Louisiana 2014 Regular Session

Louisiana House Bill HB606

Introduced
3/10/14  
Introduced
3/10/14  
Refer
3/10/14  

Caption

Provides relative to damages for failure to wear a seatbelt

Impact

The bill's implementation would modify the existing statute concerning seatbelt usage, making it possible for defendants to argue that an injured party's lack of seatbelt use should impact the damages awarded in negligence cases. This change would incentivize individuals to wear seatbelts while also providing defendants with a potential mitigation of liability in motor vehicle accident lawsuits, aligning legal consequences more closely with personal responsibility regarding safety practices.

Summary

House Bill 606 addresses the admissibility of evidence regarding safety belt usage in motor vehicle damage cases. Currently, the law prohibits introducing evidence of failing to wear a seatbelt when assessing damages after an accident. HB606 proposes to allow courts to permit such evidence, significantly altering how damages are determined in personal injury cases involving vehicle accidents. If the injured party is found to have not worn a safety belt, their awarded damages can be reduced by 15%.

Sentiment

Sentiment around HB606 appears to be mixed, with supporters advocating for personal accountability in safety measures, while opponents might view it as placing undue burden on individuals who have suffered injuries. The bill has sparked discussions focused on the balance between individual responsibility and actual accident circumstances, highlighting divergent views on personal safety laws and their enforcement.

Contention

Key points of contention regarding HB606 may revolve around arguments about fairness in injury compensation, as opponents could argue that such reductions disproportionately affect victims and may not adequately consider the realities leading to injury occurrences. Advocates for the bill, however, emphasize the role of seatbelts in enhancing safety and the need for legislation that reflects a commitment to personal responsibility. Overall, the bill raises broader questions regarding the legal implications of personal safety choices in the context of motor vehicle operation.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA HB51

Provides relative to the admissibility of evidence for failure to wear a safety belt

LA HB256

Provides relative to evidence of failure to wear a safety belt

LA HB573

Provides relative to evidence of failure to wear a safety belt

LA HB230

Provides relative to the admissibility of evidence for failure to wear a safety belt

LA HB39

Provides relative to the admissibility of evidence for failure to wear a safety belt

LA HB1018

Failure to wear a seatbelt; primary offense.

LA HB700

Provides relative to the admissibility of evidence of failure to wear a safety belt

LA HB56

Provides for the use of evidence of the failure to wear a safety belt (Item #40)

LA SB338

Provides relative to admissibility of certain evidence regarding failure to wear a safety belt. (8/1/20)

LA SB9

Provides relative to safety belts. (Item #40) (1/1/21) (EN SEE FISC NOTE GF EX)

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.