Louisiana 2011 Regular Session

Louisiana House Bill HB367

Introduced
4/25/11  

Caption

Requires verification of citizenship for recipients of public benefits

Impact

If enacted, HB 367 would significantly alter the requirements for individuals seeking public assistance in Louisiana. The law stipulates that all applicants must provide proof of citizenship through various accepted forms of documentation, which could pose challenges for certain populations, including those who may lack access to these documents. The enforcement of stricter penalties for failing to report fraud could lead to increased responsibility for public employees and heightened scrutiny of applicants, potentially complicating the process of applying for assistance.

Summary

House Bill 367 mandates the verification of citizenship for individuals applying for state, local, or federal public benefits in Louisiana. This legislative measure aims to ensure that only U.S. citizens are eligible for such benefits and outlines specific documents required to establish lawful presence. By creating the crime of failing to report fraudulent claims related to public assistance, the bill seeks to tighten oversight and accountability among public employees and agencies that administer these benefits.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 367 appears mixed, with proponents arguing that the legislation is necessary to prevent misuse of public funds and ensure that assistance is allocated appropriately. However, there is notable opposition from advocates who view the bill as overly punitive and a barrier for vulnerable populations, making it more difficult for eligible individuals to access essential services. The controversy highlights a broader debate on immigration policy and the balance between ensuring benefits for citizens while managing public resources effectively.

Contention

One primary point of contention is the requirement for extensive documentation to verify citizenship. Critics argue that this could disenfranchise low-income individuals or those born abroad but are U.S. citizens, as they may have difficulty obtaining the necessary paperwork. Additionally, the bill's enforcement provisions may raise concerns regarding racial profiling, as individuals from certain demographics may be disproportionately affected by the stricter investigations into eligibility and fraud.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA HB411

Creates the Louisiana Citizen Protection Act (EG INCREASE GF EX See Note)

LA HB646

Provides for the verification of citizenship for employment (EN NO IMPACT GF EX See Note)

LA HB342

Provides for the verification of citizenship of employees engaged in public contract work

LA SB153

Require citizenship verification before an elector may vote

LA HB233

Require elector citizenship verification; revise election law

LA HB175

Requires employers to use the E-Verify program to verify the citizenship status of applicants (OR +$1,700,000 GF EX See Note)

LA HB1909

To Create The Public Services Only For Citizens Act; And To Require Verification Of Citizenship And Residency In Order To Receive Public Assistance.

LA SB2613

Voter registration; require verification of an applicant's U.S. citizenship.

LA SB2506

Voter registration; require verification of an applicant's U.S. citizenship.

LA HB2492

Voter registration; verification; citizenship

Similar Bills

IL HB5887

ELEC CD-VERIFY CITIZENSHIP

PA HB284

Providing for secure and fair elections and the authentication of United States citizenship.

MS SB2590

Secretary of State Statewide Elections Management System; provide for voter's proof of citizenship.

MS SB2606

Voter registration; provide for certain procedures upon application.

MS HB1510

Elections; revise procedures regarding voter roll maintenance.

CA AB222

False documents.

MS SB2499

Statewide Elections Management System; compare identification databases to ensure noncitizens are not registered to vote.

SC S0128

Voter Registration