Vermont 2023-2024 Regular Session

Vermont Senate Bill S0153

Introduced
5/9/23  

Caption

An act relating to creating municipal and regional civilian oversight of law enforcement

Impact

The implementation of S0153 is expected to enhance the monitoring and reviewing of law enforcement conduct. These oversight boards will have the authority to receive, investigate, and address various complaints, including allegations of unprofessional conduct and incidents resulting in serious bodily harm or death caused by law enforcement officers. Additionally, they will publish public reports detailing their findings and recommendations, creating greater transparency and trust within communities regarding law enforcement actions.

Summary

S0153, an act relating to creating municipal and regional civilian oversight of law enforcement, proposes the establishment of community police oversight boards. These bodies are designed to investigate complaints against law enforcement agencies or officers within their jurisdiction, providing an additional layer of accountability beyond internal investigations conducted by the respective law enforcement agencies. The boards will consist of diverse members, including individuals with lived experiences impacted by law enforcement, as well as representatives from civil rights organizations and mental health experts.

Contention

Notable points of contention surrounding S0153 involve concerns related to the breadth of power given to these civilian oversight boards and how they interface with existing law enforcement practices. Supporters argue that these boards are essential for preventing misconduct and promoting law enforcement accountability, especially in light of increasing public scrutiny of police practices. Critics, however, fear that the establishment of such boards might undermine the authority of law enforcement agencies or lead to politicization of the oversight process. Additionally, questions remain about the practical implications of implementing these boards, including their funding, staffing, and operational guidelines.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

VT S0097

An act relating to creating municipal and regional civilian oversight of law enforcement

VT H0361

An act relating to creating municipal and regional civilian oversight of law enforcement

VT S0075

An act relating to civilian oversight of law enforcement

VT H0476

An act relating to miscellaneous changes to law enforcement officer training laws

VT S0184

An act relating to the temporary use of automated traffic law enforcement (ATLE) systems

VT H0562

An act relating to the temporary use of automated traffic law enforcement (ATLE) systems

VT HF3142

Local unit of government permitted to establish civilian oversight council for oversight of law enforcement.

VT H0872

An act relating to miscellaneous updates to the powers of the Vermont Criminal Justice Council and the duties of law enforcement officers

VT HB1000

Law-enforcement civilian oversight bodies; requirements of members.

VT HB1501

Law-enforcement civilian oversight bodies; requirements of members.

Similar Bills

VT S0097

An act relating to creating municipal and regional civilian oversight of law enforcement

VT H0361

An act relating to creating municipal and regional civilian oversight of law enforcement

VT S0075

An act relating to civilian oversight of law enforcement

HI SB455

Relating To The Hawaii Correctional System Oversight Commission.

HI HB1132

Relating To The Hawaii Correctional System Oversight Commission.

AZ HB2222

Independent corrections oversight committee

AZ HB2409

Independent corrections oversight committee

AZ SB1681

Independent corrections oversight committee.