Second Regular Session Seventy-fourth General Assembly STATE OF COLORADO REVISED This Version Includes All Amendments Adopted on Second Reading in the Second House LLS NO. 24-1032.01 Megan McCall x4215 SENATE BILL 24-157 Senate Committees House Committees State, Veterans, & Military Affairs Judiciary A BILL FOR AN ACT C ONCERNING CLARIFYING THE APPLICATION OF THE COLORADO OPEN101 MEETINGS LAW TO THE COLORADO GENERAL ASSEMBLY .102 Bill Summary (Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov .) Under the Colorado open meetings law (COML), any meeting of a body of the general assembly at which the adoption of any proposed policy, position, resolution, rule, regulation, or formal action occurs or at which a majority or quorum of a body of the general assembly is in attendance or expected to be in attendance can only be held after full and timely notice to the public. In addition, the COML requires that minutes HOUSE 2nd Reading Unamended March 8, 2024 SENATE 3rd Reading Unamended March 4, 2024 SENATE Amended 2nd Reading March 1, 2024 SENATE SPONSORSHIP Fenberg, Buckner, Coleman, Cutter, Exum, Fields, Hansen, Hinrichsen, Michaelson Jenet, Priola, Rodriguez, Gonzales, Jaquez Lewis, Marchman, Sullivan HOUSE SPONSORSHIP McCluskie and deGruy Kennedy, Amabile, Bird, Boesenecker, Daugherty, Duran, Froelich, Garcia, Jodeh, Lindsay, Lindstedt, McCormick, McLachlan, Sirota, Snyder, Titone Shading denotes HOUSE amendment. Double underlining denotes SENATE amendment. Capital letters or bold & italic numbers indicate new material to be added to existing law. Dashes through the words or numbers indicate deletions from existing law. of the meeting be taken and promptly recorded. The bill makes several changes and clarifications concerning the application of the COML to the general assembly and its members. Specifically, the bill provides that, for purposes of applying the notice and minutes provisions under the COML, a quorum of a state public body of the general assembly must be contemporaneous. Additionally, the bill establishes that written communication, electronic or otherwise, exchanged between members of the general assembly are not subject to the COML but any records of the communications are subject to disclosure to the extent required by the "Colorado Open Records Act". The bill also defines "public business", for purposes of the application of the COML to the general assembly, as introduced legislation, including bills, resolutions, and memorials, or other matters before a statutory committee, any type of interim committee, or a committee of reference. However, "public business" does not include matters that are by nature interpersonal, administrative, or logistical or that concern personnel, planning, process, training, or operations, as long as the merits or substance of matters that are expressly defined as being public business are not discussed. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:1 SECTION 1. Legislative declaration. (1) The general assembly2 finds and declares that:3 (a) The United States and Colorado constitutions each create4 tripartite systems of government centered around representative5 legislative bodies, which our founders envisioned would arrive at sound6 policy through deliberation of the needs and values of their constituents;7 (b) Legislators take an oath of office to faithfully fulfill the duties8 of their position, which calls upon them to craft policy, establish the state9 budget, vote on legislation, and provide oversight of state departments;10 (c) The general assembly commits to ensuring open access to the11 deliberation of public business and the formation of public policy because12 the democratic process necessitates transparent discourse on policy13 matters of statewide importance;14 157-2- (d) The general assembly considers legislation through a dynamic,1 iterative process, the outcome of which is determined by legislators'2 votes, which are recorded, posted publicly, and take place in open3 meetings both in committees and on the floors of each chamber;4 (e) A fundamental component of the legislative process is a5 legislator's ability to understand other legislators' positions on a piece of6 legislation, which is inherently necessary to legislators' ability to7 successfully enact legislation into law;8 (f) The general assembly is distinct from any other state public9 body based on the volume and broad scope of the legislation it considers,10 the limited duration of its legislative sessions, and its large membership11 of one hundred legislators;12 (g) The policy-making function of the general assembly is13 furthered by the often informal, direct flow and sharing of information,14 research, and ideas between and among legislators concerning policy15 positions and legislation;16 (h) The caucus whips, a traditional position in legislative bodies,17 play a particularly important role in facilitating communication and18 information gathering concerning legislators' positions and votes on19 legislation, as do individual legislators who sponsor the legislation;20 (i) Several constitutional provisions grant power to and impose21 requirements on the general assembly and affect the manner in which the22 general assembly operates, including:23 (I) Section 20 of article V of the state constitution, often referred24 to as "GAVEL" or "Give a Vote to Every Legislator", which creates a25 transparent and open process for all legislation that is introduced in the26 general assembly by requiring that:27 157 -3- (A) Every introduced bill be assigned to a committee of reference;1 (B) The committee consider each bill assigned to the committee2 on its merits; and3 (C) The committee take formal action on each bill;4 (II) Section 22a of article V of the state constitution, which was5 initiated to prohibit legislators from requiring or committing themselves6 to a caucus position, ensuring autonomy for individual