Louisiana 2014 Regular Session

Louisiana House Bill HR113

Introduced
5/5/14  

Caption

Authorizes a committee member to abstain from voting under certain circumstances

Impact

The impact of HR 113 focuses on refining the legislative process within committees. By permitting abstentions under certain circumstances, the bill empowers committee members to act responsibly by not voting if they lack sufficient information. This change is expected to enhance the decision-making integrity of committees, fostering a more informed legislative process overall. Furthermore, it strengthens the procedural framework of the House, aligning it with principles of accountability and deliberation.

Summary

House Resolution 113, proposed by Representative Lopinto, seeks to amend House Rule 14.42 concerning the voting procedures of committee members. The resolution specifically allows a committee member to abstain from voting when they believe they cannot make an informed decision due to their absence from all or a significant part of the committee discussions related to the matter at hand. This aims to ensure that absent members do not cast votes that could be ill-informed or inconsistent with the committee's deliberations.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HR 113 appeared to be generally positive among proponents who support the resolution as a necessary improvement to the legislative process. They argue that it promotes better governance by allowing members to abstain from votes rather than making uninformed decisions. However, concerns were raised about potential misuse or confusion surrounding the abstention process, emphasizing the need for clear guidelines to prevent members from avoiding accountability.

Contention

Despite the aforementioned support, the bill may encounter contention regarding its implementation. Questions may arise around the criteria for determining which absences justify an abstention, and how to ensure that committee members do not exploit this provision to evade voting altogether. This concern highlights a balancing act between member discretion and maintaining a robust legislative framework that ensures active participation and accountability.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA HR12

Creates and provides for the Fiscal Note Review Committee and provides for the locking of a member's voting machine under certain circumstances

LA HCR2

Amend Uniform Rules: Abstain From Voting

LA HCR2

Amend Uniform Rules: Abstain From Voting

LA SB439

Authorizing certain 911 personnel to be members of Emergency Medical Services Retirement System under certain circumstances

LA S3126

Allows Right to Farm Act complaints to be filed with county agriculture development board in adjacent county under certain circumstances and creates alternate voting members on such boards.

LA S3246

Allows Right to Farm Act complaints to be filed with county agriculture development board in adjacent county under certain circumstances and creates alternate voting members on such boards.

LA A4766

Allows Right to Farm Act complaints to be filed with county agriculture development board in adjacent county under certain circumstances and creates alternate voting members on such boards.

LA A2318

Clarifies voting ability of members of State Agriculture Development Committee.

LA HB743

Relative to the membership, voting procedures, and proxies of the La. Sentencing Commission

LA HB290

Provides for an extension of time for voting on election day under certain circumstances (OR SEE FISC NOTE GF EX)

Similar Bills

NJ AR96

Changes membership of Budget and Labor Committees; clarifies that bill or resolution may be listed on committee agenda for purposes of amendment.

MI HB4326

Campaign finance: contributions and expenditures; provision related to officeholders raising funds when facing a recall; modify, and require candidate to establish a separate account used for recall purposes. Amends secs. 3, 11, 12, 21, 24 & 52 of 1976 PA 388 (MCL 169.203 et seq.) & adds sec. 21b.

MI HB4870

Campaign finance: contributions and expenditures; funds donated to a candidate for recall efforts; require candidate to establish a separate account used for recall purposes. Amends secs. 3, 11, 12, 21, 24 & 52 of 1976 PA 388 (MCL 169.203 et seq.) & adds sec. 21b.

MN HC6

A concurrent resolution recognizing wild rice as sacred and central to the culture and health of Indigenous Peoples in Minnesota and critical to the health and identity of all Minnesota citizens and ecosystems and establishing a commitment to passing legislation to protect wild rice and the freshwater resources upon which it depends.

CA SB1048

Advisory bodies.

CA SB602

Advisory bodies.

CA AB3239

Advisory bodies.

KS HR6003

Providing temporary rules of the House of Representatives for the 2023 session until permanent rules are adopted.