SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED 2024 Third Extraordinary Session SENATE BILL NO. 7 BY SENATOR LUNEAU LEGISLATORS. Provides for legislative continuances and extensions of time for legislators and legislative employees. (Item #20) (gov sig) 1 AN ACT 2 To amend and reenact R.S. 13:4163, relative to legislative continuance or extension for 3 legislators and legislative employees; to provide for motions involving legislative 4 continuance or extension; to provide a presumption that a motion is proper; to 5 provide for oppositions to a motion for continuance or extension; to provide for 6 proof of opposition to a motion by clear and convincing proof; to provide for denial 7 of a motion for continuance or extension; and to provide for related matters. 8 Be it enacted by the Legislature of Louisiana: 9 Section 1. R.S. 13:4163 is hereby amended and reenacted to read as follows: 10 ยง4163. Ex parte motion for legislative continuance or extension of time, legislators 11 or employees engaged in legislative or constitutional convention 12 activities 13 A.(1) A member of the legislature and a legislative employee shall have 14 peremptory grounds for may seek a continuance or extension of a criminal case, 15 civil case, or administrative proceeding as provided below. The continuance or 16 extension shall be sought by written motion specifically alleging these grounds. 17 There shall be a presumption that a motion for continuance sought pursuant to Page 1 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED 1 this Section is proper and shall be granted unless there is proof sufficient to 2 overcome the presumption. 3 (2) For purposes of this Section, "legislative employee" means the clerk of 4 the House of Representative Representatives, the secretary of the Senate, and an 5 employee of the House of Representatives, the Senate, or the Legislative Bureau, 6 when such person is employed full-time during the legislative session or during any 7 other time in which the continuance or extension is being sought. 8 B. The peremptory grounds for A motion for continuance or extension 9 pursuant to this Section is available to and for the benefit of a member or 10 legislative employee and may only be asserted or waived by a member or employee. 11 C.(1) Such peremptory grounds are available A motion for the continuance 12 of any type of proceeding and the extension of any type of deadline pertaining to a 13 criminal case, civil case, or administrative proceeding, if the presence, participation, 14 or involvement of a member or employee is required in any capacity, including any 15 pretrial or post-trial legal proceeding, during may be sought by a member or 16 employee pursuant to this Section during any of the following: 17 (a) Any time between thirty days prior to the original call to order and thirty 18 days following the adjournment sine die of any session of the legislature. 19 (b) Any time between thirty days prior to convening and thirty days following 20 adjournment sine die of any constitutional convention. 21 (c) Any time other than those provided in Subparagraph (a) or (b) of this 22 Paragraph when such person is engaged in activities, including travel, in connection 23 with or ordered by: (i) the legislature; (ii) any legislative committee or subcommittee 24 appointed by the president of the Senate or the speaker of the House of 25 Representatives; (iii) any committee or commission appointed by the governor or 26 other person authorized to make such appointments; or (iv) any constitutional 27 convention or commission. 28 (2) Such peremptory These grounds are available to any member or 29 employee enrolled as counsel of record when his participation is required. The Page 2 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED 1 availability of other counsel to assume the duties or responsibilities of counsel 2 invoking the continuance or extension does not negate the peremptory nature of his 3 motion overcome the presumption that the motion is proper. 4 D.(1) A motion for legislative continuance or extension filed by a legislative 5 employee shall be accompanied by an affidavit, verifying such employment or 6 service, executed by the presiding officer or the clerk or secretary of the respective 7 house. 8 (2) A motion for legislative continuance or extension shall be filed at no cost 9 to a member, employee, or a client of a member or employee. 10 E.(1)(a) If the grounds for a legislative continuance or extension are founded 11 upon the convening of a regular legislative session or a constitutional convention, the 12 motion for legislative continuance or extension shall be timely if filed no later than 13 five calendar days prior to the hearing or proceeding to be continued. 14 (b) If the grounds for a legislative continuance or extension are founded upon 15 any provision of Subparagraph (C)(1)(c) of this Section or upon the issuance of a call 16 for an extraordinary session of the legislature, the motion for legislative continuance 17 or extension shall be timely if filed no later than five calendar days prior to the 18 hearing or proceeding to be continued or no later than two days following the 19 issuance of the notice of the meeting or of the call for the extraordinary legislative 20 session, which ever occurs last. 21 (c) The provisions of this Paragraph shall not be applied so as to impede the 22 peremptory nature of rebut the presumption provided for in this Section. 