SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 2024 Regular Session SENATE BILL NO. 75 BY SENATOR MORRIS (On Recommendation of the Louisiana State Law Institute) COURTS. Provides for electronic filing and record retention. (8/1/24) 1 AN ACT 2 To amend and reenact Code of Civil Procedure Articles 253 and 2853, Code of Criminal 3 Procedure Article 14.1, and R.S. 44:116(D) and the introductory paragraph of R.S. 4 44:116(E)(1) and R.S. 44:116(E)(2), to enact Section 4 of Chapter 3 of Title I of 5 Book VI of the Code of Civil Procedure, to be comprised of Code of Civil Procedure 6 Article 2911, Code of Criminal Procedure Article 14.2, R.S. 9:2761 and 2762, and 7 R.S. 44:117, and to redesignate Code of Civil Procedure Article 258 and R.S. 44:117, 8 relative to electronic filing and record retention; to provide for the filing of 9 pleadings, documents, and exhibits in civil proceedings; to provide for the filing, 10 retention, and recordation of testaments; to provide for electronic and facsimile 11 filings in criminal proceedings; to provide for the effectiveness of electronic records; 12 to provide for the reproduction, maintenance, and destruction or return of original 13 records; to provide for the preservation of filings in the conveyance records; to 14 provide for redesignations; and to provide for related matters. 15 Be it enacted by the Legislature of Louisiana: 16 Section 1. Code of Civil Procedure Articles 253 and 2853 are hereby amended and 17 reenacted and Section 4 of Chapter 3 of Title I of Book VI of the Code of Civil Procedure, Page 1 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 1 to be comprised of Code of Civil Procedure Article 2911, is hereby enacted to read as 2 follows: 3 Art. 253. Pleadings, documents, and exhibits to be filed with clerk 4 A. All pleadings or documents to be filed in an action or proceeding instituted 5 or pending in a court, and all exhibits introduced in evidence, shall be delivered or 6 transmitted to the clerk of the court for such that purpose. The clerk of court shall 7 endorse thereon the fact and date of filing, and shall retain possession thereof for 8 inclusion in the record, or in the files of his the clerk's office, as required by law. 9 The endorsement of the fact and date of filing shall be made upon receipt of the 10 pleadings or documents by the clerk of court and shall be made without regard to 11 whether there are orders in connection therewith to be signed by the court. 12 B. The filings as provided in Paragraph A of this Article and all other 13 provisions of this Chapter may be transmitted electronically in accordance with a 14 system established by a the clerk of court or by Louisiana Clerks' Remote Access 15 Authority. When such a system is established, the The clerk of court shall adopt and 16 implement procedures a system for the electronic filing and storage of any pleading, 17 document, or exhibit, and the official record shall be the electronic record filed with 18 a pleading. A pleading or document filed electronically is deemed filed on the date 19 and time stated on the confirmation of electronic filing sent from the system, if the 20 clerk of court accepts the electronic filing. Public access to electronically filed 21 pleadings and documents shall be in accordance with the rules governing access to 22 paper filings. The clerk of court may convert into an electronic record any pleading, 23 document, or exhibit as set forth in R.S. 44:116. The originals of conveyances shall 24 be preserved by the clerk of court. 25 C. The clerk of court may convert into an electronic record any pleading, 26 document, or exhibit that is filed in paper form. If requested by the filing party, 27 the clerk of court shall return to the filing party the original of any document 28 or exhibit that has been converted into an electronic record. 29 D. The official record shall be the electronic record. The original of any Page 2 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 1 filed document or exhibit shall be maintained by the filing party during the 2 pendency of the proceeding and until the judgment becomes final and definitive, 3 unless otherwise provided by law or order of the court. Upon request and 4 reasonable notice, the original document shall be produced to the court. Upon 5 reasonable notice, the original document shall be made available to the opposing 6 party for inspection. 7 E. Unless otherwise directed by the court, the original of all documents 8 and exhibits introduced or proffered into evidence, submitted with a petition for 9 executory process, or filed in a summary judgment proceeding shall be retained 10 by the clerk of court until the order or judgment becomes final and definitive. 11 C. F. A judge or justice presiding over a court in this state may sign a court 12 order, notice, official court document, and other writings required to be executed in 13 connection with court proceedings by use of an electronic signature as defined by 14 R.S. 9:2602. 15 D. Any pleading or document in a traffic or criminal action may be filed with 16 the court by facsimile transmission in compliance with the provision of the Code of 17 Criminal Procedure Article 14.1. 18 E. The clerk shall not refuse to accept for filing any pleading or other 19 document signed by electronic signature, as defined by R.S. 9:2602, and executed 20 in connection with court proceedings, or which complies with the procedures for 21 electronic filing implemented pursuant to this Article, if any applicable fees for filing 22 and transmission are paid, solely on the ground that it was signed by electronic 23 signature. 