Arizona 2024 2024 Regular Session

Arizona Senate Bill SB1655 Comm Sub / Analysis

Filed 03/22/2024

                    Assigned to HHS 	AS PASSED BY COW 
 
 
 
 
ARIZONA STATE SENATE 
Fifty-Sixth Legislature, Second Regular Session 
 
AMENDED 
FACT SHEET FOR S.B. 1655 
 
health care institutions; regulation 
Purpose 
Makes various changes related to the licensing, oversight and regulation of behavioral 
health entities (BHEs) and sober living homes. 
Background 
Health care institutions in Arizona are licensed and overseen by the Department of Health 
Services (DHS), including enforcement of health care institution statutes, rules and regulations. 
DHS must: 1) review and approve plans and specifications for institution construction or 
modification; 2) have access to books, records, accounts and any other necessary health care 
institution information; and 3) require nursing care institutions and assisted living facilities to 
provide annual influenza and pneumonia vaccines to residents. Additionally, DHS may: 1) inspect 
every part of a health care institution to ensure compliance with standard medical practice;  
2) conduct investigations of health care institution conditions and problems with noncompliance; 
and 3) develop facility manuals and guides to health care institutions and the general public (A.R.S. 
§ 36-406). Health care institutions must be in substantial compliance with state laws governing 
health care institutions to be licensed and avoid enforcement action by DHS (A.R.S. § 36-425). 
Statute requires the Director of DHS (Director) to establish minimum standards and 
requirements for the licensure of sober living homes to ensure the public health, safety and welfare. 
The Director may use the current standards adopted by any recognized national organization 
approved by DHS as guidelines in prescribing the minimal standards and requirements but must 
include outlined statutory policies and procedures (A.R.S. § 36-2062). A sober living home is any 
premises, place or building that provides alcohol-free or drug-free housing that: 1) promotes 
independent living and life skills development; 2) may provide activities that are directed primarily 
toward recovery from substance use disorders; 3) provides a supervised setting to a group of 
unrelated individuals who are recovering from substance use disorders; and 4) does not provide 
any medical or clinical services or medication administration on-site, except for verification of 
abstinence (A.R.S. § 36-2061). 
If there is a cost associated with increased DHS oversight of BHEs and sober living homes, 
then there may be a fiscal impact to the state General Fund (state GF) associated with this 
legislation. Additionally, S.B. 1655 increases the cap on various health-related civil penalties, 
which are deposited into the state GF. 
Provisions 
Behavioral Health Entities  
1. Allows the Director, by rule, to establish a monitoring program for BHEs that identifies the 
circumstances in which DHS must assign staff, on a temporary basis, to monitor and provide 
professional assistance to a licensee that is not in substantial compliance with licensing 
requirements.  FACT SHEET – Amended  
S.B. 1655 
Page 2 
 
 
2. Requires the rules of the monitoring program to establish staffing levels based on monitoring 
needs and the corresponding fees based on a cost assessment calculating the duration of the 
monitoring schedule, a pre-disclosed hourly rate and actual costs. 
3. Sets the minimum civil penalty assessed for terminating the operation of a health care 
institution without proper handling of patient medical records, as prescribed, at $5,000. 
4. Prohibits the Director from accepting an accreditation report in lieu of a compliance inspection 
of a:  
a) health care institution that has been subject to a criminal penalty in the preceding five years; 
or 
b) behavioral health entity. 
5. Clarifies that DHS must establish a corrective action plan with non-compliant health care 
entities. 
6. Voids a health care institution license if the licensee does not pay any civil penalties or the 
provider agreement fees assessed. 
7. Excludes behavioral health entities from laws granting DHS compliance survey exemptions 
for facilities that have been deficiency free for 24 months.  
8. Removes the requirement that DHS issue a provisional license to an unlicensed health care 
institution that is not in substantial compliance with DHS licensure requirements and that the 
Director believes best serves patients and the public by being provided a chance to correct 
deficiencies. 
9. Prohibits the Director from issuing more than two nonconsecutive provisional licenses to a 
single health care institution. 
10. Declares a person that operates or maintains a behavioral health entity or sober living home 
without a license guilty of a class 6 felony, subject to a daily civil penalty of between $5,000 
and $10,000 for each violation, which may be assessed for each resident or patient determined 
to be impacted by the violation.  
11. Requires the Director, through the Attorney General, to bring action for an injunction to 
restrain the violation or to enjoin the future operation or maintenance of the BHE. 
12. Requires DHS, in addition to all other licensing standards and requirements, to establish a 
designated one-year license, by rule, for BHEs that use funds received directly or indirectly 
from any federal health care program. 
13. Prohibits DHS from: 
a) issuing a BHE license for greater than 12 months; 
b) issuing a temporary license to a behavioral health applicant or licensee; 
c) assessing a civil penalty on a BHE in an amount less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for 
each violation; 
d) rescinding, in whole or in part, sanctions imposed on a BHE;  FACT SHEET – Amended  
S.B. 1655 
Page 3 
 
