First Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO INTRODUCED LLS NO. 23-0483.02 Jessica Herrera x4218 SENATE BILL 23-111 Senate Committees House Committees Local Government & Housing A BILL FOR AN ACT C ONCERNING PUBLIC EMPLOYEES ' WORKPLACE PROTECTION .101 Bill Summary (Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov .) The "National Labor Relations Act" does not apply to federal, state, or local governments and the "Colorado Labor Peace Act" excludes governmental entities, with an exception for mass transportation systems, leaving public employees without the protection afforded by these labor laws. The bill grants certain public employees, including individuals employed by counties, municipalities, fire authorities, school districts, public colleges and universities, library districts, special districts, public defender's offices, the university of Colorado hospital authority, the SENATE SPONSORSHIP Rodriguez, HOUSE SPONSORSHIP Woodrow, Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. Denver health and hospital authority, the general assembly, and a board of cooperative services, the right to: ! Discuss or express views regarding public employee representation or workplace issues; ! Engage in protected, concerted activity for the purpose of mutual aid or protection; ! Fully participate in the political process while off duty and not in uniform, including speaking with members of the public employer's governing body on terms and conditions of employment and any matter of public concern and engaging in other political activities in the same manner as other citizens of Colorado without discrimination, intimidation, or retaliation; and ! Organize, form, join, or assist an employee organization or refrain from organizing, forming, joining, or assisting an employee organization. The bill also prohibits certain public employers from discriminating against, coercing, intimidating, interfering with, or imposing reprisals against a public employee for engaging in any of the rights granted. The Colorado department of labor and employment (department) is charged with enforcing any alleged violation of these rights and is granted rule-making authority. A party may appeal the department's final decision to the Colorado court of appeals. The bill requires the court of appeals to give deference to the department. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1 SECTION 1. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add article 32 to title2 29 as follows:3 ARTICLE 324 Protections For Public Workers5 29-32-101. Short title. T HE SHORT TITLE OF THIS ARTICLE 32 IS6 THE "PROTECTIONS FOR PUBLIC WORKERS ACT".7 29-32-102. Legislative declaration. (1) T HE GENERAL ASSEMBLY8 HEREBY DECLARES THAT PUBLIC EMPLOYEES ARE THE BACKBONE OF THE9 STATE AND ENSURE THAT COLORADANS HAVE ACCESS TO STRONG PUBLIC10 SERVICES. HOWEVER, BECAUSE PUBLIC EMPLOYEES ARE EXEMPT FROM11 SB23-111-2- PROTECTIONS AFFORDED BY THE "NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS ACT"1 AND THE "COLORADO LABOR PEACE ACT", WHEN THEY SPEAK OUT ON2 ISSUES IN THEIR WORKPLACE OR COME TOGETHER WITH THEIR COWORKERS3 TO IMPROVE THEIR WORKING CONDITIONS , THEY CAN BE DISCIPLINED AND4 TERMINATED. THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FURTHER DECLARES THAT PUBLIC5 EMPLOYEES SHOULD HAVE THE FOLLOWING RIGHTS AND SHOULD BE6 PROTECTED FROM RETALIATION , INCLUDING DISCIPLINE OR TERMINATION,7 IF THEY CHOOSE TO EXERCISE THESE RIGHTS:8 (a) T O SPEAK OUT ON ISSUES OF PUBLIC CONCERN AND FULLY9 ENGAGE IN THE POLITICAL PROCESS OUTSIDE OF WORK IN THE SAME10 MANNER AS OTHER CITIZENS OF COLORADO;11 (b) T O SPEAK OUT ABOUT CONCERNS WITH THE TERMS AND12 CONDITIONS OF THEIR EMPLOYMENT ;13 (c) T O ENGAGE IN PROTECTED