFFICIALS. 27 
 28 
 29 
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE SENATE OF THE NINETY -FOURTH GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE 30 
STATE OF ARKANSAS, AND BY THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, A MAJORITY OF ALL 31 
MEMBERS ELECTED TO EACH HOUSE AGREEING THERETO: 32 
 33 
 THAT the following is proposed as an amendment to the Constitution of 34 
the State of Arkansas, and upon being submitted to the electors of the state 35 
for approval or rejection at the next general election for Representatives 36   As Engrossed:  S2/22/23 	SJR2 
 
 	2 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
 
and Senators, if a majority of the electors voting thereon at the election 1 
adopt the amendment, the amendment shall become a part of the Constitution of 2 
the State of Arkansas, to wit: 3 
 4 
 SECTION 1.  The Arkansas Constitution is amended to add an additional 5 
amendment to read as follows:  6 
 § 1.  Definitions. 7 
 As used in this amendment: 8 
 (1)  "Elected official" means a person elected or appointed to 9 
one (1) of the following offices:  10 
 (A)  Governor; 11 
 (B)  Lieutenant Governor; 12 
 (C)  Attorney General; 13 
 (D)  Secretary of State; 14 
 (E)  Treasurer of State; 15 
 (F)  Auditor of State; 16 
 (G)  Commissioner of State Lands; 17 
  (H)  Member of the House of Representatives; 18 
 (I)  Member of the Senate; 19 
 (J)  Chief Justice of the Supreme Court; 20 
 (K)  Justice of the Supreme Court; 21 
 (L)  Chief Judge of the Court of Appeals; 22 
 (M)  Judge of the Court of Appeals; 23 
 (N)  Circuit court judge; 24 
 (O)  District court judge; 25 
 (P)  Prosecuting attorney;  26 
 (Q)  County judge;  27 
 (R)  Justice of the peace; 28 
 (S)  Sheriff;  29 
 (T)  Circuit clerk; 30 
 (U)  County clerk;  31 
 (V)  Assessor;  32 
 (W)  Coroner;  33 
 (X)  Treasurer;  34 
 (Y)  County surveyor; 35 
 (Z)  Collector of taxes; or  36  As Engrossed:  S2/22/23 	SJR2 
 
 	3 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
 
 (AA)  Constable.   1 
 (2)  "Recall" means the voting by the electors of the state or a  2 
district, circuit, county, or township, as the case m ay be, to ascertain 3 
whether or not it is the desire of the majority of the electors to allow an 4 
elected official to remain in that office for the duration of his or her 5 
elected term; and  6 
 (3)  “Recall petition” means one (1) or more sheets of signatures 7 
of qualified electors demanding the recall of an elected official.  8 
 9 
 § 2.  Petition. 10 
 (a)  The qualified electors of the state or a district, circuit, 11 
county, or township, as the case may be, may petition for the recall of an 12 
elected official by filing a recall petition demanding the recall of the 13 
elected official. 14 
 (b)(1)(A) The recall petition for the recall of an elected official 15 
elected statewide shall be signed by qualified electors of the state in a 16 
number of at least twenty -five percent (25%) of t he votes cast for Governor 17 
at the last general election at which a Governor was elected.  18 
 (B)  At least ten percent (10%) of the number of statewide 19 
signatures of qualified electors collected under subdivision (b)(1)(A) of 20 
this section shall be from at least fifty (50) different counties of the 21 
state.  22 
 (2)  The recall petition for an elected official elected by a 23 
district shall be signed by qualified electors of the district in which the 24 
elected official is serving in a number of at least twenty -five percent (25%) 25 
of the votes cast for Governor within the district at the last general 26 
election at which a Governor was elected. 27 
 (3)  The recall petition for an elected official elected by 28 
a circuit shall be signed by qualified electors of the circuit in which the 29 
elected official is serving in a number of at least twenty -five percent (25%) 30 
of the votes cast for Governor within the circuit at the last general 31 
election at which a Governor was elected.  32 
 (4)  The recall petition for an elected official el ected by 33 
a county shall be signed by qualified electors of the county in which the 34 
elected official is serving in a number of at least twenty -five percent (25%) 35 
of the votes cast for Governor within the county at the last general election 36  As Engrossed:  S2/22/23 	SJR2 
 
