Montana 2023 Regular Session

Montana House Bill HB89

Introduced
12/12/22  
Refer
12/20/22  
Engrossed
1/24/23  
Refer
1/25/23  
Enrolled
3/20/23  

Caption

Revise laws related to Montana national guard life insurance and court martials

Impact

The impact of HB 89 on state law is considerable. The elimination of tax exemptions and reimbursements may result in increased financial burdens for service members and their families, particularly those relying on life insurance benefits. By repealing certain provisions regarding military courts and courts-martial, the state would potentially centralize judicial processes but could also lead to concerns about adequate legal protections for service members in disciplinary matters. This restructuring may also influence how military justice is administered in the state, impacting both service members and local jurisdictions that engage with military personnel.

Summary

House Bill 89 seeks to revise existing laws concerning military affairs in Montana. This bill aims to eliminate national guard life insurance reimbursements, as well as state income tax exemptions for premiums paid on life insurance policies for service members. Additionally, the bill proposes the removal of various laws related to military courts and courts-martial, resulting in a significant overhaul of how these matters are codified under state law. The bill is positioned as a modernization of military affairs, attempting to streamline and simplify legal frameworks governing service members.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 89 appears mixed, with a clear divide emerging among stakeholders. Supporters argue that the bill simplifies an convoluted legal structure and improves fiscal responsibility by abolishing redundant tax breaks. However, opponents express concerns about the financial implications for active and former military members, suggesting that the reductions in tax benefits constitute insufficient support for those who have served. The sentiments highlight an ongoing tension between fiscal conservatism and veteran welfare, fostering a complex dialogue about the treatment of service members in legislation.

Contention

Notable points of contention arise from the elimination of specific protections and benefits previously intended for military members. Critics have voiced apprehensions that repealing laws concerning life insurance reimbursements and tax exemptions may discourage potential recruits from the national guard. Furthermore, the dissolution of certain military judicial frameworks could lead to inadequacies in addressing service members' legal rights. As these changes may affect the financial and legal landscapes for service personnel, discussions around HB 89 remain contentious among lawmakers and advocacy groups.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

MT SB66

Generally revise laws related to Montana national guard benefits and rights

MT HB329

Make the Montana ammunition act permanent

MT HB440

Providing tax incentives to put Montana-produced food first

MT SB273

Generally revising medical savings account laws

MT SB537

Provide tax incentives for the sale of Montana-produced food

MT SB40

Generally revise laws related to Montana national guard duty status

MT SB550

Generally revise income tax laws and clarify income tax reform provisions

MT HB235

Revise social security income taxation

MT SB489

Revise capital gains tax law to support first responders and law enforcement

MT HB911

Generally revise individual income tax laws

Similar Bills

OH HB251

Designate Deputy Sheriff James "Jim" Wert Memorial Highway

OH HB269

Designate Sgt Bradley J. Harper USMC Memorial Highway

OH HB515

Create the Norton Music Boosters license plate

OH SB179

Create Hilliard Davidson Wildcats license plate

OH SB163

Create Dublin City Schools license plate

OH HB483

Create "Save a Warrior" license plate

OH HB533

Create the Iota Phi Theta license plate

OH HB627

Create Ohio Society for Respiratory Care license plate