Page 1
February 14, 2023 SB 23-016
Legislative Council Staff
Nonpartisan Services for Colorado’s Legislature
Revised Fiscal Note
(replaces fiscal note dated January 20, 2023)
Drafting Number:
Prime Sponsors:
LLS 23-0213
Sen. Hansen
Rep. McCormick; Sirota
Date:
Bill Status:
Fiscal Analyst:
February 14, 2023
Senate Finance
Matt Bishop | 303-866-4796
matt.bishop@coleg.gov
Bill Topic: GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION REDUCTION MEASURES
Summary of
Fiscal Impact:
☒ State Revenue
☒ State Expenditure
☐ State Transfer
☒ TABOR Refund
☒ Local Government
☒ Statutory Public Entity
The bill creates a state income tax credit for new, electric-powered lawn equipment;
requires the Public Employees’ Retirement Association and insurance companies to
study climate risks to their investment portfolios; authorizes the Department of Natural
Resources to regulate Class VI injection wells; updates the state’s greenhouse gas
emissions reduction goals; and commissions a study on electric transmission capacity.
Beginning in FY 2023-24, the bill reduces state revenue and increases state, local,
and statutory public entity expenditures.
Appropriation
Summary:
For FY 2023-24, the bill requires appropriations of $457,454 to various state agencies.
See State Appropriations section for detail.
Fiscal Note
Status:
The revised fiscal note reflects the introduced bill, as amended by the Senate
Transportation and Energy Committee.
Table 1
State Fiscal Impacts Under SB 23-016
Budget Year
FY 2023-24
Out Year
FY 2024-25
Revenue General Fund ($5.4 million) ($11.2 million)
Total Revenue ($5.4 million) ($11.2 million)
Expenditures General Fund $265,664 $222,645
Cash Funds $191,790 $439,582
Centrally Appropriated $49,619 $93,201
Total Expenditures $507,073 $755,428
Total FTE 3.4 FTE 5.9 FTE
Transfers - -
Other Budget Impacts TABOR Refund ($5.4 million) ($11.2 million)
General Fund Reserve $39,850 $33,397 Page 2
February 14, 2023 SB 23-016
Summary of Legislation
The bill includes a number of provisions to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in the state. For
tax years 2024 to 2026, the bill creates a nonrefundable income tax credit equal to 30 percent of the
purchase price of new electric powered law equipment. The credit will be provided as a discount to
purchasers and then claimed by sellers as a credit against their taxes. If the value of the credit exceeds
the sellers tax liability, the credit may be carried forward for five years.
In addition, the bill:
establishes GHG reduction goals of 65 percent by 2035, and 80 percent by 2040, 90 percent by 2045,
and increases the 2050 goal to 100 percent;
requires insurance companies that report more than $100 million in premiums to complete an
annual climate risk disclosure;
requires the Public Employees’ Retirement Association (PERA) to include climate-risk
assessments in its annual investment stewardship report and to adopt proxy-voting procedures
that ensure that the PERA board’s voting decisions are in alignment with statewide greenhouse
gas pollution reduction goals;
specifies that wastewater thermal energy equipment is a type of pollution control device that may
be certified as pollution control equipment and that qualifies as a clean heat resource for utilities’
clean heat plans;
authorizes the Colorado Oil and Gas Conservation Commission (COGCC) to regulate Class VI
Injection Wells after publically determining that the COGCC has the necessary resources to ensure
the safe and effective regulation of these wells;
modifies how fixed bill credits are calculated for community solar gardens that receive a net
metering credit from a utility;
expands the types of projects eligible for financing under the Colorado Electric Transmission
Authority Act to include facilities that are renovated, rebuilt, or reconditioned;
directs the Colorado Electric Transmission Authority (CETA) to conduct a study on the need for
expanded transmission, report on its findings to the PUC by September 1, 2024, and submit a final
report to the legislature by January 31, 2025; and
requires local governments to expedite review of land use applications to renovate, rebuild, or
recondition transmission lines.
Background
GHG emissions reduction targets. House Bill 19-1261, Climate Action Plan to Reduce Pollution,
establishes goals to reduce GHG emissions measured relative to the 2005 baseline emissions. This bill
updates the GHG reduction goals by adding intermediary targets and increasing the final 2050 goal.
