LCO No. 3020 1 of 6 General Assembly Raised Bill No. 441 February Session, 2024 LCO No. 3020 Referred to Committee on GOVERNMENT ADMINISTRATION AND ELECTIONS Introduced by: (GAE) AN ACT CONCERNING ELECTION ADMINISTRATION OVERSIGHT. Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Assembly convened: Section 1. (NEW) (Effective July 1, 2024) (a) There is established a 1 Municipal Election Accountability Board, which shall be within the 2 office of the Secretary of the State for administrative purposes only, for 3 the purpose of reviewing the administration of elections, primaries and 4 referenda, including the conduct of early voting, absentee voting and 5 same-day election registration, in municipalities in this state whenever 6 such municipalities are referred to the board for such review, overseeing 7 the administration of elections in such municipalities where necessary 8 and establishing procedural safeguards for the effective conduct of such 9 elections, primaries and referenda in such municipalities. Nothing in 10 this section shall be construed to (1) affect the powers and duties under 11 title 9 of the general statutes of the Secretary of the State or the State 12 Elections Enforcement Commission, and (2) preclude any person from 13 seeking additional remedies under said title, including chapter 151a of 14 the general statutes. 15 Raised Bill No. 441 LCO No. 3020 2 of 6 (b) (1) The Municipal Election Accountability Board shall be 16 comprised of: (A) The Secretary of the State, or the Secretary's designee, 17 who shall be the chairperson of the board; (B) the executive director of 18 the State Elections Enforcement Commission, or the executive director's 19 designee; (C) the Treasurer, or the Treasurer's designee; (D) the 20 Comptroller, or the Comptroller's designee; (E) nine members 21 appointed by the Secretary of the State, with the advice and consent of 22 the General Assembly, as follows: (i) One member who shall be 23 admitted to the practice of law in this state and has expertise in election 24 administration; (ii) two members who shall be moderators that are 25 certified under section 9-229 of the general statutes and enrolled in 26 different political parties and who shall be selected from a list of five 27 recommendations by the Registrars of Voters Association of 28 Connecticut; (iii) two members who shall be registrars of voters and 29 enrolled in different political parties and who shall be selected from a 30 list of five recommendations by the Registrars of Voters Association of 31 Connecticut; (iv) two members who shall be town clerks and enrolled in 32 different political parties and who shall be selected from a list of five 33 recommendations by the Connecticut Town Clerks Association; and (v) 34 two members who shall be chief elected officials of municipalities and 35 enrolled in different political parties and who shall be selected from a 36 list of five recommendations by, jointly, the Connecticut Conference of 37 Municipalities and the Connecticut Council of Small Towns; and (F) one 38 member appointed by each of the four legislative leaders, as defined in 39 section 4-9d of the general statutes, who shall have expertise in election 40 administration or election law, provided appointments under 41 subparagraphs (E) and (F) of this subdivision shall be made so that no 42 single municipality is represented by more than one member. 43 (2) Members described in subparagraphs (E) and (F) of subdivision 44 (1) of this subsection shall serve for a term of four years and until a 45 successor is appointed, and initial appointment of such members shall 46 be made not later than August 1, 2024. Members described in said 47 subparagraphs shall recuse themselves from participating in any matter 48 in which a conflict exists or where the member is a representative of a 49 Raised Bill No. 441 LCO No. 3020 3 of 6 municipality subject to oversight of the board. The filling of any vacancy 50 shall be for the remainder of the applicable member's term. The 51 members of the board shall serve without compensation, but shall be 52 reimbursed for expenses incurred in the performance of their duties. 53 Sec. 2. (NEW) (Effective July 1, 2024) (a) (1) Whenever the Secretary of 54 the State or the State Elections Enforcement Commission is of the 55 opinion that a reasonable likelihood of irregularity or impropriety in the 56 administration of any election, primary or referendum in a municipality 57 exists, based on any formal or informal complaint received by the 58 Secretary or the commission, the Secretary or the commission, as 59 applicable, may refer such municipality to the Municipal Election 60 Accountability Board for a review hearing on such municipality's 61 procedures related to the conduct of any such election, primary or 62 referendum. Any such referral shall be accompanied by supporting 63 evidence, including, but not limited to, affidavits, written or electronic 64 correspondence and documented findings from an investigation. 65 (2) Whenever a judge of the Superior Court is of the opinion that a 66 reasonable likelihood of irregularity or impropriety in the 67 administration of any election, primary or referendum in a municipality 68 exists, based on a matter before such court involving such municipality's 69 alleged violation of any provision of title 9 of the general statutes, such 70 judge may refer such municipality to the Municipal Election 71 Accountability Board for a review hearing on such municipality's 72 procedures related to the conduct of any such election, primary or 73 referendum. Any such referral shall be accompanied by supporting 74 evidence, including, but not limited to, any record developed during a 75 judicial proceeding. 