Second Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO REENGROSSED This Version Includes All Amendments Adopted in the House of Introduction LLS NO. 24-0240.01 Jery Payne x2157 HOUSE BILL 24-1051 House Committees Senate Committees Transportation, Housing & Local Government Finance Appropriations A BILL FOR AN ACT C ONCERNING THE REGULATION OF BUSINESSES THAT OBTAIN A PERMIT101 FROM THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION TO TOW MOTOR102 VEHICLES, AND, IN CONNECTION THEREWITH, MAKING AN103 APPROPRIATION.104 Bill Summary (Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov/ .) Transportation Legislation Review Committee. The bill requires a driver of tow trucks to undergo a fingerprint-based criminal history record check (check). If the check produces a criminal history that HOUSE 3rd Reading Unamended April 24, 2024 HOUSE Amended 2nd Reading April 23, 2024 HOUSE SPONSORSHIP Boesenecker and Mauro, SENATE SPONSORSHIP Gonzales and Priola, Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. the public utilities commission (commission) determines is inappropriate to drive a tow truck, the driver will not be permitted to drive the tow truck. Current law authorizes the commission to deny or refuse to renew a towing carrier permit if: ! The towing carrier was convicted within the last 5 years of a felony or a towing-related offense or has failed to satisfy a civil penalty imposed by the commission; or ! The commission determines that it is not in the public interest for the towing carrier to hold a towing carrier permit. The bill: ! Authorizes the commission to suspend or revoke a permit for each of these specified violations; ! Authorizes the commission to suspend or revoke a permit if it is not in the public interest for the towing carrier to hold a towing permit; and ! Sets a rebuttable presumption that it is not in the public interest for a towing carrier to hold a permit if the towing carrier has violated the towing laws. The bill prohibits a member of the towing task force in the department of regulatory agencies, which advises the commission on towing matters, from voting on a matter that will financially benefit the member or if the member is the subject of a complaint about which the task force is advising the commission. Current law requires the commission to report certain towing issues and financial information to certain committees of the Senate and House of Representatives of the general assembly. The bill requires the commission to promulgate a rule to require towing carriers to provide: ! Any information needed to prepare the report; ! Audited financial statements; and ! Any other information required by the commission. The bill directs the commission to aggregate and anonymize the financial statements and make the aggregated and anonymized data publicly available. A towing carrier is forbidden from patrolling or monitoring property to enforce parking restrictions on behalf of the property owner. Currently, the owner of a motor vehicle pays to retrieve the motor vehicle when the vehicle has been nonconsensually towed from another person's property. The bill requires certain property owners to pay for the removal of the vehicle from their property and for any storage for the first 30 days. The towing carrier is required to notify the vehicle owner that the vehicle owner can retrieve the vehicle free of charge for the first 30 days. If a motor vehicle is nonconsensually towed in violation of the 1051 -2- rights granted in state statute, the towing carrier must, within 48 hours after the determination of a statutory violation, return the vehicle to the place it was towed from. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1 SECTION 1. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-10.1-401, amend2 (2) as follows:3 40-10.1-401. Permit requirements - rules. (2) (a) (I) The4 commission may deny an application FOR or SUSPEND, REVOKE, OR refuse5 to renew a permit under this part 4 of a person who THAT has, within the6 immediately preceding five years, been convicted of, or pled guilty or7 nolo contendere to, a felony or a towing-related offense. The commission8 may also deny an application under this part 4 or SUSPEND, REVOKE, OR9 refuse to renew the permit of a towing carrier based upon a determination10 that the towing carrier or any of its owners, principals, officers, members,11 partners, or directors has not satisfied a civil penalty arising out of any AN12 administrative or enforcement action brought by the commission.13 (II) A TOWING CARRIER THAT APPLIES FOR A PERMIT OR THAT14 APPLIES TO RENEW A PERMIT SHALL DISCLOSE TO THE COMMISSION EACH15 PERSON THAT IS IDENTIFIED AS A PRINCIPAL IN ACCORDANCE WITH RULES16 PROMULGATED BY THE COMMISSION .17 (b) The commission may deny an application FOR or SUSPEND,18 REVOKE, OR refuse to renew a permit of a towing carrier under this part19 4 based on a determination that there is good cause to believe the20 issuance of or renewal of the permit IT is not in the public interest FOR21 THE TOWING CARRIER TO POSSESS A PERMIT. The determination is subject22 to appeal in accordance with commission rules. IT IS REBUTTABLY23 PRESUMED THAT A TOWING CARRIER'S POSSESSION OF A PERMIT IS NOT IN24 1051-3- THE PUBLIC INTEREST IF THE TOWING CARRIER HAS WILLFULLY AND1 REPEATEDLY FAILED TO COMPLY WITH THIS ARTICLE 10.1 OR PART 18 OR2 21 OF ARTICLE 4 OF TITLE 42.3 SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-10.1-403, amend4 (4)(d)(II); and add (3.5), (4)(e), and (4)(f) as follows:5 40-10.1-403. Towing task force - creation - conflict of interest6 - rules - report - repeal. (3.5) (a) A MEMBER SHALL NOTIFY THE TASK7 FORCE AND ABSTAIN FROM VOTING IF:8 (I) THE MEMBER WILL FINANCIALLY BENEFIT FROM, OR HAS A9 FINANCIAL INTEREST IN A PERSON THAT WILL BENEFIT FROM, A10 RATE-SETTING RECOMMENDATION MADE BY THE TASK FORCE ; OR11 (II) THE TASK FORCE IS ADVISING THE COMMISSION ABOUT A12 COMPLAINT, AND THE MEMBER IS THE SUBJECT OF THE COMPLAINT OR HAS13 A FINANCIAL INTEREST IN A PERSON THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE14 COMPLAINT.15 (b) A MEMBER DOES NOT HAVE A CONFLICT OF INTEREST IF THE16 MEMBER BENEFITS MERELY FROM BELONGING TO A CLASS THAT IS17 AFFECTED BY THE RATE SETTING DESCRIBED IN SUBSECTION (3.5)(a)(I) OF18 THIS SECTION.19 (4) (d) (II) This subsection (4)(d) is repealed, effective July 1,20 2026 SEPTEMBER 1, 2026.21 (e) BY SEPTEMBER 1, 2025, THE COMMISSION SHALL PROMULGATE22 RULES REQUIRING EACH TOWING CARRIER TO PROVIDE, AS A CONDITION23 OF PERMIT ISSUANCE OR RENEWAL ON OR AFTER A DATE SPECIFIED IN THE24 RULES, ANY INFORMATION NEEDED TO PREPARE THE REPORT REQUIRED BY25 SUBSECTION (4)(d)(I) OF THIS SECTION.26 (f) THE COMMISSION MAY PROMULGATE RULES TO COLLECT OTHER27 1051 -4- INFORMATION REQUIRED AS PART OF THE TOWING CARRIER PERMITTING1 PROCESS. THE INFORMATION REQUIRED BY RULE MAY INCLUDE THE2 ANNUAL VOLUME OF TOWS BY CATEGORY, THE CURRENT PRICING PER3 CATEGORY OF TOW FOR ALL FEES CHARGED, AND THE NUMBER OF TOW4 TRUCKS EACH TOWING CARRIER OPERATES .5 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-10.1-405, amend6 (3)(a)(IV) introductory portion, (3)(a)(IV)(A), (3)(a)(IV)(C), (3)(b)(I)(H),7 (3)(c), (4)(b)(II), (5)(b), (5)(c) introductory portion, (5)(d) introductory8 portion, and (8); repeal (4)(f)(III), (8), and (9)(b)(I); and add (3)(a)(V),9 (3)(d), (3)(e), (4)(f)(I)(C), and (5)(e) as follows:10 