South Dakota 2022 Regular Session

South Dakota House Bill HB1129

Introduced
1/25/22  
Refer
1/25/22  
Report Pass
2/3/22  
Engrossed
2/7/22  
Refer
2/8/22  
Report Pass
3/2/22  
Enrolled
3/7/22  

Caption

Prohibit forms of discrimination in access to organ transplantation.

Impact

If enacted, HB1129 will amend South Dakota state laws to include clear restrictions against discriminatory practices in organ transplants. It establishes that discrimination based solely on disability is unfair and constitutes a violation under existing statutes related to discriminatory practices. This aligns state law with broader civil rights protections that promote equality and fairness in healthcare access for individuals with disabilities.

Summary

House Bill 1129 aims to eliminate discrimination in accessing organ transplantation on the basis of an individual's mental or physical disability. This legislation seeks to ensure that patients with disabilities are not unjustly excluded from the organ transplant process unless their condition is deemed medically significant to the provision of an anatomical gift. Essentially, the bill reinforces the principle that all patients should have equal opportunities for receiving life-saving transplants, regardless of their disabilities.

Sentiment

The general sentiment around HB1129 appears to be positive, with strong support from advocates of disability rights and healthcare equity. Backers of the bill argue that it enhances the ethical framework of medical practices relating to organ donation and transplant. It is perceived as a progressive step towards ensuring fairness in healthcare, particularly for marginalized groups who often face hurdles in accessing necessary services.

Contention

While the bill seems to enjoy widespread support, there may be discussions regarding the definition of 'medically significant' disabilities and the criteria used to assess them. Concerns might arise around the implications of these definitions on transplant eligibility assessments. However, the overall framework established by HB1129 is largely seen as a critical measure to protect against discrimination in a life-or-death context.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

SD HB3032

Prohibiting discrimination based on an individual’s mental or physical disability in access to organ transplantation

SD S644

No CV19 Discrimination/Organ Transplantation

SD SB933

Prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation on the basis of an individual's vaccination status.

SD AB955

Prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation on the basis of an individual's vaccination status.

SD SB2302

Prohibiting discrimination in the organ transplant process.

SD HB2659

Organ transplants; disabilities; discrimination; prohibition

SD SB647

Prohibiting discrimination in organ donation process

SD HB2752

Prohibiting discrimination in access to organ transplants based on physical or mental disability

SD HB119

Relating to prohibiting organ transplant recipient discrimination on the basis of certain disabilities.

SD SB601

COVID-19 immunization; prohibition on requirement, discrimination prohibited.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.