 	4 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
 
at which a Governor was elected.  1 
 (5)  The recall petition for an elected official elected by 2 
a township shall be signed by qualified electors of the township in which the 3 
elected official is serving in a number of at least twenty -five percent (25%) 4 
of the votes cast fo r Governor within the township at the last general 5 
election at which a Governor was elected. 6 
 (c)  If an elected official's position requires performing the duties 7 
of more than one (1) office under § 1(1) of this amendment, a single recall 8 
petition is required which shall encompass all offices. 9 
 10 
 § 3.  Recall of elected officials. 11 
 (a)(1)(A)  The recall of an elected official shall be initiated by 12 
filing a notice of intent to circulate a recall petition with the Secretary 13 
of State.   14 
 (B)  If the Secretary of State is the subject of the recall 15 
petition, the notice of intent shall be filed with the Attorney General. 16 
 (2)  No recall petition shall be circulated before the notice of 17 
intent is filed. 18 
 (3)  The notice of intent to circulate a recall petition shall 19 
state the reason the elected official should be recalled. 20 
 (4)  The filer of the notice of intent to circulate a recall 21 
petition shall within five (5) calendar days after filing the notice of 22 
intent notify the elected official who will be t he subject of a recall 23 
petition by certified mail with return receipt requested. 24 
 (b)(1)  Each sheet of a recall petition shall contain signatures from 25 
only one (1) county. 26 
 (2)  The sheets of a recall petition shall be organized by county 27 
to facilitate voter identification. 28 
 (c)(1)  The recall petition shall be filed with the Secretary of State 29 
not less than sixty (60) calendar days nor more than eighty (80) calendar 30 
days after the filing of the notice of intent to circulate a recall petition. 31 
 (2)  If the Secretary of State is the subject of the recall 32 
petition, the recall petition shall be filed with the Attorney General. 33 
 (d)(1)(A)  Within thirty (30) calendar days after the recall petition 34 
is filed, the Secretary of State shall determine whether the recall petition 35 
is sufficient and, if the recall petition is sufficient, shall state the 36  As Engrossed:  S2/22/23 	SJR2 
 
 	5 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
 
sufficiency in a letter to the filer of the notice of intent. 1 
 (B)  If the Secretary of State is the subject of the recall 2 
petition, the Attorney General shall dete rmine whether the recall petition is 3 
sufficient and, if the recall petition is sufficient, shall state the 4 
sufficiency in a letter to the filer of the notice of intent. 5 
 (2)(A)  If the recall petition is found to be insufficient, the 6 
letter shall state th e reasons creating the insufficiency. 7 
 (B)(i)  The recall petition may be amended to correct or 8 
amend an insufficiency within thirty (30) calendar days after the original 9 
determination of insufficiency. 10 
 (ii)  An amended or corrected recall petition s hall 11 
be filed with the Secretary of State or, if the Secretary of State is the 12 
subject of the recall petition, the Attorney General.  13 
 (C)  For a statewide recall petition, correction or 14 
amendment of an insufficient recall petition shall be permitted on ly if:   15 
 (i)  The recall petition contains valid signatures of 16 
qualified electors equal to at least seventy -five percent (75%) of the number 17 
of statewide signatures of qualified electors required; and 18 
 (ii)  At least ten percent (10%) of the number of 19 
statewide signatures of qualified electors submitted on the recall petition 20 
are from at least fifty (50) counties of the state.   21 
 (3)(A)  Within fifteen (15) calendar days after the filing of an 22 
amended recall petition, the Secretary of State shall e xamine the recall 23 
petition again to determine sufficiency and shall state the sufficiency of 24 
the amended recall petition in a letter to the filer of the notice of intent 25 
to circulate a recall petition. 26 
 (B)  If the Secretary of State is the subject of th e recall 27 
petition, then within fifteen (15) calendar days after the filing of an 28 
amended recall petition the Attorney Genera l shall examine the recall 29 
petition again to determine sufficiency and shall state the sufficiency of 30 
the amended recall petition in a letter to the filer of the notice of intent 31 
to circulate a recall petition. 32 
 (e)(1)(A)  Immediately upon finding an original or amended recall 33 
petition sufficient, the Secretary of State shall notify the Governor who 34 
shall immediately call a special ele ction for the purpose of submitting the 35 
recall proposal to the appropriate electors. 36  As Engrossed:  S2/22/23 	SJR2 
 
 	6 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
 
 (B)  If the Secretary of State is the subject of the recall 1 
petition, the Attorney General shall notify the Governor immediately upon 2 
finding an original or amended rec all petition sufficient.  3 
 (C)  If the Governor is the subject of the recall petition, 4 
the Secretary of State shall notify the Lieutenant Governor, who shall 5 
immediately call a special election. 6 
 (2)(A)  The special election for the purpose of submitting the 7 
recall proposal to the appropriate electors shall be held within ninety (90) 8 
calendar days after the call for a special election. 9 
 (B)  However, if the next following general election is to 10 
be held within one hundred twenty (120) calendar days of the original or 11 
amended recall petition being found sufficient, the recall proposal shall be 12 
submitted at the next following general election. 13 
 (f)  If the Attorney General performs one (1) or more duties of the 14 
Secretary of State under this sectio n due to the Secretary of State being the 15 
subject of the recall petition, the Attorney General may employ outside legal 16 
counsel to defend a legal challenge regarding the sufficiency of a recall 17 
petition.   18 
 19 
 § 4.  Form of recall petition. 20 
 (a)  The recall petition regarding an elected official shall be in 21 
substantially the following form: 22 
 "PETITION FOR RECALL 23 
To the Secretary of State [or the Attorney General, if the Secretary of State 24 
is the subject of the recall petition]: 25 
We, the undersigned qualified electors of 26 
________________________________________ 27 
 (Arkansas or District, Circuit, 28 
County, or Township) 29 
respectfully order that ____________________________________________________ 30 
 (Name of Elected Official) 31 
be referred to the people of ___________________________________________ 32 
 (Arkansas or District, Circuit, County, 33 
or Township) 34 
to the end that the recall of the elected official may be approved or 35 
rejected by the vote of the qualified electors at an election to be held for 36  As Engrossed:  S2/22/23 	SJR2 
 