CONCERTED ACTIVITY FOR THE14 PURPOSE OF MUTUAL AID OR PROTECTION ;15 (d) T O ORGANIZE, FORM, JOIN, OR ASSIST AN EMPLOYEE16 ORGANIZATION OR TO REFRAIN FROM DOING SO ; AND17 (e) T O PURSUE AN EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION WITH THEIR18 COWORKERS WITHOUT INTERFERENCE .19 29-32-103. Definitions. A S USED IN THIS ARTICLE 32, UNLESS THE20 CONTEXT OTHERWISE REQUIRES :21 (1) "C OUNTY" MEANS ONLY:22 (a) A CITY AND COUNTY; AND23 (b) A COUNTY WITH A POPULATION OF LESS THAN SEVEN24 THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED PEOPLE PURSUANT TO THE OFFICIAL FIGURES OF25 THE MOST RECENT UNITED STATES DECENNIAL CENSUS.26 (2) "D IVISION" MEANS THE DIVISION OF LABOR STANDARDS AND27 SB23-111 -3- STATISTICS WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT .1 (3) "E MPLOYEE ORGANIZATION " MEANS AN ORGANIZATION IN2 WHICH PUBLIC EMPLOYEES MAY PARTICIPATE AND THAT EXISTS FOR THE3 PURPOSE, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, OF ACTING ON BEHALF OF AND FOR THE4 BENEFIT OF THE PUBLIC EMPLOYEES CONCERNING PUBLIC EMPLOYEE5 GRIEVANCES, LABOR DISPUTES, WAGES, HOURS, AND OTHER TERMS AND6 CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT. "EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION" INCLUDES ANY7 AGENTS OR REPRESENTATIVES OF THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION8 DESIGNATED BY THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION .9 (4) "G OVERNING BODY" MEANS THE ELECTED OR APPOINTED10 REPRESENTATIVE BODY OF A PUBLIC EMPLOYER .11 (5) "P UBLIC EMPLOYEE" MEANS AN INDIVIDUAL EMPLOYED BY A12 PUBLIC EMPLOYER.13 (6) (a) "P UBLIC EMPLOYER" MEANS:14 (I) A COUNTY OR A MUNICIPALITY;15 (II) A DISTRICT, BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT , SPECIAL16 DISTRICT CREATED PURSUANT TO TITLE 32, AUTHORITY, OR OTHER17 POLITICAL SUBDIVISION OF THE STATE, A COUNTY, OR A MUNICIPALITY;18 (III) T HE COLORADO SCHOOL FOR THE DEAF AND THE BLIND ,19 ESTABLISHED IN ARTICLE 80 OF TITLE 22;20 (IV) A STATE INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION, AS DEFINED IN21 SECTION 23-18-102 (10)(a), AND A LOCAL DISTRICT COLLEGE OPERATING22 PURSUANT TO ARTICLE 71 OF TITLE 23;23 (V) T HE OFFICE OF STATE PUBLIC DEFENDER CREATED IN SECTION24 21-1-101;25 (VI) T HE UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO HOSPITAL AUTHORITY26 CREATED IN SECTION 23-21-503;27 SB23-111 -4- (VII) THE DENVER HEALTH AND HOSPITAL AUTHORITY CREATED1 IN SECTION 25-29-103;2 (VIII) T HE JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE STAFF , THE LEGISLATIVE3 COUNCIL STAFF, THE OFFICE OF LEGISLATIVE LEGAL SERVICES, THE STAFF4 OF THE OFFICE OF THE CHIEF CLERK OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES ,5 AND THE SENATE SERVICES STAFF;6 (IX) T HE MAJORITY AND MINORITY CAUCUS STAFF OF THE HOUSE7 OF REPRESENTATIVES AND THE SENATE ; OR8 (X) A BOARD OF COOPERATIVE SERVICES ESTABLISHED PURSUANT9 TO THE "BOARDS OF COOPERATIVE SERVICES ACT OF 1965", ARTICLE 5 OF10 TITLE 22.11 (b) "P UBLIC EMPLOYER" DOES NOT INCLUDE THE STATE OR ANY12 POLITICAL SUBDIVISION OF THE STATE WHERE THE STATE OR POLITICAL13 SUBDIVISION OF THE STATE ACQUIRES OR OPERATES A MASS14 TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM , OR ANY CARRIER BY RAILROAD , EXPRESS15 COMPANY, OR SLEEPING CAR COMPANY SUBJECT TO THE FEDERAL16 "R AILWAY LABOR ACT", 45 U.S.C. SEC. 151 ET SEQ., AS AMENDED.17 (7) "U NFAIR LABOR PRACTICE" MEANS A VIOLATION OF THE RIGHTS18 OR OBLIGATIONS DESCRIBED IN THIS ARTICLE 32.19 29-32-104. Protections for public workers. (1) A PUBLIC20 EMPLOYEE HAS THE RIGHT TO:21 (a) D ISCUSS OR EXPRESS THE PUBLIC EMPLOYEE 'S VIEWS22 REGARDING PUBLIC EMPLOYEE REPRESENTATION , WORKPLACE ISSUES, OR23 THE RIGHTS GRANTED TO THE PUBLIC EMPLOYEE IN