If enacted, the bill would amend section 708-829 of the Hawaii Revised Statutes, specifically increasing the maximum monetary penalties associated with littering. Additionally, the bill introduces mandatory community service hours for violators: first offenses would require four hours of picking up litter or community work, while subsequent offenses would demand eight hours. These changes highlight a dual approach to punishment—financial penalties complemented by community engagement, aiming to instill a sense of responsibility regarding litter in public areas.
Summary
House Bill 44 aims to address the issue of littering in Hawaii by amending the maximum fine for the petty misdemeanor offense of criminal littering. The bill seeks to increase the penalty from $1,000 to $2,000 to deter individuals from littering in public spaces, which the legislature identifies as a significant problem detrimental to the state's natural beauty and tourism appeal. The intention behind the bill is to emphasize the importance of maintaining Hawaii's environment and to encourage responsible behavior among residents and visitors alike.
Contention
While the bill has the potential to significantly impact littering behaviors in Hawaii, it is likely to generate discussions around the effectiveness of increased financial penalties. Critics may argue whether higher fines alone will result in behavioral change or merely penalize those who are less able to pay. There may also be concerns regarding the practical implementation of community service requirements and whether adequate systems are in place to monitor compliance. The effectiveness of such punitive measures in achieving real change will be a critical point of debate among stakeholders.
A resolution to direct the Clerk of the House of Representatives to only present to the Governor enrolled House bills finally passed by both houses of the One Hundred Third Legislature.