Researcher: TA Page 1 4/21/21 OLR Bill Analysis HB 6641 AN ACT CONCERNING THE REMOTE AND ONLINE PROVISION OF MUNICIPAL SERVICES. SUMMARY This bill makes numerous changes allowing municipal entities and other public agencies to conduct business electronically. Generally, the changes allow specified (1) notices and applications to be sent electronically and (2) hearings or meetings to be held using electronic equipment (§§ 7-15 & 17-28). The bill also allows public agencies to hold meetings remotely under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) through conference call, videoconference, or other technology (§§ 2 & 29). It specifically allows municipalities to hold town meetings and budget adoption proceedings using electronic equipment (§§ 3-4 & 16). The bill allows towns, cities, and boroughs, whenever they are required by the law or a charter to advertise a legal notice in a newspaper, to instead post the notice on their websites. It similarly allows town, city, borough, and district clerks, wherever they are required by the law or a charter to file a notice, to instead post the notice on their websites (§ 1). Additionally, the bill requires town clerks to designate a website for paying recording fees (e.g., recording documents on the land records) and accept payments for these fees through the website in a manner they prescribe. It similarly imposes these requirements on registrars of vital statistics for vital records fees (e.g., birth certificates) (§§ 5 & 6). (Typically, the town clerk serves as the registrar of vital statistics.) Lastly, the bill makes technical and conforming changes. EFFECTIVE DATE: October 1, 2021 2021HB-06641-R000547-BA.DOCX Researcher: TA Page 2 4/21/21 §§ 2 & 29 — FOIA Conducting Meetings Under current law, FOIA’s definition of “meeting” includes those held by electronic equipment, but it does not explicitly authorize, or establish procedures for, telephone or other remotely held meetings (see BACKGROUND). The bill explicitly allows meetings to be held under FOIA using electronic equipment or simultaneously in-person and using electronic equipment. (Presumably, they can also hold in-person meetings.) It requires that meetings held using either of these methods provide opportunity for comment or testimony, voting, or other participation, as applicable. Additionally, it requires meeting participants (both agency members and the public) to state their name and title (if applicable) each time before speaking in a meeting conducted using electronic equipment. Under the bill, "electronic equipment" means any technology facilitating real-time public access to and participation in meetings, including telephone, video, or other conferencing platforms. Meeting Minutes Under existing law, FOIA requires (1) public agencies to make meeting minutes available in the agency's office within seven days after the meeting and (2) public agencies, other than those of political subdivisions (e.g., municipalities), to post meeting minutes on their websites within this timeframe. The bill extends both of these requirements (and the exception to the website positing requirement) to any audio or video recording or transcript of a meeting. (However, the bill does not require agencies to record or transcribe meetings.) Agendas for Regular Meetings Under current law, FOIA requires state agencies to post agendas for regular meetings on their websites at least 24 hours before the meeting but it does not apply this requirement to political subdivisions. The bill instead requires all public agencies to post their meeting agendas on their websites. Under the bill, regular meeting agendas must also 2021HB-06641-R000547-BA.DOCX Researcher: TA Page 3 4/21/21 include instructions for the public to (1) attend the meeting in person or electronically and (2) comment, vote, or otherwise participate, as applicable. Notices of a Special Meeting The bill similarly requires that the above instructions for meeting attendance and participation be included in any notice of a special meeting. (A special meeting is one held to consider business that (1) was unforeseen when scheduling regular meetings and (2) should be addressed before the next regular meeting.) The bill allows notices of a special meeting to be electronically sent to a public agency's members rather than delivered to their homes as current law requires. Current law also allows members to waive delivery of the notice by filing a written waiver with the agency's clerk or secretary. The bill allows members to submit these waivers electronically. §§ 3-4 & 16 — TOWN MEETINGS AND BO ARD OF FINANCE PROCEEDINGS The bill allows town meetings to be held under FOIA using electronic equipment or simultaneously in-person and using electronic equipment. (Presumably, they may also be held in-person). It requires that meetings held using either of these methods provide opportunity for comment or testimony, voting, or other participation, as applicable. Presumably, the bill's provisions allowing voting through electronic equipment apply