LCO \\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147-R01- SB.docx 1 of 12 General Assembly Substitute Bill No. 1147 January Session, 2023 AN ACT CONCERNING THE ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE PROGRAM OF THE DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION. Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Assembly convened: Section 1. Section 22a-20a of the general statutes is repealed and the 1 following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective October 1, 2023): 2 (a) As used in this section: 3 (1) "Environmental justice community" means (A) a United States 4 census block group, as determined in accordance with the most recent 5 United States census, for which thirty per cent or more of the 6 population consists of low income persons [who are not 7 institutionalized] and have an income below two hundred per cent of 8 the federal poverty level; or (B) a distressed municipality, as defined in 9 subsection (b) of section 32-9p; 10 (2) "Affecting facility" means any (A) electric generating facility with 11 a capacity of more than ten megawatts; (B) sludge or solid waste 12 incinerator or combustor; (C) [sewage treatment plant with a capacity 13 of more than fifty million gallons per day] publicly owned treatment 14 works in a community with combined sewers that transport both 15 storm water and sanitary sewage, or an expanded design flow rate for 16 any publicly owned treatment works; (D) intermediate processing 17 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 2 of 12 center, volume reduction facility, solid waste transfer station, resource 18 recovery facility, chemical recycling facility or multitown recycling 19 facility with a combined monthly volume in excess of twenty-five tons; 20 (E) [new or expanded] landfill, including, but not limited to, a landfill 21 that contains ash, construction and demolition debris or solid waste; 22 (F) medical waste incinerator; [or] (G) major source of air pollution, as 23 defined by the federal Clean Air Act; (H) pipeline, terminal or bulk 24 commercial storage facility not providing direct-to-consumer retail or 25 delivery for fossil fuels, including coal, oil, petroleum and natural gas; 26 or (I) facility with a diversion of more than two million gallons of 27 water per day. "Affecting facility" shall not include (i) the portion of an 28 electric generating facility that uses nonemitting and nonpolluting 29 renewable resources such as wind, solar and hydro power or that uses 30 fuel cells, (ii) any facility for which a certificate of environmental 31 compatibility and public need was obtained from the Connecticut 32 Siting Council on or before January 1, 2000, [or] (iii) a facility of a 33 constituent unit of the state system of higher education that has been 34 the subject of an environmental impact evaluation in accordance with 35 the provisions of sections 22a-1b to 22a-1h, inclusive, and such 36 evaluation has been determined to be satisfactory in accordance with 37 section 22a-1e; or (iv) a facility with a diversion of water greater than 38 two million gallons in any twenty-four-hour period that diverts water 39 for public water supply purposes within a service area, as defined in 40 regulations adopted pursuant to subsection (b) of section 22a-377, that 41 includes the origin of such diversion; 42 (3) "Meaningful public participation" means (A) residents of an 43 environmental justice community have an appropriate opportunity to 44 participate in decisions about a proposed facility or the expansion of 45 an existing facility that may adversely affect such residents' 46 environment or health; (B) the public's participation may influence the 47 regulatory agency's decision; and (C) the applicant for a new or 48 expanded permit, certificate or siting approval seeks out and facilitates 49 the participation of those potentially affected during the regulatory 50 process; [and] 51 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 3 of 12 (4) "Community environmental benefit agreement" means a written 52 agreement entered into by the chief elected official or town manager of 53 a municipality and an owner or developer of real property whereby 54 the owner or developer agrees to develop real property that is to be 55 used for any new or expanded affecting facility and to provide 56 financial resources for the purpose of the mitigation, in whole or in 57 part, of impacts reasonably related to the facility, including, but not 58 limited to, impacts on the environment, including, but not limited to, 59 air quality and watercourses, quality of life, asthma rates, traffic, 60 parking and noise; 61 (5) "Council" means the Connecticut Siting Council; 62 (6) "Department" means the Department of Energy and 63 Environmental Protection; 64 (7) "Environmental or public health stressors" means: (A) Sources of 65 environmental pollution, including, but not limited to, concentrated 66 areas of air pollution, mobile sources of air pollution, contaminated 67 sites, transfer stations or other solid waste facilities, recycling facilities, 68 scrap yards and point-sources of water pollution, including, but not 69 limited to, water pollution from facilities or combined sewer 70 overflows, or (B) conditions that may cause potential public health 71 