Researcher: MK Page 1 5/25/23 OLR Bill Analysis sSB 1118 (File 644, as amended by Senate "A")* AN ACT CONCERNING A STUDY OF THE CONSOLIDATION OF THE FAMILY VIOLENCE MODEL POLICY GOVERNING COUNCIL AND THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE OFFENDER PROGRAM STANDARDS ADVISORY COUNCIL. SUMMARY This bill (1) changes the name of the “Family Violence Model Policy Governing Council” to the “Domestic Violence Criminal Justice Response and Enhancement Advisory Council”; (2) increases its membership from 19 to 26 members; and (3) expands the scope of its purpose and responsibilities, including by incorporating those of the Domestic Violence Offender Program Standards Advisory Council, which the bill repeals. Separately, the bill requires the court, upon the motion of an injured spouse, to terminate any orders it entered requiring the injured spouse to make alimony payments if the recipient-spouse is subsequently convicted of certain crimes against the injured spouse. (It does this by amending sSB 5, as amended by Senate “A.”) The bill also deletes obsolete provisions and makes technical and conforming changes (§§ 2 & 3). *Senate Amendment “A” replaces the underlying bill, which would have required the chairpersons of the Family Violence Model Policy Governing Council and the Domestic Violence Offender Program Standards Advisory Council to study whether consolidating the councils would enhance their services. EFFECTIVE DATE: July 1, 2023, except the provision on alimony awards is effective October 1, 2023. 2023SB-01118-R01-BA.DOCX Researcher: MK Page 2 5/25/23 § 1 — DOMESTIC VIOLENCE CR IMINAL JUSTICE RESPONSE AND ENHANCEMENT ADVISORY COUNCIL The bill renames the “Family Violence Model Policy Governing Council” as the “Domestic Violence Criminal Justice Response and Enhancement Advisory Council” (the “council”), increases its membership, and broadens the scope of its purpose and responsibilities. Purpose and Responsibilities Current law charges the council with: 1. evaluating policies and procedures law enforcement agencies use when responding to family violence incidents and violations of restraining and protective orders, 2. reviewing and updating the statewide model law enforcement policy on family violence, and 3. evaluating the accuracy of data collected by the Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection (DESPP) and the judicial branch’s Court Support Services Division (CSSD). The bill broadens the council’s purpose and responsibilities by, among other things, requiring it to collect and analyze any additional data related to domestic violence and the criminal justice response available from the judicial branch court operations, state’s attorneys, public defenders, domestic violence advocates, or domestic violence offender programs. Additionally, the bill requires the council to evaluate and advise on: 1. the existing domestic violence offender program standards, including reviewing and updating them as needed; 2. the pretrial family violence education program, including the program’s eligibility criteria; 3. dedicated domestic violence dockets, including statewide expansion of the dockets; 2023SB-01118-R01-BA.DOCX Researcher: MK Page 3 5/25/23 4. the use of electronic monitoring; 5. risk assessments used in a family violence case from arrest through adjudication; 6. arrest, prosecution, penalties, and monitoring for violations of family violence restraining orders or criminal protective orders issued in family violence cases; 7. processing and execution of arrest warrants for family violence incidents; 8. monitoring compliance, enforcement, and victim notification of firearm seizure and surrender in family violence cases; 9. programming offered to individuals convicted of a family violence crime and currently incarcerated with the Department of Correction (DOC); and 10. training and education for criminal justice stakeholders, including law enforcement, judges, and judicial branch staff. Membership and Appointments The bill increases the council’s membership from 19 to 26. Under current law, the council’s 19 members are appointed as follows: 1. one each by the governor, the Senate president pro tempore, House speaker, and the Senate and House minority leaders; 2. a domestic violence victim, appointed by the Senate majority leader; 3. a municipal police officer with experience in domestic violence training, appointed by the House majority leader; 4. a Police Officer Standards and Training Council (POST) representative with experience in domestic violence training, appointed by the chairperson of the council; 2023SB-01118-R01-BA.DOCX Researcher: MK Page 4 5/25/23 5. a representative of the Office of the Chief State’s Attorney, the Chief Public Defender’s Office, and the Office of the Victim Advocate; 6. a Division of State Police representative with experience in domestic violence training and a commanding officer in the Division of State Police, appointed by the DESPP commissioner; 7. a Superior Court judge assigned to hear criminal matters, appointed by the chief court administrator; 8. a domestic violence victim, a victim advocate with courtroom experience in domestic violence