Louisiana Senate Bill SB509

Louisiana 2020 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/31/20
• Refer: 5/4/20

Caption

Provides relative to performance audits of charter schools in certain school systems. (gov sig)

Impact

The proposed legislation imposes a moratorium on the issuance of new charter schools within affected school systems until the identified performance audits are completed. This is designed to ensure that existing educational practices are scrutinized before further expansions occur. The law does allow for the renewal of existing charters that maintain a performance letter grade of 'D' or higher, thereby ensuring that better-performing schools are not penalized by the moratorium.

Summary

Senate Bill 509 seeks to implement performance audits of charter schools operating in certain academic crisis school systems, specifically those that have had schools transferred to the Recovery School District. The bill mandates the legislative auditor to conduct thorough audits on charter schools established between January 1, 2005, and January 1, 2020. This initiative aims to evaluate the innovative teaching methods in these schools and to identify which methods have been successfully replicated across other educational institutions. A report of the findings is required to be submitted to the Senate and House committees on education by September 30, 2021.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SB 509 appears to embrace a cautious approach to expanding charter schools. Supporters argue that the bill is vital for ensuring accountability in charter education, particularly in districts that are struggling academically. However, there are concerns from some educational advocates who fear that the moratorium may stifle educational innovation and limit choices for students in underserved areas. The debate centers on balancing accountability and educational access in times of need.

Contention

A notable point of contention revolves around the implications of the moratorium on new charter schools. Proponents emphasize the importance of auditing existing charters to improve standards and ensure effective teaching methods are used, while critics argue that this may lead to fewer educational options for families in struggling districts. There is significant discussion about the role of charter schools in the broader educational ecosystem and the potential consequences of delaying new charters at a time when many school systems are in desperate need of reform and choice.