Kentucky 2022 2022 Regular Session

Kentucky House Bill HB218 Introduced / Bill

                    UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 1 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
AN ACT relating to expungement. 1 
Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Kentucky: 2 
Section 1.   KRS 431.073 is amended to read as follows: 3 
(1) Any person who has been: 4 
(a) Convicted of a Class D felony violation of KRS 17.175, 186.990, 194A.505, 5 
194B.505, 217.181, 217.207, 217.208, 218A.140, 218A.1415, 218A.1416, 6 
218A.1417, 218A.1418, 218A.1423, 218A.1439, 218A.282, 218A.284, 7 
218A.286, 218A.320, 218A.322, 218A.324, 218A.500, 244.165, 286.11-057, 8 
304.47-025, 324.990, 365.241, 434.155, 434.675, 434.850, 434.872, 511.040, 9 
512.020, 514.030, 514.040, 514.050, 514.060, 514.065, 514.070, 514.080, 10 
514.090, 514.100, 514.110, 514.120, 514.140, 514.150, 514.160, 516.030, 11 
516.060, 516.090, 516.108, 517.120, 518.040, 522.040, 524.100, 525.113, 12 
526.020, 526.030, 528.020, 528.040, 528.050, 530.010, or 530.050; 13 
(b) Convicted of a series of Class D felony violations of one (1) or more statutes 14 
enumerated in paragraph (a) of this subsection arising from a single incident; 15 
(c) Granted a full pardon; or 16 
(d) Convicted of a Class D felony, or an offense prior to January 1, 1975 which 17 
was punishable by not more than five (5) years' incarceration, which was not a 18 
violation of KRS 189A.010, 508.032, or 519.055, abuse of public office, a sex 19 
offense, or an offense committed against a child, and did not result in serious 20 
bodily injury or death; or of a series of felony offenses eligible under this 21 
paragraph; 22 
 may file with the court in which he or she was convicted an application to have the 23 
judgment vacated. The application shall be filed as a motion in the original criminal 24 
case. The person shall be informed of the right at the time of adjudication. 25 
(2) (a) A verified application to have the judgment vacated under this section shall be 26 
filed no sooner than upon[five (5) years after the] completion of the person's 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 2 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
sentence, or upon[five (5) years after the] successful completion of the 1 
person's probation or parole, whichever occurs later. 2 
(b) Upon the payment of the filing fee and the filing of the application, the Circuit 3 
Court clerk shall serve a notice of filing upon the office of the 4 
Commonwealth's attorney or county attorney that prosecuted the case and the 5 
county attorney of the county where the judgment was entered. The office of 6 
the Commonwealth's attorney or county attorney that prosecuted the case shall 7 
file a response within sixty (60) days after being served with the notice of 8 
filing. That time period may be extended for good cause, but the hearing on 9 
the application to vacate the judgment shall occur no later than one hundred 10 
twenty (120) days following the filing of the application. The inability to 11 
determine the location of the crime victim shall constitute good cause for an 12 
extension of time. No hearing upon the merits of the application shall be 13 
scheduled until the Commonwealth's response has been filed, or if no 14 
response is received, no later than one hundred twenty (120) days after the 15 
filing of the application. 16 
(c) In any case in which the Commonwealth objects that the application is grossly 17 
incomplete, the court shall order the person or agency originating the 18 
application to supplement the application. 19 
(3) Upon the filing of the Commonwealth's response to an application, or if no response 20 
is received, no later than one hundred twenty (120) days after the filing of the 21 
application, the court shall set a date for a hearing and the Circuit Court clerk shall 22 
notify the office of the Commonwealth's attorney or county attorney that prosecuted 23 
the case. The office of the Commonwealth's attorney or county attorney that 24 
prosecuted the case shall notify the victim of the crime, if there was an identified 25 
victim. The Commonwealth's attorney or county attorney shall be authorized to 26 
obtain without payment of any fee information from the Transportation Cabinet 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 3 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
regarding the crime victim's address on file regarding any vehicle operator's license 1 
issued to that person. 2 
(4) (a) In an application pursuant to subsection (1)(d) of this section, upon the filing 3 
of the Commonwealth's response objecting to the vacating of a judgment and 4 
expungement of a record, the court shall schedule a hearing within one 5 
