Louisiana 2011 Regular Session

Louisiana Senate Bill SB206

Introduced
4/25/11  

Caption

Provides for the Health Care Compact. (See Act) (OR FF RV See Note)

Impact

If enacted, SB206 could lead to a fundamental reorganization of state health care laws. States that participate in the compact would gain the authority to override federal health care regulations, potentially affecting thousands of existing federal regulations and programs. This could lead to varied health care policies across states, as each state will have the discretion to legislate according to its unique needs and values. The bill includes mechanisms for funding that provide states with access to federal money to support their health care policies without the condition of adhering to federal regulations.

Summary

Senate Bill 206, also known as the Health Care Compact, proposes a significant shift in the way health care is regulated within member states. The bill establishes a framework for states to collectively take control over their health care regulations, asserting that the authority to regulate health care should primarily reside with the states rather than the federal government. This legislation aims to create a compact among states that allows them to suspend federal health care laws that conflict with state regulations once the compact is approved by Congress.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB206 is polarized among various stakeholders. Supporters argue that the bill restores local autonomy and allows states to tailor their health care systems to better serve their populations, promoting innovation and responsiveness. Critics, however, express concern that this decentralization could lead to inadequate health care standards, disparities in treatment accessibility, and challenges in funding responsibilities for states abandoning federal programs. The debate underscores the tension between state control versus federal oversight in health care policy.

Contention

Key points of contention include the implications of a state's ability to unilaterally suspend federal health regulations, which opponents argue could undermine the uniformity that federal laws provide. Additionally, the financial ramifications for states inheriting funding responsibilities for health care programs previously managed by the federal government raise concerns over potential inadequacies in state-level health care resources. As states navigate their health care challenges, the long-term effects of adopting such a compact remain uncertain.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA HB1090

Provides relative to the Interstate Health Care Compact (EG FF RV See Note)

LA SB176

Authorizes DHH to develop and maintain an upper payment limit financing methodology for all health care providers licensed by DHH. (gov sig) (EN FF EX See Note)

LA SB644

Provides for the Interstate Compact on the Placement of Children. (see Act) (RE2 FF EX See Note)

LA SB186

Provides relative to the Occupational Therapy Licensure Compact. (1/1/24) (EN SEE FISC NOTE SG RV See Note)

LA SB13

Provides for the Recognition of Emergency Medical Services Personnel Licensure Interstate Compact (REPLICA). (7/1/21) (Item #44) (EN SEE FISC NOTE SG EX See Note)

LA SB203

Provides relative to the Physical Therapy Licensure Compact. (gov sig) (EG DECREASE SG RV See Note)

LA SB198

Provides relative to the Recognition of Emergency Medical Services Personnel Licensure Interstate Compact ("REPLICA"). (gov sig) (EG SEE FISC NOTE SG EX See Note)

LA SB202

Provides relative to the Nurse Licensure Compact. (gov sig) (EG2 INCREASE SG EX See Note)

LA HB5

Relating to the Interstate Health Care Compact.

LA HB5

Relating to the Interstate Health Care Compact.

Similar Bills

MI HB5791

Elections: petitions; filing requirements for congressional candidates; modify. Amends secs. 93, 94, 98, 133, 134 & 138 of 1954 PA 116 (MCL 168.93 et seq.).

US SJR37

A joint resolution requiring the advice and consent of the Senate or an Act of Congress to suspend, terminate, or withdraw the United States from the North Atlantic Treaty and authorizing related litigation, and for other purposes.

US HJR89

Requiring the advice and consent of the Senate or an Act of Congress to suspend, terminate, or withdraw the United States from the North Atlantic Treaty and authorizing related litigation, and for other purposes.

TX HB1065

Relating to the Interstate Primary and Secondary Public Education Compact.

TX SB25

Relating to the Interstate Health Care Compact.

TX SB5

Relating to the Interstate Health Care Compact.

TX HB5

Relating to the Interstate Health Care Compact.

TX HB5

Relating to the Interstate Health Care Compact.