23 (2) Within seventy-two hours of the filing of a motion for a legislative 24 continuance or extension, the court or agency shall grant the continuance or 25 extension ex parte as follows unless another party has filed a motion to oppose 26 a continuance sought on the grounds provided for in this Section. A legislative 27 continuance or extension shall be granted unless there is clear and convincing 28 proof of either of the following: 29 (a) The motion is being presented for an improper purpose, such as to Page 3 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED 1 harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needleesly increase the cost of litigation. 2 (b) The objecting party has a substantial existing right or interest that 3 will be defeated or abridged and will suffer substantial and immediate 4 irreparable harm if the requested continuance is granted. 5 F. The court may grant the motion ex parte or grant a hearing on a 6 motion to oppose the continuance. If a hearing is granted, it shall be conducted 7 by telephone, or other electronic means within forty-eight hours of the filing of 8 the motion to oppose. 9 G.(1)(a) If the grounds for the motion are pursuant to Subparagraph (C)(1)(a) 10 or (b) of this Section, and the continuance or extension is granted, it shall be 11 granted for a period of not less than sixty thirty days from the date of adjournment 12 sine die of the session of the legislature or of the constitutional convention. 13 (b)(2) If the grounds for the motion are pursuant to Subparagraph (C)(1)(c) 14 of this Section, the continuance or extension shall be granted for the day or days the 15 member or employee is engaged in such activities. 16 F.H.(1) The provisions of this Section shall not apply to cases in the Supreme 17 Court of Louisiana, criminal cases where the death penalty is sought, and 18 administrative rulemaking authorized by R.S. 49:961. 19 (2) The provisions of this Section shall not apply to cases and proceedings 20 wherein a member or employee is called as a witness, in which instances the 21 provisions of R.S. 13:3667.1 and 3667.3 shall apply. 22 G. Any action taken against a person, including any sanction imposed on an 23 attorney, who has filed a motion for legislative continuance or extension and which 24 results from the failure of such person or attorney to appear or comply with an order 25 of the court or agency or any deadline shall be considered an absolute nullity and 26 shall be set aside by the court or agency upon the filing of a motion by the aggrieved 27 person or attorney. 28 H.(1) Any person or attorney who has filed a motion for legislative 29 continuance or extension which has been denied or which has not been granted Page 4 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED 1 within seventy-two hours of filing may apply directly to the Supreme Court of 2 Louisiana for supervisory writs to review the action or inaction of the court or 3 agency where the motion was filed. 4 (2) If a motion filed pursuant to Subsection G of this Section is denied, such 5 denial shall be an appealable order. 6 I.(1) For sufficient cause shown, the court shall consider a motion for 7 legislative continuance or extension at any time prior to the hearing or proceeding. 8 (2) The motion for a legislative continuance or extension may be filed by 9 electronic means such as facsimile transmission or electronic mail, or any other 10 means authorized by law, provided that the mover shall provide all opposing counsel 11 or parties with a copy of the motion, simultaneously with the transmission of the 12 motion to the court. 13 (3) If seeking a continuance or extension of a court proceeding or 14 deadline occurring outside the time frame of a legislative session or 15 constitutional convention, a member of the legislature or legislative employee 16 that is a party or an attorney for a party to an action may obtain a legislative 17 continuance upon a showing of good cause. A showing, accompanied by an 18 affidavit executed in accordance with Paragraph (D)(1) of this Section, that the 19 member or employee is required to attend an interim committee hearing or 20 other official legislative function and that the presence of the member or 21 employee in court is necessary and essential to a fair and proper trial or other 22 proceeding in the suit may be considered good cause. 23 (4)(a) A court denying a properly filed motion for a legislative 24 continuance or extension shall assign specific reasons for the denial. Any person 25 or attorney who has filed a motion for legislative continuance or extension that 26 has been denied may apply directly to the supreme court for supervisory writs 27 to review the action or inaction of the court where the motion is filed. 28 (b) If the supreme court affirms the lower court's denial of a motion for 29 a legislative continuance or extension based on Paragraph (E)(2) of this Section, Page 5 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED 1 the supreme court may exercise its jurisdiction of disciplinary proceedings 2 against the member of the legislature or legislative employee whose motion was 3 denied or refer the matter to the office of disciplinary counsel. 4 J. The provisions of this Section shall not apply to proceedings wherein 5 a temporary restraining order, protective order, preliminary injunction, 6 permanent injunction, court-approved consent agreement resulting from an 7 action brought, or order issued pursuant to any of the following: 8 (1) R.S. 46:2131 et seq., R.S. 46:2151 et seq., R.S. 46:2171 et seq., R.S. 9 46:2181 et seq., R.S. 9:361 et seq., R.S. 9:372, Children's Code Article 1564 et 10 seq., Code of Civil Procedure Articles 3604 and 3607.1, or peace bonds pursuant 11 to Code of Criminal Procedure Article 30(B). 