Second Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO INTRODUCED LLS NO. 24-0695.01 Michael Dohr x4347 HOUSE BILL 24-1136 House Committees Senate Committees Education A BILL FOR AN ACT C ONCERNING MEASURES TO ENCOURAG E HEALTHIER SOCIAL MEDIA101 USE BY YOUTH.102 Bill Summary (Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov .) The bill requires the department of education (department) to create and maintain a resource bank of evidence-based, research-based, and promising program materials and curricula pertaining to the mental health impacts of social media use by children and teens (youth). The resource bank will be used in elementary and secondary schools in the state. The department is required to convene a stakeholder group to assist HOUSE SPONSORSHIP Pugliese and Amabile, SENATE SPONSORSHIP Cutter and Smallwood, Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. in the creation of the resource bank. The bill requires the department to expand local student wellness programs to include programs that address the impacts of problematic technology use on the mental and physical well-being of Colorado youth. The bill requires a social media platform to display a pop-up warning to a user who is under the age of 18 when the user: ! Has spent one hour on social media platforms in a 24-hour period; and ! Is on a social media platform between the hours of 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. The warning must state that data shows that youth who spend more than 3 hours per day on social media double the risk of experiencing poor mental health outcomes, including anxiety and depression symptoms. The warning must include links to resources on the platform for setting screen time limits and links to the health-effect data. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1 SECTION 1. Legislative declaration. (1) The general assembly2 finds and declares that:3 (a) On May 23, 2023, U.S. Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy4 released a Social Media and Youth Mental Health advisory to recognize5 the growing impact of social media on youth mental health and6 well-being as a significant public health challenge that requires7 immediate awareness and action;8 (b) The advisory includes recommendations for policymakers to9 address this issue, including to "support the development,10 implementation, and evaluation of digital and media literacy curricula in11 schools and within academic standards" and "ensure technology12 companies share data relevant to the health impacts of their platforms";13 (c) In the United States, up to 95% of youth ages 13 to 17 report14 using social media platforms, and a third of youth report using social15 media "almost constantly";16 (d) A study of youth in the United States ages 12 to 15 found that17 HB24-1136-2- youth who spend three or more hours a day on social media had double1 the risk of experiencing poor mental health outcomes, including2 experiencing symptoms of depression and anxiety. As of 2021, the3 average time spent on social media for this age group is three-and-a-half4 hours a day, with one in four youth spending five or more hours a day on5 the platforms, and one in seven spending seven or more hours a day on6 social media.7 (e) A systematic review of 42 studies on the effects of excessive8 social media use found a consistent relationship between social media use9 and poor sleep quality, reduced sleep duration, sleep difficulties, and10 depression among youth;11 (f) Social media sites are designed to maximize user engagement,12 which can encourage excessive social media use and behavioral13 dysregulation. Youth undergo critical periods of brain development, and14 social media exposure and frequent