matters, and a representative of the Connecticut Coalition Against Domestic Violence, Inc. (CCADV), each appointed by the CCADV executive director; 9. a representative of legal aid programs in Connecticut, appointed by the executive director of the Legal Assistance Resource Center of Connecticut; and 10. a representative of the Connecticut Police Chiefs Association, appointed by the president of the association. The bill increases the council’s membership to 26 and makes the following changes to its composition: 1. substitutes the Senate majority leader’s appointment with a representative of a community-based organization that provides group counseling or treatment to domestic violence perpetrators; 2. adds the Office of Policy Management secretary, the Board of Pardons and Paroles chairperson, and the DESPP and DOC commissioners, or their designees; 3. instead of their representatives, adds the POST chairperson, the chief public defender, the chief state’s attorney, and the victim advocate or their designees; 4. increases the chief court administrator’s appointments from one 2023SB-01118-R01-BA.DOCX Researcher: MK Page 5 5/25/23 to four by adding (a) a CSSD family relations counselor or supervisor, (b) a CSSD administrator, and (c) an administrator from the Office of Victim Services; 5. increases the CCADV executive director’s appointments from three to four by adding an executive director of a community- based organization that provides direct services to persons impacted by domestic violence; and 6. removes the representative of the legal aid programs in Connecticut. Under existing law, unchanged by the bill, members serve four-year terms, may be reappointed, and must continue to serve until successors are appointed and qualified. By law, legislators may serve as council members. Chairperson and Staff The bill specifies that the council’s chairpersons are responsible for scheduling its meetings. Under current law, the Public Safety and Security Committee’s administrative staff serves as the council’s administrative staff. Under the bill, the Judiciary Committee’s administrative staff must do so instead. Reporting Under existing law, the council must submit an annual report by January 15 to the Judiciary and Public Safety and Security committees on the effectiveness of the existing model law enforcement policy on family violence and any recommended changes. The bill expands this report to also include recommendations for any statutory or policy changes within the council’s purview, including any recommended updates or amendments to the existing domestic violence offender program standards. § 5 — DOMESTIC VIOLENCE OF FENDER PROGRAM STAND ARDS ADVISORY COUNCIL REPEALED 2023SB-01118-R01-BA.DOCX Researcher: MK Page 6 5/25/23 Under current law, the Domestic Violence Offender Program Standards Advisory Council is a 16-member council created to promulgate, review, and update and amend as needed the domestic violence offender program standards presented to the Criminal Justice Policy Advisory Committee. Current law also requires the council to annually report its activities to the Judiciary Committee, including any updates or amendments to the domestic violence offender program standards adopted in the previous calendar year. The bill repeals this advisory council and instead incorporates its responsibilities into the newly named Domestic Violence Criminal Justice Response and Enhancement Advisory Council. § 4 — ALIMONY AWARDS Among other things, sSB 5 (as amended by Senate “A”) prohibits the court from ordering an injured spouse to make temporary or permanent alimony payments to a spouse who is convicted of any of the following crimes after the marriage date: 1. criminal attempt or conspiracy to commit murder, murder with special circumstances, felony murder, or arson murder of the other spouse; 2. 1st degree sexual assault and 1st degree aggravated sexual assault of the other spouse; 3. a class A or B felony offense of 2nd degree sexual assault or 3rd degree sexual assault with a firearm of the other spouse; 4. a class A or B felony family violence crime; or 5. any crime in another state, with essential elements that are substantially the same as the crimes listed above. This bill requires the court to terminate any alimony order if the recipient-spouse is subsequently convicted of any of the above crimes against the injured spouse. The court must do so upon a motion filed by the injured spouse to terminate alimony based upon the conviction. sSB 5 (as amended by Senate “A”) defines an “injured spouse” as the 2023SB-01118-R01-BA.DOCX Researcher: MK Page 7 5/25/23 spouse who was the victim of one of the crimes listed above, regardless of whether physical injury occurred in the commission of the crime. BACKGROUND Related Bill sSB5 (File 552, as amended by Senate “A”), reported favorably by the Judiciary and Appropriations committees, contains provisions that prohibit a court from ordering an injured spouse to make temporary or permanent alimony payments to a spouse who is convicted of certain crimes after the marriage date. COMMITTEE ACTION Judiciary Committee Joint Favorable Substitute Yea 37 Nay 0 (03/31/2023)