hundred twenty (120) days of the Commonwealth's response. The prosecutor 6 
shall specify in the objection the reasons for believing a denial of the 7 
application is justified. At the hearing at which the applicant or his or her 8 
attorney must be present, the applicant must prove by clear and convincing 9 
evidence that: 10 
1. Vacating the judgment and expunging the record is consistent with the 11 
welfare and safety of the public; 12 
2. The action is supported by his or her behavior since the conviction or 13 
convictions, as evidenced that he or she has been active in rehabilitative 14 
activities in prison and is living a law-abiding life since release; 15 
3. The vacation and expungement is warranted by the interests of justice; 16 
and 17 
4. Any other matter deemed appropriate or necessary by the court to make 18 
a determination regarding the petition for expungement is met. 19 
(b) At the hearing, the applicant may testify as to the specific adverse 20 
consequences he or she may be subject to if the application is denied. The 21 
court may hear testimony of witnesses and any other matter the court deems 22 
proper and relevant to its determination regarding the application. The 23 
Commonwealth may present proof of any extraordinary circumstances that 24 
exist to deny the application. A victim of any offense listed in the application 25 
shall have an opportunity to be heard at any hearing held under this section. 26 
(c) If the court determines that circumstances warrant vacation and expungement 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 4 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
and that the harm otherwise resulting to the applicant clearly outweighs the 1 
public interest in the criminal history record information being publicly 2 
available, then the original conviction or convictions shall be vacated and the 3 
records shall be expunged. The order of expungement shall not preclude a 4 
prosecutor's office from retaining a nonpublic record for law enforcement 5 
purposes only. 6 
(5) The court may order the judgment vacated, and if the judgment is vacated the court 7 
shall dismiss with prejudice any charges which are eligible for expungement under 8 
subsection (1) of this section or KRS 431.076 or 431.078, and[, upon full payment 9 
of the fee in subsection (11) of this section,] order expunged all records in the 10 
custody of the court and any records in the custody of any other agency or official, 11 
including law enforcement records, if the court finds that: 12 
(a) The person had not, after June 27, 2019, had a felony conviction vacated and 13 
the record expunged pursuant to this section; 14 
(b) [The person had not in the five (5) years prior to the filing of the application to 15 
have the judgment vacated been convicted of a felony or a misdemeanor; 16 
(c) ]No proceeding concerning a felony or misdemeanor is pending or being 17 
instituted against the person; and 18 
(c)[(d)] For an application pursuant to subsection (1)(d) of this section, the 19 
person has been rehabilitated and poses no significant threat of recidivism. 20 
(6) If the court has received a response from the office of the Commonwealth's attorney 21 
or county attorney that prosecuted the case stating no objection to the application to 22 
have the judgment vacated, or if one hundred twenty (120) days have elapsed since 23 
the filing of the application and no response has been received from the victim or 24 
the office of the Commonwealth's attorney or county attorney that prosecuted the 25 
case, the court may, without a hearing, vacate the judgment in the manner 26 
established in subsection (5) of this section. 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 5 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
(7) Upon entry of an order vacating and expunging a conviction, the original conviction 1 
shall be vacated and[, upon full payment of the fee in subsection (11) of this 2 
section,] the record shall be expunged. The court and other agencies shall cause 3 
records to be deleted or removed from their computer systems so that the matter 4 
shall not appear on official state-performed background checks. The court and other 5 
agencies shall reply to any inquiry that no record exists on the matter. The person 6 
whose record is expunged shall not have to disclose the fact of the record or any 7 
matter relating thereto on an application for employment, credit, or other type of 8 
application. If the person is not prohibited from voting for any other reason, the 9 
person's ability to vote shall be restored and the person may register to vote. 10 
(8) An order vacating a conviction under this section shall not extend or revive an 11 
