Arkansas 2023 Regular Session

Arkansas Senate Bill SB59

Introduced
1/12/23  
Refer
1/17/23  
Report Pass
1/30/23  
Refer
2/1/23  
Report Pass
2/6/23  
Engrossed
2/7/23  
Refer
2/7/23  
Report Pass
2/16/23  
Enrolled
2/23/23  
Chaptered
3/1/23  

Caption

To Amend The Law With Respect To Circumstances That Justify The Use Of Physical Force Upon Another Person.

Impact

The implications of SB59 on state laws are significant, particularly in how it formalizes the conditions under which physical force can be justified. By including 'school employee' in the definitions and allowing these individuals to apply physical force for disciplinary purposes, the bill aims to provide legal protections for educators acting in the interest of their students. However, it raises concerns regarding the boundary between appropriate discipline and potential abuse of power by those in positions of authority, thereby affecting the state's legal framework around child welfare and safety.

Summary

Senate Bill 59 amends Arkansas law concerning the use of physical force upon minors and incompetent persons. The bill specifies that parents, guardians, teachers, and other school employees are permitted to use reasonable and appropriate physical force when required to maintain discipline or promote the welfare of the minor or incompetent person under their care. This expansion of definitions around who may use such force and under what circumstances marks a significant legislative change for schools and caregivers in Arkansas.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB59 appears to be mixed. Proponents of the bill argue that it empowers educators and caregivers to effectively manage classroom behavior and ensure a conducive environment for learning. In contrast, critics fear that it could lead to the justification of excessive physical force and harm towards vulnerable individuals, arguing for the need to establish clear guidelines and limits on physical discipline. The divergence in perspectives highlights an ongoing debate about authority in educational settings and child protection.

Contention

One of the notable points of contention regarding SB59 is the potential for misinterpretation of what constitutes 'reasonable' physical force. Detractors express concerns that the bill may encourage overly aggressive disciplinary measures, undermining the safety and well-being of minors in educational environments. This aspect of the bill necessitates careful scrutiny to ensure that it does not inadvertently endorse harmful practices while seeking to balance the needs for discipline and care within schools.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

AR SMR1

In Respectful Memory Of David Pryor, Former Governor Of Arkansas And United States Senator.

AR HR1057

In Respectful Memory Of David Pryor, Former Governor Of Arkansas And United States Senator.

AR SR27

In Respectful Memory Of Shorter College President Dr. O. Jerome Green.

AR SB78

To Amend The Arkansas Data Centers Act Of 2023; To Prohibit Foreign-party-controlled Ownership Of A Digital Asset Mining Business; And To Declare An Emergency.

AR SB10

An Act For The Administrative Office Of The Courts - Court Personnel Appropriation For The 2024-2025 Fiscal Year.

AR HB1065

An Act For The Department Of Finance And Administration - Disbursing Officer Appropriation For The 2024-2025 Fiscal Year.

AR SR5

To Authorize The Introduction Of A Nonappropriation Bill To Amend The Arkansas Data Centers Act Of 2023 And To Prohibit Foreign-party-controlled Ownership Of A Digital Asset Mining Business.

AR HR1009

To Authorize The Introduction Of A Nonappropriation Bill To Amend The Arkansas Data Centers Act Of 2023 And To Prohibit Foreign-party-controlled Ownership Of A Digital Asset Mining Business.

AR HR1015

To Authorize The Introduction Of A Nonappropriation Bill To Amend The Arkansas Data Centers Act Of 2023 And To Amend The Requirements For A Digital Asset Mining Business Or Business Using A Blockchain Network.

AR SR16

To Authorize The Introduction Of A Nonappropriation Bill To Amend The Arkansas Data Centers Act Of 2023 And To Amend The Requirements For A Digital Asset Mining Business Or Business Using A Blockchain Network.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.