25 LC 48 1604S The Senate Committee on Judiciary offered the following substitute to HB 179: A BILL TO BE ENTITLED AN ACT To amend Article 2 of Chapter 6 of Title 5 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated,1 relating appellate practice, so as to provide for the digital recording of certain trial2 proceedings; to amend Article 2 of Chapter 14 of Title 9 of the Official Code of Georgia3 Annotated, relating to procedure for persons under sentence of state court of record, so as to4 provide for digital recording of certain felony trial proceedings; to amend Title 15 of the5 Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to courts, so as to provide for the digital6 recording of certain Georgia State-wide Business Court proceedings; to provide for the7 utilization and regulation of digital recording systems; to provide for definitions; to provide8 for related matters; to provide for an effective date; to repeal conflicting laws; and for other9 purposes.10 BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF GEORGIA:11 PART I12 SECTION 1-1.13 Article 2 of Chapter 6 of Title 5 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to14 appellate practice, is amended by revising Code Section 5-6-41, relating to reporting,15 - 1 - 25 LC 48 1604S preparation, and disposition of transcript, correction of omissions or misstatements,16 preparation of transcript from recollections, filing of disallowed papers, filing of stipulations17 in lieu of transcript, and reporting at party's expense, as follows:18 "5-6-41.19 (a) For any felony trial; for any post-indictment evidentiary hearing in a felony case20 excluding arraignments, guilty pleas, bond hearings, and any hearings in which no witness21 testifies; and for all proceedings in a case in which the prosecuting attorney has filed a22 notice of intent to seek the death penalty In all felony cases, the transcript of evidence and23 proceedings shall be reported and prepared by a court reporter as provided in Code24 Section 17-8-5 or as otherwise provided by law. In all other felony proceedings, the25 transcript of evidence and proceedings shall either be reported and prepared by a court26 reporter as provided in Code Section 17-8-5 or as otherwise provided by law or, except as27 provided in Code Section 5-6-41, in the judge's discretion, be recorded via a digital28 recording system, as defined in Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform29 court rules adopted and published by order of the Supreme Court with the advice and30 consent of the council of the affected class or classes of trial courts.31 (b) In all misdemeanor cases, the trial judge may, in the judge's discretion, require the32 reporting and transcribing of the evidence and proceedings by a court reporter on terms33 prescribed by the trial judge, or, except as provided in Code Section 5-6-41, may require34 the recording of the evidence and proceedings via a digital recording system, as defined in35 Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and published36 by order of the Supreme Court with the advice and consent of the council of the affected37 class or classes of trial courts.38 (c) In all civil cases tried in the superior and city courts, in the Georgia State-wide39 Business Court, and in any other court, the judgments of which are subject to review by the40 Supreme Court or the Court of Appeals, the trial judge thereof may require the parties to41 have the proceedings and evidence reported by a court reporter, the costs thereof to be42 - 2 - 25 LC 48 1604S borne equally between them, or, except as provided in Code Section 5-6-41, recorded via43 a digital recording system, as defined in Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by44 uniform court rules adopted and published by order of the Supreme Court with the advice45 and consent of the council of the affected class or classes of trial courts; and, where an46 appeal is taken which draws in question the transcript of the evidence and proceedings, it47 shall be the duty of the appellant to have the transcript prepared at the appellant's expense. 48 Where it is determined that the parties, or either of them, are financially unable to pay the49 costs of reporting or transcribing, and the proceeding was not recorded by a digital50 recording system, as defined in Code Section 15-14-22, the judge may, in the judge's51 discretion, authorize trial of the case unreported; and, when it becomes necessary for a52 transcript of the evidence and proceedings to be prepared, it shall be the duty of the moving53 party to prepare the transcript from recollection or otherwise.54 (d) Where a trial in any civil or criminal case is reported by a court reporter or recorded55 via a digital recording system, as defined in Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for56 by uniform court rules adopted and published by order of the Supreme Court with the57 advice and consent of the council of the affected class or classes of trial courts, all motions,58 colloquies, objections, rulings, evidence, whether admitted or stricken on objection or59 otherwise, copies or summaries of all documentary evidence, the charge of the court, and60 all other proceedings which may be called in question on appeal or other posttrial61 procedure shall be reported or recorded; and, where the