Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

Hawaii House Bill HR175

Introduced
3/10/23  
Refer
3/15/23  
Report Pass
3/30/23  
Refer
3/30/23  
Report Pass
4/5/23  

Caption

Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

Impact

This resolution carries potential implications for state laws regarding land management and the environmental protection of sensitive habitats in the Makua Valley area. It underscores the need to address health and safety concerns tied to military activity, especially the cleanup of unexploded ordnance left from past military practices. By facilitating a transition from federal to state management, there are also discussions about the possibility of ultimately transferring control to a sovereign Native Hawaiian entity, which would align with Native rights advocacy.

Summary

House Resolution 175 urges the Board of Land and Natural Resources to create a task force dedicated to preparing a feasibility plan for the management transition of the Makua Military Reservation from the United States Army to the State of Hawaii upon the expiration of General Lease No. S-3848 in 2029. The resolution reflects ongoing concerns about the land's historical importance and ecological significance, as well as the implications of continued military use on surrounding communities and cultural sites.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HR175 appears to be generally positive, especially among those advocating for Native Hawaiian rights and environmental protections. Proponents see the task force as a critical step toward reclaiming stewardship of the Makua Valley for state residents and addressing historical grievances stemming from military land use. However, there may be contention regarding how to balance human needs with ecological preservation and safety concerns, highlighting the complex dynamics among state, federal, and Native stakeholders.

Contention

Notably, the resolution encourages dialogue with the United States Army to expedite the return of the valley, which includes ensuring the cleanup of hazardous materials and enhancing access to cultural sites important to Native Hawaiians. There is a risk that bureaucratic hurdles or conflicting interests might impede the task force's objectives, especially in negotiating the terms of land transfer and ensuring the protection of endangered species and historical sites already acknowledged within the region.

Companion Bills

HI HCR170

Same As Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

Similar Bills

HI SCR39

Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

HI SR33

Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

HI HCR170

Urging The Board Of Land And Natural Resources To Establish A Task Force To Prepare A Feasibility Plan For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation To The State From The United States Army Upon The Expiration Of General Lease Number S-3848.

HI HB2327

Relating To Federal Lands.

HI HR87

Requesting The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Convene A Makua Valley Task Force To Prepare For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation From The United States Army To The State.

HI HCR106

Requesting The Department Of Land And Natural Resources To Convene A Makua Valley Task Force To Prepare For The Transition Of The Management Of The Makua Military Reservation From The United States Army To The State.

HI HB547

Relating To Federal Lands.

HI SB902

Relating To Federal Lands.