Second Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO REVISED This Version Includes All Amendments Adopted on Second Reading in the Second House LLS NO. 24-0562.02 Jennifer Berman x3286 HOUSE BILL 24-1336 House Committees Senate Committees Transportation, Housing & Local Government Finance Finance Appropriations Appropriations A BILL FOR AN ACT C ONCERNING THE DEPLOYMENT OF BROADBAND THROUGH GRANTS101 ADMINISTERED BY THE COLORADO BROADBAND OFFICE, AND, IN102 CONNECTION THEREWITH , REDUCING AN APPROPRIATION .103 Bill Summary (Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov/ .) Sunset Process - House Transportation, Housing, and Local Government Committee. The "Connect Colorado to Enhance Economic Development, Telehealth, Education, and Safety Act" (act), which created the broadband deployment board (board) in the governor's office of information technology and tasked the board with awarding grant money SENATE Amended 2nd Reading April 30, 2024 HOUSE 3rd Reading Unamended April 17, 2024 HOUSE Amended 2nd Reading April 15, 2024 HOUSE SPONSORSHIP Parenti and Weinberg, Boesenecker, Kipp, Lindsay, Lukens, Titone SENATE SPONSORSHIP Rodriguez and Priola, Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. from the high cost support mechanism (HCSM) for broadband deployment in unserved areas of the state, is scheduled for repeal on September 1, 2024. The department of regulatory agencies, as part of its sunset process, reviewed the act and board and recommended that they be extended for 5 years. The bill, instead, repeals the act and board, transfers the function of awarding grant money from the HCSM to the Colorado broadband office (office), and authorizes the office to award grants for unserved and underserved areas of the state. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1 SECTION 1. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 24-34-104, repeal2 (25)(a)(VI); and add (31)(a)(XI) as follows:3 24-34-104. General assembly review of regulatory agencies4 and functions for repeal, continuation, or reestablishment - legislative5 declaration - repeal. (25) (a) The following agencies, functions, or both,6 are scheduled for repeal on September 1, 2024:7 (VI) The functions of the broadband deployment board created in8 section 24-37.5-119;9 (31) (a) The following agencies, functions, or both, are scheduled10 for repeal on September 1, 2030:11 (XI) THE FUNCTIONS OF THE BROADBAND OFFICE IN12 ADMINISTERING THE BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT GRANT PROGRAM13 CREATED IN SECTION 24-37.5-905.14 SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, repeal 24-37.5-119.15 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 24-37.5-905 as16 follows:17 24-37.5-905. Broadband deployment - grant program - high18 cost support mechanism money - broadband office administrative19 fund - creation - criteria - rules - reports - definitions - repeal. (1) A S20 USED IN THIS SECTION, UNLESS THE CONTEXT OTHERWISE REQUIRES :21 1336-2- (a) "BROADBAND" HAS THE MEANING SET FORTH IN SECTION1 40-15-102.2 (b) "B ROADBAND NETWORK " HAS THE MEANING SET FORTH IN3 SECTION 40-15-102.4 (c) "C OMMISSION" MEANS THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION5 CREATED IN SECTION 40-2-101.6 (d) "HCSM" MEANS THE HIGH COST SUPPORT MECHANISM7 CREATED PURSUANT TO SECTION 40-15-208.8 (e) "INCUMBENT PROVIDER" HAS THE MEANING SET FORTH IN9 SECTION 40-15-102 (9.5).10 (f) "MIDDLE MILE INFRASTRUCTURE" HAS THE MEANING SET FORTH11 IN 47 U.S.C. SEC. 1741 (a)(9), AS AMENDED.12 (2) (a) T HE BROADBAND OFFICE SHALL ADMINISTER A BROADBAND13 DEPLOYMENT GRANT PROGRAM IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS SECTION . THE14 BROADBAND OFFICE SHALL DIRECT THE COMMISSION TO AUTHORIZE A15 THIRD-PARTY CONTRACTOR OF THE HCSM TO DISBURSE MONEY FROM THE16 HCSM FOR BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT GRANTS APPROVED BY THE17 BROADBAND OFFICE. THE