Utah 2022 Regular Session

Utah House Bill HB0231

Introduced
1/26/22  
Refer
2/7/22  
Report Pass
2/11/22  
Engrossed
2/16/22  
Refer
2/17/22  
Report Pass
2/24/22  
Enrolled
3/11/22  

Caption

Fishing and Hunting Restrictions for Nonpayment of Child Support

Impact

The legislative discussions framed this bill's impact primarily in terms of child support enforcement. By restricting recreational licenses for those who are behind on payments, the bill aims to encourage better compliance with child support obligations. Critics, however, argue that this might disproportionately affect low-income individuals, who may struggle to pay child support while also managing job transitions. They posit that linking hunting and fishing licenses—often viewed as recreational activities—to financial obligations may undermine traditional community practices associated with food gathering and conservation.

Summary

House Bill 0231 seeks to amend existing laws concerning the issuance of fishing and hunting licenses in relation to child support obligations. Specifically, the bill prohibits individuals who are delinquent on their child support payments—defined as owing at least $2,500 in arrears—from applying for or obtaining any fishing or hunting licenses, permits, or tags. The bill also makes provisions for individuals who are transitioning to new employment to maintain their ability to obtain these licenses under certain circumstances, such as providing timely information about their new job and adhering to payment schedules established with the Office of Recovery Services.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 0231 appears to be divided. Supporters of the bill argue that it holds individuals accountable for their responsibilities towards their children and incentivizes compliance with child support laws, thus benefiting the welfare of children in the state. In contrast, opponents assert that such punitive measures could further marginalize those who are struggling financially, making it harder for them to gain access to outdoor resources that are essential for subsistence. This debate highlights the tensions between enforcement of child support and the right to partake in outdoor activities vital to many families.

Contention

There are several notable points of contention related to HB 0231. Primarily, the mechanics of enforcing such restrictions raises questions about effectiveness and fairness. For instance, the bill provides exceptions for individuals who can demonstrate missed payments were due to employment changes, but how this process will be administratively managed remains to be seen. Additionally, critics worry about the implications for personal freedoms—suggesting that the state should not interfere in licensing decisions based solely on financial histories, raising larger issues about the balance between enforcement and individual rights.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

UT SB390

Revises provisions relating to the support of children. (BDR 38-85)

UT HB2603

Hunting; fishing; license; deferred prosecution

UT HB0384

Child Support Requirements

UT HB843

Free hunting/fishing for service members/veterans with 50% disability rating

UT HB1313

Nonresident hunting and fishing license; authorize for nonresident natives of Mississippi.

UT HB1134

Hunting and fishing license for national guard members.

UT HB786

Nonresident native hunting and fishing license; authorize issuance for nonresident natives of Mississippi.

UT SB195

Family Law - Child Support

UT HB0463

Child Support Modifications

UT HB3348

Relating to child support.

Similar Bills

CA SB277

Criminal procedure: search of persons.

CA AB937

Plastic products: commercial agricultural mulch film: labeling: soil biodegradable.

CA AB2632

Segregated confinement.

CA AB1464

Housing preferences.

MI SB0975

Employment security: benefits; disqualification from benefits; modify. Amends sec. 29 of 1936 (Ex Sess) PA 1 (MCL 421.29).

CA AB2564

Individual Shared Responsibility Penalty: waiver: health care service plans.

CA SB479

Termination of tenancy: no-fault just cause: natural person.

CA SB1428

Reproductive health: mifepristone and other medication.