Hawaii Senate Bill SCR10

Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

• Introduced: 1/25/23
• Refer: 1/30/23
• Report Pass: 4/4/23
• Engrossed: 4/5/23
• Refer: 4/11/23

Caption

Requesting The National Conference Of State Legislatures And Council Of State Governments To Update The Findings Of The 2004 Joint Project On Term Limits On The Potential Positive And Negative Consequences Of Implementing Term Limits For Members Of The Legislature.

Impact

The bill addresses concerns regarding the dynamics of political competition and representation in the state legislature. Proponents argue that implementing term limits could invigorate democracy by allowing new voices to enter the political arena, thereby reducing incumbency advantages that discourage potential candidates. Conversely, some worry that term limits may adversely impact institutional knowledge and legislative effectiveness as experienced lawmakers are cycled out of office, which could lead to a loss of continuity in governance.

Summary

SCR10 is a Senate Concurrent Resolution from Hawaii, focused on urging updates to the findings of a 2004 joint project on term limits for state legislators. This resolution recognizes that term limits have been adopted in numerous states and acknowledges variations in state legislation on this topic. By requesting an updated analysis of the impacts—both positive and negative—of term limits, SCR10 aims to facilitate informed discussions surrounding its implications on legislative effectiveness and nonincumbent competitiveness in elections.

Sentiment

Discussion around SCR10 reflects a mix of support and skepticism from various stakeholders. Advocates view the resolution as a necessary step toward modernizing the legislative process and ensuring broader representation in state politics. Yet, critics caution against sweeping reforms without thorough consideration of historical data and comprehensive understanding of the implications of term limits. This indicates a polarized sentiment regarding legislative reform and the balance of power within state governance.

Contention

SCR10 raises notable points regarding the effectiveness of term limits in mitigating incumbent advantages and enhancing electoral competitiveness. Some states that have repealed term limits highlight potential procedural issues and the difficulty nonincumbents face in competing against established officials. The resolution calls for a nuanced exploration of these ramifications, recognizing the complex interplay between voter engagement, legislative efficiency, and the foundational principles of representative democracy.