COMMISSION SHALL AUTHORIZE DISBURSEMENTS18 OF MONEY FROM THE HCSM FOR BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT GRANTS ONLY19 AS DIRECTED BY THE BROADBAND OFFICE .20 (b) (I) T HE BROADBAND OFFICE MAY ALLOCATE MONEY FROM THE21 HCSM FOR THE DEPLOYMENT OF BROADBAND IN UNSERVED AND22 UNDERSERVED AREAS OF THE STATE PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION AND23 SECTION 40-15-208 THROUGH THE USE OF THE HCSM SURCHARGE AND24 SURCHARGE RATE IN EFFECT ON JANUARY 1, 2018. IN DETERMINING THE 25 DEFINITION OF UNSERVED AND UNDERSERVED AREAS , THE STANDARDS26 USED BY THE BROADBAND OFFICE MUST BE CONSISTENT WITH BR OADBAND27 1336 -3- BENCHMARK STANDARDS AND ANY REVISIONS TO THE STANDARDS , AS1 DETERMINED BY THE FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION AND THE2 NATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND INFORMATION ADMINISTRATION IN3 THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE . PURSUANT TO SECTIONS4 40-15-207 AND 40-15-208, THE COMMISSION SHALL DETERMINE THE5 FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR BROADB AND DEPLOYMENT FROM THE HCSM6 MONEY. THE HCSM THIRD-PARTY CONTRACTOR SHALL MAINTAIN AND7 HOLD THE MONEY AVAILABLE FOR BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT IN A8 SEPARATE ACCOUNT FROM THE MONEY USED FOR BASIC VOICE SERVICE .9 M ONEY HELD FOR BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT MUST NOT BE DISBURSED10 FOR BASIC VOICE SERVICE, AND MONEY HELD FOR BASIC VOICE SERVICE11 MUST NOT BE DISBURSED FOR BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT .12 (II) T O MAXIMIZE THE EFFICACY OF THE GRANT PROGRAM , THE13 BROADBAND OFFICE MAY USE HCSM MONEY ALLOCATED FOR14 BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT PURSUANT TO THIS SUBSECTION (2) AND15 SECTION 40-15-208 IN ORDER TO CONDUCT, OR CAUSE TO BE CONDUCTED,16 STUDIES TO ASSESS BROADBAND NEEDS IN THE STATE .17 (3) (a) UP TO FIVE PERCENT OF THE MONEY ALLOCATED FROM THE18 HCSM FOR BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT MAY BE USED TO COVER THE19 BROADBAND OFFICE'S DIRECT AND INDIRECT COSTS TO ADMINISTER THE20 GRANT PROGRAM, INCLUDING TO COVER STAFFING COSTS FOR THE GRANT21 PROGRAM. MONEY THAT IS ALLOCATED FOR SUCH PURPOSES IS CREDITED22 TO THE BROADBAND OFFICE ADMINISTRATIVE FUND , WHICH FUND IS23 CREATED IN THE STATE TREASURY . THE FUND CONSISTS OF ALL MONEY24 ALLOCATED FROM THE HCSM FOR THE BROADBAND OFFICE 'S25 ADMINISTRATION OF THE GRANT PROGRAM AND ALL MONEY THAT THE26 GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY APPROPRIATE OR TRANSFER TO THE FUND . THE27 1336 -4- MONEY IN THE FUND IS CONTINUOUSLY APPROPRIATED FOR THE PURPOSES1 SET FORTH IN THIS SECTION . ALL INTEREST EARNED FROM THE2 INVESTMENT OF MONEY IN THE FUND IS CREDITED TO THE FUND . ALL3 MONEY NOT EXPENDED AT THE END OF A STATE FISCAL YEAR REMAINS IN4 THE FUND AND DOES NOT REVERT TO THE GENERAL FUND OR ANY OTHER5 FUND.6 (b) EXCEPT AS REQUIRED TO COMPLY WITH SUBSECTIONS (2)(b)(II)7 AND (3)(a) OF THIS SECTION, THE BROADBAND OFFICE SHALL NOT AWARD8 ITSELF MONEY FROM THE HCSM.9 (c) THE BROADBAND OFFICE SHALL PROHIBIT GRANT RECIPIENTS10 FROM USING GRANT MONEY TO SUBSIDIZE EXPENSES ASSOCIATED WITH11 TELECOMMUNICATIONS OPERATIONAL EXPENSES, WITH THE EXCEPTION OF12 A ONE-TIME TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION EXPENSE AND REGULATORY13 COMPLIANCE.14 (4) O N OR BEFORE DECEMBER 31, 2024, THE BROADBAND OFFICE15 SHALL ESTABLISH GRANT PROGRAM CRITERIA AND GUIDELINES FOR16 AWARDING HCSM MONEY FOR NEW PROJECTS TO EXPAND BROADBAND17 ACCESS AND TO INCREASE BR OADBAND AFFORDABILITY IN THE STATE ,18 WHICH CRITERIA AND GUIDELINES MUST INCLUDE :19 (a) T HE ESTABLISHMENT OF A TWO-TIERED GRANT PROGRAM THAT20 PRIORITIZES FUNDING AS FOLLOWS:21 (I) U P TO SIXTY PERCENT OF AVAILABLE GRANT MONEY MUST BE22 USED TO FINANCE TIER ONE PROJECTS FOR MIDDLE MILE INFRASTRUCTURE ;23 AND24 (II) U P TO FORTY PERCENT OF AVAILABLE