Arizona 2023 2023 Regular Session

Arizona Senate Bill SB1246 Comm Sub / Analysis

Filed 06/21/2023

                      	SB 1246 
Initials JB 	Page 1 	Vetoed 
 
ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 
Fifty-sixth Legislature 
First Regular Session 
Senate: TAT DPA 6-0-1-0 | 3
rd
 Read 29-0-1-0 
House: TI DPA/SE 7-4-0-0 | 3
rd
 Read 31-26-3-0 
Final Pass: 16-12-2-0  
 
SB 1246: electronic certificates of title 
NOW: election; transportation tax; Maricopa County 
Sponsor: Senator Farnsworth, LD 10 
Vetoed  
Overview 
Requires Maricopa County, beginning on January 1, 2026, if approved by qualified electors voting 
in a countywide election, to levy and the Arizona Department of Transportation (ADOT) to collect 
a County Transportation Excise Tax and County Public Transportation Excise Tax, both to be in 
effect for 20 years. Additionally, if approved by the voters, establishes a transportation excise tax 
Plan.  
History 
In 2004, Maricopa County voters approved a countywide transportation tax levied at a rate up to 
10% of the state transaction privilege tax (one-half-cent transaction tax). Revenues from the half-
cent transportation tax are deposited into the Regional Area Road Fund (RARF). Laws 2003, 
Chapter 217 established the Regional Planning Agency Transportation Policy Committee (TPC) 
which is tasked with the approval of a 20-year comprehensive, performance-based, multimodal 
and coordinated regional transportation plan in Maricopa County. The tax will end on December 
31, 2025. 
The Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG) is a council of governments that serves as the 
regional planning and policy agency for the metropolitan Phoenix area. Monies collected from the 
voter-approved transportation taxes are deposited into MAG's RARF to be used by MAG for 
maintenance and capital expenses of freeways and the state highway system (A.R.S. § 42-6106). 
House Bill 2685 required Maricopa County to hold a county-wide election to continue the half-
cent transportation tax. The bill was passed by the Legislature and transmitted to the Governor 
on June 24th, 2022. The Governor vetoed House Bill 2685 on July 6th, 2022.  
Provisions 
County Transportation Excise Tax  
1. Requires, if approved by the qualified electors voting at a county-wide election, a county with 
a population of 3,000,000 or more people to levy, and ADOT to collect a transportation excise 
(County Transportation Excise Tax) tax beginning January 1, 2026. (Sec. 26) 
2. Directs County Transportation Excise Tax to be levied and collected: 
a) At a rate of up to 8.6% ($ 0.43) of the state transaction privilege tax (TPT) rate on January 
1, 1990; 
b) At a rate of up to 8.6% of the jet fuel excise tax rate; and 
c) On the use or consumption of electricity or natural gas by customers in the county who 
are subject to use tax, at a rate equal to the state TPT rate that applies to customers 
engaging in the county in the utilities TPT classification. (Sec. 26)    	SB 1246 
Initials JB 	Page 2 	Vetoed 
3. States that the Plan adopted by the regional planning agency will specify the distribution of 
the collected monies and requires the Plan to distribute the revenues as follows: 
a) 53.5% to the RARF for freeways and other routes in the state highway system, including 
maintenance and capital expense; 
b) 18.5% to the RARF for major arterial streets, intersection improvements and regional 
programs, including capital expense and implementation studies. At least 13.5% is 
required to be distributed for major arterial streets and intersection improvements; and 
c) 28% to the Public Transportation Fund for capital costs, maintenance and operation of 
public transportation mode classifications. (Sec. 26) 
4. Prohibits the RARF distribution for freeways and other routes in the state highway system and 
the distribution for major arterials and intersection improvements from being decreased. (Sec. 
