Louisiana 2010 Regular Session

Louisiana House Bill HB355

Introduced
3/29/10  
Refer
3/29/10  

Caption

Authorizes nonprofit victim's rights advocacy organizations to nominate members to the Board of Pardons, Board of Parole, and the Crime Victims Reparations Board

Impact

The bill's implication on state laws revolves around modifying existing governance structures for boards that deal with critical aspects of criminal justice and victim support. By allowing nominees from nonprofit advocacy organizations, the law encourages an environment where victims' rights are prioritized, potentially leading to changes in how parole and pardon decisions are made. The engagement of these advocacy groups not only broadens the professional landscape of representatives on the boards but may also alter the dynamics surrounding legislative discussions on crime and punishment in the state.

Summary

House Bill 355 seeks to amend the membership composition of the Board of Pardons, Board of Parole, and the Crime Victims Reparations Board by allowing nonprofit victim's rights advocacy organizations to nominate members to these boards. This change aims to expand the representation of victims' interests in the decision-making processes of these boards, thereby enhancing the voice of advocacy groups that focus on the rights of crime victims within Louisiana's criminal justice system. The bill signifies a more inclusive approach that integrates diverse perspectives into boards that traditionally had a more limited composition based on gubernatorial appointments alone.

Sentiment

The general sentiment surrounding HB 355 has largely been positive among advocates for victims' rights, who view this legislative change as a long-overdue acknowledgment of the need for advocacy representation in state governance. Proponents argue that having members from relevant organizations ensures that victims' perspectives are adequately considered during crucial decisions regarding pardons and parole. However, some concerns have been raised regarding the potential for political influences in the nomination process and whether this would truly reflect the needs of a diverse population of crime victims.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the balance of influence between nonprofit organizations and traditional state governance. Critics may express worry about the implications of elevating advocacy organizations within formal governance structures, fearing it could politicize the decision-making process around victim support and criminal rehabilitation. The effectiveness of these boards hinges on impartiality and fair representation, and the inclusion of advocacy-group nominees could lead to concerns about favoritism or biases that might arise from their affiliations. Thus, while the intent of HB 355 aligns with enhancing victim rights, discussions around governance integrity are likely to emerge.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA SB436

Allows nonprofit victim's rights advocacy organizations to nominate members to the Board of Pardons, the Board of Parole, and the Crime Victims Reparations Board. (8/15/10)

LA SB202

Provides relative to the membership, duties and operations of the parole board and pardon board. (8/15/11) (EN NO IMPACT See Note)

LA HB518

Merges the functions and duties of the Board of Parole into the Board of Pardons and creates a committee on parole which shall be part of the Board of Pardons (EN DECREASE GF EX See Note)

LA SB400

Merges the board of Pardon and Parole. (8/1/12) (OR -$385,220 GF EX See Note)

LA HB418

Provides relative to the membership of the Board of Parole

LA HB130

Provides for qualifications of members of the Board of Pardons

LA HB190

Provides for the qualifications of members of the Board of Parole

LA HB06723

An Act Concerning Reform Of Parole Release And Revocation Practices And The Membership Of The Board Of Pardons And Paroles.

LA HB199

Pardons and Paroles; increased members on board

LA HB3633

Pardon and Parole Board; providing for alternate membership on the Pardon and Parole Board; effective date.

Similar Bills

CA SCA1

Elections: recall of state officers.

CA AB227

Governor: appointments.

NH CACR1

Relating to the governor. Providing that there be a lieutenant governor who shall assume the duties of the governor if the governor is incapacitated.

NH CACR1

Relating to the governor. Providing that there be a lieutenant governor who shall assume the duties of the governor if the governor is incapacitated.

HI HB1420

Proposing To Amend Sections Of Article V Of The Hawaii State Constitution.

CA SB181

Administrative Procedure Act: repeal of regulations.

CA SCA6

Elections: recall of state officers.

CT HB07223

An Act Concerning The Order Of Gubernatorial Succession Under Certain Permanent And Temporary Circumstances.