GRANT MONEY MUST BE25 USED TO FINANCE TIER TWO PROJECTS AND OTHERWISE UNDERFUNDED26 BROADBAND NEEDS, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO:27 1336 -5- (A) POLE REPLACEMENTS AND ATTACHMENTS , LINE EXTENSIONS,1 LONG DROPS, NETWORK UPGRADES THAT STRENGTHEN CYBERSECURITY ,2 AND NETWORK INFRASTRUCTURE , INCLUDING WIRELINE AND WIRELESS3 FACILITIES SUCH AS TOWERS AND SATELLITE INFRASTRUCTURE ; AND4 (B) D IGITAL EQUITY INITIATIVES TO HELP CLOSE THE DIGITAL5 DIVIDE IN THE STATE, INCLUDING INITIATIVES FOR BASIC INTERNET6 ACCESS, COMPUTER AND DEVICE DISTRIBUTION , DIGITAL LITERACY7 TRAINING, AND BROADBAND WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT TRAINING ;8 (b) T HE FOLLOWING MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR PROJECTS THAT9 ARE AWARDED GRANT MONEY :10 (I) S UPPORT FOR BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT IN UNSERVED OR11 UNDERSERVED AREAS;12 (II) S PEED REQUIREMENTS;13 (III) M ATCHING FUNDING REQUIREMENTS ;14 (IV) A PPLICANT ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS;15 (V) G ENERALLY ACCEPTED INDUSTRY RELIABILITY AND16 PERFORMANCE STANDARDS ;17 (VI) T IMELINES FOR COMPLETION OF A PROJECT;18 (VII) R EASONABLE COST REQUIREMENTS FOR A PROJECT ;19 (VIII) C OMPLIANCE STANDARDS ; AND20 (IX) R EPORTING AND ACCOUNTABILITY REQUIREMENTS ; AND21 (c) T HE FOLLOWING CRITERIA FOR REVIEWING AND PRIORITIZING22 APPLICANTS' PROPOSED PROJECTS:23 (I) T HE PURPOSE AND PROJECT IMPACTS;24 (II) T HE GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION OF BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT ;25 (III) B ROADBAND NETWORK REDUNDANCY , DIVERSITY, AND26 LATENCY;27 1336 -6- (IV) BROADBAND NETWORK SPEEDS ;1 (V) T HE AMOUNT OF MATCHING MONEY AVAILABLE ;2 (VI) T HE COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF THE PROJECT;3 (VII) T HE AMOUNT OF SUPPORT THE PROJECT WOULD PROVIDE FOR4 LOW-INCOME HOUSEHOLDS; AND5 (VIII) T HE EXTENT TO WHICH THE PROJECT WOULD SUPPORT6 CRITICALLY UNSERVED AREAS.7 (5) I N ESTABLISHING THE GRANT PROGRAM , THE BROADBAND8 OFFICE SHALL:9 (a) S OLICIT INPUT FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC AND VARIOUS10 STAKEHOLDERS, INCLUDING AT LEAST THE FOLLOWING GROUPS OF11 STAKEHOLDERS:12 (I) I NDUSTRY ASSOCIATIONS;13 (II) L OCAL GOVERNMENTS ;14 (III) T RIBAL GOVERNMENTS;15 (IV) O THER STATE AGENCIES;16 (V) F EDERAL AGENCIES;17 (VI) B ROADBAND CONSUMERS ; AND18 (VII) O THER KEY STAKEHOLDERS THAT THE BROADBAND OFFICE19 IDENTIFIES;20 (b) C REATE A WORK GROUP, INCLUDING THE EXTERNAL21 STAKEHOLDERS IDENTIFIED IN SUBSECTION (5)(a) OF THIS SECTION, TO22 HELP REVIEW GRANT APPLICATIONS AND RECOMMEND PROJECTS FOR23 GRANT AWARDS;24 (c) E STABLISH A FORMAL APPEALS PROCESS FOR GRANT25 APPLICATIONS THAT ARE NOT AWARDED GRANTS . THE SOLE REMEDY FOR26 AN APPLICANT THAT PREVAILS ON APPEAL IS THE FINANCING OF THE27 1336 -7- APPLICANT'S PROPOSED PROJECT IN THE CURRENT OR NEXT FISCAL YEAR ,1 SUBJECT TO THE AVAILABILITY OF MONEY IN THE HCSM.2 (d) AS PART OF A GRANT APPLICATION THAT AN APPLICANT FILES3 OR AS PART OF AN APPEAL OF A GRANT DECISION THAT AN APPELLANT4 FILES, REQUIRE THAT THE APPLICANT OR APPELLANT INCLUDE A SPEED5 TEST PERFORMED:6 (I) ON AN INCUMBENT PROVIDER'S BROADBAND NETWORK ; AND7 (II) IN ACCORDANCE WITH INDUSTRY -STANDARD SPEED-TEST8 PROTOCOLS IDENTIFIED BY THE FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION;9 (e) INCLUDE A FORMAL PROCESS BY WHICH THE BROADBAND10 OFFICE, ELIGIBLE APPLICANTS, AND INCUMBENT PROVIDERS MAY11 CHALLENGE OR APPEAL AN APPLICANT'S DATA INCLUDED IN THE12 APPLICATION TO PREVENT THE FINANCING OF PROJECTS THAT WOULD13 CAUSE OVERBUILD OR DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL OR OTHER STATE14 FUNDING; AND15 (f) ESTABLISH A PROCESS FOR ENSURING THAT PROJECTS THAT ARE16 AWARDED GRANTS COMPLY WITH ALL STATE AND FEDERAL BROADBAND17 DEPLOYMENT REPORTING OBLIGATIONS .18 (6) P URSUANT TO SECTION 24-37.5-106 (4), THE CHIEF19 