26) 
5. Prohibits County Transportation Excise Tax revenue from being used: 
a) For any light rail, commuter rail, street cars or trollies;  
b) To influence the outcome of an election;  
c) For polling;  
d) On any project that will result in a reduction in existing lane miles on a highway or a state 
highway;  
e) On any project that will result in a reduction in existing lane miles on a street or roadway 
unless a third-party engineering study determines the reduction is necessary to reduce 
congestion, and the findings are presented in a public hearing;  
f) On active transportation projects; and  
g) For extending light rail between 7th Avenue and 19th Avenue and Adams Street and 
Jefferson Street in Phoenix. (Sec. 26) 
6. Requires the County Transportation Excise Tax to be in effect for 20 years. (Sec. 26) 
County Public Transportation Excise Tax 
7. Requires, if approved by the qualified electors voting at a county-wide election, a county with 
a population of 3,000,000 or more people to levy, and ADOT to collect a transportation excise 
tax for public transportation (County Public Transportation Excise Tax) beginning January 1, 
2026. (Sec. 26) 
8. Directs the County Public Transportation Excise Tax to be levied and collected:  
a) At a rate of up to 1.3% ($ .065) of the TPT rate on January 1, 1990;  
b) At a rate of up to 1.3% of the jet fuel excise tax rate; and  
c) On the use or consumption of electricity or natural gas by customers in the county who 
are subject to use tax, at a rate equal to the state TPT rate that applies to customers 
engaging in the county in the utilities TPT classification. (Sec. 26) 
9. Requires the net revenues collected by the Public Transportation Excise Tax to be distributed 
and deposited in the Public Transportation Fund for:  
a) Capital costs, maintenance and operation of public transportation mode classifications; 
and  
b) Capital costs and utility relocation costs associated with a light rail public transit system. 
(Sec. 26) 
10. States that no more than 25% of County Public Transportation Excise Tax revenues may be 
used for capital rehabilitation of the light rail system. (Sec. 26) 
11. Defines capital rehabilitation of the light rail system as capital maintenance, repair or 
improvements that ensure regional assets remain in a state of good repair to preserve the 
safety and reliability of the system. (Sec. 26)    	SB 1246 
Initials JB 	Page 3 	Vetoed 
12. States the Public Transportation Excise Tax will be in effect for 20 years. (Sec. 26) 
13. Prohibits Public Transportation Excise Tax revenues from being used: 
a) For any light rail extension, commuter rail, street cars or trollies 
b) To influence the outcome of an election;  
c) For polling;  
d) For any project that will reduce existing lane miles on a highway or state highway, unless 
a third-party engineering study determines the reduction is necessary to reduce 
congestion, and the findings are presented in a public hearing; and 
e) To extend light rail between 7th Avenue and 19th Avenue and Adams Street and Jefferson 
Street in Phoenix. (Sec. 26) 
Countywide Election  
14. Describes processes for the county to call a countywide election for the levy of the County 
Transportation Excise Tax and the County Public Transportation Excise Tax. (Sec. 31) 
15. Requires the county to conduct the election on a consolidated election date at least one year 
before the date on which an existing county excise tax would otherwise be discontinued. (Sec. 
31) 
16. Modifies population requirements for highly populated counties from 1,200,000 to 3,000,000 
or more. (Sec. 5) 
17. Removes the ability for monies from any account in the RARF to be spent to determine public 
opinion before the election is called. (Sec. 9) 
Regional Planning Agency and Transportation Infrastructure Investment Plan 
18. Requires the regional planning agency in the county to develop and adopt a Plan in 
cooperation with state and local public transportation authorities and coordination with ADOT. 
(Sec. 17) 
19. Defines Plan as a comprehensive, performance-based, multimodal and coordinated regional 
strategic transportation infrastructure investment Plan approved for a county. (Sec. 17) 
20. Directs the regional planning agency to consider truck parking availability when considering 
the construction, expansion or modification of freeways or other routes in the state highway 
system. (Sec. 15) 
21. Requires the regional planning agency to allocate at least $90,000,000 for the implementation 
of commercial motor vehicle parking that is consistent with the adopted truck parking plan on 
or before December 31, 2045. (Sec. 17) 
22. Requires the Plan to allocate County Transportation Excise Tax revenues in the: 
a) RARF for freeways and other routes in the state highway system; 
b) RARF for major arterial streets, intersection improvements and regional programs; and 
c) Public Transportation Fund for capital costs, maintenance and operation of public 
transportation mode classifications. (Sec. 17) 
23. Requires the Plan to allocate Public Transportation Excise Tax revenues in the Public 
Transportation Fund for:  
a) Capital costs, maintenance and operation of public transportation mode classifications; 
and  
b) Capital costs and utility relocation costs associated with a light rail public transit system. 