 	7 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
 
this purpose; and each of us for himself or herself says:  I have personally 1 
signed this petition; I am a qualified elector of (Arkansas or District, 2 
Circuit, County, or Township) , and my printed name, date of birth, residence, 3 
city or town of residence, and dat e of signing this petition are correctly 4 
written after my signature.” 5 
 (b)(1)  Each sheet of each recall petition containing the signatures 6 
shall be verified by the person who circulated the sheet of the recall 7 
petition by his or her affidavit attached to the recall petition.  8 
 (2)  The affidavit shall be in substantially the following form: 9 
"STATE OF ARKANSAS     ) 10 
COUNTY_____________    ) 11 
I, ________________________, under oath, state that the above -listed persons 12 
signed this sheet, and each of them sig ned his or her name on this sheet in 13 
my presence.  I believe that each has correctly stated his or her name, date 14 
of birth, residence, city or town of residence, and date of signing the 15 
petition. 16 
Signature ____________________________________________ 17 
Address ________________________________________________ 18 
Subscribed and sworn to before me this the ______day of ________, ____. 19 
Signature ____________________________________________________ 20 
 Notary Public 21 
My Commission Expires: ____________________________ ________." 22 
 (c)  A petition shall be sufficient if it substantially follows the 23 
format of this section, disregarding clerical and technical errors. 24 
 25 
 § 5.  Ballot. 26 
 (a)  At the election the recall proposal shall be printed on the ballot 27 
in substantially the following form: 28 
Name:                  Office:              29 
   “For Permitting _______________________ ________________________to 30 
continue to serve the term of office for which elected ............ /_/ 31 
 32 
Name:  Office: 33 
   Against Permitting _________ ___________ ______________________ to         34 
continue to serve the term of office for which elected ........... /_/.” 35 
 (b)(1)  If at the election a majority of the qualified electors voting 36  As Engrossed:  S2/22/23 	SJR2 
 
 	8 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
 
on the recall proposal vote against permitting the elected offici al to 1 
continue to serve the term of office to which he or she was elected, an 2 
immediate vacancy shall exist in the office, and the vacancy shall be filled 3 
in the manner prescribed by law. 4 
 (2)  If at the election a majority of the qualified electors 5 
voting on the recall proposal vote for permitting the elected official to 6 
continue to serve the term of office for which he or she elected, the elected 7 
official shall serve the full term for which he or she was elected. 8 
 9 
 § 6.  Frequency of recall. 10 
 After one (1) recall petition and election, no further recall petition 11 
shall be filed against the same elected official during the same term of 12 
office. 13 
 14 
 § 7.  Recall expenses. 15 
 All expenses of an election for the recall of an elected official shall 16 
be paid for in the same manner and from the same source as provided by 17 
applicable law for election expenses. 18 
 19 
 § 8.  Ballot question. 20 
 (a)  A recall proposal shall be considered a ballot question for 21 
purposes of applicable laws on measures referred to voters.  22 
 (b)  An elected official, any person or entity acting on behalf of an 23 
elected official, or any other person or entity who receives contributions or 24 
makes expenditures for the purpose of attempting to influence the 25 
qualification, passage, or defeat of a rec all petition or recall proposal 26 
shall be considered a ballot question committee and shall comply with 27 
applicable laws on measures referred to voters.  28 
 29 
 SECTION 2.  EFFECTIVE DATE.  This amendment shall be effective on and 30 
after January 1, 2025.  31 
 32 
 SECTION 3.  BALLOT TITLE AND POPULAR NAME.  When this proposed 33 
amendment is submitted to the electors of this state on the general election 34 
ballot: 35 
 (1)  The title of this Joint Resolution shall be the ballot 36  As Engrossed:  S2/22/23 	SJR2 
 
 	9 	02-22-2023 10:04:33 MBM079 
 
 
title; and  1 
 (2)  The popular name shall be "A Co nstitutional Amendment t o 2 
Create a Procedure for the Recall of Persons Elected to the Offices of 3 
Governor, Lieutenant Governor, Attorney General, Secretary of State, 4 
Treasurer of State, Auditor of State, Commissioner of State Lands, Member of 5 
the House of Representatives, Member of the Senate, Chief Justice of the 6 
Supreme Court, Justice of the Supreme Court, Chief Judge of the Court of 7 
Appeals, Judge of the Court of Appeals, Circuit Judge, District Judge, County 8 
Judge, Justice of the Peace, Sheriff, Circuit Clerk, County Clerk, Assessor, 9 
Coroner, Treasurer, County Surveyor, Collector of Taxes, or Constable". 10 
 11 
/s/J. Payton 12 
 13 
 14 
 15 
 16 
 17 
 18 
 19 
 20 
 21 
 22 
 23 
 24 
 25 
 26 
 27 
 28 
 29 
 30 
 31 
 32 
 33 
 34 
 35 
 36