Table 2
Changes to GHG Emissions Reduction Goals
Year Existing Goal SB 23-016 Goal
2025 26% 26%
2030 50% 50%
2035 n/a 65%
2040 n/a 80%
2045 n/a 90%
2050 90% 100% Page 3
February 14, 2023 SB 23-016
Class VI Geologic Sequestration Wells. Class VI wells are used for the geologic sequestration and
long-term storage of carbon dioxide in deep rock formations. Class VI injection permits are designed
to protect underground drinking water sources and are regulated by the U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA), in states, including Colorado, that have not enacted their own regulatory
process for these permits. Senate Bill 21-264 required the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) to
study the resource needed to safely and effectively regulate greenhouse gas sequestration. The
COGCC Class VI Report is the result.
This bill authorizes the COGCC to issue Class VI injection permits, which will require the COGCC to
pursue Class VI primacy with the EPA. The COGCC currently only has primacy for Class II wells,
which are used for the injection of fluids associated with oil and natural gas production. North Dakota
and Wyoming are the only states to have primacy for permitting Class VI wells.
As of January 2023, only two Class VI wells, both in Illinois, are currently permitted by the EPA. Thirty
additional permits are under consideration. Geologic sequestration is regulated under the federal Safe
Drinking Water Act for the purpose of protecting underground sources of drinking water.
State Revenue
Income tax credit for electric powered lawn equipment. The income tax credit is expected to
decrease General Fund revenue by $5.4 million in FY 2023-24 (half-year impact) and by $11.2 million
in FY 2024-25, with similar impacts through FY 2026-27. The bill reduces income tax revenue to the
General Fund, which is subject to TABOR.
Based on estimated per capita unit sales of electric lawn and garden equipment in California applied
to Colorado’s population, and assuming the credit will be utilized on 95 percent of qualifying
equipment purchases, the credit will be claimed on an estimated 205,400 units in 2024 and
208,900 units in 2025. This analysis assumes tax liability will exceed the value of the credit each year.
To the extent credits are carried forward, revenue impacts may vary from those estimated in this
analysis.
Pollution control equipment fees. By expanding the definition of “pollution control equipment” to
include wastewater thermal energy equipment, the bill may increase the number of applications
CDPHE receives to certify pollution control equipment. Fee revenue, which has not been estimated
and is subject to TABOR, accrues to the Pollution Control Equipment Certification Fund.
Injection well fees. If Colorado attains Class VI injection well primacy, COGCC may generate
fee-based revenue from well operators. This fee revenue, which has not been estimated, may begin to
accrue in FY 2024-25.
State Expenditures
The bill increases state expenditures in multiple state agencies by about $500,000 in FY 2023-24 and
$750,000 in FY 2024-25, from the General Fund and the Oil and Gas Conservation Cash Fund.
Expenditures are shown in Table 3 and detailed below.
Page 4
February 14, 2023 SB 23-016
Table 3
Expenditures Under SB 23-016
FY 2023-24 FY 2024-25
Department of Natural Resources
Personal Services $151,142 $369,022
Operating Expenses $2,160 $6,210
Capital Outlay Costs $13,340 $33,350
Legal Services $21,148 -
Training $4,000 $6,000
Computer Software - $25,000
Centrally Appropriated Costs
1
$31,789 $85,242
FTE – Personal Services 1.6 FTE 4.6 FTE
FTE – Legal Services 0.1 FTE -
DNR Subtotal $223,579 $524,824
Department of Public Health and Environment
Personal Services $28,433 $37,909
Legal Services $137,462 $164,954
Centrally Appropriated Costs
1
$5,969 $7,959
FTE – Personal Services 0.3 FTE 0.4 FTE
FTE – Legal Services 0.7 FTE 0.9 FTE
CDPHE Subtotal $171,864 $210,823
Department of Revenue
Personal Services $44,327 -
Operating Expenses $945 -
Capital Outlay Costs $6,670 -
Computer Programming and Testing $40,435 -
Office of Research and Analysis $7,392 $7,328
Document Management - $12,453
Centrally Appropriated Costs
1
$11,861 -
FTE – Personal Services 0.7 FTE -
DOR Subtotal $111,630 $19,781
Total $507,073 $755,428
Total FTE 3.4 FTE 5.9 FTE
1
Centrally appropriated costs are not included in the bill's appropriation.
