LCO No. 3057 1 of 12 General Assembly Raised Bill No. 5507 February Session, 2024 LCO No. 3057 Referred to Committee on JUDICIARY Introduced by: (JUD) AN ACT CONCERNING STATE AGENCY AND COURT PROCEEDINGS RELATING TO ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION LINES. Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Assembly convened: Section 1. Subdivision (2) of subsection (a) of section 22a-20a of the 1 2024 supplement to the general statutes is repealed and the following is 2 substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 1, 2024): 3 (2) "Affecting facility" means any (A) electric generating facility with 4 a capacity of more than ten megawatts; (B) sludge or solid waste 5 incinerator or combustor; (C) sewage treatment plant with a capacity of 6 more than fifty million gallons per day; (D) intermediate processing 7 center, volume reduction facility or multitown recycling facility with a 8 combined monthly volume in excess of twenty-five tons; (E) new or 9 expanded landfill, including, but not limited to, a landfill that contains 10 ash, construction and demolition debris or solid waste; (F) medical 11 waste incinerator; [or] (G) major source of air pollution, as defined by 12 the federal Clean Air Act; or (H) an electric transmission line of a design 13 capacity of sixty-nine kilovolts or more. "Affecting facility" shall not 14 include (i) the portion of an electric generating facility that uses 15 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 2 of 12 nonemitting and nonpolluting renewable resources such as wind, solar 16 and hydro power or that uses fuel cells, (ii) any facility for which a 17 certificate of environmental compatibility and public need was obtained 18 from the Connecticut Siting Council on or before January 1, 2000, or (iii) 19 a facility of a constituent unit of the state system of higher education that 20 has been the subject of an environmental impact evaluation in 21 accordance with the provisions of sections 22a-1b to 22a-1h, inclusive, 22 and such evaluation has been determined to be satisfactory in 23 accordance with section 22a-1e; 24 Sec. 2. Subsection (b) of section 16-50bb of the general statutes is 25 repealed and the following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 1, 26 2024): 27 (b) Payments from the account shall be made upon authorization by 28 the State Treasurer. An application for reimbursement shall be 29 submitted not later than sixty days after the conclusion of a certification 30 proceeding, except for a facility described in subdivisions (5) and (6) of 31 subsection (a) of section 16-50i, by each municipality entitled to receive 32 a copy of an application under section 16-50l, as amended by this act, in 33 order to defray expenses incurred by such municipalities in 34 participating as a party to a certification proceeding, except for a 35 proceeding on an application for a facility described in subdivision (5) 36 or (6) of subsection (a) of section 16-50i. Any moneys remaining after 37 payments to municipalities in accordance with this section shall be 38 refunded to the applicant in even amounts. Where more than one 39 municipality seeks moneys from such account, the council shall evenly 40 distribute such moneys among the municipalities. No municipality may 41 receive moneys from the account in excess of [twenty-five] seventy-five 42 thousand dollars. No municipality may receive moneys from the 43 account in excess of the dollar amount such municipality has expended 44 from its own municipal funds. 45 Sec. 3. Section 16-50l of the general statutes is repealed and the 46 following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 1, 2024): 47 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 3 of 12 (a) To initiate a certification proceeding, an applicant for a certificate 48 shall file with the council an application, in such form as the council may 49 prescribe, accompanied by a filing fee of not more than twenty-five 50 thousand dollars, which fee shall be established in accordance with 51 section 16-50t, and a municipal participation fee of [twenty-five] 52 seventy-five thousand dollars to be deposited in the account established 53 pursuant to section 16-50bb, as amended by this act, except that an 54 application for a facility described in subdivision (5) or (6) of subsection 55 (a) of section 16-50i shall not pay such municipal participation fee. An 56 application shall contain such information as the applicant may 57 consider relevant and the council or any department or agency of the 58 state exercising environmental controls may by regulation require, 59 including the following information: 60 (1) In the case of facilities described in subdivisions (1), (2) and (4) of 61 subsection (a) of section 16-50i: (A) A description, including estimated 62 costs, of the proposed transmission line, substation or switchyard, 63 covering, where applicable underground cable sizes and specifications, 64 overhead tower design and appearance and heights, if any, conductor 65 sizes, and initial and ultimate voltages and capacities; (B) a statement 66 and full explanation of why the proposed transmission line, substation 67 or switchyard is necessary and how the facility conforms to a long-range 68 plan for expansion of the electric power grid serving the state and 69 interconnected utility systems, that will serve the public need for 70 adequate, reliable and economic service; (C) a map of suitable scale of 71 the proposed routing or