12 (2) Code of Criminal Procedure, including Article 871.1, regarding the 13 disposition and sentence of a criminal matter. 14 (3) R.S. 46:1846 to prohibit communications between offenders and 15 victims following a charge or after sentencing for any crime of violence. 16 (4) R.S. 15:574.4.2(A)(5) as condition of a parole release that requires 17 that the parolee stay away from any specific person. 18 K. The provisions of this Section shall not apply to child custody 19 proceedings or proceedings pursuant to the Domestic Violence Prevention 20 Firearm Transfer Act, Code of Criminal Procedure Article 1001 et seq. 21 L. The provisions of this Section shall not apply to proceedings for writs 22 of habeas corpus for the determination and enforcement of rights to the custody 23 of a minor or for the release of a person in custody in which the family court has 24 original jurisdiction. 25 Section 2. This Act shall become effective upon signature by the governor or, if not 26 signed by the governor, upon expiration of the time for bills to become law without signature 27 by the governor, as provided by Article III, Section 18 of the Constitution of Louisiana. If 28 vetoed by the governor and subsequently approved by the legislature, this Act shall become 29 effective on the day following such approval. Page 6 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED The original instrument was prepared by Angela Lockett-De Jean. The following digest, which does not constitute a part of the legislative instrument, was prepared by Thomas L. Tyler. DIGEST SB 7 Reengrossed 2024 Third Extraordinary Session Luneau Present law provides that legislators and legislative employees have a peremptory ground to file a written motion for continuance or extension of a criminal case, civil case, or administrative proceeding if the legislator or employee's presence, participation, or involvement is required in any capacity, including any pretrial or post-trial legal proceeding, during: (1)Any time 30 days prior to call to order of a legislative session or 30 days following its adjournment sine die; or (2)Any time between 30 days prior to convening and 30 days following adjournment sine die of any constitutional convention. Proposed law retains present law but provides for a presumption that a motion for continuance is proper and is to be granted unless there is proof sufficient to overcome the presumption. Present law provides that the continuance or extension may only be asserted or waived by the legislator or legislative employee enrolled as counsel of record when his participation is required. Provides that the availability of other counsel to assume the duties or responsibilities of counsel invoking the continuance or extension does not negate the peremptory nature of his motion. Proposed law retains present law but provides that the availability of other counsel does not overcome the presumption that the motion is proper. Present law provides that a continuance or extension is also available when the legislator or legislative employee is engaged in activities, including travel, in connection with or ordered by: (1)The legislature; (2)Any legislative committee or subcommittee appointed by the president of the Senate or the speaker of the House of Representatives; (3)Any committee or commission appointed by the governor or other person authorized to make such appointments; or (4)Any constitutional convention or commission. Present law requires that the filing of a motion for continuance or extension be accompanied by an affidavit executed by the presiding officer, clerk, or secretary of the respective house verifying employment or service. Present law requires if the grounds for continuance or extension are founded on the convening of a regular session or constitutional convention, the motion is to be filed no later than five calendar days prior to the hearing or proceeding to be continued. Provides that if the grounds for the motion are founded on a legislative activity, including travel, or upon issuance of an extraordinary legislative session the continuance or extension is to be filed no later than five calendar days prior to the hearing or proceeding to be continued but no later than two days following issuance of the notice of the meeting or call of the Page 7 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED extraordinary session. Present law requires a court or agency to grant the motion for continuance or extension ex parte within 72 hours of the filing of the motion and if granted, the continuance or extension shall be for not less than 60 days from the date of adjournment sine die or the constitutional convention. Proposed law requires a court or agency to grant the motion for continuance or extension ex parte within 72 hours of the filing of the motion and if granted, the continuance or extension shall be for not less than 30 days from the date of adjournment sine die or the constitutional convention. Proposed law provides for granting the continuance or extension within 72 hours of filing of the motion unless another party has filed a motion to oppose the continuance or extension. Provides for granting the motion unless there is clear and convincing proof of one of the following: (1)The motion is being presented for an improper purpose, such as to harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needleesly increase the cost of litigation. (2)The objecting party has a substantial existing right or