legislators and7 allowing for the free debate of the merits of matters pending before the8 general assembly throughout the legislative process;9 (III) Section 1 of article V of the state constitution, which vests10 the legislative power of the state in the general assembly, thereby11 establishing the plenary authority of the general assembly, which12 authority is restricted only by constitutional requirements or prohibitions;13 and14 (IV) Section 12 of article V of the state constitution, which vests15 each house of the general assembly with the power to determine the rules16 of its proceedings;17 (j) In addition to constitutional provisions that affect the18 procedures of the general assembly, various state laws also affect the19 general assembly, including the Colorado open meetings law set forth in20 part 4 of article 6 of title 24, Colorado Revised Statues;21 (k) While the general assembly is one of multiple state public22 bodies subject to the Colorado open meetings law, there has been23 considerable ambiguity about how to apply the law to the general24 assembly, largely stemming from a lack of clarity about what constitutes25 "public business";26 (l) Additionally, terminology in the Colorado open meetings law27 157 -4- is outdated and does not take into account how electronic1 communications have evolved to become a ubiquitous and necessary form2 of communication to any modern workplace, including for the general3 assembly;4 (m) The "Colorado Open Records Act", part 2 of article 72 of title5 24, Colorado Revised Statutes, governs access to physical and electronic6 public records of the general assembly, and all custodians of public7 records are required to make public records available pursuant to the8 terms of that act; and9 (n) The general assembly seeks to clarify key provisions and10 terminology in the Colorado open meetings law as it relates to the11 legislative procedures of the general assembly, acknowledging an interest12 in protecting the openness of, transparency of, and public inclusion in the13 legislative process.14 SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 24-6-402, add15 (2.5) as follows:16 24-6-402. Meetings - open to public - legislative declaration -17 definitions. (2.5) (a) FOR PURPOSES OF APPLYING SUBSECTIONS (2)(c)(I)18 AND (2)(d)(I) OF THIS SECTION TO A MEETING OF A STATE PUBLIC BODY OF19 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY, A QUORUM MUST BE CONTEMPORANEOUS .20 (b) N OTWITHSTANDING SUBSECTIONS (1)(b) AND (2)(d)(III) OF21 THIS SECTION, ANY FORM OF WRITTEN COMMUNICATION , ELECTRONIC OR22 OTHERWISE, EXCHANGED BY TWO OR MORE MEMBERS OF THE GENERAL23 ASSEMBLY IS NOT SUBJECT TO THIS PART 4, BUT ANY RECORDS OF THE24 COMMUNICATION ARE SUBJECT TO DISCLOSURE TO THE EXTENT REQUIRED25 BY THE "COLORADO OPEN RECORDS ACT", PART 2 OF ARTICLE 72 OF TITLE26 24.27 157 -5- (c) FOR PURPOSES OF THE APPLICATION OF THIS PART 4 TO THE1 GENERAL ASSEMBLY, "PUBLIC BUSINESS":2 (I) M EANS:3 (A) I NTRODUCED LEGISLATION, INCLUDING BILLS, RESOLUTIONS,4 AND MEMORIALS; 5 (B) P ROPOSED LEGISLATION , WHICH INCLUDES A BILL , 6 RESOLUTION, OR MEMORIAL, IF A DRAFT OF THE PROPOSED LEGISLATION7 PREPARED BY THE OFFICE OF LEGISLATIVE LEGAL SERVICES IS BEING8 DISCUSSED BY A QUORUM OF A STATUTORY COMMITTEE OR A COMMITTEE9 OF REFERENCE DURING A REGULAR OR SPECIAL LEGISLATIVE SESSION OF10 THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OR BY A QUORUM OF ANY TYPE OF INTERIM11 COMMITTEE; OR12 (C) OTHER MATTERS BEFORE A STATUTORY COMMITTEE , ANY TYPE13 OF INTERIM COMMITTEE, OR A COMMITTEE OF REFERENCE; AND14 (II) D OES NOT INCLUDE MATTERS THAT ARE BY NATURE15 INTERPERSONAL, ADMINISTRATIVE, OR LOGISTICAL OR THAT CONCERN16 PERSONNEL, PLANNING, PROCESS, TRAINING, OR OPERATIONS, IF THE17 MERITS OR SUBSTANCE OF MATTERS SET FORTH IN SUBSECTION (2.5)(c)(I)18 OF THIS SECTION ARE NOT DISCUSSED . AS USED IN THIS SUBSECTION19 (2.5)(c)(II), " MERITS OR SUBSTANCE" HAS THE SAME MEANING AS SET20 FORTH IN SUBSECTION (2)(d)(III) OF THIS SECTION.21 SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 2-3-303, add (3)(i) 22 as follows:23 2-3-303. Functions - report - definitions. (3) (i) (I) (A) O N OR 24 AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS SUBSECTION (3)(i)(I)(A), BUT BEFORE25 D ECEMBER 31, 2024, ON OR AFTER JANUARY 1, 2025, BUT BEFORE 26 D ECEMBER 31, 2025, AND ON OR AFTER JANUARY 1, 2026, BUT BEFORE 27 157 -6- DECEMBER 31, 2026, THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE SHALL CONSIDER THE1 APPLICATION OF SECTION 24-6-402 TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY AT A2 MEETING OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMI TTEE . THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE3 SHALL ALLOW THE OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE PUBLIC COMMENT IN4 CONNECTION WITH THE MEETING .5 (B) T HIS SUBSECTION (3)(i)(I) IS REPEALED, EFFECTIVE JULY 1, 6 2027.7 (II) O N OR AFTER JANUARY 1, 2027, UPON REQUEST BY A MEMBER 8 OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE , THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE SHALL9 CONSIDER THE APPLICATION OF SECTION 24-6-402 TO THE GENERAL10 ASSEMBLY AT A MEETING OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMI TTEE . THE EXECUTIVE11 COMMITTEE SHALL ALLOW THE OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE PUBLIC12 COMMENT IN CONNECTION WITH THE MEETING .13 SECTION 4. Applicability. This act applies to meetings of the14 general assembly, state public bodies of the general assembly, and15 members of the general assembly occurring on or after the effective date16 of this act.17 SECTION 5. Safety clause. The general assembly finds,18 determines, and declares that this act is necessary for the immediate19 preservation of the public peace, health, or safety or for appropriations for20 the support and maintenance of the departments of the state and state21 institutions.22 157 -7-