site, showing details of the rights-of-way or site 72 in the vicinity of settled areas, parks, recreational areas and scenic areas, 73 residential areas, private or public schools, child care centers, as 74 described in section 19a-77, group child care homes, as described in 75 section 19a-77, family child care homes, as described in section 19a-77, 76 licensed youth camps, and public playgrounds and showing existing 77 transmission lines within one mile of the proposed route or site; (D) a 78 justification for adoption of the route or site selected, including 79 comparison with alternative routes or sites which are environmentally, 80 technically and economically practical; (E) a description of the effect of 81 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 4 of 12 the proposed transmission line, substation or switchyard on the 82 environment, ecology, and scenic, historic and recreational values; (F) a 83 justification for overhead portions, if any, including life-cycle cost 84 studies comparing overhead alternatives with underground 85 alternatives, and effects described in subparagraph (E) of this 86 subdivision of undergrounding; (G) a schedule of dates showing the 87 proposed program of right -of-way or property acquisition, 88 construction, completion and operation and, in the case of a proposed 89 transmission line, (i) any appraisal completed by an independent 90 appraiser on behalf of the applicant concerning fair compensation that 91 is to be provided to an owner of real property in connection with the 92 necessity of entering a right-of-way, including any easements or land 93 acquisition, and (ii) the applicant's certification that such applicant has 94 completed negotiations on the amount of fair compensation to be 95 provided to an owner of real property in connection with the necessity 96 of entering a right-of-way, including any easements or land acquisition; 97 (H) an identification of each federal, state, regional, district and 98 municipal agency with which proposed route or site reviews have been 99 undertaken, including a copy of each written agency position on such 100 route or site; [and] (I) an assessment of the impact of any 101 electromagnetic fields to be produced by the proposed transmission 102 line; and (J), in the case of a proposed transmission line, (i) for the ten-103 year period preceding the date of the application, the actual loads for 104 existing transmission lines in the area where the proposed transmission 105 line is to be located, (ii) for the ten-year period following the date of the 106 application, the projected load for any proposed transmission line, and 107 (iii) for the ten-year period preceding the date of application, the 108 performance of all electric circuits at issue, including a description of all 109 service outages or disruptions, the cause or causes of such outages or 110 disruptions and the time required to restore service following such 111 outages or disruptions; and 112 (2) In the case of facilities described in subdivision (3) of subsection 113 (a) of section 16-50i: (A) A description of the proposed electric 114 generating or storage facility; (B) a statement and full explanation of 115 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 5 of 12 why the proposed facility is necessary; (C) a statement of loads and 116 resources as described in section 16-50r; (D) safety and reliability 117 information, including planned provisions for emergency operations 118 and shutdowns; (E) estimated cost information, including plant costs, 119 fuel costs, plant service life and capacity factor, and total generating cost 120 per kilowatt-hour, both at the plant and related transmission, and 121 comparative costs of alternatives considered; (F) a schedule showing the 122 program for design, material acquisition, construction and testing, and 123 operating dates; (G) available site information, including maps and 124 description and present and proposed development, and geological, 125 scenic, ecological, seismic, biological, water supply, population and load 126 center data; (H) justification for adoption of the site selected, including 127 comparison with alternative sites; (I) design information, including a 128 description of facilities, plant efficiencies, electrical connections to the 129 system, and control systems; (J) a description of provisions, including 130 devices and operations, for mitigation of the effect of the operation of 131 the facility on air and water quality, for waste disposal, and for noise 132 abatement, and information on other environmental aspects; and (K) a 133 listing of federal, state, regional, district and municipal agencies from 134 which approvals either have been obtained or will be sought covering 135 the proposed facility, copies of approvals received and the planned 136 schedule for obtaining those approvals not yet received. 