Page 5
February 14, 2023 SB 23-016
Department of Natural Resources
Beginning in FY 2023-24, the DNR requires staff and other resources to develop and administer an
Underground Injection Control Program for Class VI injection wells. These costs will phase in over a
three-year period. Staffing levels are estimated based on departmental research following the
recommendations of the Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage Task Force and input from other
states that have applied for primacy to regulate Class VI wells. Standard operating and capital outlay
costs are included. This fiscal note assumes funds will be appropriated from the Oil and Gas
Conservation Cash Fund. When fully implemented, costs in DNR are estimated to total $711,385 and
7.0 FTE per year starting in FY 2025-26, assuming all necessary federal approval is received.
Primacy staff. Beginning in FY 2023-24, in order to assume permitting and enforcement authority,
the COGCC will hire a Class VI Coordinator and an Underground Injection Control Scientist to
oversee the application for primacy with the EPA, establish regulations for injection wells, and
then oversee the regulatory program. Establishing primacy is expected to take approximately one
and a half years, with the new regulatory program assumed to commence January 1, 2025. As
Class VI wells are an emerging technology, the new staff will require annual training costs to
attend relevant conferences, seminars, and workshops related to geological carbon sequestration.
Legal services. DNR requires 200 hours of legal services in FY 2023-24 only to conduct rulemaking
in conjunction with the application for primacy. Legal services are provided by the Department
of Law at a rate of $105.74 per hour. The additional hours equate to 0.1 FTE for the Department
of Law in FY 2023-24.
Regulatory staff. Assuming that primacy is granted, COGCC staff will require an additional
5.0 FTE beginning January 1, 2025, to implement all aspects of the program under EPA guidance,
including reviewing permits, evaluating environmental impacts, reporting to the EPA,
communicating with operators and the public about projects, and ensuring compliance with
permit conditions and Class VI well rules. In addition, hydrogeology staff will review injection
well permit applications to ensure underground drinking water sources will not be impacted by
injection operation, which can be accommodated with existing resources.
Computer software and hardware. In addition to staff to regulate Class VI wells, DNR will
purchase computer hardware and software to model underground reservoirs and simulate the
effects of GHG injections. Based on costs in another state that recently attained primacy, DNR
will have one-time costs of $15,000 in FY 2024-25 for the purchase of a server and costs for an
annual license fee of $10,000 for simulation software beginning in the same year.
Department of Public Health and Environment
The bill increases staff and legal services costs in CDPHE to support the COGCC and the
implementation of the new emissions reduction goals beginning in FY 2023-24.
Page 6
February 14, 2023 SB 23-016
Rulemaking support. Current law requires CDPHE to consult with COGCC on the public health
impacts of its rules and certain duties. CDPHE requires 0.4 FTE Environmental Protection
Specialist III beginning in FY 2023-24 to support the rulemaking and implementation of the
Underground Injection Control Program. Standard operating and capital outlay costs are
included, and costs have been prorated in FY 2023-24 for a September 1 start date and the General
Fund pay date shift.
Legal services. CDPHE requires 1,560 hours of legal services beginning in FY 2023-24 to support
the implementation of the new emissions reduction goals. Legal services, which are prorated in
FY 2023-24 to reflect the bill’s effective date, are provided by the Department of Law at a rate of
$105.74 per hour. The additional hours equate to 0.7 FTE in FY 2023-24 and 0.9 FTE in subsequent
years for the Department of Law. In addition, the CDPHE may require additional legal services
funding if the new goals result in subsequent litigation. This will be addressed through the annual
budget process.
Pollution control equipment certification. Workload may increase to process additional
applications to certify wastewater thermal energy equipment. These costs, which are expected to
be minimal, are paid from the Pollution Control Equipment Certification Fund.
Department of Revenue
Expenditures will increase in the Department of Revenue by to implement the new tax credit included
in the bill.
Computer programming and testing. For FY 2023-24 only, the bill requires changes to the DOR’s
GenTax system and additional computer and user acceptance testing. Approximately 83 hours of
computer programming will be required to make changes in the GenTax system, totaling $18,675.
Additional computer and user acceptance testing are required to ensure programming changes
are functioning properly, resulting in an additional $21,760. Costs also include 0.7 FTE for
development and testing support. Standard operating and capital outlay costs are included.
Document management. The bill requires an additional $12,453 in expenditures to implement
tax form changes in FY 2024-25. These expenditures will be reappropriated to the Department of
Personnel and Administration.
Data reporting. Beginning in FY 2023-24, the Office of Research and Analysis within the DOR
will expend $7,328 each year to collect and report data on the new tax credit.
Department of Regulatory Agencies
Workload will increase in FY 2023-24 in the Division of Insurance and the Public Utilities Commission,
which can be accommodated within existing appropriations.
Insurance climate risk disclosure. Workload will increase for rulemaking by the Commissioner
of Insurance regarding insurers’ requirement to participate in the annual insurer climate risk
disclosure survey, and to notify insurers that meet the threshold requirements established in the
bill with the survey and instructions.
