Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SCR39

Introduced
3/7/23  

Caption

Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

Impact

The proposed task force is intended to include diverse stakeholders, such as representatives from the Office of Hawaiian Affairs, the Legislature, families previously displaced from the area, and various nonprofit organizations with expertise related to Makua Valley. This inclusive approach aims to ensure that the transition not only considers ecological factors, such as cleanup of unexploded ordnance, but also respects cultural interests linked to Native Hawaiian heritage. The legislation highlights the need to focus on facilitating the access to cultural sites and ensuring a responsible transfer of the land that balances environmental and cultural integrity.

Summary

Senate Concurrent Resolution 39 (SCR39) urges the Board of Land and Natural Resources to establish a task force aimed at preparing a feasibility plan for the transition of the Makua Military Reservation's management from the United States Army to the State of Hawaii. This transition is particularly relevant as the current lease with the Army, General Lease Number S-3848, is set to expire in 2029. The resolution reflects a long history of military use of Makua Valley, which dates back to the 1920s and includes significant environmental and cultural considerations due to the land's historical use and the presence of numerous endangered species.

Contention

Potential points of contention surrounding SCR39 may arise concerning the management authority of the lands post-transition and how it aligns with the aspirations of Native Hawaiian groups versus federal regulations. There are considerable concerns regarding the timeline and effectiveness of the cleanup of any unexploded ordnance that remains, which has previously hindered access to cultural sites. Furthermore, the resolution marks a significant step in addressing historical grievances from communities affected by military operations, stressing the importance of recognition and reconciliation in the context of land management.

Additional_notes

The task force is also called to submit a report with findings and recommendations by 2024, indicating a proactive step toward legislative action that may include proposed legislation for the management transition. The resolution is a critical move for local governance to reclaim authority over land use and cultural stewardship in Hawaii, engaging community voices in shaping the future of the Makua Military Reservation.

Companion Bills

HI HCR170

Same As Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

Previously Filed As

HI HR87

Requesting The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Convene A Makua Valley Task Force To Prepare For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation From The United States Army To The State.

HI HCR106

Requesting The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Convene A Makua Valley Task Force To Prepare For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation From The United States Army To The State.

HI SCR209

Requesting All Branches Of The United States Military To Display The Hawaiian Flag On All United States Military Reservations And Military Training Facilities In The State.

HI SB2593

Relating To Federal Lands.

HI HB2117

Relating To Federal Lands.

HI HB697

Relating To Federal Lands.

HI HCR19

Urging The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Work With The United States Fish And Wildlife Service To Implement A Native Plant Seeding Project In Mililani Mauka To Restore The Ecological Damage From The November 2023 Wildfires.

HI HR9

Urging The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Work With The United States Fish And Wildlife Service To Implement A Native Plant Seeding Project In Mililani Mauka To Restore The Ecological Damage From The November 2023 Wildfires.

HI SR185

Requesting All Branches Of The United States Military To Display The Hawaiian Flag On All United States Military Reservations And Military Training Facilities In The State.

HI SCR123

Requesting The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Convene A Working Group To Make Recommendations On Solutions To Reduce Wildfire Risk And The Feasibility Of Establishing A Vegetation Management Program As It Relates To Landowners And Public Utilities.

Similar Bills

HI SR33

Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

HI HCR170

Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

HI HR175

Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

HI HB2327

Relating To Federal Lands.

HI HR87

Requesting The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Convene A Makua Valley Task Force To Prepare For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation From The United States Army To The State.

HI HCR106

Requesting The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Convene A Makua Valley Task Force To Prepare For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation From The United States Army To The State.

HI HB547

Relating To Federal Lands.

HI SB902

Relating To Federal Lands.