(Sec. 17) 
24. Directs the regional planning agency, beginning FY 2024, to adopt a budget process and 
outlines requirements for the budget process. (Sec. 17)    	SB 1246 
Initials JB 	Page 4 	Vetoed 
25. Stipulates that the regional planning agency must coordinate with implementing partners on 
the budget process including ADOT for freeways and other routes in the state highway system 
and the regional public transportation authority in the county for the public transportation 
system. (Sec. 17) 
26. Specifies the budget process does not apply to the annual operating budget of the regional 
public transportation authority in the county. (Sec. 17) 
27. Requires the regional planning agency to determine the use of revenues collected for capital 
projects through the transportation improvement program. (Sec. 17) 
28. States that any bonds issued against proceeds collected through the transportation excise 
taxes require consultation with the regional planning agency. (Sec. 17) 
29. Directs the regional planning agency to annually report on the status of the funded projects 
and requires the report to be posted on the agency's website. (Sec. 17) 
30. Stipulates requests for changes to transportation projects funded in the Plan that would 
materially increase costs must be submitted to the regional planning agency for approval and 
then submitted by the agency to the TPC and the State Transportation Board for consideration 
and approval. (Sec. 17) 
31. Requires a local authority that requests an enhancement to a transportation project funded by 
the Plan to pay for all costs associated with the enhancement. (Sec. 17) 
32. States that if monies are appropriated by the Legislature for a project that is identified by the 
Plan, the use of the monies for construction requires: 
a) That the project must be advanced as appropriate to reflect the estimated construction 
start date; and  
b) The monies be used in the same modal classification as transportation tax revenues. (Sec. 
17) 
33. Allows a municipality that pays for public transportation service in an adjacent municipality or 
unincorporated area to be eligible for reimbursement from monies collected under the 
transportation tax. (Sec.17) 
34. Requires the regional planning agency to post a public notice on any proposed amendments 
to the Plan that requires a new air quality conformity determination and to make the results of 
the air quality conformity analysis publicly available. (Sec. 17) 
Farebox Operating and Recovery Ratio Performance Standards   
35. Directs the public transportation element of the regional transportation Plan to include the 
following performance standards: 
a) A farebox operating ratio standard for existing bus route extensions that are in existence 
on the effective date and that are funded in whole or in part by the revenues of either 
transportation excise tax; and 
b) A farebox recovery ratio standard for existing bus routes that are in existence on the 
effective date and that are funded in whole or in part by the revenues of either 
transportation excise tax. (Sec. 30) 
36. Requires the outlined performance standards to be presented each fiscal year and to achieve 
the following percentages for each bus route in existence on the effective date: 
a) For FY 2026 through FY 2028, 13%;  
b) For FY 2029 through FY 2031, 16%; and  
c) For FY 2032 and thereafter, 19%. (Sec. 30)    	SB 1246 
Initials JB 	Page 5 	Vetoed 
37. Directs the excess costs to be allocated among affected member municipalities according to 
the proportion of the bus route that is in each municipality if the regional public transportation 
authority (authority) fails to meet the outlined performance standards. (Sec. 30) 
38. Requires member municipalities to pay their owed amounts from their perspective general 
funds to the Public Transportation Fund in the fiscal year following the fiscal year the shortfall 
occurred. (Sec. 30) 
39. States that if the authority fails to meet the outlined 19% performance standard for FY 2032 
and onward, the authority is required to proceed with a public bid for the operation of the failing 
bus route and is prohibited from submitting a proposal to bid. (Sec. 30)  
40. Requires the authority to conduct a public bid to contract the operations for all new bus routes 
identified in the Plan. The bid must require the perspective operators to demonstrate 
compliance with the following farebox operating ratio standards; 
a) 13% within the first year of operating;  
b) 16% within the fourth year of operating; and 
c) 19% within the seventh year of operating and every subsequent year. (Sec. 30)  
41. States that if the operator fails to meet the performance standards:  
a) A new public bid may be conducted; 
b) The failing bus route may be eliminated; or  
c) A new bus route may be redesigned followed by a new public bid. (Sec. 30) 
