First Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO ENGROSSED This Version Includes All Amendments Adopted on Second Reading in the House of Introduction LLS NO. 23-0838.02 Chelsea Princell x4335 SENATE BILL 23-288 Senate Committees House Committees Health & Human Services Appropriations A BILL FOR AN ACT C ONCERNING MEASURES TO DETERMINE COVERAGE FOR DOULA101 SERVICES, AND, IN CONNECTION THEREWITH , MAKING AN 102 APPROPRIATION.103 Bill Summary (Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov .) Not later than September 1, 2023, the bill requires the department of health care policy and financing (state department) to initiate a stakeholder process to promote the expansion and utilization of doula services for pregnant and postpartum medicaid recipients (recipients). The bill requires the state department to work with a maternity SENATE Amended 2nd Reading April 26, 2023 SENATE SPONSORSHIP Fields and Buckner, HOUSE SPONSORSHIP English and Joseph, Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. advisory committee to create a report detailing the findings and recommendations from the stakeholder process and submit the report to the general assembly during the state department's "SMART Act" hearing. Not later than July 1, 2024, the bill requires the state department to seek federal authorization for medicaid providers to provide doula services for pregnant and postpartum people. The bill creates a doula scholarship program to provide financial support to eligible individuals to pursue doula training and certification. To be eligible for a scholarship, individuals must agree to enroll as a doula provider and provide doula services to recipients. The bill requires the division of insurance (division) to contract with an independent entity to study the potential health-care costs and benefits of providing coverage for doula services in health benefit plans. The bill requires the division to submit a report to the general assembly during the state department's "SMART Act" hearing detailing the results and recommendations from the study during the state fiscal year 2024-25. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1 SECTION 1. Legislative declaration. (1) The general assembly2 finds and declares that:3 (a) There is strong evidence of positive maternal and infant4 outcomes associated with doula services;5 (b) Doula care is associated with a reduction in the number of low6 birth weight babies, preterm births, cesarean sections, labor inductions,7 and other medical interventions, and is associated with increased rates of8 breast-feeding;9 (c) Most pregnant persons who utilize doula services have positive10 outcomes, and the association between doula support and positive11 perinatal outcomes is even stronger for low-income people, people of12 color, and people who experience cultural or language barriers to13 accessing pregnancy care. However, individuals and families who could14 benefit the most from doula services may have the least access to it,15 financially and culturally.16 288-2- (d) The United States has the highest rate of maternal mortality1 among developed countries, with 1,205 deaths due to maternal causes in2 2021;3 (e) It is estimated that more than 80 percent of the maternal4 mortalities in the United States are preventable;5 (f) Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention6 shows that nationally, Black pregnant persons are two to three times