137 (b) Each application shall be accompanied by proof of service of a 138 copy of such application on: (1) Each municipality in which any portion 139 of such facility is to be located, both as primarily proposed and in the 140 alternative locations listed, and any adjoining municipality having a 141 boundary not more than two thousand five hundred feet from such 142 facility, which copy shall be served on the chief executive officer of each 143 such municipality and shall include notice of the date on or about which 144 the application is to be filed, and the zoning commissions, planning 145 commissions, planning and zoning commissions, conservation 146 commissions and inland wetlands agencies of each such municipality, 147 and the regional councils of governments which encompass each such 148 municipality; (2) the Attorney General; (3) each member of the 149 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 6 of 12 legislature in whose assembly or senate district the facility or any 150 alternative location listed in the application is to be located; (4) any 151 agency, department or instrumentality of the federal government that 152 has jurisdiction, whether concurrent with the state or otherwise, over 153 any matter that would be affected by such facility; (5) each state 154 department, agency and commission named in subsection (g) of section 155 16-50j; and (6) such other state and municipal bodies as the council may 156 by regulation designate. A notice of such application shall be given to 157 the general public, in municipalities entitled to receive notice under 158 subdivision (1) of this subsection, by the publication of a summary of 159 such application and the date on or about which it will be filed. Such 160 notice shall be published under the regulations to be promulgated by 161 the council, in such form and in such newspapers as will serve 162 substantially to inform the public of such application and to afford 163 interested persons sufficient time to prepare for and to be heard at the 164 hearing prescribed in section 16-50m. Such notice shall be published in 165 not less than ten-point type. A notice of such an application for a 166 certificate for a facility described in subdivision (3), (4), (5) or (6) of 167 subsection (a) of section 16-50i shall also be sent, by certified or 168 registered mail, to each person appearing of record as an owner of 169 property which abuts the proposed primary or alternative sites on 170 which the facility would be located. Such notice shall be sent at the same 171 time that notice of such application is given to the general public. Notice 172 of an application for a certificate for a facility described in subdivision 173 (1) of subsection (a) of section 16-50i shall also be provided to each 174 electric distribution company customer in the municipality where the 175 facility is proposed to be placed. Such notice shall (A) be provided on a 176 separate enclosure with each customer's monthly bill for one or more 177 months, (B) be provided by the electric distribution company not earlier 178 than sixty days prior to filing the application with the council, but not 179 later than the date that the application is filed with the council, and (C) 180 include: A brief description of the project, including its location relative 181 to the affected municipality and adjacent streets; a brief technical 182 description of the project including its proposed length, voltage, and 183 type and range of heights of support structures or underground 184 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 7 of 12 configuration; the reason for the project; the address and a toll-free 185 telephone number of the applicant by which additional information 186 about the project can be obtained; and a statement in print no smaller 187 than twenty-four-point type size stating "NOTICE OF PROPOSED 188 CONSTRUCTION OF A HIGH VOLTAGE ELECTRIC 189 TRANSMISSION LINE". 190 (c) An application for a certificate shall contain information on the 191 extent to which the proposed facility has been identified in, and is 192 consistent with, the annual forecast reports and life-cycle cost analysis 193 required by section 16-50r and other advance planning that has been 194 carried out, and shall include an explanation for any failure of the 195 facility to conform with such information. 196 (d) An amendment proceeding may be initiated by an application for 197 amendment of a certificate filed with the council by the holder of the 198 certificate or by a resolution of the council. An amendment application 199 by a certificate holder shall be in such form and contain such 200 information as the council shall prescribe. A resolution for amendment 201 by the council shall identify the design, location or route of the portion 202 of a certificated facility described in subdivisions (1) or (2) of subsection 203 (a) of section 16-50i which is subject to modification on the basis of stated 204 conditions or events which could not reasonably have been known or 205 foreseen prior to the issuance of the certificate. No such resolution for 206 amendment of a certificate shall be adopted after the commencement of 207 site preparation or construction of the certificated facility or, in the case 208 of a facility for which approval by the council of a right-of-way 209 development and management plan or other detailed construction plan 210 is a condition of the certificate, after approval of that part of the plan 211 which includes the portion of the facility proposed for modification. A 212 copy and notice of each amendment application shall be given by the 213 holder of the certificate in the manner set forth in subsection (b) of this 214 section. A copy and notice of each resolution for amendment shall be 215 given by the council in the manner set forth in subsection (b) of this 216 section. The council shall also provide the certificate holder with a copy 217 of such resolution. The certificate holder and the council shall not be 218 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 8 of 12 required to give such copy and notice to municipalities and the 219 commissions and agencies of such municipalities other than those in 220 which the modified portion of the facility would be located. 