expired statute of limitations, shall not constitute a finding of legal error regarding 12 
the proceedings leading to or resulting in the conviction, shall not nullify any 13 
findings of fact or conclusions of law made by the trial court or any appellate court 14 
regarding the conviction, and shall not constitute a finding of innocence regarding 15 
the conviction. 16 
(9) The Administrative Office of the Courts shall establish a form application to be 17 
used in filing an application to have judgment vacated and records expunged. 18 
(10) The filing fee for an application to have judgment vacated and records expunged 19 
shall be fifty dollars ($50), which shall be deposited into a trust and agency account 20 
for deputy clerks and shall not be refundable. 21 
(11)[ (a) Upon the issuance of an order vacating and expunging a conviction pursuant 22 
to this section, the applicant shall be charged an expungement fee of two 23 
hundred fifty dollars ($250), which may be payable by an installment plan in 24 
accordance with KRS 534.020. 25 
(b) When the order is issued, the court shall set a date, no sooner than eighteen 26 
(18) months after the date of the order, by which the defendant must comply 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 6 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
with the installment payment plan. The applicant shall be given notice of the 1 
total amount due, the payment frequency, and the date by which all payments 2 
must be made. The notice shall state that the expungement cannot be 3 
completed until full payment is received, and that if the applicant has not 4 
completed the installment payment plan by the scheduled date, he or she shall 5 
appear on that date to show good cause as to why he or she is unable to satisfy 6 
the obligations. Notwithstanding provisions of KRS 534.020 to the contrary, 7 
no applicant shall be ordered to jail for failure to complete an installment plan 8 
ordered pursuant to this section. 9 
(c) The revenues and interest from the expungement fee shall be deposited in the 10 
expungement fund created in KRS 431.0795. 11 
(12)] This section shall be retroactive. 12 
Section 2.   KRS 431.076 is amended to read as follows: 13 
(1) (a) On or after July 15, 2020, if a court enters an order of acquittal of criminal 14 
charges against a person, or enters an order dismissing with prejudice all 15 
criminal charges in a case against a person and not in exchange for a guilty 16 
plea to another charge, the court shall order the record expunged upon the 17 
expiration of thirty (30) days, unless the person objects to the expungement. 18 
As used in this paragraph, "criminal charges" shall not include a traffic 19 
infraction not otherwise classified as a misdemeanor. The order expunging the 20 
records shall not require any action by the person. 21 
(b) A person who has been charged with a criminal offense and who has been 22 
acquitted of the charges, or against whom charges have been dismissed and 23 
not in exchange for a guilty plea to another charge, and whose records have 24 
not been expunged pursuant to paragraph (a) of this subsection, may petition 25 
the court in which the disposition of the charges was made to expunge all 26 
charges. 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 7 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
(c) A person against whom felony charges originally filed in the District Court 1 
have not resulted in an indictment by the grand jury or in an information filed 2 
by the Commonwealth's attorney may petition the District Court in which the 3 
charges were filed to dismiss and expunge all charges for which an indictment 4 
or information has not issued. 5 
(2) An expungement petition brought under subsection (1)(b) or (c) of this section shall 6 
be filed no sooner than: 7 
(a) Sixty (60) days following the order of acquittal or dismissal with prejudice by 8 
the court; 9 
(b) Six (6) months following the date of the District Court decision to hold the 10 
matter to the grand jury; or 11 
(c) Upon entry of an order dismissing[For] charges [dismissed ]without 12 
prejudice[: 13 
1. For felony charges, three (3) years following the date of the order of 14 
dismissal without prejudice; or 15 
2. For misdemeanor charges, one (1) year following the date of the order of 16 
dismissal without prejudice]. 17 
(3) (a) If the court finds that the petition under subsection (1)(b) of this section is 18 
properly brought, the court shall grant the petition and order the expunging of 19 
the records. 20 
(b) 1. If the expungement petition is brought under subsection (1)(c) of this 21 
section, the petition shall be served upon the offices of the county and 22 
Commonwealth's attorneys that prosecuted the case. 23 
