Researcher: JC Page 1 3/27/24
OLR Bill Analysis
sHB 5382
AN ACT CONCERNING THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE OFFICE
OF THE CHILD ADVOCATE.
SUMMARY
This bill makes several changes in statutes governing the Department
of Children and Families (DCF). It:
1. generally requires, rather than allows, DCF to disclose records to
any individual when the information concerns an incident of
abuse or neglect that resulted in a child’s or youth’s death or near
death (§§ 3-4);
2. requires DCF to include additional information in permanency
plan documents (§§ 2 & 5-7);
3. allows the DCF commissioner to authorize trial home placement
of a DCF-committed child or youth before revoking the child’s or
youth’s commitment order under certain conditions (§ 5);
4. requires additional permanency planning court proceeding
notification requirements (§ 6);
5. establishes certain requirements for a child’s attorney or
guardian ad litem (GAL) during a temporary custody or
permanent guardianship proceeding (e.g., that they
communicated regularly with the child) (§§ 7-8);
6. increases the State Advisory Council on Children and Families
(SAC) membership from 20 to 25 and expands the council’s
duties to include a quarterly review of certain DCF data and an
annual review of DCF’s child protection responsibilities (§ 1); and
7. creates two working groups, one to review data and information 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 2 3/27/24
regarding the SAC’s effectiveness in discharging its child
protection responsibilities, and another to review the delivery of
children’s legal services in child protection proceedings (§§ 9-10).
EFFECTIVE DATE: July 1, 2024, except the provisions establishing
working groups are effective upon passage.
§ 1 — STATE ADVISORY COUNC IL ON CHILDREN AND FAMILIES
(SAC)
New Duties
The bill expands the SAC’s duties and requires it to conduct:
1. a quarterly review of DCF data on child safety and well-being
and permanency plans, and
2. an annual evaluation to determine the extent to which DCF is
discharging its child protection responsibilities under state and
federal law.
Council Priorities
The bill requires the SAC, in implementing these new duties, to
prioritize the following:
1. protecting children from abuse and neglect by ensuring the state
maintains an effective plan to prevent abuse and neglect and
divert children from foster care;
2. reducing and eliminating preventable child fatalities and the
unnecessary removal of children from their homes;
3. placing children in permanent and stable homes, including
placing them with family members whenever possible, and
successfully transitioning youth leaving the child welfare system
from foster care;
4. reducing disparate outcomes between minority and other
populations the child welfare system serves;
5. providing timely, appropriate, and adequate services to children 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 3 3/27/24
and families to meet the children’s physical and mental health
and their developmental needs; and
6. collaborating among state agencies to further the council’s duties.
Membership
The bill increases the council’s membership from 20 to 25 by adding
the following governor-appointed members:
1. three members of DCF youth advisory boards,
2. one member of an organization that advocates for the protection
and advancement of children’s legal rights, and
3. one member of an organization that advocates for policies to
promote child welfare.
As under existing law, the governor appoints 14 other members, and
the remaining six members represent the regional advisory councils,
which each appoint one member.
§§ 2 & 5-7 — PERMANENCY PLANNI NG
The bill requires DCF include certain information in certain
documents or reports related to permanency planning. Under existing
law, DCF must include certain information (1) in all documents entitled
“Study in Support of Permanency Plan” or “Status Report for
Permanency Planning Team,” and (2) when it submits a report to the
court when a child or youth is placed in out-of-home care because of
alleged abuse or neglect. Additionally, the bill requires DCF to file
certain information with the court when it seeks to change an order of
protective supervision.
The bill requires the permanency plan documents and the DCF
reports to court to include the following:
1. a description of (a) any new report alleging abuse or neglect
related to the child or a child’s parent received through the DCF
Telephone Careline, (b) whether the report resulted in an
investigation, (c) the investigation findings, and (d) any new 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 4 3/27/24
criminal charges made against the parent because of the
investigation; and
2. whether a child under age three was screened for developmental
and social-emotional delays, according to the procedures for
young children who are victims of abuse or neglect, and, if they
were, whether they were referred to the Birth-to-Three program.
Permanency Plan Documents (§ 2)
The bill requires DCF to include additional information in all
permanency plan documents, including whether the child was placed
in a licensed home or the home of a relative or fictive kin caregiver
eligible for licensure, and whether any applicable waivers have been
obtained. By law, a fictive kin caregiver is a person who is age 21 or
older and unrelated to a child by birth, adoption, or marriage but who
has an emotionally significant relation with the child amounting to a
familial relationship (CGS § 17a-114).