impacts, including, but not limited to, asthma, cancer, elevated blood 72 lead levels, cardiovascular disease and developmental problems in any 73 environmental justice community; 74 (8) "Major source" means (A) a major source of air pollution, as 75 defined by the federal Clean Air Act or rules or regulations adopted by 76 the department, or (B) an affecting facility that directly emits, or has 77 the potential to emit, one hundred tons per year or more of any air 78 pollutant or other applicable criteria set forth in the federal Clean Air 79 Act; and 80 (9) "Permit" means any individual facility permit, license, certificate 81 or siting approval issued by the department or council to a facility that 82 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 4 of 12 establishes the regulatory and management requirements for a 83 regulated activity pursuant to section 16-50k, 22a-174, 22a-208a or 22a-84 430. "Permit" does not include (A) any authorization or approval 85 necessary to perform a remediation conducted in accordance with the 86 regulations established pursuant to section 22a-133k; (B) applications 87 for or registrations under general permits issued by the department, 88 provided the Commissioner of Energy and Environmental Protection 89 shall evaluate the potential for environmental and health stressors 90 when issuing or renewing any general permit; (C) any permit for a 91 facility with a diversion of more than two million gallons per day 92 where such diverted water is used for public water supply purposes 93 within the exclusive service area from where such water is diverted; 94 (D) any authorization or approval required for a minor modification of 95 a facility's major source permit for activities or improvements that do 96 not increase emissions; or (E) any authorization or approval required 97 for an extension of time to complete construction of a facility. 98 (b) (1) Applicants who, on or after January 1, 2009, seek to obtain 99 any certificate under chapter 277a, new or expanded permit or siting 100 approval from the Department of Energy and Environmental 101 Protection or the Connecticut Siting Council involving an affecting 102 facility that is proposed to be located in an environmental justice 103 community or the proposed expansion of an affecting facility located 104 in such a community, shall (A) file an assessment of environmental or 105 public health stressors and a meaningful public participation plan with 106 such department or council and shall obtain the department's or 107 council's approval of such public participation plan prior to filing any 108 application for such permit, certificate or approval; [and] (B) consult 109 with the chief elected official or officials of the town or towns in which 110 the affecting facility is to be located or expanded to evaluate the need 111 for a community environmental benefit agreement in accordance with 112 subsection (d) of this section; and (C) submit and receive approval of a 113 public participation report that shall include, but not be limited to, (i) 114 an affidavit that the applicant satisfied the requirements of 115 subdivisions (2) to (5), inclusive, of this subsection; (ii) all written 116 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 5 of 12 comments received; and (iii) responses to concerns and questions 117 presented in such written and verbal comments, including any 118 changes to the activity or affecting facility proposed. Each assessment 119 of environmental or public health stressors prepared pursuant to this 120 subsection shall contain an assessment of the potential environmental 121 and public health stressors associated with the proposed new or 122 expanded affecting facility, as applicable, and shall identify any 123 adverse environmental or public health stressors that cannot be 124 avoided if the permit is granted, and the environmental or public 125 health stressors already borne by the applicable environmental justice 126 community. 127 (2) Each such meaningful public participation plan shall contain 128 measures to facilitate meaningful public participation in the regulatory 129 process and a certification that the applicant will undertake the 130 measures contained in the plan. Such plan shall identify a time and 131 place where an informal public meeting will be held that is convenient 132 for the residents of the affected environmental justice community. In 133 addition, any such plan shall identify the methods, if any, by which the 134 applicant will publicize the date, time and nature of the informal 135 public meeting in addition to the notice by mail required by 136 subdivision (3) of this subsection and the publication required by 137 subdivision [(3)] (4) of this subsection. Such methods shall include, but 138 not be limited to, (A) posting a reasonably visible sign on the proposed 139 or existing affecting facility property, printed in English, in accordance 140 with any local regulations and ordinances, (B) posting a reasonably 141 visible sign, printed in all languages spoken by at least fifteen per cent 142 of the population that reside within a one-half of a mile radius of the 143 proposed or existing affecting facility, in accordance with local 144 regulations and ordinances, [and] (C) notifying local and state elected 145 officials, in writing, and (D) a posting on electronic media, including, 146 but not limited to, relevant Internet web sites and social media 147 platforms, provided such notice is readily found by searching for the 148 name of the affecting facility on the Internet. Such methods may 149 include notifying neighborhood and environmental groups, in writing, 150 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 6 of 12 in a language appropriate for the target audience. The determination 151 of the percentage of persons that speak a language, for purposes of 152 subparagraph (B) of this subdivision, shall be made in accordance with 153 the most recent United States census. 