O F F I C E O F L E G I S L A T I V E R E S E A R C H P U B L I C A C T S U M M A R Y Page 1 PA 21-34—sHB 6531 Housing Committee AN ACT CONCERNING TH E RIGHT TO COUNSEL I N EVICTION PROCEEDINGS, THE VAL IDITY OF INLAND WETL ANDS PERMITS IN RELATION TO CERTAIN OTHER LAND U SE APPROVALS, AND EXTENDING THE TIME O F EXPIRATION OF CERT AIN LAND USE PERMITS SUMMARY: This act makes unrelated changes regarding (1) certain individuals’ right to counsel in eviction proceedings and (2) local land use approvals. It establishes a statewide “right to counsel program” to provide free legal representation to income-eligible tenants, lessees, or occupants of any residential building or land (i.e., “covered individuals”) in a covered matter initiated on or after July 1, 2021. Under the act, a “covered matter” is an (1) eviction proceeding or (2) administrative proceeding necessary to preserve a state or federal housing subsidy or prevent a proposed lease termination. The act requires the judicial branch to use available federal funds to either contract with, or enter a memorandum of agreement with, an entity to administer the program (i.e., “administering entity”). It also establishes an 11-member working group to advise on matters and policies affecting the right to counsel program. The act requires the administering entity, within available funding, to fund the provision of legal representation under the program by designated organizations (i.e., nonprofit legal services organizations). Additionally, it requires the administering entity to (1) determine, in consultation with the working group and designated organizations, how to phase in the program based on certain relevant factors and (2) starting by January 1, 2023, annually report to the Housing Committee and Judicial Department on the number of individuals represented under the program, the extent of the representation, case outcomes, and tenant engagement and education. It also requires the judicial branch, in consultation with the administering entity, working group, and designated organizations, to approve a one-page, plain- language notice that landlords and certain others must use to inform individuals of their rights under the program starting October 1, 2021. The act also specifies that it does not establish any right enforceable by a covered individual against a designated organization or the administering entity. Regarding local land use approvals, the act generally delays the effective date of municipal inland wetlands permits to coincide with the effective period of related local land use approvals (e.g., special permits, zoning variances, site plans, and subdivision plans) (§ 2). The act also gives developers more time to complete certain ongoing projects without seeking reapproval from local land use boards, O L R P U B L I C A C T S U M M A R Y Page 2 of 6 commissions, or agencies. It applies only to approvals and permits that were (1) granted on or after July 1, 2011, but before the act’s passage (June 10, 2021), and (2) unexpired on March 10, 2020 (§§ 2-9). EFFECTIVE DATE: July 1, 2021, except the concurrent wetlands permit provision (§ 2) is applicable to permits issued on or after July 1, 2021, and the extended land use approval provisions are effective upon passage (§§ 3-9). § 1 — RIGHT TO COUNSEL PROGRAM Program Eligibility Under the act, the right to counsel program is available to income-eligible residential tenants, lessees, or occupants who are parties in an eviction or certain administrative proceedings as described above. The act specifies that it applies to any residential land or building, apartment, or dwelling unit, including trailers or mobile manufactured homes and associated lots. Under the act, an individual is “income-eligible” if he or she: 1. has a household income at or below 80% of the state median income adjusted for family size, as determined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), at the time of the request for representation or 2. receives one of the following types of public assistance: Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits, Medicaid, Supplemental Security Income, refugee resettlement benefits, state rental assistance, or federal Housing Choice Voucher Program assistance. Designated Organization’s Minimum Standards The administering entity, within available funding, must fund the provision of legal representation under the program by designated organizations. Under the act “legal representation” means (1) representation in a covered matter provided by a designated organization to a covered individual and (2) all legal advice, advocacy, and assistance associated with the representation, subject to and in accordance with the Rules of Professional Conduct. A designated organization is a nonprofit legal services organization that has (1) substantial expertise in (a) housing and landlord tenant law and (b) furnishing free legal assistance to eligible individuals and (2) a demonstrated history of serving the low-income community. In addition, it must: 1. identify the geographic area in which it provides legal representation, 2. have a plan