Nebraska Legislature Bill LR280CA

Nebraska 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 1/16/24
• Refer: 1/17/24
• Failed: 4/18/24

Caption

Constitutional amendment to remove the Attorney General and the Secretary of State from the Board of Pardons

Impact

If enacted, LR280CA would modify the state constitution, impacting how the Board of Pardons operates and enhancing the independence of its decision-making process. The removal of the Attorney General and Secretary of State is seen as a move towards minimizing conflicts of interest and ensuring that clemency decisions are grounded on justice and ethics rather than political considerations. This could potentially lead to a more humane approach to pardoning practices in the state.

Summary

LR280CA proposes a significant structural change to the governance of the Board of Pardons by removing the Attorney General and the Secretary of State from their positions on the board. This bill aims to alter the makeup of this important board, which is responsible for reviewing and recommending clemency decisions. Proponents of the bill argue that this change could lead to a more impartial and fair assessment process concerning pardons and commutations, by decreasing the influence of elected officials who may have political motivations.

Contention

The discussion surrounding LR280CA highlights notable contention. Critics may argue that the involvement of the Attorney General and Secretary of State brings necessary oversight and accountability to the pardons process. They may express concerns that removing these officials could lead to a lack of checks and balances within the board, and raise questions about who would oversee the board's decisions going forward. Supporters, however, firmly believe that this restructuring would enhance the board's independence and efficacy in handling clemency requests, free from political pressures.