SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 1 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. Regular Session, 2013 SENATE BILL NO. 165 BY SENATOR MARTINY TAX/TAXATION. Requires a qualified cost report prior to issuance of a motion picture investor tax credit. (8/1/13) AN ACT1 To amend and reenact R.S. 47:6007(B)(9), (10), (11), (12), (13), (14), the introductory2 paragraph of R.S. 47:6007(D)(2)(a) and (D)(2)(c) and (d) and to enact R.S.3 47:6007(B)(15) and (16), (G) and 6007.1, relative to the motion picture investor tax4 credit; to provide for definitions; to provide for production audit reports and5 requirements; to provide for submission of a production audit report prior to being6 certified as a state-certified production for application for the credit; to provide for7 a production audit report; and to provide for related matters.8 Be it enacted by the Legislature of Louisiana:9 Section 1. R.S. 47:6007(B)(9), (10), (11), (12), (13), (14), the introductory paragraph10 of R.S. 47:6007(D)(2)(a) and (D)(2)(c) and (d) are hereby amended and reenacted and R.S.11 47:6007(B)(15) and (16), (G) and 6007.1 are hereby enacted to read as follows:12 §6007. Motion picture investor tax credit13 B. Definitions. For the purposes of this Section:14 * * *15 (9) "Production audit report" means an audit report issued by a16 qualified accountant who is unrelated to the motion picture production17 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 2 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. company and that is a report of the qualified accountant’s audit of the motion1 picture production’s cost report of production expenditures. The production2 audit report shall contain an opinion from the qualified accountant stating that3 the production’s cost report of production expenditures presents fairly, in all4 material aspects, the production expenditures expended in Louisiana pursuant5 to the provisions of this Subsection. The production audit shall be performed6 pursuant to the qualified sampling and verification procedures provided in R.S.7 47:6007.1 and shall require:8 (a) The production audit report to be performed in accordance with the9 auditing standards generally accepted in the United States of America.10 (b) The production audit report to be addressed to the party which has11 engaged the qualified accountant.12 (c) The production audit report to contain the qualified accountant's13 name, address, and telephone number.14 (d) The production audit report to be dated as of the date of completion15 of the qualified accountant's field work.16 (e) The production audit report to contain a statement of17 acknowledgment by the qualified accountant that the state is relying on the18 qualified cost report in the issuance of the tax credits under the provisions of19 this Section.20 (10) "Production expenditures" means preproduction, production, and21 postproduction expenditures in this state directly relating to a state-certified22 production, including without limitation the following: set construction and23 operation; wardrobes, makeup, accessories, and related services; costs associated24 with photography and sound synchronization, lighting, and related services and25 materials; editing and related services; rental of facilities and equipment; leasing of26 vehicles; costs of food and lodging; digital or tape editing, film processing, transfer27 of film to tape or digital format, sound mixing, special and visual effects; and28 payroll. This term shall not include expenditures for marketing and distribution, non-29 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 3 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. production related overhead, amounts reimbursed by the state or any other1 governmental entity, costs related to the transfer of tax credits, amounts that are paid2 to persons or entities as a result of their participation in profits from the exploitation3 of the production, the application fee, or state or local taxes.4 (11) "Qualified accountant" means an independent certified public5 accountant authorized to practice in this state who has sufficient knowledge of6 accounting principles and practices generally recognized in the film and7 television industry.8 (10) (12) "Resident" or "resident of Louisiana" means a natural person9 domiciled in the state. A person who maintains a permanent place of abode within10 the state and spends in the aggregate more than six months of each year within the11 state shall be presumed to be domiciled in the state.12 (11) (13) "Secretary" means the secretary of the Department of Economic13 Development.14 (12) (14) "Source within the state" means a physical facility in Louisiana,15 operating with posted business hours and employing at least one full-time equivalent16 employee.17 (13) (15) "State" means the state of Louisiana.18 (14) (16) "State-certified production" shall mean a production approved by19 the office and the secretary which is produced by a motion picture production20 company domiciled and headquartered in Louisiana and which has a viable multi-21 market commercial distribution plan.22 * * *23 D. Certification and administration.24 * * *25 (2)(a) Application. An applicant for the motion picture investor credit shall26 submit an application for initial certification to the office and the secretary of the27 Department of Economic Development that includes the following information:28 * * *29 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 4 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. (c) The office and the secretary shall submit their initial certification of a1 project as a state-certified production to investors and to the secretary of the2 Department of Revenue indicating the total base investment which shall be expended3 in the state on the state-certified