Under the bill, these permanency planning documents must also
include (1) the dates of administrative case review meetings and
permanency team meetings and (2) whether the child has received
services recommended by any of their medical, dental, developmental,
and educational providers, and a description of any concerns the
providers identify.
DCF Order of Protective Supervision (§ 7)
Under the bill, DCF must file documents with the court in any
proceeding to review, modify, terminate, or extend an order of
protective supervision. These documents must include the same health
service disclosures as the permanency plan (see above).
DCF Out-of-Home Care Report (§ 6)
By law, DCF must submit to the court a list of items for its
consideration regarding a child or youth placed in out-of-home care
because of alleged abuse or neglect.
Under current law, this includes the child’s or youth’s medical, 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 5 3/27/24
dental, developmental, educational, and treatment needs. To conform
with the health service disclosure provisions above, the bill specifies this
information includes whether DCF has received or obtained the most
recent information on the child’s health needs from any relevant service
providers. As under existing law, the information must include a
timeline to ensure that these needs are met.
Additionally, this report must include the dates of administrative
case review meetings and permanency team meetings.
Trial Home Placements (§ 5)
The bill allows the DCF commissioner to authorize a trial home
placement of a DCF-committed child or youth in the home of his or her
parent or guardian before revoking the child’s or youth’s commitment
order if (1) the court approves a permanency plan that recommends
reunifying the child with his or her parent or guardian, and (2) all
parties agree.
The bill requires the DCF commissioner to:
1. provide the court and all parties written notice of her intent to
authorize a trial home placement at least 15 days before the
authorization;
2. create a trial home placement plan that is provided to all parties
and includes (a) announced and unannounced DCF home visits
and (b) any services provided during the trial home placement
that she deems necessary to promote the child’s or youth’s well-
being; and
3. file a motion for revocation of commitment within 30 days of
when the trial home placement begins, unless she determines
that reunification is no longer in the child’s or youth’s best
interests.
Permanency Planning Court Proceeding Notifications (§ 6)
Existing law requires courts to notify a child’s or youth’s foster
parents, prospective adoptive parents, and relative caregivers when it 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 6 3/27/24
schedules a hearing concerning DCF’s permanency plan or revoking its
commitment.
The bill requires any notice provided to include the website address
for any proceeding that will be conducted on a virtual platform. The
DCF commissioner must confirm compliance with these notice
requirements with the court at the proceeding.
The bill also requires DCF to notify each attorney and any GAL for
any child or youth of (1) any new report of abuse or neglect received
through the DCF Telephone Careline relating to the child or youth or
the child’s or youth’s parent or guardian, (2) whether the report resulted
in an investigation, and (3) the investigation results.
§§ 3 & 4 — DCF RECORDS DISCL OSURES
The bill generally requires, rather than allows, DCF to disclose
records to any individual when the information concerns an incident of
abuse or neglect that resulted in a child’s or youth’s death or near death.
As under existing law, DCF may withhold disclosure if it interferes with
a pending investigation. By law, under certain circumstances, DCF must
disclose its records to certain entities without the subject’s consent.
Under the bill, DCF may withhold disclosure of these records if the
commissioner determines that it may result in harm to the safety or well-
being of the child or youth who is the subject of the records, the child’s
or youth’s family, or any individual who reported the child’s or youth’s
abuse or neglect. Additionally, DCF must not make any disclosure
prohibited by federal law, including Social Security Act provisions that
provide funds that states can use to coordinate and provide child
welfare services.
Current law allows DCF to disclose the abuse and neglect
information in general terms. The bill specifies the disclosure may only
include the child’s or youth’s age and gender and descriptions of child
abuse or neglect reports or investigations relevant to the fatality or near
fatality, including any investigation findings and actions commenced or
services provided by the department. 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 7 3/27/24
§§ 7 & 8 — ROLE OF ATTORNEY OR GAL DURING CHILD ABUSE
AND NEGLECT CASES
Under current law, GALs are allowed to present information
pertinent to the court’s determination of the child’s best interests. The
bill instead requires GALs to be prepared to present at these
determinations.