only to votes taken at the town meeting itself and do not extend to votes taken at an adjourned town meeting (i.e., a referendum). The bill also allows municipal boards of finance to hold specified meetings and hearings using electronic equipment or simultaneously in person and using electronic equipment. It applies to (1) public hearings on the proposed annual budget, (2) the board's meeting at which it votes on a recommended budget, and (3) the board's meeting to lay a tax on the grand list. (It also appears to apply to the town meeting at which the budget is voted on.) 2021HB-06641-R000547-BA.DOCX Researcher: TA Page 4 4/21/21 As with town meetings, the bill requires boards of finance holding hearings or meeting using electronic equipment to provide opportunity for comment or testimony, voting, or other participation, as applicable. §§ 7-15 & 17-28 — ELECTRONIC TRANSACTI ONS BY MUNICIPAL PROGRAMS AND ENTITIE S The bill makes numerous changes allowing municipal entities or programs to conduct business or otherwise operate using electronic means, as shown in Table 1. Generally, the changes allow specified (1) notices and applications to be sent electronically and (2) hearings or meetings to be held using electronic equipment. The bill defines "electronic equipment" for these purposes as any technology facilitating real-time communication between two or more individuals, including telephone, video, or other conferencing platforms. Table 1: Electronic Transactions Authorized by Bill § Municipal Entity or Program Action Electronic Option Allowed by Bill 8-9 Discriminatory practices board Hearing on alleged discriminatory practice Allows hearing to be conducted by electronic equipment 10 Municipal revenue- sharing agreements Opportunity for public participation in the negotiations between the municipalities Specifies that public participation may be in person, writing, or by electronic equipment 11 Foreclosed residential property registration Registration with municipal clerk of a residential property on which a plaintiff commences a foreclosure action Allows registration to be completed electronically in a manner the clerk prescribes Notice to clerk by plaintiff of any change in the registration information Allows plaintiff to provide this information by email Registration with clerk of a residential property by the person to whom title vests in a foreclosure action (or registration update if the person is the plaintiff Allows registration or update to be sent by email 2021HB-06641-R000547-BA.DOCX Researcher: TA Page 5 4/21/21 in the action) Notice to clerk by registrant of any change in the registration information Allows registrant to provide this information by email 12 Parking violation hearings Notice to vehicle owner or operator of fines, penalties, costs, or fees for alleged parking violations Allows notice to be sent to the owner's or operator's email address if known Request by owner or operator for a hearing before a parking violation hearing officer Allows owners and operators to make this request by email Hearing Allows hearing to be held in person or by electronic equipment 13-15 Municipal water pollution control authority Public hearing on sewerage system connection and use charges Allows hearing to be conducted by electronic equipment Requires that hearing notice be published on municipality's website, rather than in a newspaper as current law requires Charges that are finalized or revised after the public hearing Requires that copy of the charges be published on municipality's website, rather than in a newspaper as current law requires (the bill retains existing law's requirement that it also be filed in the municipal clerk's office) Public hearings on orders issued to building owners to (1) connect the building to an available sewerage system or (2) construct and connect the building to an alternative sewage treatment system Allows hearing to be conducted by electronic equipment 17 Local land use boards Subdivision or zoning regulations adopted by board Requires board to publish regulations on its website, in addition to making printed copies available at a reasonable price as existing law requires 18-19 Boards of Appeals to board by taxpayers Allows taxpayers to file 2021HB-06641-R000547-BA.DOCX Researcher: TA Page 6 4/21/21 assessment appeals aggrieved by a municipal assessor's actions appeals by email in a manner the board prescribes Board may meet to reduce a taxpayer's assessment The taxpayer, or the taxpayer's attorney or agent, must appear at a hearing before the board before it can reduce the assessment Allows boards to hold these hearings and meetings using electronic equipment Deems the taxpayer, attorney, or agent to have appeared at the hearing if he or she attends using electronic equipment 20 Tax assessors and boards of assessment appeals Notice to Office of Policy and Management (OPM) of deadline extensions to assessors' or boards' duties granted by the municipal chief executive officer Allows notice to be provided by email in a manner the OPM