 
e) authorizing or approving the removal of a BHE licensee and appointing another person to 
continue operation of the BHE pending further action, absent good cause and risk of life, 
health or safety of a patient; or 
f) authorizing or approving a license application for a currently licensed BHE while any 
enforcement or court action is pending against the current owner or licensee. 
14. Requires BHEs, to the extent allowed by federal law, when a resident is admitted for 
evaluation, to: 
a) obtain and document a list of the resident's medications, allergies and emergency contact 
information by the resident's arrival date; and 
b) use best efforts to notify the resident's family or next of kin within 72 hours of the initial 
evaluation and document the notification in the resident's medical record. 
15. Waives notification requirements if a resident signs a written waiver requesting that the BHE 
not notify family, next of kin or responsible persons. 
16. Prohibits BHEs from coordinating, facilitating, arranging or soliciting transportation of a 
person to the BHE if the person is obviously intoxicated or under the influence of a substance, 
unless the person is referred by an approved provider of a tribal health care program or regional 
behavioral health authority or is under order of the court. 
17. Requires BHEs, for residents 18 years or older, to inquire, both verbally and in writing, whether 
the resident wants to be transported to the resident's place of residence or another safe living 
space in Arizona, as requested by the resident after discharge. 
18. Requires a BHE resident's wishes regarding transportation to be documented on a  
DHS-prescribed form, signed by the resident and retained in the resident's medical record. 
19. Requires BHEs to use good faith in attempting to arrange safe and reliable transportation, if 
available, for residents who wish to be transported home or to another safe living space upon 
discharge. 
20. Requires BHEs to contact the statewide social service provider and area shelters to comply 
with post-discharge transportation requirements. 
21. Requires BHEs, for residents under 18 years old, to coordinate with the resident's parent or 
legal guardian and clinical social worker handling the resident's case regarding post-discharge 
transportation. 
22. Asserts that a BHE patient, resident, prospective patient or resident is a vulnerable adult. 
23. Requires the Director to adopt rules that prescribe procedures consistent with BHE statutes. 
24. Increases the cap on civil penalties for violation of health care institution statutes from $500 to 
$10,000 per violation, for each day that a violation occurs.  
25. Sets the minimum civil penalty for violation of health care institution statutes at $1,500 per 
violation, for each day that a violation occurs, for each resident or patient determined to be 
impacted the violation.  FACT SHEET – Amended  
S.B. 1655 
Page 4 
 
 
26. Requires the Director, in addition to any other civil penalty and absent a demonstration of good 
cause, to assess a civil penalty, of at least $5,000 and no more than $10,000, against any BHE 
with repeated violations, to be assessed for each resident determined to be impacted by the 
violations.  
27. Requires the Director to issue notices of assessment and for the notice to include the amount 
of the assessment. 
28. Requires DHS, in determining the amount of a civil penalty for violation of health care 
institution statutes, to consider the: 
a) number of injuries caused; 
b) severity of the injuries caused; 
c) number of deaths caused; and 
d) the cause of deaths. 
29. Requires, rather than allows, the Director, to complete outlined tasks related to the regulation 
and oversight of health care institutions.  
30. Sets the grace period for paying health care institution application and licensing fees at 30 days. 
Sober Living Homes 
31. Requires sober living homes that incorporate as a business to: 
a) file all documents required for incorporation within 10 business days before opening to 
conduct business; and 
b) display its license number on all documents. 
32. Requires the Arizona Corporation Commission (ACC) to check identification documents of a 
person that files for incorporation as a behavioral health entity or sober living home, which 
must occur at ACC. 
33. Requires the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System, the Attorney General and DHS, 
within 10 days of receiving information relating to a behavioral health entity or an incorporated 
sober living home, to notify the ACC of: 
a) a license denial, expiration, suspension, termination or revocation; 
b) the issuance of a central authorization file notice; 
c) a bankruptcy filing; 
d) litigation; and 
e) criminal charges or conviction. 
34. Requires the ACC to provide a special designation to a behavioral health entity or sober living 
home that files for incorporation. 
35. Requires any change in ownership, name or license status of a behavioral health entity to be 
coordinated and approved by the ACC, in writing, in cooperation with DHS. 
36. Exempts behavioral health entities and sober living homes from expedited filing services.  FACT SHEET – Amended  
S.B. 1655 
Page 5 
 