production within thirty days of their receipt of4 all required information. The initial certification shall include a unique identifying5 number for each state-certified production.6 (d)(i) Prior to any final certification of the state-certified production, the7 motion picture production company shall submit to the office and the secretary an8 audit of the production expenditures certified by an independent certified public9 accountant as determined by rule a production audit report. The office and the10 secretary shall review the audit, the production expense details, the production11 audit report and may require additional information needed to make a12 determination. Upon approval of the audit Within sixty days of the receipt of the13 production audit report, the office and the secretary shall issue a final tax credit14 certification letter indicating the amount of tax credits certified for the state-certified15 production to the investors for all amounts that are uncontested. If there remains16 a contested amount, the office and secretary shall diligently work to resolve the17 outstanding issues in a timely manner and the office and secretary may18 subsequently issue a supplemental tax credit certification at the time of such19 resolution, if so warranted.20 (ii) The department may request an additional production audit report21 of the expenditures submitted by the motion picture production company with22 the cost of the additional report paid by the motion picture production23 company. The motion picture production company may submit an amended24 production audit report if additional expenditures are incurred or discovered25 after the approval of the initial production audit reports issued pursuant to26 Item (i) of this Subparagraph and the office and secretary may issue a27 supplemental tax credit certification if so warranted. The rules required by this28 Subparagraph shall, at a minimum, require that:29 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 5 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. (i) The auditor shall be a certified public accountant licensed in the state of1 Louisiana and shall be an independent third party, not related to the producer.2 (ii) The auditor's opinion shall be addressed to the party which has engaged3 the auditor (e.g., directors of the production company, producer of the production).4 (iii) The auditor's name, address, and telephone number shall be evident on5 the report.6 (iv) The auditor's opinion shall be dated as of the completion of the audit7 fieldwork.8 (v) The audit shall be performed in accordance with auditing standards9 generally accepted in the United States of America and the auditor shall have10 sufficient knowledge of accounting principles and practices generally recognized in11 the film and television industry.12 * * *13 G. Notwithstanding any other law to the contrary, no motion picture14 investor tax credit shall be allowed for financing fees, interest, or payments of15 a similar nature that are paid to related parties. Motion picture investor tax16 credits shall only be allowed for financing fees, interest or payments of a similar17 nature that are made to a party who does not control the production and who18 owns twenty percent or less of the financial rewards of the production based on19 sales, exploitation of the product, or the success in lining up distribution20 agreements. No motion picture investor tax credits shall be allowed for any21 amounts that are paid to persons or entities as a result of a percentage of sales22 or participation in profits from the exploitation of the product or the success in23 lining up distribution agreements.24 §6007.1. Motion picture investor tax credit; qualified sampling and verification25 procedures26 A. A qualified accountant, as defined in R.S. 47:6007, shall perform the27 following sampling procedures when producing a production audit report28 required under the provisions of R.S. 47:6007:29 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 6 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. (1) Obtain the cost report of all production expenditures for the1 production of the motion picture production company and verify the2 mathematical accuracy of the report.3 (2) Obtain the bank statements from the motion picture production4 company relevant to the applicable production for the period covered by the5 cost report of production expenditures.6 (3) Obtain the detailed payroll registers applicable to the production.7 This report should indicate the name, address, taxpayer identification number,8 permanent address, the amount of compensation, and the employee's state of9 residence.10 (4) Foot the payroll registers mentioned in Paragraph (3) of this11 Subsection for mathematical accuracy and agree the total to the cost report of12 production expenditures mentioned in Paragraph (1) of this Subsection.13 (5) Obtain the detailed listing of non-payroll expenditures for production14 of the motion picture production company. This report should indicate the15 payee, the date of payment, the date that the payment cleared the bank, and16 amount of the payment.17 (6) Foot the detailed listing of non-payroll expenditures mentioned in18 Paragraph (5) of this Subsection for mathematical accuracy and agree the total19 to the cost report of production expenditures mentioned in Paragraph (1) of this20 Subsection.21 B. A qualified accountant shall perform the following verification22 procedures when producing a production audit report under the provisions of23 R.S. 47:6007:24 (1) From the detailed payroll registers referenced in Paragraph (A)(3)25 of this Section, segregate the gross payroll for all Louisiana residents and agree26 the total to the Louisiana payroll and salaries indicated on either the cost report27 of production expenditures