154 (3) Not less than thirty days prior to the informal public meeting, 155 the applicant shall send a notice of such informal public meeting by 156 mail to all residential households located within a one-half-mile radius 157 of the proposed or existing affecting facility. Such notice shall provide 158 the date, time and location of such meeting, a description of the 159 proposed or expanded affecting facility, a map indicating the location 160 of the affecting facility, information on how an interested person may 161 review project documents, including any complete needs assessment, 162 alternatives assessment, environmental impact analysis or assessment 163 of environmental or public health stressors, addresses for mailed and 164 Internet-based submission of written public comments and any other 165 information deemed appropriate by the department or council. The 166 applicant shall provide such notice in writing in all languages spoken 167 by not less than fifteen per cent of the population that resides within 168 such one-half-mile radius of the proposed or existing affecting facility. 169 Such applicant shall subsequently send notice by mail to all such 170 residential households of any subsequent public participation 171 opportunities that occur as part of the permit approval process before 172 the department or council, and to notify such residential households of 173 any notice of tentative or final determination by the department or 174 council. 175 [(3)] (4) Not less than ten days prior to the informal public meeting 176 and not more than thirty days prior to such meeting, the applicant 177 shall publish the date, time and nature of the informal public meeting 178 with a minimum one-quarter page advertisement in a newspaper 179 having general circulation in the area affected, and any other 180 appropriate local newspaper serving such area, in the Monday issue of 181 a daily publication or any day in a weekly or monthly publication. 182 Such advertisement shall include information on how an interested 183 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 7 of 12 person may review project documents, including any complete needs 184 assessment, alternatives assessment, environmental impact analysis 185 and assessment of environmental and public health stressors. The 186 applicant shall post a similar notification of the informal public 187 meeting on the applicant's web site, if applicable. 188 [(4)] (5) At the informal public meeting, the applicant shall make a 189 reasonable and good faith effort to provide clear, accurate and 190 complete information about the proposed affecting facility or the 191 proposed expansion of [a] such facility and the potential 192 environmental and health impacts of such affecting facility or such 193 expansion. The applicant shall accept written comments, submitted via 194 mail or electronic mail, and oral comments from any interested party, 195 and provide an opportunity for meaningful public participation at the 196 informal public meeting. Not later than thirty days after such informal 197 public meeting, the applicant shall submit to the department or council 198 a public participation report, as described in subdivision (1) of this 199 subsection. The applicant shall video record the informal public 200 meeting and submit the recording to the department or council with 201 the public participation report. 202 [(5)] (6) The Department of Energy and Environmental Protection or 203 the Connecticut Siting Council shall not take any action on the 204 applicant's application for a permit, license, certificate or approval 205 earlier than [sixty days after the informal public meeting] the date the 206 department or council approves the public participation report. For 207 any such application filed on or after November 1, [2020] 2023, if the 208 applicant fails to undertake the requirements of [subparagraphs (B) to 209 (D), inclusive, of subdivision (2) of this subsection or subdivision (3) or 210 (4) of] this subsection, any such application shall be deemed 211 insufficient. The application of an applicant who fails to receive 212 approval of such public participation report by the department or 213 council, as applicable, shall be deemed insufficient. 214 [(6)] (7) In the event that the Connecticut Siting Council has 215 approved a [meaningful public participation plan] public participation 216 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 8 of 12 report concerning a new or expanded affecting facility and an informal 217 public meeting has been held in accordance with this subsection, the 218 Department of Energy and Environmental Protection may [approve 219 such plan and] waive the requirement that an additional informal 220 public meeting be held in accordance with this subsection. 