 
37. Prohibits the ACC from issuing a certificate of good standing to a domestic or foreign 
corporation if the corporation:  
a) is a behavioral health entity or a sober living home; and 
b) does not comply with statutes related to public health and safety.  
38. Requires the signature on a certificate of disclosure declaration for a corporation that is a 
behavioral health entity or sober living home to be notarized. 
39. Requires the name of an incorporated sober living home to contain the words "sober living 
home". 
40. Specifies that the address of an incorporated behavioral health entity or sober living home: 
a) may not be a post office box or statutory agent; and 
b) must be located in Arizona, within the county where it is located. 
41. Specifies that the statutory agent of an incorporated BHE or sober living home:  
a) must be an independent third-party that is at least 18 years old and resides in Arizona; and 
b) may not be a direct or indirect owner of a relative or spouse, a controlling person or party 
with a conflict of interest. 
42. Requires DHS minimum standards for sober living home licensure to include a requirement 
that a business license be issued at least 10 business days before the sober living home opens 
to conduct business. 
43. Requires employees, owners, contracted persons and volunteers of sober living homes, as a 
condition of licensure, continued licensure or employment, to both: 
a) submit a full set of fingerprints, at the applicant's cost, to DHS for the purpose of obtaining 
a state and federal criminal records check; and 
b) have a valid fingerprint clearance card. 
44. Allows DHS to exchange fingerprint data with the Federal Bureau of Investigation. 
45. Directs DHS to establish, by rule, annual continuing education and training requirements for 
employees, volunteers and contractors who work in sober living homes, including peer 
recovery support specialists. 
46. Requires sober living homes to maintain a staff to resident ratio of two paid staff members who 
provide monitoring or assistance to residents at the sober living home for every six residents. 
47. Requires sober living homes to hold employees responsible for the direct care and supervision 
of residents on-site, 24 consecutive hours per day, seven days per week.  
48. Requires sober living home licensees to provide verification to DHS that naloxone is accessible 
at each sober living home and that staff are knowledgeable and trained in its use. 
49. Requires, rather than allows, DHS to enter the premises of any licensed sober living home, at 
any reasonable time, to determine compliance and take action if the sober living home is 
noncompliant.  FACT SHEET – Amended  
S.B. 1655 
Page 6 
 
 
50. Prohibits a sober living home licensee that has had a license revoked in any state from 
reapplying for a licensure for a period of five years. 
51. Requires DHS to post on the parent page of its public website: 
a) the name, telephone number, license number and national provider identification number; 
and 
b) if applicable, the local jurisdiction business license number and licensure status of each 
certified and licensed sober living home that directly or indirectly received federal 
resources, federal monies or payment on behalf of beneficiaries with federal health care 
program benefits. 
52. Exempts sober living homes from confidentiality requirements and requires DHS to disclose 
the address of each sober living home. 
53. Asserts that a sober living home address is a public record and subject to public record laws. 
54. Requires sober living homes, to the extent allowed by federal law, to notify a new resident's 
family or next of kin within 72 hours of accepting the resident and for the notification to be 
documented in the resident's record. 
55. Prohibits sober living homes from coordinating, facilitating, arranging or soliciting 
transportation of a person to the sober living home if the person is obviously intoxicated or 
under the influence of a substance, unless the person is referred by an approved provider of a 
tribal health care program or regional behavioral health authority or is under order of the court. 
56. Requires sober living homes, for residents 18 years or older, to inquire, both verbally and in 
writing, whether the resident wants to be transported to the resident's place of residence or 
another safe living space in Arizona, as requested by the resident after discharge. 
57. Requires a sober living home resident's wishes regarding transportation to be documented on 
a DHS-prescribed form, signed by the resident and retained in the resident's medical record. 
58. Requires sober living homes to ensure safe and reliable transportation, if available, for 
residents who wish to be transported home or to another safe living space upon discharge. 
59. Requires sober living home managers and staff to notify DHS immediately, and no more than 
six hours, after any of the following occurs: 
a) the death of a resident, including whether the death may have been drug related; 
b) a resident needed immediate intervention by an emergency medical provider or other health 
care provider for a possible overdose or other drug or alcohol-related illness; 
c) a sex-related crime may have been committed at the sober living home; or 
d) any other incident specified in rule by DHS. 
60. Prohibits sober living home managers and staff from having a personal or intimate relationship 
with a resident. 
61. Requires sober living home managers and staff to contact law enforcement if informed that a 
resident may be involved in a sex-related crime.  FACT SHEET – Amended  
S.B. 1655 
Page 7 
 