or the footnotes to the cost report of production28 expenditures.29 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 7 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. (2) From the payroll registers for Louisiana residents contained in1 Paragraph (1) of this Subsection, select all disbursements to those individuals2 whose gross salaries during the period in question exceeded five percent of the3 total disbursements indicated on the cost report of production expenditures for4 the production for further testing.5 (3) Excluding those individuals already selected for further testing in6 Paragraph (2) of this Subsection, select an additional sample consisting of the7 lesser of one-hundred twenty individual payroll disbursements or fifty percent8 of the payroll disbursements not already selected in Paragraph (2) of this9 Subsection from the payroll registers for Louisiana residents for further testing.10 (4) For each employee selected for testing in Paragraphs (2) and (3) of11 this Subsection, perform the following analysis, detailing any exceptions noted:12 (a) If the employee is a salaried employee, verify that the gross salary for13 the selected disbursement is supported by and agrees to an employment14 contract or other form of approved pay documentation.15 (b) If the employee is an hourly employee, verify that the hourly wage16 rate for the selected transaction is supported by and agrees to the approved pay17 rate documentation in the employee's personnel file.18 (c) If the employee is an hourly employee, verify that the hours paid for19 the selected transaction is supported by approved timesheets.20 (d) Verify that the disbursement of such funds is a qualifying21 expenditure given the operations of the motion picture production company.22 (e) Verify that the payroll expenditures were actually made by the23 motion picture production company as evidenced by deductions in the bank24 account statements maintained by the motion picture production company and25 that the disbursement cleared the bank during the period in question.26 (f) Review employee's personnel file, verifying that the individual is a27 natural person domiciled in or who maintains a permanent place of abode28 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 8 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. within this state and spends in the aggregate more than six months of each year1 within this state.2 (5) From the detailed payroll registers referenced in Paragraph (A)(3)3 of this Section, segregate the gross payroll for all non-Louisiana residents and4 agree the total to the non-Louisiana payroll indicated on either the cost report5 of production expenditures or the footnotes to the cost report of production6 expenditures.7 (6) From the payroll registers for non-Louisiana residents, select all8 disbursements to those individuals whose gross salaries during the period in9 question exceeded five percent of the total disbursements indicated on the cost10 report of production expenditures for the period in question for further testing.11 (7) Excluding those individuals already selected for further testing in12 Paragraph (6) of this Subsection, select an additional sample consisting of the13 lesser of one-hundred twenty individual payroll disbursements or fifty percent14 of the payroll disbursements not already selected in Paragraph (6) of this15 Subsection from the payroll registers for non-Louisiana residents, for further16 testing.17 (8) For each employee selected for testing in Paragraphs (6) and (7) of18 this Subsection, perform the following procedures, detailing any exceptions19 noted:20 (a) If the employee is a salaried employee, verify that the gross salary for21 the selected disbursement is supported by and agrees to an employment22 contract or other form of approved pay documentation.23 (b) If the employee is an hourly employee, verify that the hourly wage24 rate for the selected transaction is supported by and agrees to the approved pay25 rate documentation in the employee's personnel file.26 (c) If the employee is an hourly employee, verify that hours paid for the27 selected transaction is supported by approved timesheets.28 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 9 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. (d) Verify that the disbursement of such funds is a qualifying1 expenditure given the operations of the motion picture production company.2 (e) Verify that the payroll expenditures were actually made by the3 motion picture production company as evidenced by deductions in the bank4 account statements maintained by the motion picture production company and5 that the disbursement cleared the bank during the period in question.6 (9) From the detailed listing of non-payroll expenditures referenced in7 Paragraph (A)(5) of this Section, select all disbursements for a particular8 contract of purchase that exceeded five percent of the total disbursements9 indicated on the cost report of production expenditures for the period in10 question for further testing.11 (10) Excluding those expenditures already selected for further testing in12 Paragraph (9) of this Subsection, select an additional sample consisting of the13 lesser of one-hundred twenty individual disbursements or fifty percent of the14 non-payroll disbursements not already selected in Paragraph (9) of this15 Subsection from the detailed listing of non-payroll expenditures for further16 testing.17 (11) For each disbursement selected for testing in Paragraphs (9) and18 (10) of this Subsection, perform the following procedures, detailing any19 exceptions noted:20 (a) Verify that the transaction is supported by an original invoice or21 receipt and that the amounts are in agreement.22 (b) Verify that the expense category to which the disbursement was23 coded appears reasonable