more7 likely to die from pregnancy-related causes than White pregnant persons.8 There are between 69 and 70 deaths per 100,000 live births for Black9 pregnant persons, compared to between 26 and 27 deaths per 100,000 live10 births for White pregnant persons, and 28 deaths per 100,000 live births11 for Hispanic pregnant persons.12 (g) High rates of maternal mortality among Black pregnant13 persons span income and education levels; moreover, risk factors such as14 a lack of access to prenatal care and physical health conditions do not15 fully explain the racial disparity in maternal mortality;16 (h) A growing body of evidence indicates that stress from racism17 can result in conditions such as hypertension and preeclampsia that18 contribute to poor maternal health outcomes among Black pregnant19 persons;20 (i) In the United States, one in three births is a cesarean section,21 which costs about 50 percent more than vaginal births. Studies suggest22 that having a doula reduces the need for a cesarean section by 25 percent.23 (j) Currently, Oregon and Minnesota permit medicaid coverage24 for doula services, and New York City has launched a doula pilot25 program. Studies in Oregon, Minnesota, and Wisconsin have shown that26 when pregnant individuals use a doula, it can save the state money.27 288 -3- (2) Therefore, the general assembly finds that providing doula1 services for medicaid recipients in Colorado would significantly improve2 health outcomes for pregnant and postpartum individuals and would help3 lower the maternal mortality rate in the state.4 SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 25.5-4-506 as5 follows:6 25.5-4-506. Coverage for doula services - stakeholder process7 - federal authorization - scholarship program - training - report -8 definitions. (1) A S USED IN THIS SECTION, UNLESS THE CONTEXT9 OTHERWISE REQUIRES:10 (a) "D OULA" MEANS A TRAINED BIRTH COMPANION WHO PROVIDES11 PERSONAL, NONMEDICAL SUPPORT TO PREGNANT AND POSTPARTUM12 PEOPLE AND THEIR FAMILIES PRIOR TO CHILDBIRTH , DURING LABOR AND13 DELIVERY, AND DURING THE POSTPARTUM PERIOD .14 (b) "M ATERNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE " MEANS THE COMMITTEE15 FACILITATED BY THE STATE DEPARTMENT COMPOSED PREDOMINANTLY OF16 B LACK, INDIGENOUS, AND OTHER PEOPLE OF COLOR WITH MATERNITY17 CARE EXPERIENCE AS RECIPIENTS.18 (2) N O LATER THAN SEPTEMBER 1, 2023, THE STATE DEPARTMENT19 SHALL INITIATE A STAKEHOLDER PROCESS TO PROMOTE THE EXPANSION20 AND UTILIZATION OF DOULA SERVICES FOR PREGNANT AND POSTPARTUM21 RECIPIENTS IN THE STATE. IN CONDUCTING THE STAKEHOLDER PROCESS ,22 THE STATE DEPARTMENT SHALL :23 (a) D ESIGN AN OUTREACH STRATEGY THAT INCLUDES BEST24 PRACTICES IN COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT , INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED25 TO:26 (I) E NGAGING TRUSTED COMMUNITY PARTNERS TO SUPPORT THE27 288 -4- WORK;1 (II) R EIMBURSEMENT OF PARTICIPATION COSTS FOR INDIVIDUALS2 WHO ARE NOT OTHERWISE PAID TO PARTICIPATE ;3 (III) R EIMBURSEMENT OF CHILD CARE COSTS FOR INDIVIDUALS4 WHO PARTICIPATE; AND5 (IV) T RANSLATION SERVICES AND MEETING TIMES THAT ALLOW6 DIVERSE AND INCLUSIVE PARTICIPATION;7 (b) S OLICIT FEEDBACK RELATED TO:8 (I) I NCLUDED TRAININGS OR CERTIFICATIONS FOR DOULAS ;9 (II) A BILLING PROCESS FOR DOULA SERVICES; 10 (III) W AYS TO RECRUIT DOULAS AND INTEGRATE THEM INTO11 HOSPITAL DELIVERIES;12 (IV) S UPPORT NEEDED TO BUILD AND RETAIN A DOULA13 