use may be associated with distinct15 changes in the developing brain, including overstimulation of the16 amygdala, triggering pathways similar to those in individuals with17 substance use or gambling addictions.18 (g) The 2020 Comprehensive Health Academic Standards in19 Colorado include standards for comprehensive health and physical20 education, among them the importance of identifying and managing the21 risk and the impacts of modern technology and social media on students'22 physical and personal wellness;23 (h) Understanding more about how technology and health24 intersect can help solve certain societal problems and improve the mental25 and physical health of Coloradans. Providing free resources educators can26 use while teaching comprehensive health will help educators meet the27 HB24-1136 -3- essential skills outlined in the 2020 Comprehensive Health Academic1 Standards.2 (i) At the federal level, legislation and reforms to improve social3 media platforms that youth access are slow-moving and do not meet the4 demands and fast-moving nature of social media; and5 (j) States recognize the growing impact of social media and6 problematic technology use on youth mental health and the importance of7 enacting legislation to address those concerns. States can exercise8 leadership in this area rather than waiting for slow-moving federal9 legislation to do so.10 (2) The general assembly therefore declares that it is a matter of11 statewide concern to provide research-based education and interventions,12 including resources on the effects of social media use on brain13 development, how to mitigate the risks associated with social media use,14 and how to maintain well-being while interacting in online environments,15 to help youth make informed decisions on responsible social media use.16 SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 22-2-127.8 as17 follows:18 22-2-127.8. Social media impacts on mental health education19 literacy - resource bank - technical assistance - reporting. (1) (a) T HE20 DEPARTMENT SHALL CREATE AND MAINTAIN A RESOURCE BANK OF21 EVIDENCE-BASED, RESEARCH-BASED, AND PROMISING PROGRAM22 MATERIALS AND CURRICULA PERTAINING TO THE MENTAL HEALTH23 IMPACTS OF SOCIAL MEDIA USE BY YOUTH . THE DEPARTMENT SHALL24 CONVENE A STAKEHOLDER GROUP TO ASSIST WITH THE CREATION AND25 MAINTENANCE OF THE RESOURCE BANK . THE STAKEHOLDER GROUP SHALL26 ALSO IDENTIFY AVENUES FOR INFORMING LOCAL EDUCATION PROVIDERS ,27 HB24-1136 -4- PARENTS, YOUTH, AND THE PUBLIC ABOUT THE RESOURCE BANK . THE1 MATERIALS AND CURRICULA MAY BE USED IN ELEMENTARY AND2 SECONDARY SCHOOLS IN THE STATE . THE RESOURCE BANK MATERIALS3 AND CURRICULA MUST BE YOUTH-FRIENDLY, CULTURALLY SENSITIVE, AND4 AVAILABLE IN BOTH ENGLISH AND SPANISH, AND MAY INCLUDE INTERNET5 LINKS TO RESOURCES AND MATERIALS ABOUT THE MENTAL HEALTH6 IMPACTS OF SOCIAL MEDIA USE FROM ENTITIES THAT THE DEPARTMENT7 FINDS RELIABLE.8 (b) T O CREATE THE RESOURCE BANK DESCRIBED IN SUBSECTION9 (1)(a) OF THIS SECTION, THE DEPARTMENT SHALL CONVENE A10 STAKEHOLDER GROUP TO IDENTIFY THE MATERIALS AND CURRICULA THAT11 WILL BE A PART OF THE RESOURCE BANK .12 (2) O N AND AFTER JULY 1, 2025, THE DEPARTMENT SHALL MAKE13 THE MATERIALS IN THE RESOURCE BANK AVAILABLE WITHOUT CHARGE TO14 LOCAL EDUCATION PROVIDERS , PROFESSIONAL EDUCATORS, PARENTS OR15 GUARDIANS OF YOUTH , STUDENTS, AND COMMUNITY PROVIDERS. A LOCAL16 EDUCATION PROVIDER IS NOT REQUIRED TO ADOPT OR IMPLEMENT ANY17 MATERIAL OR CURRICULA FROM THE RESOURCE BANK . AT THE REQUEST OF18 A LOCAL EDUCATION PROVIDER , THE DEPARTMENT SHALL PROVIDE19 TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO THE LOCAL EDUCATION PROVIDER IN20 DESIGNING AGE-APPROPRIATE CURRICULA PERTAINING TO MENTAL21 