based on the invoice documentation.24 (c) Verify that the disbursement of such funds is a qualifying expenditure25 given the operations of the motion picture production company.26 (d) Verify that the expenditures were actually made by the motion27 picture production company as evidenced by deductions in the bank account28 SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 10 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. statements maintained by the motion picture production company and that the1 disbursement cleared the bank during the period in question.2 C. Before submission of the production audit report, the qualified3 accountant shall ensure that these steps have been taken:4 (1) Redact all but the last four digits of any employee's social security5 number.6 (2) Separate expenditures by calendar year, as well as the aggregate7 project totals.8 (3) Submit detailed list of all expenditures as a spreadsheet.9 The original instrument was prepared by Thomas L. Tyler. The following digest, which does not constitute a part of the legislative instrument, was prepared by Danielle Doiron. DIGEST Martiny (SB 165) Present law provides for motion picture investor tax credits for certain state-certified productions by a motion picture production company. Proposed law defines a " production audit report" as an audit report issued by a qualified accountant who is unrelated to the motion picture production company and that is a report of the qualified accountant’s audit of the motion picture production’s cost report of production expenditures. The production audit report shall contain an opinion from the qualified accountant stating that the production’s cost report of production expenditures presents fairly, the production expenditures expended in Louisiana. The production audit shall require: (1)The production audit report be performed in accordance with the auditing standards generally accepted in the United States of America. (2)The production audit report is addressed to the party which has engaged the qualified accountant. (3)The production audit report contains the qualified accountant's name, address, and telephone number. (4)The production audit report be dated as of the date of completion of the qualified accountant's field work. (5)The production audit report contains a statement of acknowledgment by the qualified accountant that the state is relying on the qualified cost report in the issuance of the tax credits under the provisions of this Section. Present law requires the office of entertainment industry development and the secretary of the Department of Economic Development (DED) submit their initial certification of a project as a state-certified production to investors and to the secretary of the Department of Revenue indicating the total base investment which is to be expended in the state on the SB NO. 165 SLS 13RS-446 ENGROSSED Page 11 of 11 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. state-certified production. Proposed law retains these provisions but requires that the initial certification be submitted within 30 days of receipt of all required information. Present law requires that prior to any final certification of the state-certified production, the motion picture production company submit to the office of entertainment industry development and the secretary of DED an audit of the production expenditures certified by an independent certified public accountant. Requires that the office and the secretary review the audit, the production expense details, and may require additional information needed to make a determination. Proposed law requires a production audit report by a qualified accountant. Present law requires that upon approval of the audit, that a final tax credit certification letter be sent to the investors indicating the amount of tax credits certified for the state-certified production. Proposed law requires that this letter be issued within 60 days after receipt of the qualified cost report and that it indicate the credits certified which are uncontested and if there is a contested amount, then the office and the secretary of DED are required to diligently work to resolve the outstanding issues in a timely manner. Proposed law provides that no motion picture investor tax credit be allowed for fees, interest, or payments of a similar nature paid to related parties and that it only be allowed if received by investors in the production who own 20% or less of the financial rewards based on sales, exploitation of the product, or the success in lining up distribution agreements. Further provides that no motion picture investor tax credit shall be allowed for any percentage of the financial awards but shall only be allowed for actually paid financing fees and interest. Proposed law requires that when producing the production audit report, the qualified accountant perform certain sampling and verification procedures enumerated in proposed law. Effective August 1, 2013. (Amends R.S. 47:6007(B)(9)(10), (11), (12), (13), (14), (D)(2)(a)(intro para) and (D)(2)(c) and (d); adds R.S. 47:6007(B)(15) and (16), (G) and 6007.1) Summary of Amendments Adopted by Senate Committee Amendments Proposed by Senate Committee on Revenue and Fiscal Affairs to the original bill 1. Changed "qualified cost report" to "production audit report" and provided for definition. 2. Removed requirements of qualified cost report and added requirements of production audit reports. 3. Changed qualifications for a "qualified accountant", requiring the accountant to be authorized to practice instead of licensed. 4. Changed the number of individual payroll disbursements needed for an additional sample from the lesser of 60 to the lesser of 120 disbursements, or 50 percent of the payroll disbursements, not already selected for further testing.