to reach and provide legal representation to income-eligible individuals with limited English proficiency, and 3. provide appropriate supervision and training. A designated organization may subcontract with a nonprofit or community organization to provide legal representation and tenant outreach and education under the program. O L R P U B L I C A C T S U M M A R Y Page 3 of 6 Working Group The act establishes an 11-member working group to advise on matters and policies affecting the right to counsel program to effectuate the right to counsel. Members and Appointments. The working group consists of the following members: 1. two each appointed by the Senate president and the House speaker; 2. one each appointed by the Senate and House majority and minority leaders; 3. the Department of Housing (DOH) commissioner, or her designee; 4. a representative of the administering entity; and 5. a judicial branch representative. All initial appointments must be made by July 31, 2021. Members serve a four-year term and may be reappointed or continue to serve until a successor is appointed. Appointing authorities fill vacancies. Meetings and Staff. The DOH commissioner, or her designee, must serve as the working group’s chairperson and schedule the first meeting, which must be held by August 30, 2021. The chairperson must convene the working group on a regular basis but not less than three times per year. The act requires DOH to provide administrative support to the working group. Relevant Factors to Phase in the Program The act requires the administering entity, in consultation with the working group and designated organizations, to determine how to phase in the program based on all relevant factors, including the: 1. prioritization of certain groups of individuals by income, zip codes, census tracts, or other priority criteria they develop; 2. availability of program funding; 3. number of available trained legal services attorneys; and 4. scope of the need for legal representation. Funding The act allows the administering entity to receive funds or services from the government, corporations, associations, or individuals to fund program administration, the provision of legal representation, and tenant outreach and education. Under the act, the judicial branch must appoint additional housing mediators to facilitate the resolution of summary process actions, if the branch receives state or federal funds under the act for that purpose. Under existing law, Superior Court judges or a committee they authorize may appoint housing mediators as they deem necessary, within available appropriations (CGS § 47a-69). Plain-language notice of tenants’ rights O L R P U B L I C A C T S U M M A R Y Page 4 of 6 The act requires the judicial branch, in consultation with the administering entity, working group, and designated organizations, to approve a one-page, plain- language notice to inform tenants of their rights under the program. The notice must (1) include a phone number for information and applying for assistance and (2) be available publicly and on the judicial branch’s website by October 1, 2021. Starting October 1, 2021, the act requires an owner, lessor, or landlord; their agent or legal representative; a housing authority; or a housing subsidy program administrator, as applicable, to attach a copy of the plain-language notice to a (1) notice to quit delivered to a covered individual for an eviction proceeding, (2) summons and complaint for a summary process eviction action, (3) lease termination notice for a public or subsidized housing unit, and (4) notice to terminate a state or federal housing subsidy. Under the act, the court must include similar plain language information in any notice scheduling a mediation or hearing that is sent to a self-represented party in an eviction proceeding. § 2 — EFFECTIVE DATE OF INLAND WETLANDS PERMIT S The act delays the effective date of municipal inland wetlands permits to coincide with the effective period of related local land use approvals. Under the act, if the inland wetlands permit is just one of the local land use approvals required to develop a property, the wetlands permit does not take effect until the other local approvals are effective. By law, inland wetlands permits are generally valid for the same length of time as the other land use approvals issued for the development, up to a maximum of 10 years. §§ 7-9 — SPECIAL PERMIT OR EX CEPTION PROJECT COMP LETION DEADLINES The act establishes a minimum validity period for special permit or exception approvals (1) granted on or after July 1, 2011, but before June 10, 2021; (2) that were unexpired on March 10, 2020; and (3) that specified a deadline by which all work connected to the approval must be completed. Under the act, these approvals are valid for a minimum of 19 years after the approval is granted. Prior law did not impose any minimum validity periods for these approvals (see BACKGROUND). The act specifies that (1) the applicable land use board, commission, or agency may extend these approvals beyond 19 years and (2) this minimum 19- year validity period applies