HEALTH.22 (3) T HE MATERIALS AND RESOURCES IN THE RESOURCE BANK THAT23 ARE AVAILABLE TO YOUTH MUST BE DEVELOPED AND UPDATED WITH24 INPUT FROM YOUTH.25 (4) L OCAL EDUCATION PROVIDERS ARE ENCOURAGED TO REPORT26 TO THE DEPARTMENT ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE RESOURCE BANK27 HB24-1136 -5- MATERIALS AND CURRICULA AND TO RECOMMEND CHANGES TO IMPROVE1 THE MATERIALS AND CURRICULA . THE DEPARTMENT IS ENCOURAGED TO2 UPDATE THE RESOURCE BANK MATERIALS AND CURRICULA BASED ON3 RECOMMENDATIONS FROM LOCAL EDUCATION PROVIDERS , PROFESSIONAL4 EDUCATORS, PARENTS OR GUARDIANS OF YOUTH , STUDENTS, AND5 COMMUNITY PROVIDERS .6 (5) T HE DEPARTMENT SHALL COLLECT DISAGGREGATED DATA ON7 HOW OFTEN THE MATERIALS AND CURRICULA ARE ACCESSED AND INCLUDE8 THAT INFORMATION AT THE DEPARTMENT 'S ANNUAL "SMART ACT"9 HEARING HELD PURSUANT TO PART 2 OF ARTICLE 7 OF TITLE 2.10 (6) A S USED IN THIS SECTION, UNLESS THE CONTEXT OTHERWISE11 REQUIRES, "LOCAL EDUCATION PROVIDER " MEANS A SCHOOL DISTRICT, A12 CHARTER SCHOOL AUTHORIZED BY A SC HOOL DISTRICT PURSUANT TO PART13 1 OF ARTICLE 30.5 OF THIS TITLE 22, A CHARTER SCHOOL AUTHORIZED BY14 THE STATE CHARTER SCHOOL INSTITUTE PURSUANT TO PART 5 OF ARTICLE15 30.5 OF THIS TITLE 22, OR A BOARD OF COOPERATIVE SERVICES CREATED16 AND OPERATING PURSUANT TO ARTICLE 5 OF THIS TITLE 22 THAT17 OPERATES ONE OR MORE PUBLIC SCHOOLS .18 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 22-25-104, amend19 (2) and (4.5); and add (3)(d) as follows:20 22-25-104. Colorado comprehensive health education program21 - role of department of education - recommended curriculum22 guidelines - allocation of funds - rules. (2) The department of education23 shall have HAS the authority to promote the development and24 implementation of local comprehensive health education programs and25 local student wellness programs, INCLUDING PROGRAMS THAT ADDRESS26 THE MENTAL HEALTH IMPACTS OF SOCIAL MEDIA USE BY YOUTH .27 HB24-1136 -6- (3) (d) THE GUIDELINES DEVELOPED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF1 EDUCATION PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (3)(a) OF THIS SECTION FOR2 GRADES SIX THROUGH TWELVE MUST INCLUDE CURRICULUM ON THE3 MENTAL HEALTH IMPACTS OF SOCIAL MEDIA USE BY YOUTH .4 (4.5) (a) The department of education shall identify programs that5 are evidence-based, culturally sensitive, and reflective of positive youth6 development guidelines for use by school districts in local comprehensive7 health education programs related to comprehensive human sexuality8 education.9 (b) T HE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION SHALL CONVENE A10 STAKEHOLDER GROUP TO IDENTIFY PROGRAMS AND RESOURCES THAT ARE11 EVIDENCE-BASED, CULTURALLY SENSITIVE, AND REFLECTIVE OF POSITIVE12 YOUTH DEVELOPMENT GUIDELINES FOR USE BY SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN13 LOCAL COMPREHENSIVE HEALTH EDUCATION PROGRAMS RELATED TO14 TECHNOLOGY USE, BRAIN DEVELOPMENT, AND THE PHYSICAL AND MENTAL15 IMPACTS OF SOCIAL MEDIA USE.16 SECTION 4. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add part 16 to article17 1 of title 6 as follows:18 PART 1619 PROTECTIONS FOR YOUTH USING SOCIAL MEDIA20 6-1-1601. Social media platform warning - youth users -21 definition. (1) A SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM MUST DISPLAY A POP -UP22 WARNING TO A USER WHO IS UNDER THE AGE OF EIGHTEEN WHEN THE23 USER:24 (a) H AS SPENT AN HOUR ON THE SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM DURING25 A TWENTY-FOUR-HOUR PERIOD; AND26 (b) I S ON A SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM BETWEEN THE HOURS OF TEN27 HB24-1136 -7- P.M. AND SIX A.M.1 (2) T HE WARNING MUST STATE THAT DATA SHOWS THAT YOUTH2 WHO SPEND MORE