Louisiana 2020 2nd Special Session

Louisiana House Bill HCR8

Introduced
9/29/20  
Introduced
9/29/20  
Refer
9/29/20  
Refer
9/29/20  
Report Pass
10/12/20  
Report Pass
10/12/20  
Engrossed
10/14/20  

Caption

Suspends the enforcement authority of the commissioner of alcohol and tobacco control for violations of COVID-19-related restrictions (Items #28, 32, 35, and 60)

Impact

By suspending the enforcement powers of the commissioner, HCR8 aims to relieve some of the burdens placed on bar owners during the COVID-19 pandemic. The resolution allows for a temporary reprieve from regulations that critics argue have been overly stringent and damaging to small businesses in the alcohol industry. Although the suspension primarily applies to violations of COVID-19 measures, it notably maintains the enforcement authority within the city of New Orleans, indicating that local governance still plays a significant role in public health measures and regulatory authority.

Summary

HCR8 is a House Concurrent Resolution from the Louisiana Legislature which seeks to suspend the enforcement authority of the commissioner of alcohol and tobacco control in relation to violations of COVID-19-related restrictions. The resolution specifically prohibits the commissioner from enforcing closures or restrictions on bars, imposing fines, or revoking licenses due to alleged violations of these restrictions. This bill is highly relevant in the context of the ongoing pandemic and its impact on businesses, particularly bars which have faced numerous restrictions to mitigate the spread of the virus.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HCR8 appears to be mixed. Supporters of the resolution argue that it is a necessary action to protect businesses from punitive measures that could lead to closures and economic downturns. Conversely, opponents may view the resolution as undermining public health efforts and fail to prioritize the safety of the community. This dichotomy highlights the tension between economic interests and health concerns that continues to evolve as the pandemic progresses.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the implications of such a suspension on public health and the potential consequences in places where enforcement power is retained, like New Orleans. Critics may express concerns that suspending enforcement could lead to a resurgence of COVID-19 cases if bars are allowed to operate without oversight during the pandemic. Additionally, it raises questions about the balance of local versus state control in emergency health responses, with varying perspectives on which approach best serves community needs.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA HCR10

Suspends the enforcement authority of the commissioner of alcohol and tobacco control for violations of COVID-19-related restrictions (Items #28, 32, 35, and 60)

LA HB47

Prohibits the commissioner of alcohol and tobacco control from imposing sanctions for violation of an emergency order (Items #28, 32, 35, and 60)

LA HCR12

Suspends laws authorizing the La. Department of Health to enforce any restriction imposed on a business or individual through a gubernatorial proclamation during a state of public health emergency (Items #2 and #28)

LA HCR13

Prohibits the state fire marshal from enforcing certain restrictions on businesses (Items #2 and 28)

LA HR17

Requests the commissioner of alcohol and tobacco control and the La. Dept. of Health to grant no-cost extensions of bar and restaurant and in-state manufacturer permits

LA SCR8

Suspends certain provisions relative to the definition of public health emergency for the purposes of the Louisiana Health Emergency Powers Act. (Item #28)

LA SB18

Provides an exemption to certain permit fees collected by the Office of Alcohol and Tobacco Control. (gov sig) (Item #35) (EN DECREASE SG RV See Note)

LA HCR15

Suspends certain provisions of the Louisiana Health Emergency Powers Act (Items #2, 28, and 41)

LA HCR2

Suspends criminal penalties for emergency order violations

LA HCR5

Suspends criminal penalties for emergency order violations (EN SEE FISC NOTE LF EX See Note)

Similar Bills

CT SJ00007

Resolution Granting The Claims Commissioner An Extension Of Time To Dispose Of Certain Claims Against The State Pursuant To Chapter 53 Of The General Statutes.

CT HJ00041

Resolution Granting The Claims Commissioner An Extension Of Time To Dispose Of Certain Claims.

CT HJ00023

Resolution Granting The Claims Commissioner Extensions Of Time To Dispose Of Certain Claims Against The State.

CT HJ00038

Resolution Concerning The Disposition Of Certain Claims Against The State Pursuant To Chapter 53 Of The General Statutes.

CA AB2009

California Travel and Tourism Commission.

CA AB1920

California Travel and Tourism Commission.

CA AB2323

Insurance: covered communications.

CT HJ00029

Resolution Granting The Claims Commissioner An Extension Of Time To Dispose Of Certain Claims Against The State Pursuant To Chapter 53 Of The General Statutes.