2. Following the filing of the petition, the court shall notify the county and 24 
Commonwealth's attorneys of an opportunity for a response to the 25 
petition. The response shall be filed within ninety (90) days after the 26 
filing of the petition. 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 8 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
3. If a response is not filed, ninety (90) days after the filing of the petition 1 
the court shall dismiss the charges without prejudice and order the 2 
expunging of the records. 3 
4. If a response is filed, ninety (90) days after the date the response is filed, 4 
if an indictment has not issued, the court shall dismiss without prejudice 5 
the charges for which an indictment has not issued and order the 6 
expunging of the records. 7 
(4) An order of expungement pursuant to this section shall expunge all criminal records 8 
in the custody of the court and any criminal records in the custody of any other 9 
agency or official, including law enforcement records, but no order of expungement 10 
pursuant to this section shall expunge records in the custody of the Department for 11 
Community Based Services. The court shall order the expunging on a form 12 
provided by the Administrative Office of the Courts. Every agency, with records 13 
relating to the arrest, charge, or other matters arising out of the arrest or charge, that 14 
is ordered to expunge records, shall certify to the court within sixty (60) days of the 15 
entry of the expungement order, that the required expunging action has been 16 
completed. All orders enforcing the expungement procedure shall also be expunged. 17 
(5) (a) If an expungement is ordered under subsection (1)(a) or (b) of this section, an 18 
appellate court which issued an opinion in the case shall order the appellate 19 
case file to be sealed and also direct that the version of the appellate opinion 20 
published on the court's Web site be modified to avoid use of the defendant's 21 
name in the case title and body of the opinion. 22 
(b) If an expungement is ordered under subsection (1)(c) of this section, an 23 
appellate court which issued an opinion in the case may, upon motion of the 24 
petitioner in the case, order the appellate case file to be sealed and also direct 25 
that the version of the appellate opinion published on the court's Web site be 26 
modified to avoid use of the petitioner's name in the case title and body of the 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 9 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
opinion. 1 
(6) After the expungement, the proceedings in the matter shall be deemed never to have 2 
occurred. The court and other agencies shall delete or remove the records from their 3 
computer systems so that any official state-performed background check will 4 
indicate that the records do not exist. The court and other agencies shall reply to any 5 
inquiry that no record exists on the matter. The person whose record is expunged 6 
shall not have to disclose the fact of the record or any matter relating thereto on an 7 
application for employment, credit, or other type of application. 8 
(7) Inspection of the records included in the order may thereafter be permitted by the 9 
court only upon petition by the person who is the subject of the records and only to 10 
those persons named in the petition. 11 
(8) Except as provided in subsection (1)(a) of this section, this section shall be 12 
retroactive. 13 
Section 3.   KRS 431.078 is amended to read as follows: 14 
(1) Any person who has been convicted of: 15 
(a) A misdemeanor, a violation, or a traffic infraction not otherwise classified as a 16 
misdemeanor or violation, or a series of misdemeanors, violations, or traffic 17 
infractions arising from a single incident; or 18 
(b) A series of misdemeanors, violations, or traffic infractions not arising from a 19 
single incident; 20 
 may petition the court in which he was convicted for expungement of his 21 
misdemeanor or violation record within that judicial district, including a record of 22 
any charges for misdemeanors, violations, or traffic infractions that were dismissed 23 
or amended in the criminal action. The person shall be informed of the right at the 24 
time of adjudication. 25 
(2) Except as provided in KRS 218A.275(8) and 218A.276(8), the petition shall be 26 
filed no sooner than upon[five (5) years after the] completion of the person's 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 10 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
sentence or upon[five (5) years after the] successful completion of the person's 1 
probation, whichever occurs later. 2 
(3) Upon the filing of a petition, the court shall set a date for a hearing, no sooner than 3 