24 F. G. If the filing party fails to comply with any requirement of the 25 requirements of Paragraph A or B of this Article, the electronic filing shall have 26 no force or effect. The district courts A court may provide by court rule for other 27 matters related to filings by electronic transmission. 28 G. H. The clerk of court may procure equipment, services, and supplies 29 necessary to accommodate electronic filings out of the clerk's salary fund. Page 3 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 1 H. I. All electronic filings shall include an electronic signature. For the 2 purpose of this Article, "electronic signature" means an electronic symbol or process 3 attached to or logically associated with a record and executed or adopted by a person 4 with the intent to sign the record. 5 J. Provided that any applicable fees for filing and transmission are paid, 6 the clerk of court shall not refuse to accept for filing any pleading or other 7 document that is signed by electronic signature and executed in connection with 8 court proceedings, or that complies with the procedures for electronic filing 9 implemented pursuant to this Article, solely on the ground that the pleading or 10 document was signed by electronic signature. 11 Comments - 2024 12 13 (a) The amendment to Paragraph B of this Article does not change the 14 rule that the clerk of court has the authority to convert any pleading, 15 document, or exhibit into an electronic record. Nevertheless, unless the court 16 directs otherwise, any original document that has legal efficacy, such as a 17 will, codicil, trust, promissory note, authentic act, affidavit, or exhibit that 18 may necessitate a physical examination by the trier of fact to determine an 19 issue, must be retained by the parties until a final and definitive judgment is 20 rendered. The judgment of a trial court becomes final and definitive when no 21 post-trial motions or appeals are taken from the judgment. The judgment of 22 a court of appeal becomes final and definitive if neither an application to the 23 court of appeal for rehearing nor an application to the supreme court for a 24 writ of certiorari is timely filed. See Article 2166(A). If a writ of certiorari 25 is granted by the supreme court, the judgment of the supreme court becomes 26 final and definitive when the delay for application for rehearing has expired 27 or the application is denied. See Article 2167(B) and (C). 28 29 (b) The amendment to Paragraph C of this Article clarifies that the 30 clerk of court may convert into an electronic record any pleading, document, 31 or exhibit that is filed in paper form. Even though the original document is 32 converted into an electronic record, the original document may still be 33 needed for examination at a hearing or trial. 34 35 (c) The amendment to Paragraph E of this Article is new and requires 36 that the original of all documents and exhibits introduced or proffered into 37 evidence, submitted with a petition for executory process, or filed in a 38 summary judgment proceeding be retained by the clerk of court until the 39 order or judgment becomes final and definitive, unless the court otherwise 40 directs. This does not change the law pertaining to the destruction of 41 documents after filing. See, e.g., R.S. 13:917, 1221, 1904, and 2562.26 42 relative to the destruction of useless records. 43 44 * * * 45 Art. 2853. Purported testament must be filed, though possessor doubts validity 46 Filing of purported testament Page 4 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 1 A. If a person has possession of a document purporting to be the testament 2 of a deceased person, even though he the person believes that the document is not 3 the valid testament of the deceased, or has doubts concerning the validity thereof, he 4 of the testament shall present it the document to the court with his a petition 5 praying that the document be filed in the record of the succession proceeding. 6 B. A person so presenting a purported testament to the court shall not be 7 deemed to vouch for its authenticity or validity, nor precluded from asserting its 8 invalidity. 9 * * * 10 SECTION 4. RETENTION OF TESTAMENTS 11 Art. 2911. Retention of testaments 12 The clerk of court shall retain in perpetuity the original of a testament 13 that is probated or ordered to be filed and executed. Until the order probating 14 the testament or ordering the testament to be filed and executed becomes final 15 and definitive, the clerk of court shall also retain the originals of all other 16 testaments filed in accordance with Article 2853. 17 Comments - 2024 18 19 In accordance with Article 2974, an appeal may be taken from orders and 20 judgments rendered in succession proceedings. 