to special permits or exceptions approved by a municipality exercising land use powers under the statutes or a special act. §§ 3-9 — OTHER PROJECT COMPLETION DEADLINES Municipalities Exercising Authority Under the Statutes (§§ 3-8) O L R P U B L I C A C T S U M M A R Y Page 5 of 6 By law, when a planning or zoning commission, combined planning and zoning commission, or an inland wetlands agency operating under the statutes approves a project, it must set an expiration date that falls within the timeframes the law specifies. Consequently, a developer must complete the project before that date or resubmit it to the local commission or agency for approval. Generally, the maximum timeframe (including any extensions granted) is 10 years from the date of approval. The act extends these timeframes for approvals that were (1) granted on or after July 1, 2011, but before June 10, 2021, and (2) unexpired on March 10, 2020. Under the act, except for large residential subdivisions, the initial deadline must be at least 14 years after approval, and the extended deadline cannot be more than 19 years after approval. Large residential subdivision approvals are valid for 19 years. The table below shows the prior and extended deadlines that apply to subdivision, wetlands, and site plans approvals granted within the above timeframe by municipalities operating under the statutes. Statutory Deadlines and Extensions Under Prior Law and the Act Land Use Approval (CGS §) Prior Law Act Residential site plans for projects with 400 or more units (§ 8-3(j)) Deadline: 10 years after approval No change No extensions Business site plans for projects with at least 400,000 square feet (§ 8-3(j)) Deadline: 5-10 years after approval (set locally) No change Extension: up to 10 years from approval Other site plans (§ 8-3(i)) Deadline: 5 years after approval At least 14 years after approval Extension: up to 10 years from approval Up to 19 years from approval Subdivisions plans for 400 or more dwelling units (§ 8-26g) Deadline: 10 years after approval 19 years after approval No extensions No change Other subdivisions (§ 8-26c(a)&(b)) Deadline: 5 years after approval At least 14 years after approval Extension: up to 10 years from approval Up to 19 years from approval Wetlands permits associated with another approval (e.g., site plans and subdivisions) (§ 22a-42a(d)(2)) Deadline: 10 years after approval or the date the associated land use approval expires (whichever is earlier) At least 14 years after approval Extension: up to 10 years from approval Up to 19 years from approval Other wetlands (§ 22a-42a(d)(2)) Deadline: 2-5 years after approval (set locally) At least 14 years after approval O L R P U B L I C A C T S U M M A R Y Page 6 of 6 Land Use Approval (CGS §) Prior Law Act Extension: up to 10 years from approval Up to 19 years from approval Municipalities Exercising Authority Under a Special Act (§ 9) The act sets a minimum approval duration of 14 years for site plan and subdivision approvals and other permits (except special permits or exceptions, see above) granted by a zoning commission, planning commission, combined planning and zoning commission, zoning board of appeals, or inland wetlands agency exercising land use powers under a special act. The act applies only to approvals that were (1) granted on or after July 1, 2011, but before the act’s passage (June 10, 2021), and (2) unexpired on March 10, 2020. The act specifies that local boards or agencies may approve extensions, but caps the total duration of an approval, including extensions, at 19 years (except special permits or exceptions, see above). The 14- and 19-year timeframes are calculated based on the initial approval date and apply regardless of conflicting special acts or approval conditions. BACKGROUND Related Act PA 21-163 gives developers more time to complete an ongoing project that was approved before July 1, 2011. Special Permits and Exceptions and Related Caselaw “Special permit” and “special exception” are synonymous. The designated local land use agency may grant special permits or exceptions pursuant to the Zoning Enabling Act (CGS § 8-2) or a special act, as applicable. Special permits and exceptions allow one to use a property in a manner explicitly permitted by the zoning regulations but subject to conditions not applicable to other uses in the same district. The rationale for special permits and exceptions is that while certain land uses may be generally compatible with the uses permitted as of right in a particular zoning district, their nature is such that their precise location and mode of operation must be individually regulated. In February 2021, the Connecticut Appellate Court issued a decision applicable to municipalities that exercise zoning powers under the statutes. It held that the law authorizes these municipalities to impose temporal conditions on special permits or exceptions, such as a condition requiring development to be completed by a specific date (International Investors v. Fairfield Planning & Zoning Commission, 202 Conn. App. 582, cert. granted, 336 Conn. 928 (March 30, 2021)).