Louisiana House Bill HB71

Louisiana 2020 2nd Special Session

• Introduced: 10/1/20
• Refer: 10/1/20

Caption

Provides relative to restrictions that apply to a church, synagogue, temple, or place of worship during a state of emergency (Items #2 and 28)

Impact

If enacted, HB 71 is expected to modify how states respond to emergencies with respect to religious organizations. Specifically, it strengthens the legal protections afforded to places of worship, ensuring that they face fewer restrictions compared to secular businesses or gatherings. This could lead to a shift in policy where religious activities are prioritized during emergencies, potentially impacting public health measures or safety protocols that local governments might wish to enforce.

Summary

House Bill 71 seeks to protect places of worship from excessive government restrictions during states of emergency. It amends existing laws to ensure that any government executive actions affecting churches, synagogues, temples, or similar places of worship do not discriminate against them. The bill mandates that all executive orders or instruments impacting these institutions include a written analysis demonstrating that they do not unduly burden the exercise of religious freedom as guaranteed by state and federal constitutions.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding the bill appears mixed, with considerable support among religious advocacy groups who view it as an essential safeguard for religious liberties. However, there are concerns from public health advocates and others who argue that such protections could undermine public safety during emergencies. The bill reflects a broader national debate on the balance between religious freedom and governmental authority, particularly in crisis situations.

Contention

Notable points of contention involve the potential implications of such protections during public health emergencies. Critics argue that prioritizing religious services over public health measures could endanger communities by allowing gatherings that might otherwise be limited to curb the spread of illness. Supporters, on the other hand, contend that religious gatherings are vital for community support and individual well-being, especially during challenging times.