21 22 Section 2. Code of Criminal Procedure Article 14.1 is hereby amended and reenacted, 23 and Code of Criminal Procedure Article 14.2 is hereby enacted, to read as follows: 24 Art. 14.1. Filing of pleadings and documents by facsimile or electronic transmission 25 Electronic filings 26 Any document in a traffic or criminal action may be transmitted 27 electronically in accordance with a system established by the clerk of court. The 28 clerk of court shall adopt a system for the electronic filing and storage of any 29 pleading, document, or exhibit other than those documents or exhibits 30 introduced and filed at a hearing or trial. Furthermore, in a court that accepts 31 electronic filings in accordance with this Article, the official record shall be the Page 5 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 1 electronic record. A pleading or document filed electronically is deemed filed 2 on the date and time stated on the confirmation of electronic filing sent from the 3 system, if the clerk of court accepts the electronic filing. Public access to 4 electronically filed pleadings and documents shall be in accordance with the 5 rules governing access to written filings. 6 Art. 14.2. Facsimile filings 7 A. Any document in a traffic or criminal action may be filed with the clerk 8 of court by facsimile transmission if permitted by pursuant to the policy of the clerk 9 of court. Filing shall be deemed complete at the time the facsimile transmission is 10 received by the clerk of court. No later than on the first business day after receiving 11 a facsimile filing, the clerk of court shall transmit to the filing party via facsimile a 12 confirmation of receipt and include a statement of the fees for the facsimile filing 13 and filing of the original document. The facsimile filing fee and transmission fee are 14 incurred upon receipt of the facsimile filing by the clerk of court and payable as 15 provided in Paragraph B of this Article. The facsimile filing shall have the same 16 force and effect as filing the original document, if the party complies with Paragraph 17 B of this Article. 18 B. Within seven days, exclusive of legal holidays, after the clerk of court 19 receives the facsimile filing, all of the following shall be delivered to the clerk of 20 court: 21 (1) The original document identical to the facsimile filing in number of pages 22 and in content of each page including any attachments, exhibits, and orders. A 23 document not identical to the facsimile filing or which that includes pages not 24 included in the facsimile filing shall not be considered the original document. 25 (2) The fees for the facsimile filing and filing of the original document stated 26 on the confirmation of receipt, if any. 27 (3) A transmission fee of five dollars, if the defendant had not been declared 28 indigent by the court. 29 C. If the filing party fails to comply with any of the requirements of Page 6 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 1 Paragraph B of this Article, the facsimile filing shall have no force or effect. 2 D. Any A court district may provide by court rule for any additional 3 requirement or provisions for filings by facsimile transmission. 4 E. In keeping with the clerk's policy, each clerk of court shall make available 5 the necessary equipment and supplies to accommodate facsimile filing in criminal 6 actions. Purchases for equipment and supplies necessary to accommodate facsimile 7 filings may be funded from any expense fund of the office of the clerk of court as the 8 clerks deem appropriate. 9 F. The filings as provided in this article and all other provisions of this code 10 may be transmitted electronically in accordance with a system established by a clerk 11 of court or by the Louisiana clerks' remote access authority. When such a system is 12 established, the clerk of court shall adopt and implement procedures for the 13 electronic filing and storage of any pleading, document, or exhibit. Furthermore, in 14 a parish that accepts electronic filings covered under this paragraph, the official 15 record shall be the electronic record. A pleading or document filed electronically is 16 deemed filed on the date and time stated on the confirmation of electronic filing sent 17 from the system, if the clerk of court accepts the electronic filing. Public access to 18 electronically filed pleadings and documents shall be in accordance with the rules 19 governing access to written filings. 20 Section 3. R.S. 9:2761 and 2762 are hereby enacted to read as follows: 21 §2761. Effectiveness of electronic record 22 An electronic record filed in accordance with R.S. 44:119 shall have 23 effect as to third persons in the same manner as if an original written 24 instrument had been filed. 25 §2762. Recordation of testaments; indexing; effectiveness 26 If a testament is recorded in the conveyance records, the clerk of court 27 shall index the testament only in the name of the testator. The recordation of the 28 testament shall not itself have any effect on the rights of the heirs, legatees, and 29 creditors of the succession and shall not make the provisions of the testament Page 7 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 1 effective against third persons. 2 Section 4. R.S. 44:116(D) and the introductory paragraph of R.S. 44:116(E)(1) and 3 R.S. 44:116(E)(2) are hereby amended and reenacted, and R.S. 44:117 is hereby enacted, to 4 read as follows: 5 §116. Photostatic, photographic, microfilm, or other photographic or electronic 6 copies of records; indexes of conveyance and mortgage records; 7 disposition; evidentiary status; preservation 8 * * * 9 D. Notwithstanding the provisions of Subsection B of this Section or any 10 other provision of law to the contrary, for any record filed on or after January 1, 11 2005, with the exception of instruments filed in the conveyance records and 12 records of a graphic nature, including but not limited to plats, maps, and photographs 13 as related to the work of a Professional Land Surveyor engaged in the "Practice of 14 Land Surveying", as defined in R.S. 37:682, a clerk of court may reproduce the 15 record as provided in this Section and may thereafter return the original record to the 16 person presenting it. 17 E.