WORKFORCE;14 (V) C OMMUNITY OUTREACH TO DETERMINE HOW TO BEST15 PROMOTE DOULA SERVICES; AND16 (VI) T HE DOULA SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM CREATED IN SUBSECTION17 (7) OF THIS SECTION.18 (3) S TAKEHOLDERS MUST BE DIVERSE WITH REGARD TO RACE ,19 ETHNICITY, IMMIGRATION STATUS, SEXUAL ORIENTATION, AND GENDER,20 AND MUST REPRESENT OTHER POPULATIONS THAT EXPERIENCE GREATER21 HEALTH DISPARITIES AND INEQUITIES . THE STATE DEPARTMENT MAY22 INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING IN THE STAKEHOLDER PROCESS :23 (a) D OULAS AND POTENTIAL DOULAS WHO MAY SERVE RECIPIENTS24 WHO INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, BLACK, INDIGENOUS, AND OTHER25 PEOPLE OF COLOR, REFUGEES, NON-ENGLISH SPEAKERS, PEOPLE LIVING IN26 RURAL AREAS, AND PEOPLE WHO WERE RECENTLY INCARCERATED ;27 288 -5- (b) INDIVIDUALS INDIRECTLY INVOLVED IN THE DELIVERY OF1 DOULA SERVICES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, CLINICAL PROVIDERS,2 HOSPITALS, MANAGED CARE ENTITIES, AND STATE PARTNERS, INCLUDING,3 BUT NOT LIMITED TO , THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND4 ENVIRONMENT, DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES , DEPARTMENT OF5 EARLY CHILDHOOD, AND DEPARTMENT OF REGULATORY AGENCIES ;6 (c) R EPRESENTATIVES FROM THE DIVISION OF INSURANCE WITH7 SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTISE; AND8 (d) R EPRESENTATIVES FROM THE MATERNITY ADVISORY9 COMMITTEE.10 (4) F OR STATE FISCAL YEAR 2024-25, THE STATE DEPARTMENT11 SHALL SUBMIT A REPORT TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AS PART OF THE12 STATE DEPARTMENT 'S "SMART ACT" PRESENTATION REQUIRED BY13 SECTION 2-7-203. THE REPORT MUST INCLUDE FINDINGS AND14 RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE STAKEHOLDER PROCESS AS DESCRIBED IN15 SUBSECTION (2) OF THIS SECTION. THE STATE DEPARTMENT SHALL WORK16 WITH THE MATERNITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE TO CREATE THE REPORT .17 (5) I N CARRYING OUT THE STAKEHOLDER PROCESS DESCRIBED IN18 SUBSECTION (2) OF THIS SECTION, THE STATE DEPARTMENT IS EXEMPT19 FROM THE "PROCUREMENT CODE", ARTICLES 101 TO 112 OF TITLE 24.20 (6) N OT LATER THAN JULY 1, 2024, THE STATE DEPARTMENT21 SHALL SEEK FEDERAL AUTHORIZATION TO PROVIDE DOULA SERVICES FOR22 PREGNANT AND POSTPARTUM PEOPLE TO IMPROVE HEALTH OUTCOMES OF23 PREGNANT AND POSTPARTUM PEOPLE WHO FACE A DISPROPORTIONATELY24 GREATER RISK OF POOR BIRTH OUTCOMES .25 (7) (a) N OT LATER THAN JULY 1, 2024, THE STATE DEPARTMENT26 SHALL CREATE A DOULA SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM THAT GRANTS FUNDS TO27 288 -6- INDIVIDUALS WITHOUT SUFFICIENT FINANCIAL RESOURCES TO COMPLETE1 DOULA TRAINING AND CERTIFICATION PROGRAMS NECESSARY TO PROVIDE2 DOULA SERVICES.3 (b) I N DESIGNING THE DOULA SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM , THE STATE4 DEPARTMENT SHALL SOLICIT INPUT FROM GROUPS IDENTIFIED IN5 SUBSECTION (3) OF THIS SECTION.6 (c) T HE STATE DEPARTMENT SHALL DEFINE ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA7 FOR THE DOULA SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM THAT INCLUDES , BUT IS NOT8 LIMITED TO, THE FOLLOWING:9 (I) P ROOF OF FINANCIAL HARDSHIP;10 (II) P ROOF OF STATE RESIDENCY; AND11 (III) A STATEMENT OF INTENT TO SERVE AS A DOULA PROVIDER IN12 C OLORADO FOR PREGNANT AND POSTPARTUM RECIPIENTS .13 (d) T HE STATE DEPARTMENT SHALL DEFINE CRITERIA FOR14 ORGANIZATIONS TO