42. Exempts transportation services required by the 'Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990' 
U.S.C §§ 12101-12213 from the farebox recovery ratio performance standards. (Sec. 30) 
Transportation Policy Committee 
43. Adds the following members to the TPC beginning FY 2025, all appointed jointly by the 
Speaker of the House of Representatives and the President of the Senate to serve six-year 
terms: 
a) Two members representing unincorporated areas of Maricopa County; 
b) Two members representing taxpayer organizations; and 
c) One member who represents residential housing development interests. (Sec. 11) 
44. Modifies the membership of the TPC by increasing the number of members who represent 
regionwide business interests from 6 to 12, of whom: 
a) Two, instead of one, represent transit interests; 
b) Two, instead of one, represent freight interests;  
c) Two represent commercial real estate interests; and 
d) Two, instead of one, represent construction interests. (Sec. 11) 
45. Directs the TPC to develop the Plan in cooperation with the regional public transportation 
authority in the county and ADOT and in consultation with the board of supervisors, Indian 
communities and cities and towns in the county. (Sec. 11) 
46. Requires the TPC to recommend approval, disapproval or modification of: 
a) The Plan; 
b) Changes to the allocation of transportation tax revenues; 
c) Budget processes; and 
d) Funding awarded through the regional program's process. (Sec.11) 
 
 
☐ Prop 105 (45 votes)     ☐ Prop 108 (40 votes)      ☐ Emergency (40 votes) ☐ Fiscal Note    	SB 1246 
Initials JB 	Page 6 	Vetoed 
Miscellaneous  
47. Requires the State Treasurer, instead of dividing and equally distributing $5,000,000 to the 
Public Transportation Fund and Regional Planning Agency, to distribute every fiscal year 
from the Construction Fund; 
a) $2,500,000 to the Public Transportation Fund; and  
b) $1,625,000 to the regional planning agency for planning and administering the Plan. 
(Sec. 8)  
48. Requires ADOT to separately account for the uses of the transportation excise tax revenues 
deposited in the bond account and the construction account to identify how the revenues are 
used for: 
a) Freeways or other routes in the state highway system; and 
b) Major arterial streets, intersection improvements and regional programs identified in the 
Plan, including capital expense and implementation studies. (Sec. 6) 
49. Restricts this state or a city, town, county or political subdivision of this state from restricting 
the use of or sale of a device based on the energy source consumed by the device or used 
to power the device. (Sec. 1) 
50. Prohibits public monies and tax revenues from the current county transportation excise tax 
from being used to extend light rail between 7th Avenue and 19th Avenue and Adams Street 
and Jefferson Street in Phoenix. (Sec. 24-25) 
51. Requires the speed limit for all types of motor vehicles to be at least 65 miles per hour on 
interstate system highways located in a county with a population of 3,000,000 or more people. 
(Sec. 3) 
52. Modifies what monies in the bond account may be used for. (Sec. 7) 
53. Removes the requirement that the Director of ADOT develops and annually updates, as a 
component of the five-year transportation facilities construction program, a plan for the use of 
monies expected to be deposited in the county's regional area road fund. (Sec. 8) 
54. Requires the Auditor General to every five years internally conduct a performance audit of the 
Plan and projects scheduled for funding during the next five years and modifies the reporting 
requirements for the audit. (Sec. 13) 
55. Establishes beginning January 1, 2026, a regional public transportation authority in a county 
with a population of 3,000,000 or more people that approved a county transportation excise 
tax. (Sec. 27) 
56. Requires the five-year transportation facilities construction program to include a plan that is 
updated annually for the use of monies expected to be deposited in a county's RARF that is 
consistent with the Plan adopted by the regional planning agency and consistent with the 
planning agency's budget process. (Sec. 20) 
57. Specifies that this act does not invalidate any action by a regional public transportation 
authority formed before the effective date. (Sec. 32) 
58. States that the Legislature intends that: 
a) The development of State Route 30 between State Route 85 and Loop 303 to begin in the 
first phase of the Plan; and 
b) The freeway allocations fund the repavement of State Route 51. (Sec. 33) 
59. Contains a severability clause. (Sec. 34)    	SB 1246 
Initials JB 	Page 7 	Vetoed 
60. Contains a conditional enactment clause. (Sec. 35) 
61. Repeals statute. (Sec. 10, 12, 16, 18, 29) 
62. Defines terms. (Sec. 4, 15, 17, 30) 
63. Makes technical changes. (Sec. 2, 4-8, 11, 13, 15, 19, 22, 25, 28) 
64. Makes conforming changes. (Sec. 2-9, 11, 13-15, 19, 21-23, 25, 28)