(1) Notwithstanding the provisions of Subsection B of this Section or any 18 other provision of law to the contrary, with the exception of instruments filed in 19 the conveyance records, a clerk of court shall not be required to maintain an 20 original record filed on or prior to December 31, 2004, provided that: 21 * * * 22 (2) A With the exception of instruments filed in the conveyance records, 23 a clerk of court may destroy any record provided for in this Subsection or return it 24 to the person who presented it for recordation after the clerk of court receives 25 certification from the state archivist that the records are not subject to R.S. 44:406 26 or R.S. 44:427 411 and after the clerk of court has preserved the record as provided 27 for in this Section. No cause of action for any claim shall exist against a clerk of 28 court for any damage or loss resulting from the return or destruction of an original 29 record in accordance with this Paragraph after receipt of the certification and Page 8 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL 1 proper preservation of the record. 2 * * * 3 §117. Preservation of filings in the conveyance records 4 A. The clerk of court shall preserve in perpetuity the original of each 5 instrument filed in the conveyance records. This Section shall prevail over any 6 other law to the contrary. 7 B. For purposes of this Part, the conveyance records include all records, 8 however denominated, that are required by law to be indexed in the index of 9 conveyances maintained by the clerk of court. 10 Section 5. The Louisiana State Law Institute is hereby directed to redesignate 11 existing R.S. 44:117, entitled "Electronic copies of records; Lafayette Parish", as R.S. 44:118 12 and to redesignate Code of Civil Procedure Article 258 as R.S. 44:119 The original instrument and the following digest, which constitutes no part of the legislative instrument, were prepared by Thomas L. Tyler. DIGEST SB 75 Original 2024 Regular Session Morris Present law (C.C.P. Art. 253) provides with respect to the filing of pleadings, documents, and exhibits with the clerk of court, including electronic transmission, electronic conversion, and use of electronic signatures. Proposed law retains present law and requires the original of any filed document or exhibit to be maintained by the filer during the pendency of the proceeding and to be made available for inspection or production to the court. Proposed law further requires the original of all documents and exhibits introduced or proffered into evidence, submitted with a petition for executory process, or filed in a summary judgment proceeding to be retained by the clerk of court during the pendency of the proceeding. Present law (C.C.P. Art. 2853) requires the filing of purported testaments in the record of the succession proceeding. Proposed law retains present law and makes technical corrections. Proposed law (C.C.P. Art. 2911) requires permanent retention by the clerks of court of testaments that have been probated or ordered to be filed and executed and provides for the retention of other filed testaments. Present law (C.Cr.P. Art. 14.1) provides for the filing of pleadings and documents by facsimile or electronic transmission. Proposed law provides for the electronic transmission of documents in traffic or criminal actions pursuant to the policy of the clerk of court. Page 9 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions. SB NO. 75 SLS 24RS-259 ORIGINAL Proposed law (C.Cr.P. Art. 14.2) provides for the facsimile transmission of documents in traffic or criminal actions pursuant to the policy of the clerk of court. Proposed law (R.S. 9:2761) provides for the effectiveness of electronic records as to third persons. Proposed law (R.S. 9:2762) provides for the recordation of testaments in the conveyance records, including indexing requirements and effectiveness against third persons. Present law (R.S. 44:116) provides for the reproduction, maintenance, and destruction or return of original records. Proposed law retains present law and adds exceptions for instruments filed in the conveyance records. Proposed law (R.S. 44:117) requires the preservation of originals of instruments filed in the conveyance records, including records that are required to be indexed by the clerk of court. Present law (R.S. 44:117) provides for the electronic recordation of filings, documents, pleadings, and other written instruments in Lafayette Parish. Proposed law redesignates certain provisions in present law. Present law (C.C.P. Art. 258) provides for the electronic filing and recording of written instruments. Proposed law redesignates certain provisions in present law. Effective August 21, 2024. (Amends C.C.P. Arts. 253 and 2853, C.Cr.P. Art. 14.1, and R.S. 44:116(D) and (E)(1)(intro. par.) and (2); adds C.C.P. Art. 2911, C.Cr.P. Art. 14.2, R.S. 9:2761 and 2762, and R.S. 44:117; redesignates C.C.P. Art. 258 and R.S. 44:117) Page 10 of 10 Coding: Words which are struck through are deletions from existing law; words in boldface type and underscored are additions.