Arizona 2023 2023 Regular Session

Arizona House Bill HB2302 Comm Sub / Analysis

Filed 02/14/2023

                      	HB 2302 
Initials JL/GC 	Page 1 	Judiciary 
 
ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 
Fifty-sixth Legislature 
First Regular Session 
 
 
HB 2302: misdemeanor expungement; requirements; procedure 
Sponsor: Representative Carter, LD 15 
Committee on Judiciary 
Overview 
Allows a person who was convicted of a misdemeanor offense to submit a petition for 
expungement (Petition) with the convicting court provided that the individual satisfies all outlined 
requirements. Specifies the procedures a court must follow when reviewing a Petition. 
History 
Current law allows an eligible person who has been convicted of a criminal offense to apply to the 
court to have the judgment of guilt set aside. When reviewing the application to set aside 
judgement (Application), the court is mandated to review a multitude of factors, record all 
reasoning regarding the Application in writing and allow any victims to be present at the hearing 
if desired. A conviction that has been set aside may not be redacted or removed from the 
individual's record but must contain an annotation indicating that it has been set aside.  
Statute requires a court to issue a certificate of second chance (Certificate) upon approval of the 
Application if the individual has not previously received a Certificate and any of the following are 
true: 
1) The conviction is for a misdemeanor, class 4, 5 or 6 felony and a minimum of two years 
has passed since the fulfillment of probation or sentencing conditions; or 
2) The conviction is for a class 2 or 3 felony and a minimum of five years has passed since 
the fulfillment of all probation or sentencing conditions. 
The Certificate releases an individual from any barriers resulting from the set aside conviction 
while obtaining an occupational license under A.R.S. Title 32. Additionally, a Certificate restores 
the individual's right to possess a firearm and provides the individual's employer and other entities 
with protections pursuant to A.R.S. § 12-588.03 (A.R.S. § 13-905). 
Provisions 
1. Allows individuals convicted of a misdemeanor to file a Petition with the convicting court 
provided that: 
a) A minimum of three years has passed since the petitioner fulfilled all probation or 
sentencing conditions; and 
b) The conviction is not for: 
i) Sexual offenses under A.R.S. Title 13, Chapter 14; 
ii) Sexual exploitation of children offenses under A.R.S. Title 13, Chapter 35.1; or 
iii) Driving under the influence offenses under A.R.S. Title 28, Chapter 4. (Sec. 1) 
2. Requires the convicting court to request that the appropriate probation department evaluate 
the Petition and submit an evaluation that includes: 
a) A written recommendation concerning the Petition; 
☐ Prop 105 (45 votes)     ☐ Prop 108 (40 votes)      ☐ Emergency (40 votes) ☐ Fiscal Note    	HB 2302 
Initials JL/GC 	Page 2 	Judiciary 
b) Whether the probationer has fulfilled the conditions of their sentence or probation; 
c) Any postconviction victim statements; 
d) Additional arrests or convictions the petitioner may have; 
e) Any written recommendations from third parties in support of expungement which have 
been submitted to the probation department. (Sec. 1) 
3. Requires a court to deny a Petition if any of the following apply: 
a) The petitioner has previously obtained expungement in any jurisdiction for an offense 
which would classify as a felony in the state of Arizona; 
b) The petitioner has unresolved or pending matters in any jurisdiction; 
c) The petitioner has failed to pay the full amount of restitution or fines ordered pursuant to 
A.R.S. Title 13, Chapter 8. (Sec. 1) 
4. Instructs all records of an individual's conviction to be sealed and prohibits any law 
enforcement agency or court from releasing copies of the records unless otherwise directed 
by court order, upon judicial approval of the Petition. (Sec. 1) 
5. States that any individual who fails to comply with the prohibition of releasing expunged 
records be liable to the petitioner for damages resulting for the failure to comply. (Sec. 1) 
6. Specifies that an individual with an expunged conviction may respond to any inquiries as if 
the conviction did not exist. (Sec. 1)