Page 7
February 14, 2023 SB 23-016
Public Utilities Commission. Workload will increase to update rules regarding community solar
gardens, which can be accomplished within the normal course of business.
Other Expenditure Impacts
All state agencies—emission reduction targets. Meeting the updated greenhouse gas emissions
reduction goals may require developing new strategies or programs relative to current law, which
may increase state expenditures in future years. The fiscal note assumes that, in the short term,
existing state resources are sufficient and that any changes will be addressed through the annual
budget process.
Centrally appropriated costs. Pursuant to a Joint Budget Committee policy, certain costs associated
with this bill are addressed through the annual budget process and centrally appropriated in the Long
Bill or supplemental appropriations bills, rather than in this bill. These costs, which include employee
insurance and supplemental employee retirement payments, are shown in Table 3.
Other Budget Impacts
TABOR refunds. The bill is expected to decrease the amount of state revenue required to be refunded
to taxpayers by the amounts shown in the State Revenue section above. This estimate assumes the
December 2022 LCS revenue forecast. A forecast of state revenue subject to TABOR is not available
beyond FY 2024-25. Because TABOR refunds are paid from the General Fund, decreased General
Fund revenue will lower the TABOR refund obligation, but result in no net change to the amount of
General Fund otherwise available to spend or save.
General Fund reserve. Under current law, an amount equal to 15 percent of General Fund
appropriations must be set aside in the General Fund statutory reserve. Based on this fiscal note, the
bill is expected to increase the amount of General Fund held in reserve by the amounts shown in
Table 1, decreasing the amount of General Fund available for other purposes.
Local Government
Workload may increase in local governments to update procedures for the requirement to expedite
review of certain land use applications. This workload is expected to be minimal.
Statutory Public Entity
Colorado Electric Transmission Authority
The bill increases expenditures in CETA to conduct the required study on expanded transmission
capacity. The study is expected to cost approximately $150,000, beginning in FY 2023-24 and
concluding in FY 2024-25 once the required reports are finalized. Costs are paid from the Electric
Transmission Operational Fund, which is continuously appropriated to CETA.
Page 8
February 14, 2023 SB 23-016
Public Employees’ Retirement Association
The bill increases expenditures in PERA related to proxy voting and updating its annual Investment
Stewardship Report.
Proxy voting procedures. The bill requires the PERA Board of Trustees to adopt proxy voting
procedures that ensure that the board’s decisions align with the statewide greenhouse gas
pollution reduction goals. Expenditures will increase in PERA to adopt changes to proxy
guidelines; research and evaluate proxy ballot proposals; and monitor compliance. The additional
workload will vary annually depending on how many proxy ballots are evaluated. For
informational purposes, PERA voted on approximately 200 proposals in 2022 that were directly
related to greenhouse gas emissions, renewable energy, or other environmental topics, and other
kinds of proposals could reasonably have an indirect relationship with Colorado’s greenhouse gas
pollution reduction goals and require similar analysis. PERA estimates annual costs of
approximately $430,000 and 2.5 FTE per year to comply with these requirements, paid equally
from the division’s trust.
Investment Stewardship Report. PERA currently publishes an Investment Stewardship Report
that explains how PERA's investment philosophy addresses climate-related risks. The bill
requires PERA to include additional detail on the process for identifying climate-related risks and
assessing and addressing risks to its investment portfolio. Workload will increase in PERA to
meet these additional requirements.
Effective Date
The bill takes effect 90 days following adjournment of the General Assembly sine die, assuming no
referendum petition is filed.
State Appropriations
For FY 2023-24, the bill requires the following appropriations:
$191,790 from the Oil and Gas Conservation Cash Fund to the Department of Natural Resources,
and 1.6 FTE. Of this amount, $21,148 is reappropriated to the Department of Law, with an
additional 0.1 FTE.
$165,895 from the General Fund to the Department of Public Health and Environment and 0.3 FTE.
Of this amount, $137,462 is reappropriated to the Department of Law, with an additional 0.7 FTE.
$99,769 from the General Fund to the Department of Revenue, and 0.7 FTE.
State and Local Government
Counties Information Technology Labor
Law Municipalities Natural Resources
PERA Personnel and Administration Public Health and Environment
Regulatory Agencies Revenue Transportation
The revenue and expenditure impacts in this fiscal note represent changes from current law under the bill for each
fiscal year. For additional information about fiscal notes, please visit: leg.colorado.gov/fiscalnotes.