40-10.1-405. Nonconsensual tows - rights of owners,11 operators, and lienholders - rules. (3) Authorization, signs, and12 notice required for tows from private property. (a) A towing carrier13 shall not nonconsensually tow a vehicle from private property unless:14 (IV) The towing carrier has received DOCUMENTED permission,15 to WHICH MUST NOT BE AUTOMATED OR PREAPPROVED, FOR EACH16 INDIVIDUAL tow OF the vehicle, within the twenty-four hours immediately17 preceding the tow, from THE FOLLOWING PERSON THAT MUST DOCUMENT18 THE PERMISSION BY SIGNING THE FORM CREATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH19 SUBSECTION (3)(d)(I) OF THIS SECTION:20 (A) The owner of or leaseholder of the private property; EXCEPT21 THAT, IF THE OWNER OR LEASEHOLDER WOULD EARN INCOME FROM THE22 NONCONSENSUAL TOW, THE TOWING CARRIER SHALL NOT PERFORM THE23 NONCONSENSUAL TOW BUT MAY AUTHORIZE ANOTHER TOWING CARRIER24 TO PERFORM THE NONCONSENSUAL TOW ;25 (C) An agent EMPLOYEE of a person described in subsection26 (3)(a)(IV)(A) or (3)(a)(IV)(B) of this section OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A27 1051 -5- PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COMPANY RETAINED TO COLLECT RENT AND1 PERFORM RESIDENTIAL SERVICES; except that the towing carrier does not2 qualify as an agent with authority to grant permission under this3 subsection (3)(a) EMPLOYEE WHO HAS A FINANCIAL INTEREST IN OR4 RELATIONSHIP WITH THE TOWING CARRIER OR A PARKING LOT5 MANAGEMENT COMPANY THAT EARNS INCOME FROM MANAGING OR6 CONTROLLING PARKING OR PERMISSION TO PARK OR THAT EARNS INCOME7 FROM NONCONSENSUAL TOWS SHALL NOT GRANT PERMISSION TO8 AUTHORIZE THE TOW; OR9 (V) THE TOWING CARRIER HAS RECEIVED PERMISSION FOR EACH10 INDIVIDUAL TOW.11 (b) (I) Except as provided in subsection (3)(b)(IV) of this section,12 a towing carrier shall not nonconsensually tow a vehicle from a parking13 space or common parking area without the towing carrier or property14 owner giving the vehicle owner or operator twenty-four hours' written15 notice, unless:16 (H) The vehicle is parked without displaying valid authorization17 in a parking lot marked for the exclusive use of residents OR INVITED18 GUESTS.19 (c) In order for a towing carrier to conduct a nonconsensual tow,20 under subsection (3)(b)(I)(G) or (3)(b)(I)(H) of this section, the property21 owner must have posted signage visible and facing the driver at each22 entryway into a parking area indicating that parking spaces are designated23 for one or more specified residents and that a vehicle parked without24 authorization is subject to being towed. The sign must also contain the25 international towing symbol no smaller than four inches by four inches26 and be permanently mounted in a position that is no lower than five feet27 1051 -6- and no higher than eight feet THAT:1 (I) IS NOT LESS THAN TWO SQUARE FEET IN SIZE;2 (II) HAS LETTERING NOT LESS THAN ONE INCH IN HEIGHT ;3 (III) HAS LETTERING THAT CONTRASTS SHARPLY IN COLOR WITH4 THE BACKGROUND ON WHICH THE LETTERS ARE PLACED AND CONTRASTS5 SHARPLY WITH THE STRUCTURE THE SIGNS ARE PLACED ON ;6 (IV) CONTAINS THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION IN THE ORDER7 LISTED BELOW:8 (A) THE RESTRICTION OR PROHIBITION ON PARKING ;9 (B) THE TIMES OF THE DAY AND DAYS THAT THE RESTRICTION IS10 APPLICABLE; BUT, IF THE RESTRICTION APPLIES TWENTY-FOUR HOURS A11 DAY, SEVEN DAYS A WEEK, THE SIGN MUST SAY "AUTHORIZED PARKING12 ONLY"; AND13 (C) THE NAME AND TELEPHONE NUMBER OF THE TOWING CARRIER14 AUTHORIZED TO PERFORM TOWS FROM THE PRIVATE PROPERTY ;15 (V) IS PRINTED IN ENGLISH AND SPANISH;16 (VI) IS PERMANENTLY MOUNTED BOTH :17 (A) AT THE ENTRANCE TO THE PRIVATE PROPERTY SO THAT THE18 SIGN FACES