INFORMATION OFFICER MAY PROMULGATE RULES TO IMPLEMENT THIS20 SECTION AND SHALL SPECIFICALLY CONSIDER PROMULGATING RULES TO 21 IMPLEMENT SUBSECTIONS (2), (4), AND (5) OF THIS SECTION.22 (7) T HE BROADBAND OFFICE MAY CONTRACT WITH A THIRD PARTY23 TO PERFORM ADMINISTRATIVE FUNCTIONS RELATED TO ADMINISTERING24 THE GRANT PROGRAM.25 (8) N OTWITHSTANDING SECTION 24-1-136 (11)(a)(I), ON OR26 BEFORE JANUARY 1, 2025, AND ON OR BEFORE JANUARY 1 OF EACH YEAR27 1336 -8- THEREAFTER, THE BROADBAND OFFICE SHALL SUBMIT AN AN NUAL REPORT1 TO THE JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE AND THE JOINT TECHNOLOGY2 COMMITTEE, OR THEIR SUCCESSOR COMMITTEES , SUMMARIZING FOR THE3 PREVIOUS CALENDAR YEAR :4 (a) T HE BROADBAND OFFICE'S GRANT ACTIVITIES; AND5 (b) HCSM EXPENDITURES MADE FOR BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT .6 (9) THIS SECTION IS REPEALED, EFFECTIVE SEPTEMBER 1, 2030.7 BEFORE THE REPEAL, THIS SECTION IS SCHEDULED FOR REVIEW IN8 ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 24-34-104.9 SECTION 4. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 6-26-101, amend (1)10 and (3) as follows:11 6-26-101. Complaints to federal trade commission - attorney12 general to provide guidance. (1) The attorney general or the attorney13 general's designee, in collaboration with the C OLORADO broadband14 deployment board OFFICE created in section 24-37.5-119 24-37.5-903 (1),15 shall develop written guidance for consumers seeking to file a complaint16 with the federal trade commission to allege that an internet service17 provider, as defined in section 40-15-209 (4)(b), has engaged in any18 practice that violates federal law regarding interference with the open19 internet.20 (3) The attorney general, in collaboration with the C OLORADO21 broadband deployment board OFFICE, shall update the written guidance22 as needed.23 SECTION 5. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 24-37.5-106, amend24 (4) as follows:25 24-37.5-106. Chief information officer - duties and26 responsibilities - rules. (4) The chief information officer may27 1336 -9- promulgate as rules pursuant to article 4 of this title 24 all of the policies,1 procedures, standards, specifications, guidelines, or criteria that are2 developed or approved pursuant to section 24-37.5-105 (4) and RULES to3 establish accessibility standards for individuals with a disability pursuant4 to section 24-85-103 AND TO IMPLEMENT THE BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT5 GRANT PROGRAM PURSUANT TO SECTION 24-37.5-905.6 SECTION 6. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 24-72-202, repeal7 (6)(b)(XV) as follows:8 24-72-202. Definitions. As used in this part 2, unless the context9 otherwise requires:10 (6) (b) "Public records" does not include:11 (XV) Granular coverage data, as defined in and submitted to the12 office of information technology pursuant to section 24-37.5-119 (9)(m);13 SECTION 7. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-15-208, amend14 (2)(a)(I)(B) as follows:15 40-15-208. High cost support mechanism - Colorado high cost16 administration fund - creation - purpose - operation - rules - report17 - repeal. (2) (a) (I) The commission is hereby authorized to establish a18 mechanism for the support of universal service, also referred to in this19 section as the "high cost support mechanism", which must operate in20 accordance with rules adopted by the commission. The primary purpose21 of the high cost support mechanism is to provide financial assistance as22 a support mechanism to:23 (B) Provide access to broadband service in unserved AND24 UNDERSERVED areas pursuant to this section and section 24-37.5-119 25 24-37.5-905 only.26 SECTION 8. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-15-209, amend27 1336 -10- (1) introductory portion, (2)(a), and (2)(c) as follows:1 40-15-209. Net neutrality conditions for internet service2 providers to receive high cost support mechanism money -3 definitions. (1) Except as provided in subsection (3) of this section, an4 internet service provider that is otherwise eligible to receive money5 through a grant from the C OLORADO broadband deployment board OFFICE6 pursuant to section 24-37.5-119 24-37.5-905 or through any state fund7 established to help finance broadband deployment is not eligible to8 receive that money if the internet service provider:9 (2) (a) If the commission learns from the C OLORADO broadband10 deployment board OFFICE that a federal agency has issued a final order or11 entered into a settlement or consent decree regarding, or a court of12 competent jurisdiction has issued a final judgment against, an internet13 service provider and that the board OFFICE has determined from the order,14 decree, or judgment that the internet service provider has engaged in15 conduct specified in subsection (1) of this section, the commission shall16 issue a written order to the internet service provider requiring the internet17 service provider to fully refund any money that the internet service18 provider received in the twenty-four months preceding the board's19 OFFICE'S determination from the high cost support mechanism pursuant20 to a grant awarded by the C OLORADO broadband deployment board 21 OFFICE under section 24-37.5-119 24-37.5-905.22 (c) The third-party contractor that maintains the high cost support23 mechanism shall allocate any money refunded to the high cost support24 mechanism pursuant to this subsection (2) to the high cost support25 mechanism account dedicated to broadband deployment, which account26 is described in section 24-37.5-119 (3) 24-37.5-905.27 1336 -11- SECTION 9. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 40-15-502, amend1 (5)(a) as follows:2 40-15-502. Expressions of state policy. (5) Universal service3 support mechanisms. (a) In order to accomplish the goals of universal4 basic service, universal access to advanced service under section5 24-37.5-119 24-37.5-905, and any revision of the definition of basic6 service under subsection (2) of this section, the commission shall create7 a system of support mechanisms to assist in the provision of basic service8 and advanced service in high-cost areas. The commission shall fund these9 support mechanisms equitably and on a nondiscriminatory, competitively10 neutral basis through assessments, which may include a rate element, on11 all telecommunications providers in Colorado. A provider's eligibility to12 receive support for basic service under the support mechanisms is13 conditioned upon the provider's offering basic service throughout an14 entire support area.15 SECTION 10. Appropriation - adjustments to 2024 long bill.16 (1) To implement this act, appropriations made in the annual general17 appropriation act for the 2024-25 state fiscal year to the office of the18 governor are adjusted as follows:19 (a) The cash funds appropriation from various sources of cash20 funds for the office of information technology for health, life, and dental21 is decreased by $25,826;22 (b) The cash funds appropriation from various sources of cash23 funds for the office of information technology for enterprise solutions is24 decreased by $254,276, and the related FTE is decreased by 2.0 FTE.25 26 SECTION 11. Act subject to petition - effective date. This act27 1336 -12- takes effect September 1, 2024; except that, if a referendum petition is1 filed pursuant to section 1 (3) of article V of the state constitution against2 this act or an item, section, or part of this act within the ninety-day period3 after final adjournment of the general assembly, then the act, item,4 section, or part will not take effect unless approved by the people at the5 general election to be held in November 2024 and, in such case, will take6 effect on the date of the official declaration of the vote thereon by the7 governor.8 1336 -13-