report or recording is transcribed,62 all such matters shall be included in the written transcript, it being the intention of this63 article that all these matters appear in the record. Where matters occur which were not64 reported or recorded, such as objections to oral argument, misconduct of the jury, or other65 like instances, the court, upon motion of either party, shall require that a transcript of these66 matters be made and included as a part of the record. The transcript of proceedings shall67 not be reduced to narrative form unless by agreement of counsel; but, where the trial is not68 reported or recorded or the transcript of the proceedings for any other reason is not69 - 3 - 25 LC 48 1604S available and the evidence is prepared from recollection, it may be prepared in narrative70 form.71 (e) Where a civil or criminal trial is reported by a court reporter or recorded via a digital72 recording system, as defined in Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform73 court rules adopted and published by order of the Supreme Court with the advice and74 consent of the council of the affected class or classes of trial courts, and the evidence and75 proceedings are transcribed, the a court reporter shall complete the transcript and file the76 original and one copy thereof with the clerk of the trial court, together with the court77 reporter's certificate attesting to the correctness thereof. In criminal cases where the78 accused was convicted of a capital felony, an additional copy shall be filed for the Attorney79 General, for which the court reporter shall receive compensation from the Department of80 Law as provided by law. The original transcript shall be transmitted to the appellate court81 as a part of the record on appeal; and one copy will be retained in the trial court, both as82 referred to in Code Section 5-6-43. Upon filing by the court reporter, the transcript shall83 become a part of the record in the case and need not be approved by the trial judge.84 (f) Where any party contends that the transcript or record does not truly or fully disclose85 what transpired in the trial court and the parties are unable to agree thereon, the trial court86 shall set the matter down for a hearing with notice to both parties and resolve the difference87 so as to make the record conform to the truth. If anything material to either party is omitted88 from the record on appeal or is misstated therein, the parties by stipulation, or the trial89 court, either before or after the record is transmitted to the appellate court, on a proper90 suggestion or of its own initiative, may direct that the omission or misstatement shall be91 corrected and, if necessary, that a supplemental record shall be certified and transmitted by92 the clerk of the trial court. The trial court or the appellate court may at any time order the93 clerk of the trial court to send up any original papers or exhibits in the case, to be returned94 after final disposition of the appeal.95 - 4 - 25 LC 48 1604S (g) Where a proceeding is recorded via a digital recording system, as defined in Code96 Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and published by97 order of the Supreme Court with the advice and consent of the council of the affected class98 or classes of trial courts, such recording shall not be considered the record of the99 proceeding unless it is transcribed and certified pursuant to subsection (b) of Code100 Section 15-14-5. Such transcript shall not be created if the recorded proceeding is also101 taken down and transcribed by a court reporter.102 (g)(h) Where a trial is not reported or recorded as referred to in subsections (b) and (c) of103 this Code section or where for any other reason the transcript of the proceedings is not104 obtainable and a transcript of the evidence and proceedings is prepared from recollection,105 the agreement of the parties thereto or their counsel, entered thereon, shall entitle such106 transcript to be filed as a part of the record in the same manner and with the same binding107 effect as a transcript filed by the court reporter as referred to in subsection (e) of this Code108 section. In case of the inability of the parties to agree as to the correctness of such109 transcript, the decision of the trial judge thereon shall be final and not subject to review;110 and, if the trial judge is unable to recall what transpired, the judge shall enter an order111 stating that fact.112 (h)(i) Where any amendment or other pleading or paper which requires approval or113 sanction of the court in any proceeding before being filed of record is disallowed or114 sanction thereof is refused, the amendment, pleading, or paper may nevertheless be filed,115 with notation of disallowance thereon, and shall become part of the record for purposes of116 consideration on appeal or other procedure for review.117 (i)(j) In lieu of sending up a transcript of record, the parties may by agreement file a118 stipulation of the case showing how the questions arose and were decided in the trial court,119 together with a sufficient statement of facts to enable the appellate court to pass upon the120 questions presented therein. Before being transmitted to the appellate court, the stipulation121 - 5 - 25 LC 48 1604S shall be approved by the trial judge or the presiding judge