Hawaii 2024 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SB1392

Introduced
1/25/23  
Refer
1/30/23  
Introduced
1/25/23  
Report Pass
2/8/24  
Refer
1/30/23  
Report Pass
2/8/24  

Caption

Relating To Periodic Reviews Of Detainees In Community Correctional Centers.

Impact

The enactment of SB1392 will alter the existing statute, specifically amending section 353-6.2 of the Hawaii Revised Statutes, thereby revising the mandated timetable for regular reviews of detentions. By extending this period, the bill seeks to ensure that the limited resources of the department can be apportioned more judiciously, thus enabling better enforcement of existing duties while simultaneously addressing the needs of pretrial detainees for expedited processes vis-a-vis their legal status. The focus on efficiency is indicative of the broader goals of bail reforms that strive to enhance fairness within the pretrial detention system.

Summary

SB1392 extends the time frame for conducting periodic reviews of pretrial detainees housed in community correctional centers from three months to six months. This modification aims to alleviate the workload of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation's intake service centers, which have shown that the current ninety-day review process yields minimal outcomes in terms of recommendations for pretrial release. The bill recognizes the need for a revised timeline that potentially allows for a more efficient processing of cases without sacrificing the quality of the initial bail reports provided to the courts within three days of admissions.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SB1392 appears generally favorable, especially among legislators advocating for reforms that streamline processes and improve the operational capacities of correctional facilities. Supporters argue that the changes will reduce the administrative burden on staff, thereby promoting better outcomes for detainees. However, there is an underlying concern from certain advocacy groups about ensuring that extending the review period does not inadvertently delay access to justice for individuals awaiting trial.

Contention

Notable points of contention center around the potential risks associated with extending the review period. Critics may argue that a longer timeframe for periodic reviews could lead to unnecessary delays in the release of eligible detainees, which could disproportionately impact marginalized individuals. The compromise between operational efficiency and safeguarding the rights and liberties of pretrial detainees remains a crucial point of discussion, signaling ongoing debates surrounding bail reform and the broader implications of corrections legislation in Hawaii.

Companion Bills

HI HB1094

Same As Relating To Periodic Reviews Of Detainees In Community Correctional Centers.

HI SB1392

Carry Over Relating To Periodic Reviews Of Detainees In Community Correctional Centers.

Previously Filed As

HI SB1392

Relating To Periodic Reviews Of Detainees In Community Correctional Centers.

HI HB1094

Relating To Periodic Reviews Of Detainees In Community Correctional Centers.

HI HB1094

Relating To Periodic Reviews Of Detainees In Community Correctional Centers.

HI HB1035

Relating To Pretrial Services Provided By The Intake Service Centers, Department Of Public Safety.

HI SB1189

Relating To Pretrial Services Provided By The Intake Service Centers, Department Of Public Safety.

HI SB2856

Relating To Pretrial Release.

HI HCR23

Requesting The Department Of Corrections And Rehabilitation, In Planning And Designing The New Oahu Community Correctional Center In Halawa, To Include A Circuit And District Court Facility And Establish A Release Procedure Under Which Detainees Or Inmates, Upon Release, Are Transported To A Site Other Than Residential Communities Or Public Spaces.

HI SCR26

Requesting The Department Of Corrections And Rehabilitation, In Planning And Designing The New Oahu Community Correctional Center In Halawa, To Include Circuit And District Court Facilities And Establish A Release Procedure Under Which Detainees Or Inmates, Upon Release, Are Transported To A Site Other Than Residential Communities Or Public Spaces.

HI SB1243

Relating To The Phaseout Of Private Correctional Facilities.

HI HB1080

Relating To The Phaseout Of Private Correctional Facilities.

Similar Bills

CA SB36

Pretrial release: risk assessment tools.

MI HB4657

Courts: state court administration; state pretrial services division; create. Amends 1927 PA 175 (MCL 760.1 - 777.69) by adding secs. 11 & 11a to ch. V.

CA AB42

Bail: pretrial release.

CA SB10

Pretrial release or detention: pretrial services.

IL SB1656

PRETRIAL RELEASE-REVOCATION

IL HB4621

PRETRIAL SERVICES

NJ A4521

Concerns provision of services to defendants on pretrial release.

NJ S2648

Concerns provision of services to defendants on pretrial release.