Under the bill, before issuing an order affecting the legal status or
placement of a child in any temporary custody or permanent
guardianship proceeding, the court must confirm that:
1. the child’s attorney has obtained a clear understanding of the
child’s situation and needs, as described in the federal Child
Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act;
2. the child’s GAL has performed an independent investigation of
the case and is prepared to present information pertinent to the
court’s determination of the child’s best interests; and
3. any attorney or GAL for the child has (a) communicated
regularly with the child, or the child’s caregivers and service
providers if the child is nonverbal, or (b) visited with the child
frequently enough to be informed of the child’s situation and
needs.
§§ 9 & 10 — WORKING GROUPS
The bill creates two working groups: one to review data and
information regarding the SAC’s effectiveness in discharging its child
protection responsibilities, and another to review the delivery of legal
services to children in child protection proceedings in the state.
For both working groups, the bill requires appointing authorities to
(1) make their initial appointments within 30 days after the bill’s passage
and (2) fill any vacancies.
The Children’s Committee chairpersons must (1) serve as the
chairpersons for both working groups and (2) schedule and hold the
first meetings within 60 days after the bill passes. 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 8 3/27/24
The bill requires the Children’s Committee’s administrative staff to
serve as administrative staff on both working groups.
SAC Working Group (§ 9)
The bill establishes a 10-member working group to (1) review
available data and information on the SAC’s effectiveness in
discharging its child protection responsibilities, and (2) develop a plan
to publicly disseminate the data and information on a regular basis. The
working group must report its findings and recommendations to the
Children’s Committee by January 1, 2025. The working group
terminates on that date or when it submits its report, whichever is later.
The bill requires the data and information to include the following:
1. quantitative and qualitative information on the safety,
permanency, and well-being of children served by DCF, aligned
with federal Child and Family Service Review requirements;
2. quality assurance information regarding the assessment and
management of risk and safety in child protective service cases,
including cases open with DCF in ongoing treatment;
3. the availability, timeliness, and effectiveness of services for
children and families, including developmental and educational
needs;
4. information on differential response, including the outcomes for
children served through state-funded diversion programs such
as Community Support for Families and Integrated Family Care
and Support;
5. disclosures regarding child fatalities consistent with the
requirements of the federal Child Abuse Prevention and
Treatment Act; and
6. a summary of findings, recommendations, and action steps
arising from DCF’s internal review of agency practice following
fatalities and near-fatalities of children where the department 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 9 3/27/24
had an open case or a case closed within the previous year.
The SAC working group consists of the following members:
1. the Children’s Committee chairpersons and ranking members;
2. the DCF commissioner or her designee;
3. the child advocate or her designee;
4. the SAC chairperson;
5. the chief public defender or her designee;
6. the Connecticut Alliance of Foster and Adoptive Families
executive director or her designee; and
7. one designated by the DCF commissioner, who represents an
entity with expertise in data collection and analysis.
Working Group to Review the Delivery of Legal Services to
Children in Child Protection Proceedings (§ 10)
The bill establishes a 16-member working group to review the
delivery of legal services to children in child protection proceedings.
The review must include models of legal service delivery previously
used in the state or currently used in other states, and recommendations
for improving the quality of legal representation provided to children
in the state. The working group must report its findings and
recommendations to the Children’s Committee and to the Chief Public
Defender’s Office by November 1, 2024. The working group terminates
on that date or when it submits its report, whichever is later.
The 16-member working group consists of the following members:
1. the Children’s Committee chairpersons and ranking members;
2. the chief public defender or her designee;
3. the child advocate or her designee;
4. the chief administrative judge of juvenile matters; 2024HB-05382-R000152-BA.DOCX
Researcher: JC Page 10 3/27/24
5. the attorney general or his designee;
6. the DCF commissioner or her designee;
7. the Connecticut Alliance of Foster and Adoptive Families
executive director or her designee;
8. two designated by the Children’s Committee House chairperson,
who are attorneys with expertise in representing children in child
welfare proceedings;
9. two designated by the Children’s Committee Senate chairperson,
who are attorneys with expertise in representing parents in child
welfare proceedings;
10. one designated by the Children’s Committee House ranking
member, who is a representative from an organization dedicated
to advancing children’s legal rights; and
11. one designated by the Children’s Committee Senate ranking
member, who is a representative from an organization dedicated
to improving children’s public policy.
The bill specifies that any working group member the Children’s
Committee chairpersons or ranking members designate may be a
General Assembly member.
COMMITTEE ACTION
Committee on Children
Joint Favorable Substitute
Yea 17 Nay 0 (03/12/2024)