THAN THREE HOURS PER DAY ON SOCIAL MEDIA DOUBLE3 THE RISK OF EXPERIENCING POOR MENTAL HEALTH OUTCOMES , INCLUDING4 ANXIETY AND DEPRESSION SYMPTOMS . THE WARNING MUST INCLUDE5 LINKS TO RESOURCES ON THE PLATFORM FOR SETTING SCREEN TIME LIMITS6 AND LINKS TO THE HEALTH-EFFECT DATA.7 (3) T HE WARNING REQUIRED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (1)(a) OF8 THIS SECTION MUST REPEAT THIRTY MINUTES AFTER THE INITIAL WARNING ,9 THEN FIFTEEN MINUTES AFTER THE SECOND WARNING , AND THEN EVERY10 FIVE MINUTES THEREAFTER.11 (4) (a) F OR PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, "SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM"12 MEANS AN INTERNET-BASED SERVICE, WEBSITE, OR APPLICATION THAT:13 (I) H AS MORE THAN TEN THOUSAND ACTIVE USERS IN COLORADO;14 (II) P ERMITS A PERSON TO BECOME A REGISTERED USER ,15 ESTABLISH AN ACCOUNT, OR CREATE A PUBLIC OR SEMI-PUBLIC PROFILE16 FOR THE PURPOSE OF ALLOWING USERS TO CREATE , SHARE, AND VIEW17 USER-GENERATED CONTENT THROUGH THE ACCOUNT OR PROFILE ;18 (III) E NABLES ONE OR MORE USERS TO CREATE OR POST CONTENT19 THAT CAN BE VIEWED BY OTHER USERS OF THE MEDIUM ; AND20 (IV) I NCLUDES A SUBSTANTIAL FUNCTION TO ALLOW USERS TO21 INTERACT SOCIALLY WITH EACH OTHER WITHIN THE SERVICE OR22 APPLICATION. A SERVICE OR APPLICATION THAT PROVIDES ELECTRONIC23 MAIL OR DIRECT MESSAGING SERVICES DOES NOT MEET THE CRITERION24 DESCRIBED IN THIS SUBSECTION (4) ON THE BASIS OF THAT FUNCTION25 ALONE.26 (b) "S OCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM " DOES NOT INCLUDE AN27 HB24-1136 -8- INTERNET-BASED SERVICE OR APPLICATION IN WHICH THE PREDOMINANT1 OR EXCLUSIVE FUNCTION IS:2 (I) E LECTRONIC MAIL;3 (II) F ACILITATING COMMERCIAL TRANSACTIONS , IF THE4 INTERACTION WITH OTHER USERS OR ACCOUNT HOLDERS IS GENERALLY5 LIMITED TO:6 (A) T HE ABILITY TO UPLOAD A POST AND COMMENT ON REVIEWS7 OR THE ABILITY TO DISPLAY LISTS OR COLLECTIONS OF GOODS FOR SALE OR8 WISH LISTS; AND9 (B) T HE PRIMARY FUNCTION OF THE PLATFORM IS FOCUSED ON10 ONLINE SHOPPING OR E-COMMERCE RATHER THAN INTERACTIONS BETWEEN11 USERS OR ACCOUNT HOLDERS ;12 (III) F ACILITATING TELECONFERENCING AND VIDEO13 CONFERENCING FEATURES THAT ARE LIMITED TO CERTAIN PARTICIPANTS14 IN THE TELECONFERENCE OR VIDEO CONFERENCE AND ARE NOT POSTED15 PUBLICLY OR FOR BROAD DISTRIBUTION TO OTHER USERS ;16 (IV) F ACILITATING SUBSCRIPTION -BASED CONTENT OR17 NEWSLETTERS;18 (V) F ACILITATING CROWD-SOURCED CONTENT FOR REFERENCE19 GUIDES SUCH AS ENCYCLOPEDIAS AND DICTIONARIES ;20 (VI) P ROVIDING CLOUD-BASED ELECTRONIC STORAGE, INCLUDING21 CLOUD-BASED STORAGE THAT ALLOWS COLLABORATIVE EDITING BY22 INVITED USERS;23 (VII) P ROVIDING INFORMATION CONCERNING BUSINESSES ,24 PRODUCTS, OR TRAVEL INFORMATION , INCLUDING USER REVIEWS OR25 RANKINGS OF BUSINESSES OR PRODUCTS ; AND26 (VIII) F ACILITATING COMMUNICATION WITHIN A BUSINESS OR AN27 HB24-1136 -9- ENTERPRISE AMONG EMPLOYEES OR AFFILIATES OF THE BUSINESS OR1 ENTERPRISE SO LONG AS ACCESS TO THE SERVICE OR APPLICATION IS2 RESTRICTED TO EMPLOYEES OR AFFILIATES OF THE BUSINESS OR3 ENTERPRISE.4 SECTION 5. Act subject to petition - effective date. This act5 takes effect at 12:01 a.m. on the day following the expiration of the6 ninety-day period after final adjournment of the general assembly; except7 that, if a referendum petition is filed pursuant to section 1 (3) of article V8 of the state constitution against this act or an item, section, or part of this9 act within such period, then the act, item, section, or part will not take10 effect unless approved by the people at the general election to be held in11 November 2024 and, in such case, will take effect on the date of the12 official declaration of the vote thereon by the governor.13 HB24-1136 -10-