South Dakota House Bill HB1218

South Dakota 2023 Regular Session

• Introduced: 2/1/23
• Refer: 2/1/23

Caption

Amend documentation requirements for emotional support animals in a rental dwelling unit.

Impact

The proposed changes will directly affect the relationship between landlords and tenants, particularly regarding the documentation required when a tenant requests an accommodation for an emotional support animal. The bill stipulates that landlords can request supporting documentation affirming the tenant's disability and the necessity of the animal. However, if a tenant's disability is apparent, landlords cannot request further documentation. This change aims to balance the rights of tenants while also protecting landlords from potential misuse of support animal claims.

Summary

House Bill 1218 aims to amend documentation requirements for emotional support animals in rental dwelling units within South Dakota. The bill redefines the terms 'service animal' and 'emotional support animal' to provide clarity and to ensure that the specific roles of these animals for individuals with disabilities are recognized. It distinguishes emotional support animals as those that provide necessary comfort to individuals with disabilities and outlines the requirements for landlords regarding documentation for tenants asserting a disability that necessitates an emotional support animal.

Contention

Notable points of contention surrounding HB 1218 include concerns over the potential for landlords to misuse the documentation requirements to reject tenants' claims. Opponents argue that the bill might place undue burdens on tenants needing emotional support animals. Furthermore, the provision allowing eviction for false claims or fraudulent documentation raises questions about enforcement and the risks it poses to tenants who may be unfairly accused. Advocates fear this could lead to discrimination against individuals with legitimate needs for emotional support animals.