OUTWARD TOWARD THE STREET AND IS VISIBLE BEFORE AND19 UPON ENTERING THE PRIVATE PROPERTY ; AND20 (B) INSIDE THE PRIVATE PROPERTY SO THAT THE SIGN FACES21 OUTWARD TOWARD THE PARKING AREA ;22 (VII) IS NOT OBSTRUCTED FROM VIEW OR PLACED IN A MANNER23 THAT PREVENTS DIRECT VISIBILITY; AND24 (VIII) IS NOT PLACED HIGHER THAN TEN FEET OR LOWER THAN25 THREE FEET FROM THE SURFACE CLOSEST TO THE SIGN 'S PLACEMENT.26 (d) (I) THE COMMISSION SHALL CREATE A FORM THAT IMPLEMENTS27 1051 -7- SUBSECTION (3)(a)(IV) OF THIS SECTION.1 (II) THE TOWING CARRIER MUST RETAIN FOR THREE YEARS THE2 SIGNED FORM REQUIRED BY SUBSECTION (3)(a)(IV) OF THIS SECTION AND,3 UPON REQUEST, PROVIDE THE SIGNED FORM TO THE VEHICLE OWNER .4 (e) A TOWING CARRIER SHALL NOT PATROL OR MONITOR PROPERTY5 TO ENFORCE PARKING RESTRICTIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PROPERTY6 OWNER.7 (4) Notice, disclosures, and towing carrier signs. (b) A towing8 carrier shall maintain a clearly visible sign at the entrance to the storage9 facility holding a nonconsensually towed vehicle. The sign must:10 (II) State: "If a vehicle is nonconsensually towed from private11 property, the owner AUTHORIZED OR INTERESTED PERSON may retrieve the12 contents of the vehicle even if the owner AUTHORIZED OR INTERESTED13 PERSON does not pay the towing carrier's fees. If the owner AUTHORIZED14 OR INTERESTED PERSON fills out the appropriate form, the owner15 AUTHORIZED OR INTERESTED PERSON may retrieve the vehicle after16 paying a reduced fee, but the owner AUTHORIZED OR INTERESTED PERSON17 still owes the towing carrier the balance of those fees."18 (f) (III) A towing carrier that enters into an agreement with a19 property owner to nonconsensually tow vehicles from the property shall20 post signs that:21 (A) Are no less than one square foot in size;22 (B) Have lettering not less than one inch in height;23 (C) Have lettering that contrasts with the background on which24 the letters are placed;25 (D) State: "Authorized Parking Only";26 (E) Include the name and telephone number of the towing carrier27 1051 -8- authorized to perform tows from the private property;1 (F) Are printed in English;2 (G) Are placed at the entrance to the private property, face3 outward toward the street, and are visible prior to entering and upon4 entering the private property;5 (H) Are placed inside the area used for parking, face toward the6 parking spaces, and, if the private property is not provided for residential7 parking and has more than ten freestanding lampposts on the property,8 are posted on each lamppost or posted upright near each lamppost;9 (I) Are not obstructed or placed in such a manner that prevents10 visibility; and11 (J) Are not placed higher than eight feet or lower than three feet12 from the ground surface closest to the sign's placement.13 (5) No mechanic's liens on contents. (b) If an authorized or14 interested person requests that a towing carrier return the contents of a15 vehicle that was towed without consent within thirty days after the16 postmarked date the notice was mailed in accordance with section17 42-4-2103 (4) or the date the operator received notice that no record18 exists for the motor vehicle, the towing carrier shall immediately retrieve19 or allow the authorized or interested person to retrieve the vehicle's20 contents. This subsection (5)(b) does not apply to the contents of a21 vehicle if the contents of the vehicle are subject to a hold order issued by22 a court, district attorney, law enforcement agency, or peace officer.23 (c) The towing carrier shall immediately retrieve a vehicle that24 has been nonconsensually towed or allow the owner AUTHORIZED OR25 INTERESTED PERSON to retrieve the vehicle if:26 (d) For an authorized or interested person to retrieve a vehicle27 1051 -9- without paying the towing carrier the total amount owed to the towing1 carrier, the authorized or interested person must sign a form affirming2 that the authorized or interested person owes the towing carrier payment3 for fees that comply with this article 10.1, part 21 of article 4 of title 42,4 or article 20 of title 38. Knowingly providing false information on the5 form is unlawful. Signing this form does not prohibit a vehicle owner6 from filing a complaint with the commission or pursuing other remedies.7 The towing carrier may use the form to take reasonable actions to collect8 the debt, including initiating a court action or using a collection agency.9 The department COMMISSION shall:10 (e) A TOWING CARRIER SHALL NOT REQUIRE A PERSON TO11 UNDERGO AN APPROVAL PROCESS OTHER THAN SIGNING THE FORM12 CREATED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (5)(d) OF THIS SECTION.13 (8) Towing carrier responsibility. For a nonconsensual tow, the14 towing carrier is responsible for the security and safety of the towed15 vehicle until it is released to an authorized or interested person.16 (9) Applicability. This section does not apply to:17 (b) A tow from a parking space that serves a business if:18 (I) The parking space is not in a common parking area; and19 SECTION 4. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-10.1-406, add20 (1)(c) as follows:21 40-10.1-406. Failure to comply. (1) No fees - return of vehicle.22 (c) WITHIN FORTY-EIGHT HOURS AFTER A TOW IS DETERMINED TO HAVE23 BEEN PERFORMED IN VIOLATION OF THIS ARTICLE 10.1 OR ANY RULES24 PROMULGATED UNDER THIS ARTICLE 10.1, THE TOWING CARRIER SHALL25 RETURN THE VEHICLE BACK TO THE LOCATION FROM WHERE IT WAS26 TOWED UNLESS:27 1051 -10- (I) THE AUTHORIZED OR INTERESTED PERSON NOTIFIES THE1 TOWING CARRIER THAT THE PERSON PREFERS TO RETRIEVE THE VEHICLE2 FROM THE TOWING CARRIER'S STORAGE FACILITY WITHOUT CHARGE ; OR3 (II) RETURNING THE VEHICLE TO THE LOCATION FROM WHERE THE4 VEHICLE WAS TOWED IS NOT PRACTICAL , AS DETERMINED BY THE5 COMMISSION.6 SECTION 5. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-10.1-409, amend7 (2) as follows:8 40-10.1-409. Violators subject to penalties. (2) A violation of9 this part 4 is a deceptive trade practice under section 6-1-105 (1)(ttt) AND10 (1)(eeee) and is subject to enforcement by the attorney general's office in11 addition to the OR A DISTRICT ATTORNEY OR enforcement AS described in12 this section.13 SECTION 6. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 40-10.1-411 as14 follows:15 40-10.1-411. Towing carrier responsibility. THE TOWING16 CARRIER IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SECURITY AND SAFETY OF THE TOWED17 VEHICLE UNTIL THE VEHICLE IS RELEASED TO AN AUTHORIZED OR18 INTERESTED PERSON.19 SECTION 7. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 6-1-105, add20 (1)(eeee) as follows:21 6-1-105. Unfair or deceptive trade practices. (1) A person22 engages in a deceptive trade practice when, in the course of the person's23 business, vocation, or occupation, the person:24 (eeee) IS A TOWING CARRIER AND CONDUCTS A NONCONSENSUAL25 TOW IN VIOLATION OF SECTION 40-10.1-405.26 SECTION 8. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-10.1-404, amend27 1051 -11- (1) as follows:1 40-10.1-404. Repeal of part - subject to review. (1) This part2 4 is repealed, effective September 1, 2025 2030. Before the repeal, this3 part 4 is scheduled for review in accordance with section 24-34-104 and4 subsection (2) of this section.5 SECTION 9. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 24-34-104, repeal6 (26)(a)(XIII); and add (31)(a)(XI) as follows:7 24-34-104. General assembly review of regulatory agencies8 and functions for repeal, continuation, or reestablishment -9 legislative declaration - repeal. (26) (a) The following agencies,10 functions, or both, are scheduled for repeal on September 1, 2025:11 (XIII) The public utilities commission's regulation of towing12 carriers under part 4 of article 10.1 of title 40.13 (31) (a) The following agencies, functions, or both, are scheduled14 for repeal on September 1, 2030:15 (XI) THE REGULATION OF TOWING CARRIERS BY THE PUBLIC16 UTILITIES COMMISSION UNDER PART 4 OF ARTICLE 10.1 OF TITLE 40.17 SECTION 10. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-10.1-116,18 amend (3) as follows:19 40-10.1-116. Commission to notify local authorities -20 procedure. (3) (a) A person injured by the noncompliance of a motor21 carrier with this article ARTICLE 10.1 or any other provision of law or an22 order, decision, rule, direction, or requirement of the commission may23 apply to a court of competent jurisdiction for the enforcement thereof,24 and the court has jurisdiction to enforce obedience thereto by injunction25 or other proper process, mandatory or otherwise, and to restrain the motor26 carrier and its officers, agents, employees, or representatives from further27 1051 -12- disobedience thereof, or to enjoin upon them obedience to the same, and1 any person so injured has cause of action in damages and is privileged to2 pursue the usual and proper remedies as in any other case.3 (b) SUBSECTION (3)(a) OF THIS SECTION CREATES AN4 INDEPENDENT CAUSE OF ACTION, WHICH IS NOT SUBJECT TO5 ADMINISTRATIVE EXHAUSTION, AGAINST A TOWING CARRIER THAT6 VIOLATED THIS ARTICLE 10.1 OR ANY OTHER PROVISION OF LAW OR AN7 ORDER, DECISION, RULE, DIRECTION, OR REQUIREMENT OF THE8 COMMISSION.9 SECTION 11. Appropriation. (1) For the 2024-25 state fiscal10 year, $165,629 is appropriated to the department of regulatory agencies.11 This appropriation is from the public utilities commission motor carrier12 fund created in section 40-2-110.5 (6), C.R.S. To implement this act, the13 department may use this appropriation as follows:14 (a) $42,973 for use by the public utilities commission for personal15 services, which amount is based on an assumption that the commission16 will require an additional 0.6 FTE;17 (b) $7,438 for use by the public utilities commission for operating18 expenses; and19 (c) $115,218 for the purchase of legal services.20 (2) For the 2024-25 state fiscal year, $115,218 is appropriated to21 the department of law. This appropriation is from reappropriated funds22 received from the department of regulatory agencies under subsection23 (1)(c) of this section and is based on an assumption that the department24 of law will require an additional 0.5 FTE. To implement this act, the25 department of law may use this appropriation to provide legal services for26 the department of regulatory agencies.27 1051 -13- SECTION 12. Act subject to petition - effective date -1 applicability. (1) This act takes effect at 12:01 a.m. on the day following2 the expiration of the ninety-day period after final adjournment of the3 general assembly; except that, if a referendum petition is filed pursuant4 to section 1 (3) of article V of the state constitution against this act or an5 item, section, or part of this act within such period, then the act, item,6 section, or part will not take effect unless approved by the people at the7 general election to be held in November 2024 and, in such case, will take8 effect on the date of the official declaration of the vote thereon by the9 governor.10 (2) This act applies to acts committed on or after the applicable11 effective date of this act.12 1051 -14-