 
62. Requires a sober living home licensee to ensure that any resident who is required to register as 
a sex offender does so within the statutorily required time frame after admission to the sober 
living home. 
Miscellaneous 
63. Exempts DHS, until June 30, 2025, from statutory rulemaking requirements for the purposes 
of amending rules related to health care institutions.  
64. Defines behavioral health entity as an adult behavioral health therapeutic home, behavioral 
health inpatient facility, behavioral health residential facility, substance abuse transitional 
facility or any person that provides behavioral health services related to substance use disorder, 
substance abuse, alcohol, drug abuse, or other behavioral health services, and that receives 
federal funds, or any federal healthcare program. 
65. Defines obviously intoxicated, person, publicly funded sober living home and vulnerable adult. 
66. Makes technical and conforming changes. 
67. Becomes effective on the general effective date. 
Amendments Adopted by Committee of the Whole 
1. Allows the Director, by rule, to establish a monitoring program for BHEs and prescribes 
requirements of the program. 
2. Removes the establishment of, and allocation of civil penalty monies to, the Indigenous 
Peoples Protection Revolving Fund. 
3. Sets the minimum civil penalty assessed for terminating the operation of a health care 
institution without proper handling of patient medical records, as prescribed, at $5,000. 
4. Allows civil penalties assessed for violations of health care institution or BHE statutes to be 
assessed for each resident or patient impacted by the violation. 
5. Removes the requirement that the Director assess a civil penalty against a person who violates 
health care institution statutes. 
6. Sets the minimum civil penalty for violation of health care institution statutes at $1,500 per 
violation, for each day that a violation occurs, for each resident or patient determined to be 
impacted by the violation. 
7. Requires the Director, in addition to any other civil penalty and absent a demonstration of good 
cause, to assess a civil penalty, of at least $5,000 and no more than $10,000, against any BHE 
with repeated violations, to be assessed for each resident determined to be impacted by the 
violations.  
8. Subjects a person associated with a residential care institution that operates without a license, 
rather than the institution itself, to a class 6 felony and daily civil penalty.  FACT SHEET – Amended  
S.B. 1655 
Page 8 
 
 
9. Removes modifications to DHS standards for nutrition and feeding assistant training programs. 
10. Prohibits the Director from accepting an accreditation report in lieu of a compliance inspection 
of a BHE, rather than a residential care institution. 
11. Removes the requirement that health care institutions maintain full compliance with all laws. 
12. Prohibits the Director from issuing more than two nonconsecutive provisional licenses to a 
single health care institution. 
13. Requires the Director, through the Attorney General, to bring action for an injunction to 
restrain a violation or to enjoin the future operation or maintenance of a BHE. 
14. Requires DHS, in addition to all other licensing standards and requirements, to establish a 
designated one-year license, by rule, for BHEs that use funds received directly or indirectly 
from any federal health care program. 
15. Prohibits DHS from: 
a) issuing a BHE license for greater than 12 months; 
b) issuing a temporary license to a behavioral health applicant or licensee; 
c) assessing a civil penalty on a BHE in an amount less than $5,000 or more than $10,000 for 
each violation; 
d) rescinding, in whole or in part, sanctions imposed on a BHE; 
e) authorizing or approving the removal of a BHE licensee and appointing another person to 
continue operation of the BHE pending further action, absent good cause and risk of life, 
health or safety of a patient; or 
f) authorizing or approving a license application for a currently licensed BHE while any 
enforcement or court action is pending against the current owner or licensee. 
16. Requires BHEs, when a resident is admitted for evaluation, to obtain and document a list of 
the resident's medications, allergies and emergency contact information by the resident's arrival 
date. 
17. Removes the prohibition on health care institution license approvals and ownership changes 
for institutions with pending enforcement or court action. 
18. Prescribes requirements for sober living homes and BHEs that file for incorporation as a 
business. 
19. Establishes background check and fingerprint clearance card requirements for sober living 
home employees and volunteers. 
20. Prescribes sober living home staffing requirements. 
21. Requires sober living home licensees to provide verification to DHS that naloxone is accessible 
at each sober living home and that staff are knowledgeable and trained in its use. 
22. Prohibits a sober living home licensee that has had a license revoked in any state from 
reapplying for a licensure for a period of five years.  FACT SHEET – Amended  
S.B. 1655 
Page 9 
 
 
23. Declares a person that operates or maintains a sober living home without a license guilty of a 
class 6 felony and subject to civil penalty. 
24. Exempts sober living homes from confidentiality requirements and asserts that sober living 
home addresses are subject to public record laws. 
25. Prohibits sober living homes from coordinating, facilitating, arranging or soliciting 
transportation of a person to the sober living home if the person is obviously intoxicated or 
under the influence of a substance. 
26. Applies BHE notification and resident transportation requirements to sober living homes. 
27. Establishes sober living home reporting requirements for the occurrence of outlined 
incidences.  
28. Defines terms. 
Senate Action 
HHS 2/13/24 DP 7-0-0 
Prepared by Senate Research 
March 22, 2024 
MM/SDR/slp