THIS ARTICLE 32;24 (b) E NGAGE IN PROTECTED , CONCERTED ACTIVITY FOR THE25 PURPOSE OF MUTUAL AID OR PROTECTION ;26 (c) F ULLY PARTICIPATE IN THE POLITICAL PROCESS WHILE OFF27 SB23-111 -5- DUTY AND NOT IN UNIFORM, INCLUDING:1 (I) S PEAKING WITH MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC EMPLOYER 'S2 GOVERNING BODY ON TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT AND ANY3 MATTER OF PUBLIC CONCERN; AND4 (II) E NGAGING IN OTHER POLITICAL ACTIVITIES IN THE SAME5 MANNER AS OTHER CITIZENS OF COLORADO, WITHOUT DISCRIMINATION,6 INTIMIDATION, OR RETALIATION; AND7 (d) O RGANIZE, FORM, JOIN, OR ASSIST AN EMPLOYEE8 ORGANIZATION OR REFRAIN FROM OR GANIZING , FORMING, JOINING, OR9 ASSISTING AN EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION .10 (2) A PUBLIC EMPLOYER SHALL NOT:11 (a) D ISCRIMINATE AGAINST, COERCE, INTIMIDATE, INTERFERE12 WITH, OR IMPOSE REPRISALS AGAINST, OR THREATEN TO DISCRIMINATE13 AGAINST, COERCE, INTIMIDATE, INTERFERE WITH, OR IMPOSE REPRISALS14 AGAINST, ANY PUBLIC EMPLOYEE FOR ENGAGING IN ANY OF THE RIGHTS15 DESCRIBED IN THIS ARTICLE 32;16 (b) D OMINATE OR INTERFERE IN THE ADMINISTRATION OF AN17 EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION ; OR18 (c) D ISCHARGE OR DISCRIMINATE AGAINST A PUBLIC EMPLOYEE19 BECAUSE THE PUBLIC EMPLOYEE HAS FILED AN AFFIDAVIT , PETITION, OR20 COMPLAINT OR GIVEN ANY INFORMATION OR TESTIMONY PURSUANT TO21 THIS ARTICLE 32, OR BECAUSE THE PUBLIC EMPLOYEE HAS FORMED ,22 JOINED, ASSISTED, OR CHOSEN TO BE REPRESENTED BY AN EMPLOYEE23 ORGANIZATION.24 29-32-105. Enforcement - rules. (1) A N AGGRIEVED PARTY IS25 BARRED FROM FILING A CLAIM THAT ALLEGES THAT A PUBLIC EMPLOYER26 HAS VIOLATED THIS ARTICLE 32 UNLESS THE CLAIM IS FILED WITHIN SIX27 SB23-111 -6- MONTHS AFTER THE DATE ON WHICH THE AGGRIEVED PARTY KNEW OR1 REASONABLY SHOULD HAVE KNOWN OF THE ALLEGED VIOLATION .2 (2) T HE DIVISION SHALL ENFORCE THE RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS3 OF THIS ARTICLE 32 AND SHALL PROMULGATE RULES AS MAY BE4 NECESSARY FOR SUCH ENFORCEMENT . THE DIVISION SHALL PROMULGATE5 SUCH RULES WITHIN ONE HUNDRED EIGHTY DAYS AFTER THE EFFECTIVE6 DATE OF THIS ARTICLE 32.7 (3) T HE DIVISION HAS THE AUTHORITY TO ADJUDICATE UNFAIR8 LABOR PRACTICE CHARGES AND ISSUE DECISIONS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE9 3 OF TITLE 8.10 (4) A PARTY MAY APPEAL THE DIVISION'S FINAL DECISION TO THE11 C OLORADO COURT OF APPEALS AND THE COURT 'S REVIEW MUST BE12 LIMITED TO DETERMINING WHETHER THE DIVISION HAS EXCEEDED ITS13 JURISDICTION OR ABUSED ITS DISCRETION BASED ON THE EVIDENCE IN THE14 RECORD BEFORE THE DIVISION.15 (5) T HE COURT OF APPEALS SHALL UPHOLD THE ACTION OF THE16 DIVISION AND TAKE APPROPRIATE STEPS TO ENFORCE THE ACTION UNLESS17 THE COURT CONCLUDES THAT THE FINAL DECISION IS :18 (a) A RBITRARY, CAPRICIOUS, OR AN ABUSE OF DISCRETION; OR19 (b) O THERWISE NOT IN ACCORDANCE WITH LAW .20 (6) T HE DIVISION MAY ENFORCE PROVISIONS OF THIS ARTICLE 3221 THROUGH THE IMPOSITION OF APPROPRIATE ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES ,22 INCLUDING REMEDIES TO ADDRESS ANY LOSS SUFFERED BY A PUBLIC23 EMPLOYEE OR GROUP OF PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FROM UNLAWFUL CONDUCT .24 29-32-106. Exemptions. (1) T HE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION25 SHALL NOT WAIVE THIS ARTICLE 32 OR ANY PROVISION OF THIS ARTICLE 3226 AS IT PERTAINS TO AN INNOVATION SCHOOL OR INNOVATION SCHOOL ZONE27 SB23-111 -7- OF A SCHOOL DISTRICT OF INNOVATION PURSUANT TO SECTION1 22-32.5-108.2 (2) T HE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION SHALL NOT :3 (a) I NCLUDE ANY PROVISION OF THIS ARTICLE 32 ON THE LIST OF4 AUTOMATIC WAIVERS CREATED PURSUANT TO SECTION 22-30.5-104 (6)(b);5 OR6 (b) G RANT A WAIVER OF ANY PROVISION OF THIS ARTICLE 32 TO A7 CHARTER SCHOOL OR A SCHOOL DISTRICT ACTING ON BEHALF OF A8 CHARTER SCHOOL PURSUANT TO SECTION 22-30.5-104 (6)(c).9 (3) A SCHOOL DISTRICT, ON BEHALF OF A CHARTER SCHOOL, SHALL10 NOT APPLY TO THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION FOR A WAIVER OF ANY11 PROVISION OF THIS ARTICLE 32 PURSUANT TO SECTION 22-30.5-104 (6)(c).12 (4) T HE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION SHALL NOT WAIVE ANY OF13 THE REQUIREMENTS OR PROVISIONS OF THIS ARTICLE 32.14 SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 29-5-215 as15 follows:16 29-5-215. Protect public workers. O N AND AFTER THE EFFECTIVE17 DATE OF ARTICLE 32 OF THIS TITLE 29, FIREFIGHTERS SHALL HAVE ALL THE18 RIGHTS AND PROTECTIONS ENUMERATED UNDER ARTICLE 32 OF THIS TITLE19 29.20 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 22-2-117 amend21 (1)(b)(IX), (1)(b)(X), and (1.5); and add (1)(b)(XI) as follows:22 22-2-117. Additional power - state board - waiver of23 requirements - rules. (1) (b) The state board shall not waive any of the24 requirements specified in any of the following statutory provisions:25 (IX) Any provisions of section 22-1-128 relating to26 comprehensive human sexuality education content requirements; or 27 SB23-111 -8- (X) Any provision of section 22-30.5-104 (3), 22-30.5-507 (3),1 22-32-109 (1)(ll), 22-32-110 (1)(k), 22-38-104 (1)(d), or 22-63-206 (1)2 relating to discrimination based on hair texture, hair type, or a protective3 hairstyle that is commonly or historically associated with race; OR4 (XI) A NY PROVISION OF ARTICLE 32 OF TITLE 29.5 (1.5) Notwithstanding any provision of this section or any other6 provision of law, the state board shall not waive requirements contained7 in article 11 of this title or TITLE 22; sections 22-7-1006.3, 22-32-105,8 22-32-109 (1)(bb)(I) and (2), 22-32-109.1 (2)(a), 22-32-146, and9 22-33-104 (4); OR ANY PROVISION OF ARTICLE 32 OF TITLE 29.10 SECTION 4. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 22-30.5-104, amend11 (6)(b)(II.5), (6)(b)(III), (6)(c)(VIII), and (6)(c)(IX); and add (6)(b)(IV)12 and (6)(c)(X) as follows:13 22-30.5-104. Charter school - requirements - authority - rules14 - definitions. (6) (b) The state board shall promulgate rules that list the15 automatic waivers for all charter schools. In promulgating the list of16 automatic waivers, the state board shall consider the overall impact and17 complexity of the requirements specified in the statute and the potential18 consequences that waiving the statute may have on the practices of a19 charter school. In accordance with its rule-making authority, the state20 board may review the list of automatic waivers at its discretion.21 Notwithstanding any provision of this subsection (6)(b) to the contrary,22 the state board shall not include the following statutes on the list of23 automatic waivers:24 (II.5) Section 22-32-110 (1)(y), concerning the power to accept25 and expend gifts, donations, or grants; and 26 (III) Part 2 of article 63 of this title 22, concerning the27 SB23-111 -9- employment of licensed personnel; AND1 (IV) A NY PROVISION OF ARTICLE 32 OF TITLE 29.2 (c) A school district, on behalf of a charter school, may apply to3 the state board for a waiver of a state statute or state rule that is not an4 automatic waiver. Notwithstanding any provision of this subsection (6)5 to the contrary, the state board may not waive any statute or rule relating6 to:7 (VIII) Section 22-33-106.1 concerning suspension and expulsion8 of students in preschool through second grade; or 9 (IX) Subsection (3) of this section and sections 22-32-110 (1)(k)10 and 22-63-206 (1) relating to discrimination based on hair texture, hair11 type, or a protective hairstyle that is commonly or historically associated12 with race; OR13 (X) A NY PROVISION OF ARTICLE 32 OF TITLE 29.14 SECTION 5. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 22-30.5-507, amend15 (7)(a)(II.5), (7)(a)(III), (7)(b)(VIII), and (7)(b)(IX); and add (7)(a)(IV)16 and (7)(b)(X) as follows:17 22-30.5-507. Institute charter school - requirements -18 authority - rules - definitions. (7) (a) Pursuant to the charter contract,19 an institute charter school may operate free from specified statutes and20 state board rules. The state board shall promulgate rules that list the21 automatic waivers for all charter schools, including institute charter22 schools. In promulgating the list of automatic waivers, the state board23 shall consider the overall impact and complexity of the requirements24 specified in the statute and the potential consequences that waiving the25 statute may have on the practices of a charter school, including an26 institute charter school. In accordance with its rule-making authority, the27 SB23-111 -10- state board may review the list of automatic waivers at its discretion.1 Notwithstanding any provision of this subsection (7)(a) to the contrary,2 the state board shall not include the following statutes on the list of3 automatic waivers:4 (II.5) Section 22-32-110 (1)(y), concerning the power to accept5 and expend gifts, donations, or grants; and6 (III) Part 2 of article 63 of this title 22, concerning the7 employment of licensed personnel; AND8 (IV) A NY PROVISION OF ARTICLE 32 OF TITLE 29.9 (b) An institute charter school may apply to the state board,10 through the institute, for a waiver of state statutes and state rules that are11 not automatic waivers. The state board may waive state statutory12 requirements or rules promulgated by the state board; except that the state13 board may not waive any statute or rule relating to:14 (VIII) Section 22-33-106.1 concerning suspension and expulsion15 of students in preschool through second grade; or 16 (IX) Subsection (3) of this section and sections 22-32-110 (1)(k)17 and 22-63-206 (1) relating to discrimination based on hair texture, hair18 type, or a protective hairstyle that is commonly or historically associated19 with race; OR20 (X) A NY PROVISION OF ARTICLE 32 OF TITLE 29.21 SECTION 6. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 22-32.5-108, amend22 (1)(b) and (1)(c); and add (1)(d) as follows:23 22-32.5-108. District of innovation - waiver of statutory and24 regulatory requirements. (1) Upon designation of a district of25 innovation, the state board shall waive any statutes or rules specified in26 the school district's innovation plan as they pertain to the innovation27 SB23-111 -11- schools or innovation school zones of the district of innovation; except1 that the state board shall not waive:2 (b) Any provision of article 64 of this title; or TITLE 22;3 (c) Any statutes that are not included in this title TITLE 22,4 including but not limited to article 51 of title 24; C.R.S. OR5 (d) A NY PROVISION OF ARTICLE 32 OF TITLE 29.6 SECTION 7. Act subject to petition - effective date. This act7 takes effect at 12:01 a.m. on the day following the expiration of the8 ninety-day period after final adjournment of the general assembly; except9 that, if a referendum petition is filed pursuant to section 1 (3) of article V10 of the state constitution against this act or an item, section, or part of this11 act within such period, then the act, item, section, or part will not take12 effect unless approved by the people at the general election to be held in13 November 2024 and, in such case, will take effect on the date of the14 official declaration of the vote thereon by the governor.15 SB23-111 -12-