of the court where the case is122 pending.123 (j)(k) In all cases, civil or criminal, any party may as a matter of right have the case124 reported by a court reporter at the party's own expense."125 SECTION 1-2.126 Article 2 of Chapter 14 of Title 9 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to127 procedure for persons under sentence of state court of record, is amended by revising Code128 Section 9-14-50, relating to transcription of proceedings, as follows:129 "9-14-50.130 All trials held under this article shall be recorded via a digital recording system, as defined131 in Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and132 published by order of the Supreme Court with the advice and consent of the council of the133 affected class or classes of trial courts and transcribed by a court reporter, or taken down134 and transcribed by a court reporter, as designated by the superior court hearing the case."135 PART II136 SECTION 2-1.137 Title 15 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to courts, is amended by revising138 Code Section 15-5A-14, relating to the employment and compensation of other personnel,139 as follows:140 "15-5A-14.141 The judge of the Georgia State-wide Business Court may employ and fix the salaries of142 stenographers, clerical assistants, and such other employees as may be deemed necessary143 by the court; and the salaries therefor shall be paid by the clerk from the amount144 appropriated by the General Assembly for such purposes. Except as provided in145 - 6 - 25 LC 48 1604S subsection (k) of Code Section 5-6-41, the judge may also provide for the recording of146 cases via a digital recording system, as defined in Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided147 for by uniform court rules adopted and published by order of the Supreme Court with the148 advice and consent of the Georgia State-wide Business Court."149 SECTION 2-2.150 Said title is further amended by revising subsection (a) of Code Section 15-7-47, relating to151 court reporters, waiver, and compensation relative to state courts, as follows:152 "(a) State courts shall make available for the reporting of civil and criminal trials a court153 reporter, as defined in Code Section 15-14-22, or a digital recording system, as defined in154 Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and published155 by order of the Supreme Court with the advice and consent of The Council of State Court156 Judges of Georgia Court reporting personnel shall be made available for the reporting of157 civil and criminal trials in state courts, subject to the laws governing same in the superior158 courts of this state, or both. Except as provided in subsection (k) of Code Section 5-6-41,159 the judge shall have discretion as to whether to use a digital recording system, as defined160 in Code Section 15-14-22."161 SECTION 2-3.162 Said title is further amended by revising subsection (f) of and by adding a new subsection to163 Code Section 15-12-83, relating to oath of court reporter attending grand jury proceeding,164 compensation, and role and responsibilities, to read as follows:165 "(f) The district attorney may utilize a digital recording system, as defined in Code166 Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and published by167 order of the Supreme Court with the advice and consent of the council of the affected class168 or classes of trial courts to record grand jury proceedings.169 - 7 - 25 LC 48 1604S (g) Except as otherwise provided in this Code section, a recording, any court reporter's170 notes, and any transcript prepared from such recording or notes shall be provided solely to171 the district attorney, who shall retain control of such recording, notes, and transcript. The172 district attorney may use such materials to the extent such use is appropriate to the proper173 performance of his or her official duties, including compliance with Article 1 of Chapter 16174 of Title 17."175 SECTION 2-4.176 Said title is further amended by revising Code Section 15-14-1, relating to power of superior177 court judges to appoint and remove, oath, and duties, as follows:178 "15-14-1.179 The judges of the superior courts shall have power to appoint and, at their pleasure, to180 remove a court reporter, as defined in Article 2 of this chapter Code Section 15-14-22, for181 the courts of their respective circuits. The court reporter, before entering on the duties of182 the court reporter's office, shall be duly sworn in open court to perform faithfully all the183 duties required of the court reporter by law. It shall be the court reporter's duty to attend184 all courts in the circuit for which such court reporter is appointed and, when directed by the185 judge, to record exactly and truly or take stenographic notes of the testimony and186 proceedings in the case tried, except the arguments of counsel. Except as provided for in187 subsection (k) of Code Section 5-6-41, the judges may provide for the recording of cases188 and proceedings via a digital recording system, as defined in Code Section 15-14-22, and189 as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and published by order of the Supreme190 Court with the advice and consent of The Council of Superior Court Judges of Georgia191 when such recording is authorized pursuant to Code Section 5-6-41."192 - 8 - 25 LC 48 1604S SECTION 2-5.193 Said title is further amended by revising subsection (a) of Code Section 15-14-2, relating to194 power of city court judges to appoint and compensation, as follows:195 "(a) The judges of the city courts of this state having concurrent jurisdiction with the196 superior courts of this state to try misdemeanor cases and to try civil cases where the197 amount involved exceeds $500.00, where not otherwise specifically provided for by law,198 may appoint an official court reporter, as defined in Article 2 of this chapter Code199 Section 15-14-22, whose compensation for reporting criminal and civil cases and for200 attendance upon court shall be the same as provided by the Judicial Council pursuant to201 Code Section 15-5-21. Except as provided in subsection (k) of Code Section 5-6-41, the202 judges may also provide for the recording of cases via a digital recording system, as203 defined in Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and204 published by order of the Supreme Court with the advice and consent of the council of the205 affected class or classes of trial courts. The court reporter reporting and transcribing civil206 cases shall be paid by the party or parties requesting the reporting or transcribing."207 SECTION 2-6.208 Said title is further amended by revising Code Section 15-14-5, relating to duty to transcribe209 and certificate, as follows:210 "15-14-5.211 (a) It shall be the duty of each court reporter to transcribe the evidence and other212 proceedings of which he has taken notes as provided by law whenever requested so to do213 by counsel for any party to such case and upon being paid the legal fees for such214 transcripts. The reporter, upon delivering the transcript to such counsel, shall affix thereto215 a certificate signed by him or her reciting that the transcript is true, complete, and correct. 216 Subject only to the right of the trial judge to change or require the correction of the217 transcript, the transcript so certified shall be presumed to be true, complete, and correct.218 - 9 - 25 LC 48 1604S (b) When a court proceeding has been recorded via a digital recording system, as defined219 in Code Section 15-14-22, and as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and220 published by order of the Supreme Court with the advice and consent of the council of the221 affected class or classes of trial courts, if requested or required by law, a transcript shall be222 prepared by a certified court reporter. If a court reporter receives such recording from the223 court, the court reporter shall transcribe the recording completely and accurately in224 accordance with rules promulgated by the Judicial Council of Georgia or any applicable225 uniform rules. The court reporter, upon delivering the transcript to the requesting party or226 upon filing it with the clerk, shall affix thereto a signed certificate reciting that the227 transcript is true, complete, and correct. Subject only to the right of the trial judge to228 change or require the correction of the transcript, a transcript so certified shall be presumed229 to be true, complete, and correct."230 SECTION 2-7.231 Said title is further amended by revising Code Section 15-14-22, relating to definitions232 relative to training and certification of court reporters, as follows:233 "15-14-22.234 As used in this article, the term:235 (1) 'Board' means the Board of Court Reporting of the Judicial Council.236 (2) 'Certified court reporter' means any person certified under this article to practice237 verbatim reporting.238 (3) 'Court reporter' means any person who is engaged in the practice of court reporting239 as a profession as defined in this article. The term 'court reporter' Such term shall include240 not only those who actually report judicial proceedings in courts but also those who make241 verbatim records as defined described in paragraph (4) of this Code section.242 (4) 'Court reporting' means the making of a verbatim record by means of manual243 shorthand, machine shorthand, closed microphone voice dictation silencer, or by other244 - 10 - 25 LC 48 1604S means of personal verbatim reporting of any testimony given under oath before, or for245 submission to, any court, referee, or court examiner or any board, commission, or other246 body created by statute, or by the Constitution of this state or in any other proceeding247 where a verbatim record is required. The taking of a deposition is the making of a248 verbatim record as defined described in this article. Such term shall not include the249 operation of a digital recording system aside from those methods of making a verbatim250 record that require the passage of an examination accepted by the board pursuant to Code251 Section 15-14-30.252 (5) 'Digital recording system' means any method for creating an electronic audio or253 audiovisual recording of a court proceeding for the purpose of creating a verbatim254 transcript as provided for by uniform court rules adopted and published by order of the255 Supreme Court with the advice and consent of the council of the affected class or classes256 of trial courts."257 PART III258 SECTION 3-1.259 This Act shall become effective on January 1, 2026.260 SECTION 3-2.261 All laws and parts of laws in conflict with this Act are repealed.262 - 11 -