secretary prescribes Request by municipality to OPM for a revaluation delay Eliminates requirement that supporting information provided by board of assessment appeals and chief executive officer be in writing Notice to taxpayers of assessment increases in municipalities for which OPM authorizes a revaluation delay Allows notice to be sent by email 21-22 Renters’ Rebate program Rebate applications filed with municipal assessor Allows applications to be filed electronically in a manner the OPM secretary prescribes Appeals filed with OPM by persons aggrieved by assessor's decision Allows appeals to be filed electronically in a manner the secretary prescribes 23 Property tax freeze for seniors Program applications Requires that applications be made in writing or electronically in a manner the municipal assessor prescribes Applicants' income tax returns Allows taxpayers to present an electronic copy of the return Biennial notice by municipal assessor to program participants of reapplication requirements (by law, program participants must reapply to the program biennially) Allows assessors to provide notice electronically at the taxpayer's option 24-25 Property tax circuit breaker Affidavit filed with municipal assessor stating applicant’s Allows affidavit to be filed electronically in a manner the 2021HB-06641-R000547-BA.DOCX Researcher: TA Page 7 4/21/21 for seniors and homeowners with disabilities income assessor prescribes Program application Allows application to be submitted by email in a manner the OPM secretary or municipal assessor (as applicable) prescribes Biennial notice by municipal assessor to program participants of reapplication requirements (by law, program participants must reapply to the program biennially) Allows assessors to provide notice electronically at the taxpayer's option Notice by grantee to municipal assessor of a property transfer by a grantor who was previously approved for the circuit breaker Allows grantee to provide notice by email in a manner the assessor prescribes Notice by tax collector to grantee of any additional tax due Allows tax collector to provide notice by email at the grantee's option Application to assessor for a grant in lieu of a property tax reduction Allows applicant to submit application by email in a manner the assessor prescribes Appeal to the OPM secretary by a person aggrieved by an assessor's decision Allows person to appeal by email in a manner the secretary prescribes 26-27 Municipal building permits Permit application Requires that applications be filed in person, by mail, or by email, in a manner the building official prescribes Permit applications containing plans and specifications previously approved by the state building inspector Allows applications to be filed in person, by mail, or by email, in a manner the building official prescribes 28 Municipal building officials Appeals filed with municipal board of appeals by persons aggrieved by the building official's decision Allows appeals by email in a manner the board prescribes Appeals filed with municipal chief executive officer when there is no board of appeals Allows appeals by email in a manner the chief executive officer prescribes BACKGROUND Related Bills 2021HB-06641-R000547-BA.DOCX Researcher: TA Page 8 4/21/21 sHB 6651, sSB 183 (File 441), and sSB 1074, reported favorably by the Government Administration and Elections Committee, authorize remote meetings under similar conditions as those in the bill. sHB 6448, reported favorably by the Planning and Development Committee, authorizes remote meetings while also requiring agencies to make their meetings (including in-person meetings) accessible to the public through electronic equipment. Telephone Meetings Under FOIA Although FOIA currently does not explicitly authorize telephone or other remotely held meetings, its definition of "meeting" includes those held by electronic equipment (CGS § 1-200(2)). In its only advisory opinion on the subject, the Freedom of Information Commission (FOIC) advised that public agencies conducting business over the phone must comply with FOIA’s open meeting requirements. According to FOIC, agencies must make sure that the public has “access to the entire proceedings taking place during the course of a meeting.” Specifically, the commission advised that the meeting must comply with at least the following: 1. members of the public who want to attend the meeting must be accommodated at a place where the greatest number of participating agency members are located; 2. people attending the meeting, including members of the public, must be able to see and inspect copies of any physical or demonstrable materials presented or used; and 3. all those attending the meeting, at whatever location, must be able to hear and identify adequately all participants in the proceedings, including individual remarks and votes (Advisory Opinion 41, 1980). COMMITTEE ACTION 2021HB-06641-R000547-BA.DOCX Researcher: TA Page 9 4/21/21 Planning and Development Committee Joint Favorable Yea 17 Nay 9 (03/31/2021)