California 2019-2020 Regular Session

California Assembly Bill AB3043

Introduced
2/21/20  
Introduced
2/21/20  
Refer
3/5/20  
Refer
3/5/20  
Report Pass
5/11/20  
Report Pass
5/11/20  
Refer
5/12/20  
Refer
5/12/20  
Report Pass
5/20/20  
Report Pass
5/20/20  
Refer
5/20/20  
Refer
5/20/20  
Report Pass
6/2/20  
Report Pass
6/2/20  
Engrossed
6/8/20  
Engrossed
6/8/20  
Refer
6/9/20  
Refer
6/9/20  
Refer
6/23/20  
Refer
6/23/20  
Report Pass
6/30/20  
Report Pass
6/30/20  
Refer
6/30/20  
Refer
6/30/20  
Report Pass
8/1/20  
Report Pass
8/1/20  
Refer
8/1/20  
Report Pass
8/4/20  
Refer
8/4/20  
Refer
8/4/20  
Refer
8/13/20  
Refer
8/13/20  
Report Pass
8/20/20  
Enrolled
8/30/20  
Enrolled
8/30/20  
Chaptered
9/30/20  
Chaptered
9/30/20  
Passed
9/30/20  

Caption

Corrections: confidential calls.

Impact

The introduction of AB 3043 represents a significant change in the legal framework governing inmate rights. Prior to this bill, inmates could only make confidential calls to their attorneys on a case-by-case basis, subject to approval by institutional authorities. By mandating a minimum time allowance for these calls, the bill enhances the legal protections afforded to inmates, enabling them to communicate privately with their legal representatives more effectively. This improvement can positively impact the legal defense processes and the overall fairness of trials for incarcerated individuals.

Summary

Assembly Bill No. 3043, also known as AB 3043, aims to enhance the rights of inmates in California regarding their ability to communicate confidentially with their attorneys. Specifically, the bill mandates that the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) must approve requests for confidential calls made by inmates to their attorneys. Under AB 3043, inmates are entitled to a minimum of 30 minutes of confidential call time per case, once per month, unless they or their attorney request less time. This legislative measure seeks to ensure that legal consultations between inmates and their attorneys are conducted privately and securely.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding AB 3043 is predominantly positive among advocates for inmate rights and legal fairness. Supporters argue that the bill addresses a vital need for accessible legal communication, which is essential for safeguarding an inmate's rights and ensuring a fair legal process. There is, however, concern among some institution heads regarding the logistics and security implications of implementing these confidential call provisions. Overall, the sentiment indicates a strong support for the need for privacy in legal matters, reflecting a broader commitment to upholding civil rights within the penal system.

Contention

Despite the overall supportive sentiment, some points of contention surrounding AB 3043 include concerns regarding the implementation details. Critics may express fears about potential challenges in maintaining security and monitoring communications while preserving the confidentiality of calls. Additionally, there may be debates about the adequacy of the 30-minute minimum allowance for attorney communications, with arguments on whether this time frame fully addresses the complexities of legal discussions necessary for adequate representation.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

CA AB1104

Corrections and rehabilitation: sentencing.

CA AB1186

Restitution fines.

CA AB2907

Firearms: restrained persons.

CA SB852

Searches: supervised persons.

CA AB2521

Criminal procedure: confidentiality and DNA testing.

CA AB2406

Crimes: theft.

CA AB855

Criminal procedure: fines, fees, and restitution.

CA SB1035

Criminal procedure: fines, fees, and restitution.

CA SB898

Criminal procedure: sexual assault resentencing.

CA AB1497

Criminal procedure.

Similar Bills

CA AB2280

Jails: confidential calls.

ME LD1603

An Act to Implement the Recommendations of the Committee To Ensure Constitutionally Adequate Contact with Counsel

CA SB954

Mediation: confidentiality: disclosure.

TX HB4066

Relating to the right of certain elected public officers to information of certain governmental and public entities; creating a criminal offense.

CA AB3168

Department of Motor Vehicles: confidential records.

TX HB3271

Relating to the right of certain public officers to access public information, documents, records, and property.

TX SB515

Relating to the right of certain public officers to access public information, documents, records, and property; creating criminal offenses.

CA SB1093

Department of Motor Vehicles: records: confidentiality.