Louisiana 2012 Regular Session

Louisiana House Bill HB851

Introduced
3/12/12  

Caption

Prohibits certain assistance in voting

Impact

The expected impact of HB851 is a more secure absentee voting process, ensuring that individuals are not influenced by those who may have personal interests in the election outcomes. This change aims at fostering a sense of independence among voters, particularly the elderly and disabled populations who often rely on support for such tasks. Critics of the bill may argue, however, that while the intent to protect voters is valid, this could also limit necessary assistance for those who may genuinely require help due to their physical or cognitive limitations.

Summary

House Bill 851 (HB851) aims to enhance the integrity of the voting process by prohibiting specific individuals from assisting voters in absentee voting. The bill specifically disallows candidates in elections, as well as the owners, operators, or administrators of nursing homes, from providing assistance to voters when casting absentee ballots. This legislation seeks to limit the potential for coercion or undue influence during the voting process, particularly in environments like nursing homes where vulnerable populations reside. The implementation of this bill would mean that individuals in these roles would have no authority to help voters complete their ballots, reinforcing the principle that voting should be a private and personal act.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB851 appears to lean towards the positive, as it aligns with ongoing efforts to ensure election integrity. Supporters of the bill, including many lawmakers concerned with voter rights, argue that it is a crucial step in safeguarding against possible abuses in the voting process. Opposition, although present, is likely to focus more on the balance needed concerning those voters needing assistance rather than outright condemnation of the bill's intent.

Contention

Some notable points of contention regarding HB851 involve the potential ramifications for individuals requiring assistance, especially the elderly in nursing homes. Opponents might express concerns about inadvertently disenfranchising voters who are unable to manage the absentee voting process independently. The legislative conversations around this bill may highlight the fine line between securing a fair election and ensuring all eligible voters have the means to exercise their rights to vote without assistance from potentially biased individuals.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA SB137

Prohibits owner, operator or administrator of a nursing home to assist any voter in casting his ballot in an election. (gov sig)

LA HB917

Provides relative to absentee voting by mail

LA HB970

Provides relative to voting by persons who are incarcerated (OR +$6,261 GF EX See Note)

LA SB161

Deletes the requirement for the registrar of voters to post a certain list of containing certain information on voters who request to vote absentee by mail or during early voting. (gov sig)

LA HB1165

Modify certain provisions pertaining to absentee voting.

LA HB1200

Provides relative to procedures for registration and voting for persons in the U.S. Service and persons residing outside of the U.S. (EN INCREASE GF EX See Note)

LA HB665

Provides relative to absentee by mail and early voting

LA HF2392

Photo ID required to register to vote and to vote, voter identification card created, provisional ballots established, identification of individuals providing assistance to a voter in a polling place required, certain voter registration and absentee voting activities prohibited, and money appropriated.

LA HF573

Photo ID required to register to vote and to vote; voter ID card created; provisional ballots established; compensation methods prohibited; identification of individuals acting as agent for absentee voter or providing assistance to voter required; counties, municipalities, and school districts prohibited from accepting contributions; absentee voting requirements amended; and money appropriated.

LA HF1188

Photo ID required to register to vote and to vote; voter ID card created; provisional ballots established; compensation methods prohibited; identification of individuals acting as agent for absentee voter or providing assistance to voter required; counties, municipalities, and school districts prohibited from accepting contributions; absentee voting requirements amended; and money appropriated.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.