Hawaii Senate Bill SCR99

Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/10/23
• Refer: 3/15/23

Caption

Requesting The Establishment Of A Working Group To Evaluate New Zealand's Model Of Decriminalizing Prostitution And Make Recommendations On How To Amend Hawaii Laws To Decriminalize Prostitution.

Impact

The proposed working group is tasked with studying the effects of New Zealand's Prostitution Reform Act 2003 and its outcomes over nearly two decades. The findings will inform recommendations on how to amend existing laws in Hawaii. This evaluation aims to help the legislature understand the potential benefits and drawbacks of decriminalization, including impacts on health and safety, sex worker rights, and law enforcement policies. Such insights could lead to significant changes in Hawaii's criminal justice and public health policies regarding sex work.

Summary

SCR99 is a Senate Concurrent Resolution that seeks to establish a working group in Hawaii to evaluate the implications of decriminalizing prostitution, using New Zealand's model as a reference. The current legal framework in Hawaii criminalizes prostitution, but this resolution aims to explore potential changes that might enhance the rights and protections of sex workers while considering public health and safety. The resolution acknowledges a growing body of research that suggests decriminalization could offer multiple benefits to those engaged in sex work, their clients, and the community at large.

Contention

While this resolution is positioned as a step towards modernizing Hawaii's approach to prostitution, it is also likely to generate discussions and debates within the community and legislature. Proponents of SCR99 may argue the need for reform to protect sex workers and reduce harm, while opponents might raise concerns over public morality, safety, and the potential for increased human trafficking. The establishment of the working group serves to navigate these complex issues and promote an informed legislative process that considers a range of perspectives and expertise.