76 (b) Not later than ten days after a referral under subsection (a) of this 77 section, the Municipal Election Accountability Board shall hold a review 78 hearing described in said subsection for the purpose of presenting to a 79 referred municipality the evidence that accompanied such referral. At 80 such review hearing, the chief executive officer, the corporation counsel 81 or any other duly authorized representative of a referred municipality 82 Raised Bill No. 441 LCO No. 3020 4 of 6 shall have a right to respond to such evidence, including, but not limited 83 to, rebuttal of any fact alleged and confrontation of any witness. Not 84 later than five days after the review hearing, the board shall vote to 85 determine (1) whether to designate such referred municipality for 86 oversight by the board in accordance with the provisions of section 3 of 87 this act, (2) if such oversight is deemed necessary, the tier to which such 88 municipality shall be designated, and (3) if such oversight is deemed 89 necessary, the length of time such municipality shall be subject to such 90 oversight. In making the determination under subdivisions (1) to (3), 91 inclusive, of this subsection, the board shall consider: (A) The referred 92 municipality's response, if any, to such evidence, (B) the nature and 93 severity of the alleged irregularity or impropriety, including whether 94 any such irregularity or impropriety constitutes a violation of the 95 provisions of chapter 151 or 151a of the general statutes, and (C) the 96 frequency with which any such irregularity or impropriety appears to 97 occur in such referred municipality. The determination of the board 98 under this subsection may be appealed in accordance with the 99 provisions of chapter 54 of the general statutes. Any such appeal shall 100 be privileged with respect to assignment. 101 Sec. 3. (NEW) (Effective July 1, 2024) A referred municipality 102 designated as a: 103 (1) Tier I municipality shall be subject to oversight by the Municipal 104 Election Accountability Board consisting of (A) development by such 105 municipality of a plan to mitigate the concerns that warranted such 106 designation by the board, which shall be submitted to the board for 107 approval and modification as required by the board, (B) mandatory 108 training of election officials in election administration procedures 109 conducted by the office of the Secretary of the State or by a certified 110 moderator, town clerk or registrar of voters, or a combination thereof, 111 selected by the Secretary of the State, and (C) distribution of instruction 112 or training manuals or other resources for promoting best practices in 113 election administration. 114 (2) Tier II municipality shall be subject to oversight by the board 115 Raised Bill No. 441 LCO No. 3020 5 of 6 consisting of (A) development by such municipality of a plan to mitigate 116 the concerns that warranted such designation by the board, which shall 117 be submitted to the board for approval and modification as required by 118 the board, (B) mandatory training of election officials in election 119 administration procedures conducted by the office of the Secretary of 120 the State or by a certified moderator, town clerk or registrar of voters, or 121 a combination thereof, selected by the Secretary of the State, (C) 122 distribution of instruction or training manuals or other resources for 123 promoting best practices in election administration, and (D) regular 124 contact with the municipality to ensure (i) compliance with such 125 mitigation plan and timely achievement of the benchmarks set forth in 126 such mitigation plan, (ii) attendance of such election officials at such 127 mandatory training, and (iii) distribution of such manuals or resources. 128 (3) Tier III municipality shall be subject to oversight by the board 129 consisting of appointment of an election monitor (A) who shall be 130 authorized to (i) conduct inspections, inquiries and investigations 131 related to any duty or responsibility under title 9 of the general statutes 132 to be carried out by any official of such municipality or appointee of 133 such official, (ii) have access to all records, data and material maintained 134 by or available to any such official or appointee, and (iii) immediately 135 report to the Secretary of the State any irregularity or impropriety in the 136 performance of any duty or responsibility described in subparagraph 137 (A)(i) of this subdivision, and (B) who shall be provided, by such 138 municipality, with any office space, supplies, equipment and services 139 necessary to properly carry out such election monitor's duties and 140 responsibilities. 141 (4) Tier IV municipality shall be subject to oversight by the board 142 consisting of the complete administration by the board of any election, 143 primary or referendum in such municipality, and all procedures related 144 to the orderly conduct of any such election, primary or referendum, 145 notwithstanding the provisions of (A) titles 7 and 9 of the general 146 statutes, (B) any special act, and (C) any charter or home rule ordinance 147 adopted pursuant to chapter 99 of the general statutes. 148 Raised Bill No. 441 LCO No. 3020 6 of 6 Sec. 4. (NEW) (Effective July 1, 2024) Not later than January 1, 2025, 149 the Municipal Election Accountability Board shall adopt regulations, in 150 accordance with the provisions of chapter 54 of the general statutes, as 151 the board deems necessary to implement the provisions of sections 1 to 152 3, inclusive, of this act. 153 This act shall take effect as follows and shall amend the following sections: Section 1 July 1, 2024 New section Sec. 2 July 1, 2024 New section Sec. 3 July 1, 2024 New section Sec. 4 July 1, 2024 New section Statement of Purpose: To establish a Municipal Election Accountability Board and a process by which said board may be authorized to exercise oversight of municipalities in the administration of their elections, primaries and referenda. [Proposed deletions are enclosed in brackets. Proposed additions are indicated by underline, except that when the entire text of a bill or resolution or a section of a bill or resolution is new, it is not underlined.]