221 (8) In addition to any other fee authorized by law, rule or 222 regulation, the department or council, as applicable, may assess each 223 permit, license or certificate applicant a reasonable fee in order to cover 224 the costs associated with the implementation of this section, including 225 all costs to provide technical assistance to permit applicants and 226 environmental justice communities to comply with the provisions of 227 this section. 228 (c) Any municipality, owner or developer may enter into a 229 community environmental benefit agreement in connection with an 230 expanded or new affecting facility. For any application filed on or after 231 November 1, 2020, for such an affecting facility that: (1) Requires a 232 certificate under chapter 277a, or (2) constitutes a new or expanded 233 permit or siting approval from the Department of Energy and 234 Environmental Protection or the Connecticut Siting Council, and that 235 is located in an environmental justice community or is proposed to be 236 located in such a community, the applicant shall enter into such an 237 agreement with the municipality if there are five or more affecting 238 facilities in such municipality at the time such application is filed. 239 Mitigation may include both on-site and off-site improvements, 240 activities and programs, including, but not limited to: Funding for 241 activities such as environmental education, diesel pollution reduction, 242 electric vehicle charging infrastructure construction, establishment of a 243 wellness clinic, ongoing asthma screening, provision of air monitoring 244 performed by a credentialed environmental professional, performance 245 of an ongoing traffic study, watercourse monitoring, construction of 246 biking facilities and multi-use trails, staffing for parks, urban forestry, 247 support for community gardens or any other negotiated benefit to the 248 environment in the environmental justice community. Prior to 249 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 9 of 12 negotiating the terms of a community environmental benefit 250 agreement, the municipality shall provide a reasonable and public 251 opportunity for residents of the potentially affected environmental 252 justice community to be heard concerning the requirements of or need 253 for, and terms of, such agreement. 254 (d) The chief elected official or town manager of a municipality shall 255 participate in the negotiations for any such community environmental 256 benefit agreement and shall implement, administer and enforce such 257 an agreement on behalf of the municipality, provided any such 258 agreement negotiated pursuant to this section on and after November 259 1, 2020, shall be approved by the legislative body of the municipality 260 prior to implementation, administration and enforcement of such 261 agreement. Such chief elected official or town manager shall select a 262 resident of the potentially affected environmental justice community to 263 participate in such negotiations. 264 (e) The terms of any community environmental benefit agreement 265 negotiated, entered into and approved in accordance with this section 266 on and after November 1, 2020, shall not constitute a separate and 267 distinct basis for a pleading to intervene in any administrative, 268 licensing or other proceeding pursuant to section 22a-19. 269 (f) (1) The Commissioner of Energy and Environmental Protection 270 shall adopt regulations, in accordance with the provisions of chapter 271 54, as are necessary and proper to carry out the purposes of this 272 section. The provisions of subsection (g) of this section shall not take 273 effect until the adoption of the regulations pursuant to this subsection. 274 Such regulations shall include, but not be limited to, provisions 275 regarding: (A) Procedures and requirements for creating the 276 meaningful public participation plan and the public participation 277 report required by this section; (B) the identification and measurement 278 of the relative impact of environmental and public health stressors 279 across communities; (C) tools for stakeholder industries and sectors to 280 use that take account of any such environmental or public health 281 stressors, including tools to help inform decisions about potential 282 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 10 of 12 locations for new or expanded affecting facilities that comply with the 283 provisions of this section; and (D) standards for denying or placing 284 conditions on permits. The commissioner shall consult with 285 stakeholder industries and sectors when developing the regulations 286 pursuant to this section. 287 (2) Notwithstanding any provision of the general statutes, the 288 commissioner may subject the renewal of any permit issued for an 289 affecting facility to some or all of the provisions of this section and any 290 regulation adopted pursuant to this subsection by adopting 291 regulations, in accordance with the provisions of chapter 54, that 292 include, but are not limited to, the identification of: (A) Each type of 293 renewal permit subject to the provisions of this subdivision; (B) the 294 types of affecting facilities subject to the provisions of this subdivision; 295 and (C) the specific requirements of this section and any regulation 296 adopted pursuant to this subsection that apply to each such renewal 297 permit and affecting facility. No renewal permit shall be subject to the 298 requirements of this section prior to the effective date of regulations 299 adopted pursuant to this subdivision. 