221 (e) At least [sixty] ninety days prior to the filing of an application with 222 the council, the applicant shall consult with the municipality in which 223 the facility may be located and with any other municipality required to 224 be served with a copy of the application under subdivision (1) of 225 subsection (b) of this section concerning the proposed and alternative 226 sites of the facility. Such consultation with the municipality shall 227 include, but not be limited to, good faith efforts to meet with the chief 228 elected official of the municipality, the legislative body of the 229 municipality and each member of the legislature in whose assembly or 230 senate district the facility or any alternative location listed in the 231 application is to be located. At the time of the consultation, the applicant 232 shall provide the chief elected official, the legislative body of the 233 municipality and each member of the legislature in whose assembly or 234 senate district the facility or any alternative location listed in the 235 application is to be located with any technical reports concerning the 236 public need, the site selection process and the environmental effects of 237 the proposed facility. In the case of a proposed transmission line, at the 238 time of the consultation, the applicant shall provide the chief elected 239 official, the legislative body of the municipality and each member of the 240 legislature in whose assembly or senate district the facility or any 241 alternative location listed in the application is to be located with any 242 independent appraisal completed at the request of the applicant due to 243 the necessity of entering a right-of-way, including any easements or 244 land acquisition, required for the construction of a proposed 245 transmission line. The applicant shall also provide a copy of any such 246 appraisal to the owner of any real property affected by the necessity of 247 entering a right-of-way, including any easements or land acquisition. 248 Such appraisal shall include the total projected costs associated with 249 securing any required right-of-way access, easements or land 250 acquisition. The cost of any such appraisal shall be borne solely by the 251 applicant. In addition, at the time of the consultation, the applicant shall 252 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 9 of 12 provide the chief elected official, the legislative body of the municipality 253 and each member of the legislature in whose assembly or senate district 254 the facility or any alternative location listed in the application is to be 255 located with a report that includes a summary of the (1) status of any 256 negotiation with the owner of real property concerning the total amount 257 of compensation to be paid to such owner to secure any required right-258 of-way access, easements or land acquisition, and (2) economic impact 259 that the proposed facility is anticipated to have on the municipality, 260 including the impact on the municipality's tax base. The municipality 261 may conduct public hearings and meetings as it deems necessary for it 262 to advise the applicant of its recommendations concerning the proposed 263 facility. Within sixty days of the initial consultation, the municipality 264 shall issue its recommendations to the applicant. No later than fifteen 265 days after submitting an application to the council, the applicant shall 266 provide to the council all materials provided to the municipality and a 267 summary of the consultations with the municipality including all 268 recommendations issued by the municipality. 269 (f) (1) For a facility described in subdivision (6) of subsection (a) of 270 section 16-50i, at least ninety days before filing an application with the 271 council, the applicant shall consult with the municipality in which the 272 facility is proposed to be located and with any other municipality 273 required to be served with a copy of the application under subdivision 274 (1) of subsection (b) of this section. Consultation with such municipality 275 shall include, but not be limited to, good-faith efforts to meet with the 276 chief elected official of the municipality or such official's designee. At 277 the time of the consultation, the applicant shall provide the municipality 278 with any technical reports concerning the need for the facility, including 279 a map indicating the area of need, the location of existing surrounding 280 facilities, a detailed description of the proposed and any alternate sites 281 under consideration, a listing of other sites or areas considered and 282 rejected, the location of all schools near the proposed facility, an analysis 283 of the potential aesthetic impacts of the facility on said schools, as well 284 as a discussion of efforts or measures to be taken to mitigate such 285 aesthetic impacts, a description of the site selection process undertaken 286 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 10 of 12 by the prospective applicant and the potential environmental effects of 287 the proposed facility. The applicant shall also provide copies of such 288 technical reports to such municipality's planning commission, zoning 289 commission or combined planning and zoning commission and inland 290 wetland agency. 291 (2) Not later than sixty days after the initial municipal consultation 292 meeting, the municipality, in cooperation with the applicant, may hold 293 a public information meeting. If the municipality decides to hold a 294 public information meeting, the applicant shall be responsible for 295 sending notice of such meeting to each person appearing of record as an 296 owner of property which abuts the proposed or alternate facility 297 locations and for publishing notice of such meeting in a newspaper of 298 general circulation in the municipality at least fifteen days before the 299 date of the public information meeting. Such applicant shall pay all 300 administrative expenses associated with such public information 301 meeting. 302 (3) The municipality shall present the applicant with proposed 303 alternative sites, which may include municipal parcels, for its 304 consideration not later than thirty days after the initial consultation 305 meeting. The applicant shall evaluate these alternate sites presented as 306 part of the municipal consultation process and include the results of its 307 evaluations in its application to the council. The applicant may present 308 any such alternatives to the council in its application for formal 309 consideration. 310 Sec. 4. Subsection (c) of section 16-50p of the general statutes is 311 repealed and the following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 1, 312 2024): 313 (c) (1) The council shall not grant a certificate for a facility described 314 in subdivision (3) of subsection (a) of section 16-50i, either as proposed 315 or as modified by the council, unless it finds and determines a public 316 benefit for the facility and considers neighborhood concerns with 317 respect to the factors set forth in subdivision (3) of subsection (a) of this 318 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 11 of 12 section, including public safety. 319 (2) The council shall not grant a certificate for a facility described in 320 subdivision (1) of subsection (a) of section 16-50i, that is substantially 321 underground or underwater except where such facility interconnects 322 with existing overhead facilities, either as proposed or as modified by 323 the council, unless it finds and determines a public benefit for a facility 324 substantially underground or a public need for a facility substantially 325 underwater. 326 (3) For purposes of this section, a public benefit exists when a facility 327 is necessary for the reliability of the electric power supply of the state or 328 for the development of a competitive market for electricity and a public 329 need exists when a facility is necessary for the reliability of the electric 330 power supply of the state. 331 (4) Any application for an electric transmission line with a capacity of 332 three hundred forty-five kilovolts or more that is filed on or after May 333 1, 2003, and proposes the underground burial of such line in all 334 residential areas and overhead installation of such line in industrial and 335 open space areas shall have a rebuttable presumption of meeting a 336 public benefit for such facility if the facility is substantially underground 337 and meeting a public need for such facility if the facility is substantially 338 above ground. Such presumption may be overcome by evidence 339 submitted by a party or intervenor to the satisfaction of the council. 340 (5) The council shall not grant a certificate for a facility described in 341 subdivision (1) of subsection (a) of section 16-50i, that includes 342 expanded easements over state or federally designated historic 343 properties unless it: (A) Considers neighborhood concerns with respect 344 to public safety and the economic impact that the proposed facility is 345 anticipated to have on the municipality, including the impact on the 346 municipality's tax base; and (B) finds and determines that any adverse 347 impact caused by the proposed facility to the municipality and such 348 historic properties is substantially outweighed by the public benefit 349 described in subdivision (3) of this subsection. 350 Raised Bill No. 5507 LCO No. 3057 12 of 12 Sec. 5. Section 16-50q of the general statutes is repealed and the 351 following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective July 1, 2024): 352 Any party or intervenor may obtain judicial review of an order issued 353 on an application for a certificate or an amendment of a certificate in 354 accordance with the provisions of section 4-183. Any judicial review 355 sought pursuant to this chapter shall be privileged in respect to 356 assignment for trial in the Superior Court. If a municipality seeks 357 judicial review under this section, and such municipality is a prevailing 358 party in the action, the court may award the municipality reasonable 359 attorneys' fees and costs. 360 This act shall take effect as follows and shall amend the following sections: Section 1 July 1, 2024 22a-20a(a)(2) Sec. 2 July 1, 2024 16-50bb(b) Sec. 3 July 1, 2024 16-50l Sec. 4 July 1, 2024 16-50p(c) Sec. 5 July 1, 2024 16-50q Statement of Purpose: To amend a statutory provision relating to the rights of parties and intervenors in proceedings before the Siting Council relating to the construction of electric transmission lines. [Proposed deletions are enclosed in brackets. Proposed additions are indicated by underline, except that when the entire text of a bill or resolution or a section of a bill or resolution is new, it is not underlined.]