CONDUCT TRAINING AND CERTIFICATION PROGRAMS15 FOR DOULAS THAT INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO:16 (I) A N APPROVED CERTIFICATION PROCESS FOR DOULAS ;17 (II) A N EQUITABLE APPROACH TO DOULA RECRUITMENT AND18 TRAINING; AND19 (III) A N APPROVED BUDGET TO PROVIDE FREE TRAINING TO20 ATTENDEES.21 (e) T HE STATE DEPARTMENT MAY REQUIRE INDIVIDUALS WHO22 RECEIVE SCHOLARSHIP MONEY PURSUANT TO THE DOULA SCHOLARSHIP23 PROGRAM DESCRIBED IN THIS SUBSECTION (7) TO SUBMIT TO THE STATE24 DEPARTMENT, NOT LATER THAN SIX MONTHS AFTER THE INDIVIDUAL 'S25 COMPLETION OF DOULA TRAINING OR CERTIFICATION , DOCUMENTATION26 THAT THE INDIVIDUAL IS SERVING AS A DOULA FOR RECIPIENTS OR IS27 288 -7- WORKING TOWARD ENROLLMENT AS A DOULA MEDICAL ASSISTANCE1 PROVIDER. IF AN INDIVIDUAL DOES NOT COMPLETE THE DOCUMENTATION ,2 THE STATE DEPARTMENT MAY SEEK REPAYMENT OF THE FUNDS AWARDED3 TO THE INDIVIDUAL THROUGH THE DOULA SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM .4 (f) A NY MONEY APPROPRIATED TO THE DOULA SCHOLARSHIP5 PROGRAM AND NOT EXPENDED PRIOR TO JULY 1, 2024, IS FURTHER6 APPROPRIATED TO THE STATE DEPARTMENT THROUGH JUNE 30, 2025, TO7 BE USED FOR THE SAME PURPOSE.8 (g) N OTWITHSTANDING SECTION 24-1-136 (11)(a)(I), THE STATE9 DEPARTMENT SHALL REPORT ANNUALLY BEGINNING IN 2025 TO THE10 GENERAL ASSEMBLY AS PART OF THE STATE DEPARTMENT 'S "SMART11 A CT" PRESENTATION, AS REQUIRED BY SECTION 2-7-203, ON THE12 UTILIZATION AND OUTCOMES OF THE DOULA SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM .13 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 10-16-155.5 as14 follows:15 10-16-155.5. Actuarial review of doula services - report -16 definition. (1) T HE DIVISION SHALL CONTRACT WITH AN INDEPENDENT17 ENTITY TO CONDUCT AN ACTUARIAL REVIEW OF THE POTENTIAL18 HEALTH-CARE COSTS AND BENEFITS OF INCLUDING COVERAGE FOR DOULA19 SERVICES FOR PREGNANT AND POSTPARTUM PERSONS COVERED BY HEALTH20 BENEFIT PLANS.21 (2) T HE DIVISION SHALL PRESENT THE RESULTS FROM THE22 ACTUARIAL REVIEW CONDUCTED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (1) OF THIS23 SECTION TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AS PART OF THE DIVISION 'S "SMART24 A CT" PRESENTATION REQUIRED BY SECTION 2-7-203 DURING STATE FISCAL25 YEAR 2024-25.26 (3) A S USED IN THIS SECTION, UNLESS THE CONTEXT OTHERWISE27 288 -8- REQUIRES, "DOULA" MEANS A TRAINED BIRTH COMPANION WHO PROVIDES1 PERSONAL, NONMEDICAL SUPPORT TO PREGNANT AND POSTPARTUM2 PEOPLE AND THEIR FAMILIES PRIOR TO CHILDBIRTH , DURING LABOR AND3 DELIVERY, AND DURING THE POSTPARTUM PERIOD .4 SECTION 4. Appropriation. (1) For the 2023-24 state fiscal5 year, $100,000 is appropriated to the department of health care policy and6 financing for use by the other medical services division. This7 appropriation is from the general fund. To implement this act, the division8 may use this appropriation for the doula scholarship program.9 (2) For the 2023-24 state fiscal year, $100,000 is appropriated to10 the department of regulatory agencies for use by the division of insurance.11 This appropriation is from the division of insurance cash fund created in12 section 10-1-103 (3), C.R.S. To implement this act, the division may use13 this appropriation for personal services.14 SECTION 5. Safety clause. The general assembly hereby finds,15 determines, and declares that this act is necessary for the immediate16 preservation of the public peace, health, or safety.17 288 -9-