Kentucky 2023 Regular Session

Kentucky House Bill HB252

Introduced
2/10/23  

Caption

AN ACT relating to immunity from criminal liability for health care providers.

Impact

The enactment of HB 252 could significantly impact state laws concerning health care malpractice and provider liability. By establishing immunity for health care providers, this bill may encourage more professionals to provide care, knowing they are shielded from potential criminal charges arising from their actions. However, the bill explicitly states that it does not protect against gross negligence or malicious misconduct, maintaining accountability for egregious failures in care.

Summary

House Bill 252 relates to granting immunity from criminal liability for health care providers in the Commonwealth of Kentucky. The legislation proposes that health care providers will be immune from criminal charges for any harm or damages that stem from their acts or omissions while providing health services. This bill aims to protect medical professionals from legal repercussions as they perform their duties, especially in complex medical scenarios where decisions must be made rapidly.

Sentiment

Sentiment surrounding HB 252 has been mixed among lawmakers and advocacy groups. Proponents argue that this legislation is necessary to safeguard health care providers, particularly in high-stress environments like hospitals where quick decisions often lead to complicated outcomes. They posit that this immunity could support a more willing participation of providers in care contexts without fear of criminal repercussions. Conversely, opponents express concern that this could lower the standards of care, as some may feel less accountable for their actions, fearing a potential decline in patient safety.

Contention

Notable points of contention regarding HB 252 revolve around the potential ramifications of granting broad immunity to health care providers. Critics warn that it may create a culture of impunity within the health care system, potentially leading to neglect in patient care standards, as some providers may exploit this protection. The distinction drawn in the bill between acts protected by immunity and those involving gross negligence sets the stage for ongoing debates about the appropriate balance between protection for professionals and accountability for patient outcomes.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

KY HB159

AN ACT relating to immunity from criminal liability for health care providers.

KY HF1647

Immunity from criminal liability provided for health care providers when performing health treatment and services.

KY SF971

Immunity from criminal liability for health care providers when providing health treatment and services establishment

KY HB2190

Relating to immunity from criminal liability for certain health care practitioners.

KY SB2380

Relating to immunity from criminal liability for certain health care practitioners.

KY HB84

AN ACT relating to liability protection in emergencies.

KY SB86

Provides immunity from liability to certain providers of health care. (BDR 3-501)

KY HB742

Provides for immunity from civil and criminal liability for in vitro fertilization service providers

KY HB282

AN ACT relating to health care services agencies.

KY SB145

AN ACT relating to healthcare.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.