thirty (30) days after the filing of the petition, and shall notify the county attorney; 4 
the victim of the crime, if there was an identified victim; and any other person 5 
whom the person filing the petition has reason to believe may have relevant 6 
information related to the expungement of the record. Inability to locate the victim 7 
shall not delay the proceedings in the case or preclude the holding of a hearing or 8 
the issuance of an order of expungement. 9 
(4) For a petition brought under subsection (1)(a) of this section, the court shall order 10 
expunged all records in the custody of the court and any records in the custody of 11 
any other agency or official, including law enforcement records, if at the hearing the 12 
court finds that: 13 
(a) The offense was not a sex offense or an offense committed against a child; 14 
(b) [The person had not in the five (5) years prior to the filing of the petition for 15 
expungement been convicted of a felony or a misdemeanor; 16 
(c) ]No proceeding concerning a felony or misdemeanor is pending or being 17 
instituted against the person; and 18 
(c)[(d)] The offense is not one subject to enhancement for a second or 19 
subsequent offense or the time for such an enhancement has expired. 20 
(5) For a petition brought under subsection (1)(b) of this section, the court may order 21 
expunged all records in the custody of the court and any records in the custody of 22 
any other agency or official, including law enforcement records, if at the hearing the 23 
court finds that: 24 
(a) The offense was not a sex offense or an offense committed against a child; 25 
(b) [The person had not in the five (5) years prior to the filing of the petition for 26 
expungement been convicted of a felony or a misdemeanor; 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 11 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
(c) ]No proceeding concerning a felony or misdemeanor is pending or being 1 
instituted against the person; and 2 
(c)[(d)] The offense is not one subject to enhancement for a second or 3 
subsequent offense or the time for such an enhancement has expired. 4 
(6) Upon the entry of an order to expunge the records, the proceedings in the case shall 5 
be deemed never to have occurred; the court and other agencies shall cause records 6 
to be deleted or removed from their computer systems so that the matter shall not 7 
appear on official state-performed background checks; the persons and the court 8 
may properly reply that no record exists with respect to the persons upon any 9 
inquiry in the matter; and the person whose record is expunged shall not have to 10 
disclose the fact of the record or any matter relating thereto on an application for 11 
employment, credit, or other type of application. 12 
(7) The filing fee for a petition under this section shall be [one hundred dollars ($100). 13 
The first ]fifty dollars ($50), which[ of each fee collected pursuant to this 14 
subsection] shall be deposited into a trust and agency account for deputy clerks and 15 
shall not be refundable. 16 
(8) Copies of the order shall be sent to each agency or official named therein. 17 
(9) Inspection of the records included in the order may thereafter be permitted by the 18 
court only upon petition by the person who is the subject of the records and only to 19 
those persons named in the petition. 20 
(10) This section shall be deemed to be retroactive, and any person who has been 21 
convicted of a misdemeanor prior to July 14, 1992, may petition the court in which 22 
he was convicted, or if he was convicted prior to the inception of the District Court 23 
to the District Court in the county where he now resides, for expungement of the 24 
record of one (1) misdemeanor offense or violation or a series of misdemeanor 25 
offenses or violations arising from a single incident, provided that the offense was 26 
not one specified in subsection (4) and that the offense was not the precursor 27  UNOFFICIAL COPY  	22 RS BR 916 
Page 12 of 12 
XXXX  	Jacketed 
offense of a felony offense for which he was subsequently convicted. This section 1 
shall apply only to offenses against the Commonwealth of Kentucky. 2 
(11) As used in this section, "violation" has the same meaning as in KRS 500.080. 3 
(12) Any person denied an expungement prior to June 25, 2013, due to the presence of a 4 
traffic infraction on his or her record may file a new petition for expungement of the 5 
previously petitioned offenses, which the court shall hear and decide under the 6 
terms of this section. No court costs or other fees, from the court or any other 7 
agency, shall be required of a person filing a new petition under this subsection. 8 
Section 4.   The following KRS section is repealed: 9 
431.0795  Expungement fund.  10