Hawaii House Bill HCR171

Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/10/23
• Refer: 3/15/23

Caption

Requesting The Department Of Commerce And Consumer Affairs, In Consultation With The Department Of Taxation, To Conduct A Study On The Social And Economic Impacts Of Permitting The Sale Of Aerial Fireworks And Imposing A Tax On The Sale Of Aerial Fireworks.

Impact

The resolution acknowledges that existing penalties have not successfully deterred illegal fireworks activities, which persist due to cultural practices tied to significant celebrations in Hawaii. By proposing a new framework that permits the controlled sale of aerial fireworks under a taxed environment, HCR171 aims to explore the possibility of regulating these products better, thereby enhancing public safety while potentially generating additional state revenue.

Summary

HCR171 is a House Concurrent Resolution introduced in the State of Hawaii, seeking to address the issues related to the illegal sale and use of aerial fireworks. This resolution calls upon the Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs, in collaboration with the Department of Taxation, to conduct a comprehensive study of the social and economic impacts of legalizing the sale of aerial fireworks and applying a tax on their sale. The resolution emerges in response to rising incidents of injuries, property damage, and fatalities caused by illegal aerial fireworks, which have become a growing concern within neighborhoods across the state.

Conclusion

In summary, HCR171 seeks to facilitate a study that can inform future legislative action regarding aerial fireworks in Hawaii. It emphasizes the importance of evaluating both the potential economic benefits of taxation while also addressing the substantial risks associated with aerial fireworks usage. The outcomes of this study may significantly influence state policy on fireworks regulations.

Contention

The proposal does raise significant points of contention around the legal status of aerial fireworks. Stakeholders may argue about the effectiveness of taxation as a deterrent to illegal activities and whether this move might unintentionally normalize the use of aerial fireworks, leading to more frequent injuries and property damage. Furthermore, the study must consider whether implementing mandatory liability insurance for permit holders would enhance safety or merely add another layer of bureaucracy.