300 (g) (1) On and after the adoption of regulations pursuant to 301 subdivision (1) or (2) of subsection (f) of this section, the department's 302 review of any such application or renewal permit shall be conducted in 303 accordance with any such regulations, as applicable, and the council's 304 review of any such application may be conducted in accordance with 305 any such regulations. 306 (2) The department or the council, as applicable, may deny any 307 application for a permit for a new affecting facility upon a finding that 308 approval of the permit, as proposed, would, together with other 309 environmental or public health stressors affecting the applicable 310 environmental justice community, result in adverse cumulative 311 environmental or public health stressors in such environmental justice 312 community that are higher than those borne by other communities 313 within the state, county or other geographic unit of analysis, as 314 determined by the department or council. Any such determination by 315 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 11 of 12 the department shall be made in accordance with the applicable 316 regulations adopted pursuant to subsection (f) of this section and any 317 such determination by the council may be made in accordance with 318 such regulations. 319 (3) If such permit is granted, the department or council, as 320 applicable, may impose conditions on the construction and operation 321 of the new affecting facility that are intended to mitigate 322 environmental and public health impacts. 323 (4) The department or the council, as applicable, shall provide 324 notice, in writing, to any applicant for any such new affecting facility 325 of any tentative determination regarding compliance with the 326 applicable regulations adopted pursuant to subsection (f) of this 327 section. 328 (5) If any hearing is held on any application or renewal permit 329 subject to the requirements of this section, compliance with the 330 applicable regulations adopted pursuant to subsection (f) of this 331 section shall be considered at such hearing. 332 (6) The department or council, as applicable, shall publish any 333 determination made pursuant to this subsection to the department's or 334 council's Internet web site. 335 (h) Notwithstanding any provision of the general statutes, the 336 department or council, as applicable, may, after review of the public 337 participation report and any other relevant information, including 338 testimony and written comments received in connection with the 339 meaningful public participation plan, apply conditions to a permit for 340 the expansion of an existing affecting facility concerning the 341 construction and operation of the facility to protect the environment 342 and public health, upon a finding by the department or council, as 343 applicable, that approval of such permit, as proposed, would, together 344 with other environmental or public health stressors affecting the 345 applicable environmental justice community, result in adverse 346 Substitute Bill No. 1147 LCO {\\PRDFS1\SCOUSERS\FORZANOF\WS\2023SB-01147- R01-SB.docx } 12 of 12 cumulative environmental or public health stressors in such 347 environmental justice community that are higher than those borne by 348 other communities in the state, county or other geographic unit of 349 analysis, as determined by the department or council. Any such 350 determination by the department shall be made in accordance with the 351 applicable regulations adopted pursuant to subsection (f) of this 352 section and any such determination by the council may be made in 353 accordance with such regulations. 354 (i) If a permit applicant applies for more than one permit for a 355 proposed new or expanded affecting facility, the permit applicant shall 356 only be required to comply with the provisions of this section once, 357 unless the department or council, as applicable, determines that more 358 than one informal public meeting is necessary due to the complexity of 359 the permit applications necessary for the proposed new or expanded 360 affecting facility. Nothing in this subsection shall be construed to limit 361 the authority of the department or council to hold or require any 362 public hearing, as may be required by any other provision of the 363 general statutes, federal law or rule or regulation. 364 (j) Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the right of an 365 applicant to continue facility operations during the process of permit 366 approval to the extent such right is conveyed by an applicable law, 367 rule or regulation. 368 This act shall take effect as follows and shall amend the following sections: Section 1 October 1, 2023 22a-20a LCO Statement: In Subsec. (b)(3) "not more than" was changed to "within" for consistency. ENV Joint Favorable Subst.