Vermont 2023-2024 Regular Session

Vermont Senate Bill S0208

Introduced
1/3/24  

Caption

An act relating to judicial retention and judicial nominations

Impact

Furthermore, S.208 mandates the establishment of procedures for members of the Joint Legislative Committee on Judicial Retention to conduct courtroom observations of judges up for retention. This addition promotes a more comprehensive review of judges' performances and is aimed at improving the quality and fairness of the judicial evaluation process. Another notable point within the bill is the emphasis on empathy and an understanding of equity and bias as part of the evaluation criteria for judicial performance, reflecting modern values in the judicial system.

Summary

S.208 aims to modify the processes surrounding judicial retention and nominations. It proposes several significant changes, including the requirement for a vote for retention on all judges in the General Assembly once they commence the retention process. This increased accountability is thought to enhance judicial oversight, ensuring that judicial officers are evaluated by their peers and the legislative body effectively.

Contention

Notably, the bill appropriates $50,000 for the Judiciary to reimburse the Judicial Nominating Board for the expenses incurred in employing paralegals during judicial nominations. This funding aspect might raise discussions regarding budget allocation and the support of judiciary processes in a time of tight financial management. Overall, S.208 presents a structured approach to enhance judicial accountability while also incorporating considerations relevant to contemporary legal standards.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

VT H0799

An act relating to judicial retention and judicial nominations

VT S0270

An act relating to judicial nominations and confirmations

VT H0780

An act relating to judicial nominations and appointments

VT S0109

An act relating to miscellaneous judiciary procedures

VT S0033

An act relating to miscellaneous judiciary procedures

VT H0878

An act relating to miscellaneous judiciary procedures

VT HB0512

Judicial Retention Changes

VT SCR1044

Judicial retention elections

VT H0256

An act relating to Judiciary Employees Labor Relations Act

VT SB280

Relating to electoral reforms of WV judiciary

Similar Bills

NJ AR96

Changes membership of Budget and Labor Committees; clarifies that bill or resolution may be listed on committee agenda for purposes of amendment.

MI HB4326

Campaign finance: contributions and expenditures; provision related to officeholders raising funds when facing a recall; modify, and require candidate to establish a separate account used for recall purposes. Amends secs. 3, 11, 12, 21, 24 & 52 of 1976 PA 388 (MCL 169.203 et seq.) & adds sec. 21b.

MI HB4870

Campaign finance: contributions and expenditures; funds donated to a candidate for recall efforts; require candidate to establish a separate account used for recall purposes. Amends secs. 3, 11, 12, 21, 24 & 52 of 1976 PA 388 (MCL 169.203 et seq.) & adds sec. 21b.

MN HC6

A concurrent resolution recognizing wild rice as sacred and central to the culture and health of Indigenous Peoples in Minnesota and critical to the health and identity of all Minnesota citizens and ecosystems and establishing a commitment to passing legislation to protect wild rice and the freshwater resources upon which it depends.

CA SB602

Advisory bodies.

CA SB1048

Advisory bodies.

CA AB3239

Advisory bodies.

KS HR6003

Providing temporary rules of the House of Representatives for the 2023 session until permanent rules are adopted.