Arizona 2024 2024 Regular Session

Arizona Senate Bill SB1456 Introduced / Fiscal Note

Filed 03/13/2024

                    Fiscal Note 
 
 
BILL # SB 1456 	TITLE:  CTEs; in-demand programs; funding 
SPONSOR: Bennett 	STATUS: Senate Engrossed 
PREPARED BY: Gordon Robertson  
 
 
Description 
 
The bill would require the Office of Economic Opportunity (OEO) to develop a state-wide in-demand education list for the 
purposes of Career and Technical Education District (CTED) funding for 9
th
 grade students and students enrolled in the 
year immediately following high school graduation. OEO currently develops multiple regional in-demand lists for the same 
purpose. The bill would modify the enrollment requirements for 9
th
 grade CTED students such that these students would 
be included in Average Daily Membership (ADM) counts if they are in enrolled in a statewide in-demand program in 9
th
 
grade and continue in the CTED in 10
th
 grade. 
 
Estimated Impact 
 
Based on data from the Department of Education (ADE), we estimate the bill would increase General Fund K-12 Basic 
State Aid expenses by $7.7 million annually beginning in FY 2025. The actual impact could be higher or lower than our 
estimate depending on the share of 9
th
 grade students and students enrolled after graduation who would be counted in 
ADM under a statewide in-demand list, the contents of which are uncertain.  
 
Analysis 
 
ADE reports that in FY 2024, there are 33,270 9
th
 grade students enrolled in a CTED. Given that these students generally 
attend a CTED on a part-time basis, these 33,270 students would only generate ADM of 6,732. Under current law, 
however, the actual 9
th
 grade ADM included in Basic State Aid calculations is lower than 6,732 due to 2 additional 
statutory limitations that apply to funding such students. To be included in ADM counts, ADE interprets current statute to 
require a 9
th
 grader to: 
 
• Be enrolled in a CTED program that, at the time they enroll, is included in the "in-demand education" list for their 
region that is published by OEO. 
• Continue in the CTED until at least the 40
th
 day of their 11
th
 grade year.  
 
When factoring in these requirements, CTED students who reached their 40
th
 day of 11
th
 grade this year and were 
enrolled in an in-demand program in 9
th
 grade generated fundable ADM of 1,551 during the current school year, for a 
total cost of $6.9 million. Under the bill, to be included in ADM counts, 9
th
 grade students would instead be required to: 
 
• Be enrolled in a CTED program that, at the time they enroll, is included in a statewide "in-demand education" list.  
• Continue in the CTED until their 10
th
 grade year.  
 
ADE estimates that funding students under these new requirements would cost $14.6M beginning in FY 2024, or $7.7M 
above current law. The department's estimates assume that total 9
th
 grade ADM would increase from 1,159 under current 
law to 2,451 under the bill, or an increase of 1,292, including: 
 
(Continued)  - 2 - 
 
 
• An increase of 193 ADM, or $1.2 million, to require that 9
th
 graders only continue in a CTED until 10
th
 grade instead of 
11
th
 grade. 
• An increase of 1,099 ADM, or $6.5 million, to expand the list of fundable 9
th
 grade CTED programs to include 
programs on a statewide list developed by OEO instead of a regional list.  
 
ADE's estimate assumes that the new statewide in-demand list would include all regional in-demand programs. Should a 
statewide in-demand list exclude some programs otherwise found on a regional in-demand list, the actual impact of the 
change to a statewide in-demand list could be lower than estimated.  
 
The bill would also allow students enrolled in a CTED in the year after graduation to generate ADM only if they are 
enrolled in a program on the statewide "in-demand education" list. We lack sufficient information to estimate the cost of 
this relatively small population being funded under a statewide list instead of regional lists.  
 
Local Government Impact 
 
None 
 
3/13/24