interest that will be defeated or abridged and will suffer substantial and immediate irreparable harm if the requested continuance is granted. Proposed law authorizes the court to grant the motion ex parte or grant a hearing on a motion to oppose the continuance. Provides that if a hearing is granted, the hearing shall be conducted by telephone, or other electronic means within 48 hours of the filing of the opposition. Present law provides that if an action taken against a person, including any sanction imposed on an attorney, who has filed a motion for continuance or extension and which results from the failure of such person or attorney to appear or comply with an order of the court or agency or any deadline shall be considered an absolute nullity and shall be set aside by the court or agency upon the filing of a motion by the aggrieved person or attorney. Provides that if the motion is denied, then the denial is an appealable order. Proposed law deletes this provision. Present law provides that if any person or attorney who has filed a motion for continuance or extension which has been denied or which has not been granted within 72 hours of filing may apply directly to the supreme court for supervisory writs to review the action or inaction of the court or agency where the motion was filed. Proposed law deletes this provision. Present law provides that for sufficient cause, the court shall consider a motion of continuance or extension at any time prior to the hearing or proceeding. Present law provides that a motion for continuance may be filed by electronic means such as facsimile transmission or electronic mail, or any other means authorized by law, provided that the mover provides all opposing counsel or parties with a copy of the motion, simultaneously with the transmission of the motion to the court. Proposed law retains these present law provisions. Proposed law authorizes a legislator or legislative employee to obtain a continuance or extension upon a showing of good cause when seeking a continuance of a court proceeding or deadline outside the time frame of a legislative session or constitutional convention. Requires that the showing, be accompanied by an affidavit, that the member or employee is Page 8 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED required to attend an interim committee hearing or other official legislative function and that the presence of the member or employee in court is necessary and essential to a fair and proper trial or other proceeding in the suit may be considered good cause. Proposed law requires the court to assign specific reasons for denial of a properly filed motion for legislative continuance or extension. Provides for direct appeal to the supreme court for supervisory writs to review the action or inaction of the court. Proposed law if the supreme court affirms the lower court's denial of a motion for continuance or extension based on a determination that the motion was (1) being presented for an improper purpose, such as to harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needleesly increase the cost of litigation; or (2) that the objecting party has a substantial existing right or interest that will be defeated or abridged and will suffer substantial and immediate irreparable harm if the requested continuance is granted then the supreme court may exercise its jurisdiction of disciplinary proceedings against the member of the legislature or legislative employee whose motion was denied or refer the matter to the office of disciplinary counsel. Proposed law does not apply to wherein a temporary restraining order, protective order, preliminary injunction, permanent injunction, court-approved consent agreement resulting from an action brought, or order issued pursuant to any of the following items: (1)R.S. 46:2131 et seq., R.S. 46:2151 et seq., R.S. 46:2171 et seq., R.S. 46:2181 et seq., R.S. 9:361 et seq., R.S. 9:372, Children's Code Article 1564 et seq., Code of Civil Procedure Articles 3604 and 3607.1, or peace bonds pursuant to Code of Criminal Procedure Article 30(B). (2)Code of Criminal Procedure, including Article 871.1, regarding the disposition and sentence of a criminal matter. (3)R.S. 46:1846 to prohibit communications between offenders and victims following a charge or after sentencing for any crime of violence. (4)R.S. 15:574.4.2(A)(5) as condition of a parole release that requires that the parolee stay away from any specific person. Proposed law also does not apply to child custody proceedings or proceedings pursuant to the Domestic Violence Prevention Firearm Transfer Act, Code of Criminal Procedure Article 1001 et seq. nor to proceedings for writs of habeas corpus for the determination and enforcement of rights to the custody of a minor or for the release of a person in custody in which the family court has original jurisdiction. Effective upon signature of the governor or lapse of time for gubernatorial action. (Amends R.S. 13:4163) Summary of Amendments Adopted by Senate Committee Amendments Proposed by Senate Committee on Judiciary A to the original bill 1. Reduces the number of days the legislative continuance or extension must be granted from the date of adjournment of the legislative session or constitutional convention from 60 to 30 days. 2. Makes technical changes. Page 9 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 7 SLS 243ES-18 REENGROSSED Senate Floor Amendments to engrossed bill 1. Adds items to which a continuance or extension does not apply. Page 10 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions.